Guides
Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: how to compare the two
Compare Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage on cost, networks, prior authorization, drug coverage and switching back, using your own doctors and drugs.
Neither choice is better for everyone. Original Medicare lets you use almost any doctor or hospital in the country that accepts Medicare and has few prior authorization rules, but it has no yearly out-of-pocket cap unless you add a Medigap policy and a separate drug plan. A Medicare Advantage plan bundles coverage with a yearly cost limit and often extras, but it restricts you to a network and uses prior authorization more often. The right comparison uses your own doctors, drugs and expected care.
What you are choosing between
With Original Medicare, the federal government pays Part A and Part B claims directly. You can add a stand-alone Part D drug plan and, if you want, a Medigap policy to cover the cost sharing. With Medicare Advantage, you enroll in one private plan that provides Part A and Part B coverage, usually with Part D drug coverage inside it. In 2026, according to KFF, 55% of people with Parts A and B were in Medicare Advantage; the rest were in Original Medicare.
Seven criteria that decide it
| Criterion | Original Medicare (with or without Medigap) | Medicare Advantage |
|---|---|---|
| Doctors and hospitals | Any provider that accepts Medicare, nationwide | The plan's network; HMOs limit out-of-network care, PPOs allow it at higher cost |
| Yearly cost limit | None in Original Medicare; Medigap can cover most cost sharing | An in-network limit by law ($9,250 maximum in 2026), often lower |
| Premium | Part B premium, plus Medigap and Part D premiums | Part B premium, plus a plan premium that is often $0 |
| Prior authorization | Used for a limited list of services | Common, and set by each plan |
| Drug coverage | Separate Part D plan | Usually included |
| Extras | None; dental, vision and hearing are not covered | Often dental, vision, hearing or fitness benefits, with limits |
| Switching back | Medigap policies are guaranteed only in certain windows | Can leave in the fall or early in the year; Medigap may require underwriting |
The weight you give each row depends on your health, your budget and how you feel about uncertainty.
Cost: premium versus risk
The cheaper plan on paper is not always the cheaper plan in a bad year. A worked example with labeled hypothetical numbers and 2026 Medicare amounts follows. Say a person has one 5-day hospital stay and $30,000 of Medicare-approved outpatient services in a year. The numbers ignore premiums and drugs.
- Original Medicare with no supplement: the Part A deductible is $1,736. The Part B deductible is $283, and 20% of the other $29,717 is $5,943.40, so the Part B cost is $6,226.40. The total is $7,962.40, and there is no cap.
- Original Medicare with a Medigap Plan G: the plan pays the Part A deductible and the coinsurance, so the person owes $283.
- A Medicare Advantage plan with a hypothetical $5,000 in-network limit: the person pays the plan's copays and coinsurance up to $5,000, and possibly less.
Now add the premiums. A Medigap policy has its own monthly premium on top of Part B, and a Medicare Advantage plan may have no extra premium. A person who rarely uses care may pay less with a no-premium plan; a person who expects heavy use may prefer the predictability of Medigap or the cap of a plan. See Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N for what each letter pays and the Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage cost comparison to run your own numbers.
Networks and prior authorization
Medicare Advantage networks differ for every plan, even from the same company, so check each doctor, hospital and specialist you use, and confirm by phone. Original Medicare has no network, but providers can opt out of Medicare, and some do not accept assignment. prior authorization is more widespread in Medicare Advantage, where it can apply to hospital stays, imaging, and some drugs. Rules from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services since 2026 require Medicare Advantage plans to give specific reasons for denials and to decide most standard requests within 7 calendar days. Medicare Advantage networks and prior authorization: what to expect explains the details.
Drugs
Original Medicare alone has no outpatient drug coverage, so you would need a stand-alone Part D plan, or go without and risk a late penalty. In Medicare Advantage, drug coverage is usually built in, and you cannot add a separate Part D plan to most Medicare Advantage HMOs and PPOs. In both cases, check the formulary for your drugs. For 2027 the Part D standard out-of-pocket cap is $2,400 and the standard deductible is $700; plans can charge less.
Switching later
You can change each year during the Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, and people in Medicare Advantage can also switch from January 1 to March 31. Switching from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare is easy; buying a Medigap policy afterward can be the hard part. Outside protected windows, insurers in most states can use medical underwriting and may decline you or charge more because of health conditions. KFF estimates that about 74% of people in Medicare Advantage have a condition that could lead to a denial of a Medigap policy outside protected windows. That is why the exit is worth thinking about before you join. See How to leave a Medicare Advantage plan: dates, options and risks.
Questions to answer before you decide
- Which doctors, hospitals and pharmacies do I use, and are they in the network?
- What drugs do I take, and what does each plan charge for them?
- What could a bad year cost me with and without a yearly limit?
- How much would I pay in premiums for each option?
- Do I travel or live in more than one state?
- If I started with Medicare Advantage, how would I return to Original Medicare and Medigap?
A State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor, a licensed broker or the Medicare helpline can help with the specifics, and there is no cost for a counselor.
Key takeaways
- Original Medicare offers broad provider choice with no yearly cap; Medicare Advantage offers a yearly limit and extras within a network.
- Compare total cost in a good year and a bad year, including premiums, not only the monthly premium.
- Prior authorization and network rules are the main day-to-day differences.
- Going back to Original Medicare is simple, but buying Medigap later may involve medical underwriting.
- Check your doctors and drugs against each plan every fall.