Glossary
Independent dispute resolution (IDR)
The process under the No Surprises Act where a neutral entity settles payment disagreements between a health plan and an out-of-network provider.
Also called: IDR, federal IDR process, arbitration for out-of-network payment
Independent dispute resolution is how a plan and an out-of-network provider settle how much the provider should be paid when a surprise bill situation arises and the two sides cannot agree. It applies to services covered by the federal protections, such as emergency care and certain care at in-network facilities. It is a dispute between the plan and the provider or air ambulance company. You, the patient, are not a party and are not asked to pay more.
After a required period of negotiation, either side can start the process. A certified IDR entity, a neutral outside organization, receives each side's proposed payment amount and generally picks one of the two, considering the qualifying payment amount and other factors such as the provider's experience and the complexity of the case. The decision binds the parties, and the losing party typically pays the entity's fee.
Patients sometimes confuse this with their own right to dispute a bill that is far above a good faith estimate, which is a separate process for uninsured and self-pay patients.
Your part is to confirm you were billed only your in-network cost sharing. In October 2026 CMS convened certified IDR entities to discuss improving the program, so details may change. The CMS site lists the current process.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026