Guides
Surprise medical bills and the No Surprises Act: what is protected
The federal law shields you from many out-of-network bills for emergencies, in-network facilities and air ambulances, but not ground ambulances.
The No Surprises Act, in effect since January 1, 2022, protects most people with private health insurance from unexpected out-of-network bills in three situations: emergency care, non-emergency care from an out-of-network provider at an in-network hospital or surgery center, and air ambulance services. In those cases you generally owe only your in-network cost sharing, and the provider may not bill you for the difference between its charge and what the plan pays. The law does not cover every unexpected bill. Ground ambulance rides, for example, are outside the federal law, and so are charges for care your plan does not cover at all. This guide explains what is protected, what is not and how to dispute a bill that looks wrong.
What a "surprise bill" is
Normally, a provider outside your plan's network can bill you its full charge, and the plan pays only its allowed amount for that service, if it pays at all. The gap between the two is called balance billing. It becomes a surprise when you had no real chance to choose an in-network provider, such as an ambulance to the nearest emergency room, or an anesthesiologist you never met who is not in your plan's network even though the hospital is.
The No Surprises Act limits that practice for the situations below. Before 2022, protection depended on a patchwork of state laws, and many of those state laws still apply to plans the federal law does not reach, or to services it leaves out.
What the federal law protects
According to CMS, the federal law applies to most types of health insurance and protects you against:
- Emergency services. Emergency care, including care after you are stabilized in many cases, is protected whether or not the hospital is in your network. The plan cannot require prior approval, and it cannot apply higher out-of-network cost sharing.
- Non-emergency care at in-network facilities. If you go to an in-network hospital, outpatient department or ambulatory surgical center, certain providers there may be out of network, such as anesthesiologists, radiologists, pathologists or assistant surgeons. You are protected from balance bills from them.
- Air ambulance. Out-of-network air ambulance bills are covered when the plan would otherwise cover the transport.
In each case you pay what you would have paid in network, a copay, coinsurance or deductible amount, and that payment counts toward your deductible and out-of-pocket maximum as if the provider were in network. The plan and the provider settle the rest between themselves, usually through the federal independent dispute resolution process. That process is for providers and plans, not patients, so you do not take part in it.
What it does not protect
The federal law has gaps. Do not assume protection in these situations:
- Ground ambulances. The federal law does not cover ground ambulance rides. Some states have their own rules, so check your state insurance department.
- Care that is not covered. If the plan excludes the service, the law does not make it covered.
- Care you choose at an out-of-network provider for a non-emergency service when you had real choices, outside an in-network facility.
- Plans that are not covered by the law, such as some short-term and non-insurance arrangements. Check your plan documents if you are unsure.
- Bills from an in-network provider for a service that was mis-coded or costs more than expected. Those are billing errors or ordinary cost sharing, not surprise bills under this law.
There is also a narrow consent exception. For some non-emergency care, a provider can ask you to sign a notice and consent form giving up the protection. Providers cannot do that for certain services, including emergency care and, for example, many hospital-based specialties like anesthesiology and radiology when the facility is in network. Read any consent form before signing and ask whether an in-network alternative exists.
If you are uninsured or paying yourself
Providers usually must give a good faith estimate if you ask for one, or when you schedule care at least 3 business days ahead, according to CMS. You may be able to dispute the bill if the final charge is at least $400 above the estimate. CMS runs a help line for these questions at 1-800-985-3059. See good faith estimate for how the estimate works.
A worked example (hypothetical numbers)
Say Priya has a plan with a $1,000 deductible she has not met, 20% coinsurance and an in-network allowed amount of $5,000 for a knee scope at an in-network surgery center. The anesthesiologist, unknown to her, is out of network and bills $3,000 separately.
- Without the federal protection, the plan might pay little for the anesthesiologist, and Priya could face a balance bill for much of the $3,000.
- With it, Priya pays only her in-network share for that service. Suppose the plan's in-network allowed amount for the anesthesia is $1,200. Her share is her remaining deductible and coinsurance on that amount, and it counts toward her deductible and out-of-pocket maximum.
- The anesthesiologist cannot bill her for the rest. Any difference between the plan's payment and the provider's charge is settled between the plan and the provider.
If a bill arrives for more than her expected share, Priya should compare it against the plan's explanation of benefits first.
How to dispute a bill that looks wrong
- Stop and do not pay yet. Do not pay the first bill quickly, because a payment can be treated as acceptance. Ask for a hold on collections while you review it.
- Compare the bill with your explanation of benefits. If the EOB says you owe a smaller amount than the bill, the provider is billing you for more than the plan says you owe. Use how to get an itemized medical bill and spot billing errors to request the itemized version.
- Check whether the law applies. The surprise bill protection checker walks through the situations above.
- Call the provider's billing office and the plan. Say that you believe the bill is covered by the No Surprises Act and ask them to rebill at in-network cost sharing. Ask for the name of the person and keep the date. Follow up in writing.
- If the provider does not correct it, file a complaint. CMS runs a federal No Surprises help desk, and your state insurance department handles complaints against insurers and often providers. CMS's consumer page at cms.gov/nosurprises has the current complaint process.
- Negotiate or appeal if it does not apply. If it is a legitimate bill, see how to negotiate a medical bill: steps and what to say.
Key takeaways
- The federal law covers emergency care, out-of-network providers at in-network facilities and air ambulances for most private coverage.
- You pay only in-network cost sharing, and it counts toward your deductible and out-of-pocket maximum.
- Ground ambulances and non-covered services are outside the federal law, and some states fill part of the gap.
- Uninsured and self-pay patients can ask for a good faith estimate and may dispute a bill that is $400 or more above it.
- If a bill looks wrong, compare it with the EOB, put your objection in writing and use the regulator's complaint process.