Guides
How to compare Part D plans: formulary, pharmacies and total cost
Compare Part D plans by checking each of your drugs on the formulary, your pharmacies in the network, and the full-year cost, not the premium alone.
To compare Part D plans, start with your own prescriptions: for each plan, check whether every drug is on its formulary, at what tier and with what restrictions, then confirm that your pharmacy is in its network and add up the full-year cost, including premium, deductible and cost sharing. The plan with the lowest premium is often not the plan with the lowest yearly cost, because the premium is only one part of the total. The best time to do this is the Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, since plans change their lists and prices every January.
Step 1: write down what you take
Make a list for each person that includes:
- Every prescription drug, with its dose and how often you fill it (monthly, or every 90 days).
- Whether each is a generic drug, a brand-name drug or a specialty drug.
- The pharmacies you use, and whether you would use a mail-order option.
- Any drugs you may start in the coming year, if your doctor has told you.
Medicare.gov's plan finder asks for the same information, and the doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet gives you a place to record it.
Step 2: check each drug on each plan
Every plan publishes a formulary. For each of your drugs, record three things.
- Is it covered? If not, the plan will generally not pay for it unless you get an exception.
- What tier is it on? The tier sets your cost: low tiers (often generics) have the smallest copays, and higher tiers, including specialty drugs, have higher cost sharing.
- Are there restrictions? Common ones are prior authorization (the plan must approve before paying), step therapy (you must try a cheaper drug first) and quantity limits (a cap on how much is covered per fill).
A restriction does not mean you cannot get the drug, but it adds steps, and a doctor's office may need to submit paperwork. Ask your doctor whether the restrictions fit how you take the drug. If a drug is off the list or restricted in a way that does not work for you, a formulary exception request is the route, and what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need covers it. But an exception is not guaranteed, so do not choose a plan counting on one.
Step 3: check the pharmacy network
Plans contract with pharmacies. Some plans designate preferred pharmacies, where your cost sharing is lower. Check:
- Is your regular pharmacy in the network, and is it preferred or standard?
- Does the plan offer mail-order pricing, and would a 90-day supply lower your cost?
- Is there a pharmacy near you if you travel or split time between places?
The same drug can cost different amounts at preferred and standard pharmacies under the same plan, so run the comparison both ways if you can use either.
Step 4: add up the yearly cost
The premium is what you pay monthly just to have the plan. The total yearly cost is:
premium times 12, plus the deductible you would pay, plus cost sharing on your fills, up to the out-of-pocket cap
In 2026 the standard cap is $2,100, and in 2027 it is $2,400, with a standard deductible of $615 in 2026 and $700 in 2027 (CMS). Plans can set a lower deductible. The cap guide at The Part D out-of-pocket cap and the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan explains how it works.
Here is an illustration with labeled hypothetical figures, not real plan prices. Say you take two drugs that cost the pharmacy price of $20 and $300 per monthly fill, so $320 a month together, and you are choosing between two plans.
| Plan A | Plan B | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly premium | $10 | $40 |
| Deductible | $640 | $0 |
| Drug 1 (generic) after deductible | $5 copay | $5 copay |
| Drug 2 (brand) after deductible | $60 copay | $45 copay |
- Plan A: premiums are $10 x 12 = $120. The deductible takes the first two fills in full: $320 x 2 = $640. Months 3 to 12 are ten months of $5 + $60 = $65, which is $650. Total: $120 + $640 + $650 = $1,410.
- Plan B: premiums are $40 x 12 = $480. There is no deductible, so all twelve months are $5 + $45 = $50, which is $600. Total: $480 + $600 = $1,080.
In this made-up case, the plan with four times the premium costs $330 less over the year. Change the numbers, such as a drug you fill rarely or a plan with a small deductible, and the result can flip. That is why the exercise matters: work out each plan's total with your own list. Neither total here comes near the cap, but if you take a very expensive drug, the cap limits both.
Step 5: look at plan stability and service
- Formulary changes mid-year. Plans may make some changes during the year, usually with notice; the plan's materials explain them. A drug that is stable on the list this year can still move next year.
- Plan availability. Not every plan returns each year. For 2027, KFF counted 316 stand-alone Part D plans nationally, down from 360, and 9 for the average beneficiary compared with 11.
- Star ratings and service. Medicare publishes quality ratings for plans; they are a signal, not a guarantee.
- Extra Help. If you qualify, the picture changes: the premium and cost sharing are subsidized, and which plan is cheapest for you can change. See Extra Help with Part D costs: the low-income subsidy explained.
Medicare Advantage drug coverage
If you are in or considering a Medicare Advantage plan with drug coverage, the same method applies: the drug list, the pharmacies and the total yearly cost are part of the plan, along with its doctors and out-of-pocket limit. You cannot pair a stand-alone Part D plan with most Medicare Advantage plans, so the drug check is part of choosing the plan as a whole.
After you choose
Keep the formulary notice your plan mails each fall, confirm the effective date, and recheck in January that the first fill prices as expected. If a fill costs more than the plan said it would, call the plan before paying again, and ask a State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor for free help. Medicare Part D explained: drug plans, formularies and costs covers the basics, and the Annual Enrollment Period guide covers the window.
Key takeaways
- Start with your own drug list, doses and pharmacies, not the plan's advertised premium.
- For each plan, check coverage, tier and restrictions for every drug.
- Pharmacy choice affects cost: confirm network and preferred status.
- Compare total yearly cost: premium times 12, plus deductible, plus cost sharing, bounded by the cap.
- Recheck every fall, because lists, prices and plan availability change each January.