Guides

How to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step

Read the denial notice, ask for your file, send a written internal appeal before the deadline with your doctor's support, then use external review if it fails.

To appeal a denied claim, read the denial notice to find the exact reason and the deadline, request a written appeal with your plan, send it before the deadline with supporting records and a letter from your doctor, and keep copies of everything. If the plan upholds its decision, most plans must also offer an independent external review. For most health plans the internal appeal deadline is at least 180 days from the date on the denial notice, but the notice itself states the date that applies to you. The steps below follow the order most people need them.

Step 1: Read the denial notice before you do anything else

A denial is not the end of the claim. It is a decision the plan has to explain in writing. Formally it is called an adverse benefit determination, and the notice should tell you:

  • Which service, date and provider the decision covers.
  • The specific reason, often with a code that the plan's paperwork explains.
  • The plan rule or clinical criteria the plan relied on, which you can ask for free of charge.
  • How to appeal, where to send the appeal, and the deadline.
  • How to reach an independent reviewer or a consumer assistance office.

Check whether the denial is on a claim already paid for (a claim denial after care) or a request before care (a prior authorization denial). The steps are similar, but a pre-care denial may qualify for a faster track. Also compare the notice with your explanation of benefits, because the two documents sometimes use different codes for the same service.

Step 2: Rule out a paperwork problem

Some denials are fixable without a formal appeal. Call the plan and ask whether the claim was coded correctly, whether the provider submitted it with the right diagnosis and procedure, whether a required referral or authorization was on file, and whether the plan has the right information about other coverage you hold. Ask the provider's billing office to resubmit if an error is found. Write down the date, the person's name and what was said, and ask for a reference number.

This call does not replace an appeal and does not stop the deadline clock. If the issue is not resolved quickly, file the appeal. See why health claims get denied: the most common reasons for which reasons can usually be fixed with a corrected claim and which need an argument.

Step 3: Ask for your claim file

You are entitled to a copy of the documents the plan used to decide, without charge, on request. Ask for the claim file, the clinical criteria applied and the name and specialty of any reviewer the plan consulted. These show you exactly what to rebut. If the plan says a service is not medically necessary, the criteria it used are the document to argue against.

Step 4: Gather support

A strong packet usually includes:

  • A copy of the denial notice and the explanation of benefits.
  • A letter from the treating doctor explaining why the service is needed for you, what was tried before and what could happen without it.
  • The relevant medical records, test results and notes, not the entire chart.
  • The plan's own policy language or your summary of benefits, if it supports coverage.
  • Any published clinical guideline the doctor cites.

Ask the provider's office early. Doctors' offices handle many such requests, and the letter often takes the longest. how to write a health insurance appeal letter that gets read covers what the letter itself should contain.

Step 5: File the internal appeal in writing

Send the appeal by the method the notice names. Keep proof of delivery: certified mail, a fax confirmation, or a portal confirmation you screenshot. Put your name, member ID, claim number, the date of service and the denial date at the top. State plainly what you are asking for, such as payment of the claim or approval of the service. If the care is urgent and a delay could seriously harm your health, say so and ask for an expedited review. Group plans generally must decide an urgent appeal within 72 hours, and your doctor can usually request it for you.

You may ask the plan to review the appeal again with a different reviewer than the one who made the first decision. Plans are generally required to use someone who was not involved in the original denial, and not that person's subordinate.

Deadlines and decision times at a glance

These are the usual outer limits for non-grandfathered private plans under federal rules. Your plan's notice controls, and state rules, Medicare, Medicaid and some other plans differ.

Stage Typical limit
File the internal appeal At least 180 days from the denial notice
Plan decides an urgent appeal 72 hours
Plan decides a standard appeal before care 30 days
Plan decides an appeal of a claim for care you already received 60 days
Request external review after the final internal denial Generally 4 months

appeal and external review deadlines: how many days you have explains each limit, and appeal and external review deadline calculator counts days from your notice date.

A worked example with round numbers

This is an illustration, not a prediction. Say a plan denies a $6,000 outpatient procedure because it was "not medically necessary." The notice is dated March 1. Say the patient asks for the criteria on March 5, the office sends a doctor's letter by March 25, and the appeal is mailed with delivery confirmation on April 1. That is day 31 of a 180-day window, well inside the limit. The plan upholds the denial on May 15, citing the same criteria. The patient then asks for external review within the four-month window, with the same doctor's letter and one added guideline. An independent reviewer decides without regard to the plan's earlier conclusion. If the reviewer sides with the patient, the plan is generally bound by that decision.

If the internal appeal fails

The final denial letter should explain external review, a process in which an independent reviewer outside the plan examines the case. See external review explained: when an independent reviewer decides for who qualifies and how binding the result is. You can also complain to your state insurance department, which can look into whether the plan followed the rules (how to file a complaint with your state insurance department). If your coverage comes from an employer, the employer's benefits office or the U.S. Department of Labor's benefits assistance can sometimes help. For a particular case, a licensed broker, a patient advocate or a lawyer can advise you.

Key takeaways

  • The denial notice states the reason and your deadline: read it first.
  • Most plans give at least 180 days to appeal internally, so there is usually time to build a careful packet.
  • Ask for your claim file and the criteria the plan used, free of charge.
  • A doctor's letter and focused records matter more than a long letter.
  • If the plan upholds the denial, independent external review is generally the next step.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic