Guides
Medical debt and your rights: collections, credit reports, lawsuits
What debt collectors may and may not do, how medical debt can appear on credit reports, what happens if you are sued and where state protections come in.
When a medical bill goes unpaid, the provider may send it to a collector or sell it, the account can be reported to credit bureaus under rules that have changed over the years, and in some cases the creditor can sue. You keep rights throughout: federal law limits how collectors may contact you, lets you demand proof of the debt, and lets you dispute errors on your credit report. Many states add protections, and nonprofit hospitals have their own rules about collection practices. Because medical debt is often a billing error, insurance mistake or a bill that qualifies for financial assistance, the first move is usually to verify the debt rather than pay it.
How a medical bill becomes debt
Most medical bills do not go to collections right away. A typical sequence is a statement from the provider, one or more reminders, then a referral to an outside collection agency or a sale of the debt to a debt buyer. The timing varies by provider and by state. Hospitals that are nonprofit organizations must follow federal tax rules before taking certain collection actions, which are described below.
At any stage, the bill may be wrong. Insurance claims can be processed late, denied by mistake, or billed to you before the plan has paid. Check the explanation of benefits first, and ask for an itemized bill (see how to get an itemized medical bill and spot billing errors). Also check whether the Surprise medical bills and the No Surprises Act: what is protected covers the charge, because a protected surprise bill is not yours to pay beyond in-network cost sharing.
What collectors may and may not do
The federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) applies to third-party debt collectors and debt buyers. In general:
- A collector must send a written validation notice describing the debt and the creditor, and telling you how to dispute it.
- If you dispute the debt in writing within the period stated in the notice (30 days from receiving it), the collector must stop collecting until it sends verification.
- Collectors may not harass or threaten you, call at unreasonable hours, lie about what you owe, or tell other people about your debt (apart from limited exceptions).
- They may not threaten actions they cannot or do not intend to take, such as arrest for an unpaid bill.
The original provider collecting its own bill is usually not covered by the FDCPA, but state laws often cover it. If you think a collector broke the rules, keep records and file a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and your state attorney general.
A practical step: send a letter by certified mail, return receipt requested, asking the collector to validate the debt and confirm the amount, the date of service and the original creditor. Keep a copy. Do not agree to pay, and do not make a small payment, until you have verified the debt, because in some states a payment can restart the time limit for suing.
Medical debt and credit reports
Credit reports are governed by the Fair Credit Reporting Act, which gives you the right to see your reports and dispute errors. Medical collections have been treated differently from other debts at times. The three national credit bureaus changed their voluntary practices in recent years, for example by waiting before showing unpaid medical collections and removing paid ones, and federal rulemaking on medical debt in credit reports has moved back and forth. Because the rules in effect change, check the current policy at consumerfinance.gov and at each bureau.
What does stay constant:
- You can get your credit reports free from the official site, AnnualCreditReport.com.
- If a medical account shows an incorrect amount, a debt that insurance should have paid, or one that is not yours, dispute it in writing with the bureau and with the company that reported it.
- Medical bills that were delayed because of insurance processing are a common source of errors.
When you are sued
If a creditor or debt buyer sues, you will get a summons and a complaint. Do not ignore them. If you do not respond by the deadline stated in the court papers, the court may enter a default judgment, which can allow the creditor to seek a wage garnishment or a bank account levy, depending on state law.
If you receive court papers:
- Note the deadline to respond, which is stated in the summons and varies by state.
- Find out whether the plaintiff is the original provider or a buyer of the debt, and ask for proof that it owns the debt.
- Contact a legal aid office or a licensed consumer attorney. Many offer free or low-cost help for debt cases.
- Check the statute of limitations, the time limit for suing. It varies by state and by the type of debt, and it can be affected by some payments or acknowledgments.
- Respond in the way the court requires, even if you plan to negotiate.
Legal details are particular to your state and facts, so this is where a lawyer, not a general guide, is the right source.
Nonprofit hospitals and financial assistance
Federal tax law requires nonprofit hospital organizations to have a written financial assistance policy, to limit what eligible patients are charged, and to make reasonable efforts to determine eligibility before taking certain "extraordinary collection actions," such as reporting to credit bureaus, selling the debt or suing. The IRS rule includes a waiting period after the first bill before those actions. See hospital financial assistance and charity care: how to apply. If an account has already gone to collections, you can still ask the hospital whether you qualify, because many will take the account back or adjust it.
State protections
States differ. Some limit interest on medical debt, restrict wage garnishment, bar liens on a primary home for certain debts, require hospitals to screen for aid, or limit collections against patients who have financial assistance. Your state attorney general or insurance department can tell you what applies. For the state regulator's complaint process, see how to file a complaint with your state insurance department.
What to do, in order
- Do not ignore letters or calls, but do not pay under pressure either.
- Ask the collector for written validation and keep every notice.
- Check the bill against the EOB and the itemized charges.
- Ask the provider about financial assistance and a payment plan. See how to negotiate a medical bill: steps and what to say.
- Review your credit reports and dispute errors.
- If you are sued, respond on time and get legal help.
Key takeaways
- Verify a medical debt before paying: ask for written validation, compare it with your EOB and check for billing errors.
- Federal law limits harassment and misstatements by third-party collectors and lets you dispute a debt in writing.
- Rules on how medical debt appears on credit reports have changed, so check current policy with the CFPB and the bureaus.
- Never ignore a lawsuit: missing the deadline can lead to a default judgment.
- Nonprofit hospitals must have financial assistance policies and follow rules before aggressive collection, and many states add protections.