Tools

Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage cost comparison

Compares a year of cost under Original Medicare with Medigap and a drug plan against Medicare Advantage, at light, moderate and heavy use. All inputs editable.

Runs entirely in your browser: nothing you enter is sent or stored by this site. Results are estimates for planning, not a quote or advice.

How to use it

  1. Pick the plan year. 2026 uses official CMS figures. 2027 uses official drug figures, but the Part A and Part B numbers are a Trustees projection, because CMS had not announced them as of November 16, 2026.
  2. Choose Medigap Plan G, Plan N or no Medigap.
  3. Read the boxes under "Original Medicare" and "Medicare Advantage". Replace every one you can with a quote or a plan document. The Medicare Advantage design, the visit price and the use levels are illustrations, not data about any real plan.
  4. Edit the three use levels: office visits, other doctor and outpatient costs, hospital admissions and full-price drug costs.
  5. Choose which level to see line by line.

How the math works

For each use level the tool prices a year twice.

Original Medicare with Medigap and a drug plan. Part B costs you the deductible and then 20% of the approved amount. Plan G pays that 20% and the Part A deductible. Plan N pays them too, except copays of up to $20 a visit, which the tool caps at the 20% share. Without Medigap you also pay the 20% and one Part A deductible per admission. Premiums are Part B, Medigap and the drug plan, times 12.

Medicare Advantage. You pay the Part B premium and the plan's premium, plus its deductible, copays and coinsurance, capped at its out-of-pocket limit. Drugs use the same Part D rules in both: you pay the deductible, then 25% up to the cap.

Example, 2026 defaults, Plan G, moderate use (8 visits, $4,000 of other services, 1 admission, $3,000 of drugs):

  • Original: Part B $2,435 (12 × $202.90), Plan G $2,328 (12 × $194), drug plan $420, medical $283 (the Part B deductible), drugs $1,211.25. Total about $6,677.
  • Advantage: Part B $2,435, plan $172 (12 × $14.37), drug premium $136, medical $1,920 (8 × $15, $1,000 for the admission, 20% of $4,000), drugs $1,211.25. Total about $5,874.

At light use the totals are about $6,066 and $3,488. At heavy use they are about $7,566 and $12,143. The order flips with use, which is the point of the tool, but the defaults are not a forecast.

What it assumes

  • Doctors accept Medicare's approved amount, so there are no excess charges.
  • Each admission is a new benefit period and lasts under 60 days.
  • Premium starting points: the 2026 Part B premium is from CMS, the Plan G average of $194 is KFF's 2025 figure, the Advantage premiums are CMS averages, and the drug plan premium is CMS's national average.
  • The 2027 Advantage out-of-pocket limit was not found, so the 2026 maximum of $9,250 stands in until you type the real one.

Where it stops being right

  • Networks, prior authorization, and which of your doctors and drugs a plan covers matter more than the totals. The tool cannot see them.
  • Medigap premiums depend on age, state and insurer, and after your Medigap open enrollment window most states let insurers use medical underwriting.
  • Dental, vision, hearing, the emergency room copay under Plan N, and costs outside the network are not modeled.
  • Both choices are for one year. Your next year can differ.

Ask your State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor, Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE for plan-specific answers.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Related guides

Terms used here

Latest on this topic