Guides

What does health insurance cover and what is left out?

Health plans sort care into covered, covered with limits and excluded. Learn how to tell which is which and where your plan writes it down.

Health insurance covers care that the plan's contract lists as a benefit, that a provider in the plan's rules delivers, and that meets the plan's definition of medically necessary. Care falls into three groups: covered, covered with limits, and excluded. Doctor visits, hospital stays, emergency care, prescriptions and preventive services are covered by most major medical plans. Cosmetic procedures, long-term custodial care and treatments the plan calls experimental are commonly left out. Exactly where a service lands depends on your plan, so the plan's own documents are the final word.

The three groups

Covered. The plan lists the service as a benefit and pays its share once any deductible, copay or coinsurance applies. Covered does not mean free. It means the plan shares the cost under the rules in your Summary of Benefits and Coverage.

Covered with limits. The plan pays only if a condition is met. Typical conditions include:

  • Authorization. The plan must approve the service in advance. See prior authorization.
  • Medical necessity. The plan covers the service only when it judges it appropriate for your condition under accepted standards.
  • Visit or day caps. A set number of physical therapy visits, for example, or a limited number of days in a rehabilitation facility.
  • Drug rules. A medicine is covered only if it is on the plan's formulary, and the plan may require you to try a cheaper drug first, or limit the quantity per month.
  • Network rules. The plan pays fully, partly or not at all depending on whether the provider is in its network.

Excluded. The plan states it will not pay at all. You owe the entire bill, and the money does not count toward your deductible or out-of-pocket maximum. Common exclusions on major medical plans include cosmetic surgery done only to change appearance, custodial long-term care (help with bathing, dressing and eating), treatments the plan considers experimental or investigational, and non-emergency care outside the country. Many medical plans also leave out adult routine dental, vision and hearing care, which are often sold as separate policies; see dental insurance explained: plans, waiting periods and annual limits.

What the law makes mandatory

Individual and small-group plans under the Affordable Care Act must cover ten categories of essential health benefits, and non-grandfathered plans must cover recommended preventive care without charging you cost sharing when you use an in-network provider. Large employer plans, including self-funded ones, are not required to cover the same ten-category package, although they must follow other federal rules, such as covering preventive services and not placing annual or lifetime dollar limits on essential benefits they do cover. Short-term plans and health care sharing ministries do not have to follow these benefit rules at all. The guide on Essential health benefits: the 10 categories ACA plans must cover covers the ten categories in detail.

Two situations that surprise people

Emergency care. Under the federal rules for non-grandfathered plans, emergency services are covered without prior authorization and without a network penalty when a person with an average knowledge of health believes the situation is an emergency (the "prudent layperson" standard). The plan cannot deny the claim because the final diagnosis turned out to be minor. What you may still owe is ordinary cost sharing.

Medical necessity is the plan's definition. Two plans can treat the same service differently because each defines "medically necessary" in its contract, usually by reference to accepted standards of care. If a plan says a service is not necessary, you generally have the right to ask for the criteria it used and to appeal; the guide on why health claims get denied: the most common reasons shows how the process starts.

A worked example with made-up plan rules

Say a hypothetical plan has these rules. A knee replacement is covered with prior authorization. A cosmetic nose reshaping is excluded. A diabetes drug is covered on tier 2 of the formulary. Here is how three services might play out for someone on that plan.

Service Plan treats it as What the member should do Result if skipped
Knee replacement Covered with limits (prior authorization) Ask the surgeon's office to request approval first The plan may deny the claim even though the surgery is a covered benefit
Cosmetic nose reshaping Excluded Plan to pay the full price, or skip it No coverage in any case
Diabetes drug Covered, tier 2 Fill it at an in-network pharmacy Out-of-network pharmacy may pay less

Notice that "covered" and "approved for this claim" are different questions. A claim can be denied because a step was skipped, even though the service itself is a benefit. Skipped steps are a common reason claims are denied.

Where to read your plan's list

  1. Summary of Benefits and Coverage. A standard four-page document every plan must provide, with common services, cost sharing and a few examples. Start here; How to read a Summary of Benefits and Coverage explains how to read it.
  2. Evidence of Coverage or certificate of coverage. The full contract. Look for the sections called "Covered services," "Exclusions" and "Limitations."
  3. The formulary. The plan's drug list, with tiers and restrictions. Insurers publish it online.
  4. The provider directory and member services. To confirm that a specific doctor, test or procedure is covered, call the number on your card and ask. Write down the date, the person's name and what they said.

Before a planned procedure, ask the plan three things: is the service covered, does it need prior authorization, and is my provider in network. The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet gives you a place to record the answers.

Key takeaways

  • Care falls into covered, covered with limits and excluded; excluded services cost you the whole bill and do not count toward your caps.
  • "Covered" can still be denied if you skip a step such as prior authorization or use an out-of-network provider.
  • ACA individual and small-group plans must cover ten benefit categories; short-term plans and sharing ministries do not have to.
  • The Summary of Benefits and Coverage is the quickest place to check; the full contract's exclusions section is the final word.
  • Ask the plan directly before expensive care, and keep a record of the answer.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic