Guides

What to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need

Steps when a plan refuses a prescription: learn why, request a formulary exception or prior authorization, appeal, and look at lower-cost options meanwhile.

Start by finding out exactly why the plan said no, because the fix depends on the reason. If the drug needs approval first, your prescriber submits a prior authorization request. If the drug is not on the plan's drug list, you can ask for an exception. If the plan wants you to try another drug first, you can ask for an exception to that rule. If the plan has already denied a request, you can appeal, and many denials can go to an independent reviewer afterward. While that happens, ask about a temporary supply, a generic or a lower-cost alternative, and manufacturer or charity programs. Keep every notice, and watch the deadline printed on it.

Step 1: Find out why

A pharmacy rejection and a plan denial are not the same thing. A pharmacy rejection is a message at the counter, often a code, and it may mean a paperwork step is missing. A denial is a decision by the plan, which should come in a written notice. Ask the pharmacist what the rejection says, then ask your prescriber's office or the plan's member services. The common reasons are these:

Reason What it means Where to go next
Not on the formulary The plan's drug list does not include the drug Ask for a formulary exception
Prior authorization required The plan wants clinical information before paying Your prescriber submits a request
step therapy The plan wants you to try a different, usually cheaper drug first Show you tried it, or ask for an exception
Quantity limit The plan caps how much is dispensed per fill Ask for a higher limit with a medical reason
Excluded drug or class The plan's benefit does not cover the category Ask whether an exception or appeal is possible; look at alternatives
Wrong pharmacy The drug must come from a network or specialty pharmacy Switch pharmacy or ask for an exception

Also check simple things: a typed-in wrong dose, an expired prior authorization, or a refill requested too soon. These fix themselves with a phone call.

Step 2: Ask for prior authorization or an exception

For drugs that need prior authorization, the prescriber sends the plan the diagnosis, test results and treatments tried. Plans use written criteria, and the criteria are typically available on request. how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied explains the process.

A formulary exception is a request to cover a drug the plan does not usually cover, to waive a step-therapy or quantity rule, or to charge a lower cost-sharing tier. Under federal rules, most non-grandfathered private plans must have a process for this, and Medicare Part D plans have one called a coverage determination. The request usually needs a supporting statement from your prescriber explaining why the covered alternatives would not work or would be harmful, for example because you tried them and had side effects, because they did not control your condition, or because a drug interaction makes them unsafe. If a delay would seriously harm your health, ask for an expedited decision. Federal rules set short timelines for these requests, generally in the range of 72 hours for a standard request and 24 hours for an expedited one for many plans and Medicare Part D, though the exact times depend on your plan type. Your notice and plan documents give the timeline that applies to you.

Be specific in the request. A note that says "needs this drug" is weaker than one that lists the diagnosis, the dates and doses of earlier drugs, why each failed or was not suitable, and the likely result of switching.

Step 3: Appeal if the answer is no

A denial notice must explain the reason and how to appeal. In most private plans you have at least 180 days from the date of the denial notice for an internal appeal; Medicare plans use shorter, specific deadlines printed on the notice. Your prescriber can often request a peer-to-peer conversation with the plan's reviewing physician. An appeal letter should include the denial reference number, a short history, the prescriber's reasoning and any supporting studies or guidelines. The claim denial appeal letter builder helps assemble one, and how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step covers the general steps.

If the plan upholds its decision, ask whether independent external review is available. For many denials in private plans it is, and the reviewer is not employed by the plan. The appeal and external review deadline calculator can help you track the dates. A state insurance department can answer questions about state-regulated plans and take complaints.

Step 4: Bridge the gap

While you wait, ask about these:

  • A temporary supply. Many plans or pharmacies can authorize a short supply while a request is pending, especially when you are changing plans or starting a new drug. Ask your pharmacist and the plan; do not assume.
  • A generic or biosimilar. A generic contains the same active ingredient as the brand and often costs much less, and a biosimilar is a close copy of a biologic drug. Ask your prescriber whether one fits your situation.
  • A different drug on the formulary. If your prescriber agrees that a covered alternative is medically appropriate, it may be the quickest route.
  • Manufacturer assistance. Drug makers run assistance programs for people with commercial insurance, and some have free-drug programs for people who qualify by income. Ask the manufacturer or your prescriber's office. The effects of those programs on your deductible are covered in copay accumulators and maximizers: why coupons may not count.
  • Public or charity help. If you have Medicare, Extra Help may lower drug costs for people with limited income (Extra Help with Part D costs: the low-income subsidy explained). Nonprofit patient-assistance foundations and community clinics' pharmacy programs may also help.
  • Coupon and discount cards. These can lower a cash price, but paying cash through a discount card generally means the spending may not count toward your plan's deductible; ask the plan how it treats those purchases.

A labeled example

Say Sam has a hypothetical plan that covers Drug A (the preferred drug) but not Drug B, which Sam's doctor prescribed after Drug A caused a severe reaction. The pharmacy rejects Drug B. Sam calls the plan, which says Drug B is excluded without an exception. Sam's doctor sends an exception request, attaching the chart note about the reaction. The plan approves it for six months. If it had denied the request, Sam would file an internal appeal using the denial's date and reference number, ask for a peer-to-peer call, and, if that failed, ask for external review. These are illustrations: your plan's wording and timeline will differ.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Paying cash at the pharmacy and never asking why. A rejection may be a missing authorization that is easy to fix.
  • Missing the deadline on the notice. Appeal rights can lapse.
  • Skipping the prescriber's statement. Plans decide exceptions on clinical information, so a bare request rarely succeeds.
  • Switching plans at open enrollment without checking the formulary for the drugs you take. The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet helps with that.

Key takeaways

  • Find out the reason first: not on the list, needs prior authorization, step therapy, quantity limit, exclusion or pharmacy rule.
  • Ask for an exception or prior authorization with a specific supporting statement from your prescriber; ask for an expedited decision if delay is harmful.
  • You can appeal a denial, usually within 180 days for private plans, and many denials can go to external review.
  • Use the gap time for a temporary supply, a generic, a covered alternative or assistance programs.
  • Keep every notice and date, and check the next plan year's formulary before you enroll.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic