Guides

Copay accumulators and maximizers: why coupons may not count

How drug-maker copay assistance may bypass your deductible and out-of-pocket maximum under an accumulator or maximizer program, with an example and checks.

A copay accumulator is a health plan policy under which the value of a drug manufacturer's coupon or assistance card is not counted toward your deductible or out-of-pocket maximum. A copay maximizer is a related program that sets your copay at a figure designed to draw out the full amount of the manufacturer's assistance over the year, and that assistance usually does not count either. In both cases the coupon pays at the pharmacy counter, but your plan's clock for the deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum may not move. The result can be a bill later in the year, when the coupon runs out and you owe the whole deductible.

What manufacturer assistance is

Drug makers offer copay assistance programs for expensive brand-name and specialty drugs. You enroll, show the card at the pharmacy, and the manufacturer pays part or all of your share of the cost, often down to a small flat amount. These programs are generally available only to people with commercial (non-government) insurance. Federal law bars them for people covered by programs such as Medicare Part D and Medicaid, in part because of anti-kickback rules.

Before accumulators, a coupon was an ordinary payment toward your cost sharing: if a plan's drug deductible was $2,000 and the coupon paid that amount, the plan treated your deductible as met. Plans and pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs), the companies that administer drug benefits for many plans, argue that coupons steer people toward expensive brand drugs when cheaper alternatives exist and that the drug maker, not the patient, then pays the bill. Patient and disease groups reply that people with chronic conditions need the drug their doctor chose and are penalized for using an assistance program. Both sides are describing the same mechanism; the disagreement is about who should bear the cost.

How an accumulator works

Under an accumulator, the plan accepts the manufacturer's payment at the counter but does not count it toward your deductible or out-of-pocket maximum. The plan counts only what you personally pay. The coupon pays the first part of the year, and the plan's deductible still shows as unmet. When the coupon's annual limit is used up, you start paying cost sharing out of your own pocket as if no money had been spent, because from the plan's accounting, none has.

A labeled example

Say a hypothetical plan has a $3,000 deductible, then 20% coinsurance, and a $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum. Say your specialty drug costs $2,000 per month (round numbers for illustration, not real prices), and the manufacturer's program pays up to $12,000 per year.

Without an accumulator (coupon counts). Month 1: your share is the $2,000 you owe toward the deductible, and the coupon pays it. Month 2: your share is the remaining $1,000 of the deductible plus 20% of the other $1,000, which is $200, so $1,200, again paid by the coupon. From month 3 your share is 20% of $2,000, or $400 a month. Counted amounts reach $3,200 after month 2, then grow by $400 a month, so the $6,000 maximum is reached in month 9. The coupon covers all of it, about $6,000 for the year, which is under its $12,000 limit. You pay $0.

With an accumulator (coupon not counted). The plan's records show $0 toward your deductible, so each month the plan asks for a share of the full $2,000 claim, and the coupon pays it. Months 1 through 6 use $2,000 each, or $12,000, and the coupon is now exhausted. The plan's records still show $0 met. You now pay from your own pocket: month 7, $2,000 toward the deductible; month 8, $1,000 to finish the deductible plus $200 coinsurance, or $1,200; months 9 through 12, $400 each, or $1,600. Your total is $4,800 for the year, even though the manufacturer paid $12,000, twice what it paid in the first case. The timing, with the bills arriving late in the year, can be as hard as the total.

Item Coupon counts Accumulator in place
Deductible credited by the end of month 6 Met in month 2 $0
Manufacturer pays over the year About $6,000 $12,000 (cap reached)
You pay over the year $0 $4,800

How a maximizer differs

A maximizer program is usually run through a PBM or a third-party vendor. The plan labels the drug "non-essential" or an excluded benefit and sets your copay at a number chosen to equal the manufacturer's annual assistance limit divided across the months of the year. Your own copay, as you see it, can then be low or even $0 so long as you enroll in the manufacturer's program, because the plan drains the assistance by design. Typically the manufacturer's payments do not count toward your deductible or maximum either. If you do not enroll, the plan may charge a much higher share. Critics say the design converts a patient-support program into plan revenue; PBMs and plans say it saves money on high-cost drugs and offsets their costs. Check the exact terms because they vary.

Where the rules stand

Whether accumulators and maximizers are allowed depends on your plan type and your state. A number of states have passed laws requiring plans to count manufacturer assistance toward cost sharing, but those laws generally reach only plans regulated by the state. Self-funded employer plans (where the employer pays claims itself, see self-funded plan) are typically governed by federal law instead, so a state ban may not apply. Federal rules have also shifted over time, and legal challenges have affected them, so a plan's policy can differ from last year's. Check with your state insurance department, your plan documents and your employer's benefits office for the rules that currently apply to you.

How to find out whether your plan uses one

  • Read the plan documents. Search the summary of benefits, evidence of coverage or drug benefit materials for "accumulator," "manufacturer assistance," "copay card," "coupon," "alternative funding" or "non-essential benefit."
  • Ask directly. Call member services and ask: "If I use a manufacturer copay card, does the amount count toward my deductible and out-of-pocket maximum?" Ask for the answer in writing or note the date, time and name.
  • Ask your specialty pharmacy or the manufacturer's program. They often see accumulator behavior first and can describe what happens when a card's annual cap is reached.
  • Watch your claims. Compare the plan's deductible tracker with what you paid. If the coupon payment does not show in the tracker, your plan is not counting it. The deductible and out-of-pocket tracker helps record this, and how to track your deductible and out-of-pocket spending explains what to compare.

What you can do

  • Plan the cash flow. If you use a coupon, ask when its annual cap runs out and set aside money for the month after.
  • Ask your prescriber about alternatives. A lower-cost or preferred drug, or a different dose schedule, may change what you owe. The steps for asking a plan to cover a different drug are in what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need.
  • Compare plans at open enrollment. If you take a specialty drug, compare the drug list, the deductible and the plan's policy on coupons. A PBM guide explains who runs the drug benefit.
  • Ask your employer. In a job-based plan the employer decides which programs to use, and benefits staff can say whether it can change the policy.
  • Contact the state. If a state-regulated plan appears to break a state law on counting assistance, the state insurance department takes complaints.
  • Ask a professional about taxes. Special rules apply when a plan is paired with a health savings account; a tax professional can say how assistance interacts with your eligibility.

Key takeaways

  • An accumulator does not count a drug maker's coupon toward your deductible or out-of-pocket maximum; a maximizer sets your copay to draw out the whole assistance amount, usually with the same result.
  • The coupon pays at the counter, but the plan's clock may not move, so you can owe the full deductible once the coupon runs out.
  • Rules differ by state and plan type, and self-funded employer plans often fall outside state laws.
  • Look for the policy in plan documents, ask member services in writing, and check your deductible tracker against what you paid.
  • Plan for the month the coupon ends, and ask your prescriber and your benefits office about options.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic