Blog

After an abnormal mammogram, what does insurance pay for next?

Timeline from screening mammogram to callback, ultrasound, MRI, biopsy and pathology: which steps are preventive, where cost sharing starts, how to log claims.

The call or letter says the screening mammogram showed something that needs another look. Most callbacks turn out not to be cancer, but the steps that follow are billed differently from the screening that started them, and the costs can add up quickly even when the answer is good. The screening itself is the preventive step, and plans must cover it without cost sharing when it is in network and you are in the recommended group. Almost everything after it is generally treated as diagnostic, which means the deductible, copays and coinsurance come into play.

This post follows the usual sequence in order, says which steps are billed as preventive and which as diagnostic, shows where cost sharing begins with a worked example, and ends with a way to keep a running list of claims so the bills make sense. It describes how coverage generally works. Your plan, your state's laws and your clinicians decide the details, and none of this is medical advice about what tests you need.

Step 1: the screening mammogram, the preventive step

A screening mammogram is a test for a person with no symptoms. Under the Affordable Care Act's preventive-services rule, non-grandfathered private plans cover recommended screenings with no cost sharing at in-network providers. The plan's preventive list says the ages and intervals it applies. See Free preventive care under the ACA: what is covered at no cost and preventive care. Two things can make the screening itself carry a charge:

  • An out-of-network facility. The no-cost rule applies in network.
  • Extras. Some plans treat 3D mammography (tomosynthesis) the same as standard screening, and some state laws require that. Others bill it differently. Ask before the appointment whether the technology the facility uses is covered as screening.

If the facility says it will "read the screening and call you back if there is a problem," ask whether it can tell you, before you book, how it bills the additional images when a callback happens on the same day. Some facilities do a diagnostic workup on the spot. That convenience is also what turns a $0 appointment into a bill, because the screening and the extra views may be billed as two services.

Step 2: the callback and the diagnostic mammogram

A callback usually means more images of one area: extra views, magnification or compression. Because these are done to evaluate a finding, they are billed as a diagnostic mammogram. A diagnostic mammogram is covered under your plan's diagnostic imaging benefit, which means your deductible, copay or coinsurance applies. Some states have passed laws that limit or remove cost sharing for diagnostic breast imaging, and some plans waive it voluntarily. Federal rules on how much of the follow-up counts as part of the screening have been moving, so ask the plan how it treats the callback for your plan year, and ask your state insurance department whether a state law adds protection for your type of plan.

Questions to ask the plan:

  1. Is a diagnostic mammogram subject to my deductible, or is it a copay service?
  2. Is there a state or plan rule that waives cost sharing for a callback after an abnormal screening?
  3. Which facilities are in network for diagnostic imaging? A hospital outpatient department may bill a facility fee in addition to the radiologist's fee.

Write down the date of the screening, the date of the callback and the findings the letter gave. If a claim is later processed as diagnostic when you believe it should be part of the screening, those dates help.

Step 3: ultrasound

Breast ultrasound is often the next step, either right after the diagnostic mammogram or on another day. It is billed as a diagnostic service. Plans differ on whether ultrasound is a copay service, a deductible service or a coinsurance service, and on whether it is billed by the facility, the radiologist or both. Ask the facility, in advance, what it expects to bill, and then ask the plan what it allows for those services.

An ultrasound may be done in the same session as the diagnostic mammogram. If so, check the explanation of benefits to see whether the plan processed them as two services with two cost-sharing amounts. A same-day pair can have a combined charge or two separate charges, and you want to know which.

Step 4: breast MRI and prior authorization

If the images are not conclusive, or if you have a higher-than-average risk, a clinician may order a breast MRI. Most plans require prior authorization for MRI. The ordering clinic usually submits the request, but you can protect yourself with a few steps. My doctor ordered an MRI: does it need prior authorization first? covers the process in detail; the short version is below.

  • Ask the clinic whether the request was submitted and get the reference number.
  • Ask the plan whether the approval names the facility where the MRI will be done. An approval for one facility may not apply to another, and a hospital and a freestanding imaging center can be priced very differently.
  • Ask whether the plan has a preferred network for advanced imaging. Plans sometimes steer MRIs to specific sites with lower cost sharing.
  • If the situation is urgent, ask the clinic to request an expedited review. A plan generally has to decide an urgent request faster than a routine one. how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied explains the process.

A denial is not final. It starts the appeal process, and the clinician's letter explaining why the MRI is needed is often the most important document.

Step 5: the biopsy

A biopsy removes a small sample of tissue for testing. A needle biopsy is often guided by ultrasound, mammography or MRI. It is billed as a diagnostic or surgical procedure, with separate charges that can include the facility, the radiologist or surgeon who performs it, the imaging guidance and sometimes a marker placed in the breast. Prior authorization may apply, and the plan may treat the biopsy as an outpatient procedure under a different cost-sharing line than imaging.

In many plans the biopsy is where the deductible is finally exhausted, so the bills that follow may be cheaper. In plans with high deductibles, the sum of the earlier steps can bring the patient to the deductible just before the biopsy. Section "The money: a worked example" below shows how that works.

If you have choices about where the biopsy is done, compare the facility's network status first, then ask for a cost estimate. A person with insurance can ask the provider for the expected billing codes and the plan for the allowed amount. The in-network vs out-of-network care: what it means for your bill guide covers what network status does to the bill.

Step 6: pathology, and where it is read

The tissue goes to a pathologist, and the pathologist's report is the result. Pathology is billed by the lab or the pathology group, separate from the biopsy. The lab is often chosen by the facility or the doctor who did the procedure, not by you, and it may not be in your network even if the facility is.

You can reduce the chance of a surprise by asking two questions before the biopsy. Which lab will read the tissue? Is that lab in network for my plan? If the lab is not in network, ask whether the tissue can be sent to an in-network lab instead. This is often possible when asked early.

The No Surprises Act protects patients from some out-of-network bills for services such as pathology and radiology when they are provided in connection with a visit to an in-network hospital or similar facility. The protection depends on where and how the service was delivered, so it is not a guarantee for every lab bill. See No Surprises Act and Surprise medical bills and the No Surprises Act: what is protected. Before paying any out-of-network pathology bill, check whether the protections apply.

The money: a worked example

Say Maya has a plan with a $2,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance after the deductible and a $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum. In January she gets an in-network screening mammogram and pays $0. A callback follows in February. All figures are round-number illustrations of the plan's allowed amounts.

Step Allowed amount Maya owes Deductible left after
Diagnostic mammogram $250 $250 $1,750
Ultrasound $300 $300 $1,450
MRI $1,400 $1,400 $50
Biopsy $1,000 $50 + 20% of $950 = $240 $0
Pathology $450 20% of $450 = $90 $0
Total $3,400 $2,280

Check the arithmetic. The deductible portion is $250 + $300 + $1,400 + $50 = $2,000. The coinsurance base after the deductible is $950 + $450 = $1,400, and 20% of $1,400 is $280. Add $2,000 and $280 and the total is $2,280. The out-of-pocket maximum of $6,000 is far away, so nothing is capped.

Now change one thing. In a second case, Maya's state has a law that removes cost sharing for diagnostic breast imaging, and her plan applies it to the diagnostic mammogram and the ultrasound. The first two lines drop to $0 and the deductible has $2,000 left before the MRI. The MRI of $1,400 is entirely deductible, leaving $600. The biopsy of $1,000 uses the remaining $600 and then 20% of $400, which is $80, so Maya owes $680 for the biopsy. Pathology owes $90. Her total is $1,400 + $680 + $90 = $2,170. The rule would have saved her $110 in this illustration, not as much as a reader might expect, because the MRI and biopsy still count. Laws like this matter most for people with high deductibles and copay plans where each imaging step carries a flat copay.

A final point is timing. If the callback begins in late December and the biopsy happens in January, the deductible resets, and the same bills can cost more or less depending on where they fall. A clinician can sometimes schedule a nonurgent step earlier or later, but nobody should delay a test a clinician says is urgent to save money. Ask the clinician what the time frame is.

Keep a running list of claims

During a workup there are many small claims from many places, and they arrive over weeks. A running list shows where you are against the deductible and makes duplicated or miscoded lines easy to find. A simple table with these columns works.

  • Date of service
  • Provider and facility
  • Service
  • Billed amount (from the bill)
  • Allowed amount and amount applied to the deductible (from the explanation of benefits)
  • What you owe, and what you paid
  • Network status
  • Notes (reference numbers, call dates)

Match each bill to an explanation of benefits before paying, and watch for the same service billed twice, a screening billed as diagnostic, a different lab than you expected and charges from an out-of-network provider. The deductible and out-of-pocket tracker and how to track your deductible and out-of-pocket spending show how to keep the running total, and the out-of-pocket maximum, in view. When your total reaches the out-of-pocket maximum, the plan pays covered in-network services in full for the rest of the plan year.

If the results lead to a diagnosis and treatment, I was just diagnosed with cancer, what do I check about insurance first? covers what to do in the first weeks. If a bill from this workup seems wrong, the steps in Is a screening colonoscopy really free? Claims checked against the bill for finding a miscoded claim apply here too.

Where to get help

  • The plan's member services can say how it processes each step and which facilities and labs are in network. Get a reference number.
  • The facility's billing office can give estimates and can resubmit a miscoded claim.
  • A hospital social worker or financial counselor can explain financial assistance programs for the facility.
  • Your state insurance department can say whether a state law reduces cost sharing for breast imaging and takes complaints about a plan's processing.
  • A navigator or your employer's benefits office can help you read your plan documents.

Key takeaways

  • The screening mammogram is the preventive step and is covered without cost sharing in network. The callback imaging, biopsy and pathology that follow are generally diagnostic, so deductibles, copays and coinsurance apply.
  • Some states and some plans reduce or remove cost sharing for diagnostic breast imaging. Ask the plan and the state insurance department about your plan year, because the rules are changing and vary by plan type.
  • Breast MRI usually needs prior authorization, and the approval can name a specific facility. Confirm both before the appointment.
  • Ask who will read the biopsy tissue and whether the lab is in network before the procedure, because the pathology bill is the one most likely to come from an unexpected provider.
  • A running list of every claim, matched to explanations of benefits, shows how close you are to the deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum and catches coding errors early.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic