Guides
How out-of-network claims work: allowed amounts and balance bills
A plan pays an out-of-network claim from its own allowed amount, not the provider's charge, so the provider may bill you the difference.
When you see an out-of-network provider, your plan does not pay a percentage of the provider's bill. It first decides what it considers an acceptable price for the service, called the allowed amount, then pays its share of that figure after your deductible and coinsurance. The provider's charge can be much higher than the allowed amount, and because it has no contract with your plan, it may be free to bill you the difference. That difference is the balance bill.
The three prices on every out-of-network claim
Every claim carries up to three numbers, and confusing them is the main reason these bills surprise people.
- The billed charge. What the provider lists for the service. It is a starting price that few payers ever pay in full.
- The allowed amount. What your plan treats as the eligible price for that service. Out of network, the plan sets this itself. An in-network provider has agreed to the plan's allowed amount as full payment; an out-of-network one has not.
- The patient responsibility. Your deductible, copay or coinsurance applied to the allowed amount, plus any balance bill.
The plan's payment is calculated only from the second number. The rest is your problem unless a law or contract says otherwise.
How plans set the allowed amount
Plans use different formulas, and the plan document or the summary of benefits should say which. Common methods include:
- Usual, customary and reasonable (UCR) rates. A reference built from what providers in the area typically charge for the service. Plans differ in how they build it and where they set it, for example at a chosen percentile of area charges. See usual, customary and reasonable charge.
- A percentage of Medicare rates. Some plans set the allowed amount as a multiple of what Original Medicare would pay.
- A plan fee schedule or a negotiated one-off rate. Some plans pay from their own schedule, and some will negotiate a single-case agreement with a provider.
Because there is no common formula, two plans can allow very different amounts for the same service. Ask the plan how it determines the allowed amount for out-of-network services before a planned procedure, and ask for the answer in writing.
A worked example with round numbers
This is an illustration, not a price. Say you have a plan with a $2,000 out-of-network deductible that you have already met and 40% out-of-network coinsurance. An out-of-network specialist charges $1,200 for a procedure. The plan's allowed amount is $600.
- Your coinsurance: 40% x $600 = $240.
- The plan pays: $600 - $240 = $360.
- The balance bill: $1,200 - $600 = $600.
- You owe the provider: $240 + $600 = $840.
On this claim you owe $840, even though the plan's "40% coinsurance" sounds like $480 on the full $1,200 charge. Had the same provider been in network with the same $600 negotiated rate and 20% coinsurance, you would owe $120 and nothing else.
Now compare a case that falls under federal surprise-billing protection, for instance emergency care at an out-of-network hospital. The same $600 allowed amount would typically leave you owing only your in-network cost sharing, say 20% x $600 = $120, with no balance bill. The plan and the provider sort out the remaining payment between themselves; the federal dispute process is open to them, not to you. The No Surprises Act defines which services qualify.
Where the money may go: plan to you or to the provider
For out-of-network claims some plans send the payment straight to the provider, and some send it to you, leaving you to pay the provider. If you paid up front, you generally have to submit a claim yourself, often with an itemized bill and proof of payment, within the plan's filing deadline. That deadline is in your plan documents; check it as soon as you pay a bill out of network.
Out-of-network spending may count toward a separate out-of-network deductible and limit, or may not count at all toward your in-network out-of-pocket maximum. Balance-billed amounts do not count toward the cap in most plans. Your explanation of benefits shows what the plan applied.
What you can do if the bill is higher than expected
- Match the numbers. Compare the provider's bill with your explanation of benefits line by line. The steps are in How to read an explanation of benefits (EOB) line by line, and the Medical bill and EOB checker helps you spot lines that do not reconcile.
- Ask whether a protection applies. Emergency care, certain out-of-network providers at in-network facilities and air ambulance rides are protected from balance bills under federal law; some states add protections for other situations.
- Ask the plan to reprocess. If an in-network provider was unavailable, or you were not told the provider was out of network, ask for a network exception or an adjustment to the allowed amount.
- Negotiate with the provider. Many providers will accept a lower amount, a payment plan or a discount for prompt payment. See how to negotiate a medical bill: steps and what to say.
- Appeal if the plan denied or underpaid. Use the internal appeal and then external review, as in how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step.
- Contact the state insurance department. It can tell you which rules cover your plan and take complaints. Plans paid for by an employer that pays claims itself are usually regulated by the federal government rather than the state, so the answer depends on the plan.
Key takeaways
- The plan pays from its own allowed amount, not the provider's charge; the gap is the balance bill.
- Plans use different methods to set out-of-network allowed amounts, so ask for the method before planned care.
- Your coinsurance applies to the allowed amount, which usually makes the total bill larger than the coinsurance rate suggests.
- Federal protections cover emergencies, some out-of-network providers at in-network facilities and air ambulances, but not ground ambulances.
- Compare each bill with the explanation of benefits before paying, and ask for an adjustment, a network exception or a lower price when the bill does not match.