Blog

Why can the same surgery cost me less at a surgery center than a hospital?

A surgery center and a hospital outpatient department can perform the same procedure at very different facility prices; here is why, and how to compare them.

Two facilities can offer the same colonoscopy, cataract removal or knee arthroscopy on the same morning, and the plan's allowed amount for the facility can differ by thousands of dollars. The surgeon's skill may be the same. What differs is the type of facility, how it is paid, what it must staff and keep ready for emergencies, and what your plan negotiated with it.

This post compares an ambulatory surgery center (ASC) with a hospital outpatient department (HOPD), shows the deductible and coinsurance arithmetic with invented numbers, lists the questions that bear on safety and billing, and says which patients may be better off at the hospital even when it costs more.

What each setting is

An ambulatory surgery center is a licensed or certified facility that does planned surgeries and procedures where the patient goes home the same day. It has operating rooms and recovery space but no emergency department, no inpatient beds and no intensive care unit. Many are owned by physicians, by hospital systems, by companies that run many centers or by combinations of these.

A hospital outpatient department is part of a hospital, on its main campus or in a building the hospital owns elsewhere, where patients have procedures without being admitted. It can draw on the hospital's blood bank, intensive care unit, pharmacy and on-call specialists if something goes wrong.

The ownership detail matters for billing. A surgery center owned by a hospital system is sometimes operated and billed as a hospital outpatient department even though it looks like a freestanding clinic. Whether a given location bills as an ASC or an HOPD is something to ask, not assume. The facility's billing office can say which it is, and your plan's customer service can say how it processes each.

Why the price differs

Insurers and Medicare pay facilities under different payment methods, and hospitals carry costs that surgery centers do not. The main reasons the facility charge differs:

  • Facility fees. A facility fee is the charge for the use of the building, equipment, nurses and supplies, separate from the surgeon's and anesthesiologist's professional fees. Hospital facility fees generally reflect the costs of standing capacity, such as 24-hour emergency readiness, and the hospital's higher overhead. Critics of the difference argue it can reflect market power and not extra care; hospitals respond that the fees pay for services that all patients benefit from having available.
  • Negotiated rates. Under a commercial plan, each facility has its own contract with the insurer, and the resulting allowed amount for the same procedure code can be very different between an in-network ASC and an in-network hospital. The contract is not public in full, though price-transparency rules require hospitals and plans to publish some rates.
  • Medicare payment. Medicare pays ASCs and HOPDs through separate payment systems, and for many procedures the ASC rate is lower. The patient's coinsurance is a percentage of the payment, so a lower payment means a lower coinsurance bill as well.
  • Case mix. Surgery centers usually take lower-risk, shorter procedures, so a comparison of averages can overstate the difference for a particular patient.

Side-by-side comparison

Factor Ambulatory surgery center Hospital outpatient department
Typical facility price Usually lower for the same procedure Usually higher, often with a separate facility fee
Same-day discharge Required; no inpatient beds Same-day or overnight stay possible
Emergency backup Transfer agreement with a nearby hospital Hospital resources on site
Procedures offered Planned, lower-risk procedures Wider range, including complex cases
Anesthesia and surgeon Billed separately; may or may not be in network Billed separately; may or may not be in network
Billing status Depends on ownership; some are billed as hospital departments Hospital billing rules
Scheduling Often easier and faster Often depends on operating-room availability

Read the second row of the table as a statement about structure and not quality. The right choice depends on the patient, not the label.

How your deductible and coinsurance turn the gap into dollars

A lower allowed amount helps most when you have not met your deductible or when coinsurance applies. Here is a worked illustration. The numbers are invented and round; real prices vary widely and some plans use flat copays for surgeries.

Say Priya has a plan with a $3,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance and a $7,000 out-of-pocket maximum. She has paid $1,000 toward the deductible this year, so $2,000 remains. Her doctor recommends a knee arthroscopy and both the surgery center and the hospital are in her network.

At the surgery center. The plan's allowed amount for the facility is $4,000.

  1. The first $2,000 goes to the remaining deductible: Priya pays $2,000.
  2. The remaining $2,000 is subject to 20% coinsurance: $2,000 × 0.20 = $400.
  3. Priya's facility cost: $2,000 + $400 = $2,400.

At the hospital outpatient department. The allowed amount for the facility is $7,500.

  1. Deductible: $2,000.
  2. Remaining: $7,500 − $2,000 = $5,500, and 20% of $5,500 = $1,100.
  3. Priya's facility cost: $2,000 + $1,100 = $3,100.

The difference is $3,100 − $2,400 = $700 for Priya. The plan pays $4,000 − $2,400 = $1,600 at the surgery center and $7,500 − $3,100 = $4,400 at the hospital, a gap of $2,800 that Priya never sees on her own bill but that shows up in premiums over time.

Now change one assumption. If Priya had already met her deductible, the arithmetic becomes simple coinsurance: 20% of $4,000 is $800 at the surgery center and 20% of $7,500 is $1,500 at the hospital, a gap of $700 again. If she had been close to her out-of-pocket maximum, the gap could disappear because both bills would hit the same ceiling. The surgeon's and anesthesiologist's fees are separate and are not included here; they are often the same at both sites if the same doctors work at both. The out-of-pocket maximum caps what she pays for covered in-network care in the plan year, which is why the order of the year's bills matters.

Network status comes before price

A cheaper facility is not cheaper if it is out of your plan's network. Check three separate things, because each can be in or out of network on its own:

  1. The facility itself.
  2. The surgeon.
  3. The anesthesia group, which is often a separate company that contracts with the facility.

The federal No Surprises Act protects patients from most surprise out-of-network bills when a patient goes to an in-network hospital, hospital outpatient department or ambulatory surgical center and an out-of-network provider is involved, such as an anesthesiologist the patient did not choose. See Surprise medical bills and the No Surprises Act: what is protected for what it covers and what it does not. It does not help if you choose an out-of-network facility on purpose. For the basics of network rules, see in-network vs out-of-network care: what it means for your bill.

When you call to verify, ask for the plan's answer and the date and the name of the person who gave it, and ask the facility to confirm the same three entities. A good faith estimate is the written estimate a facility must give an uninsured or self-pay patient before scheduled care. If you are using insurance, ask the plan for a cost estimate through its member portal or customer service instead.

Safety questions to ask any facility

Lower cost should not come at the price of preparedness. These are questions a patient can reasonably ask a surgery center or a surgeon's office, and they apply to hospitals as well:

  1. Is the facility licensed in this state and certified by Medicare? Licensing rules for surgery centers vary by state.
  2. Is it accredited? Accrediting organizations such as The Joint Commission and the Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care review ASCs; ask which one and whether it is current.
  3. What happens in an emergency? Ask whether there is a written transfer agreement with a nearby hospital and how long a transfer typically takes.
  4. Does my surgeon have privileges at a hospital? Surgeons who do their cases at a surgery center often also have admitting privileges at a hospital, which helps if the patient needs to be admitted.
  5. Who gives the anesthesia and what type is planned? Ask about the anesthesia plan for your health conditions.
  6. What is the policy if I need to stay overnight? Some centers have short recovery stays; others do not.
  7. Does the surgeon or any other clinician own part of the facility? Many do, and it is legal and common, but it is a fair question; the answer helps you weigh a recommendation.
  8. How many times has the center done this procedure and what is its infection and transfer rate? A good center can answer or point you to published measures. If it cannot, that is information too.

Who may be better off at the hospital

A lower price does not make the surgery center the better fit for everyone. Patients whose doctors may suggest a hospital setting even for a procedure that is routine for others include:

  • People with serious heart, lung or kidney disease, or poorly controlled diabetes, where the anesthesiologist wants backup resources.
  • People with severe obstructive sleep apnea or other airway issues that make anesthesia riskier.
  • People on blood thinners or with bleeding disorders where the risk of complications is higher.
  • People whose procedure may turn out to need more than planned, such as a diagnostic procedure that may become a larger operation.
  • People who will need an overnight stay or monitoring afterward.
  • Children and older adults whose care may call for a facility with specialized staff, depending on the center.

The surgeon and the anesthesiologist make that call based on the patient's health history, and a patient who asks "Is this a good fit for a surgery center, and why or why not?" usually gets a straight answer. In an ideal case the choice of site is a medical decision first and a cost decision second.

A reasoned case for and against surgery centers

The case in favor is that moving suitable, planned procedures out of the hospital lowers the price per procedure for patients and plans, reduces waits and keeps beds and operating rooms available for complex cases. Many patients report that centers are smaller and easier to get through.

The case against, as critics put it, is that centers may attract the healthiest and best-insured patients, leaving hospitals with riskier cases and a higher average cost; that physician ownership can create an incentive to refer patients to centers they own; and that lower prices at the center can sit alongside higher volume. Supporters respond that the safety record for appropriate cases is good and the savings are real. Neither side is a reason to skip the individual checks above.

A short process for comparing two facilities

  1. Ask your surgeon which facilities they use and which, if any, they believe suit your health history.
  2. Confirm network status for the facility, the surgeon and the anesthesia group, with the plan.
  3. Ask the plan for the estimated allowed amount and your share at each, using the procedure code your surgeon's office gives you.
  4. Ask the facility whether it bills as an ASC or a hospital outpatient department and whether a separate facility fee applies.
  5. Check how much of your deductible and out-of-pocket maximum remains with the health insurance cost estimator or your plan's portal, since the dollar gap depends on it.
  6. Decide with your surgeon, weighing price against health risks, and keep the estimates in writing.

If a bill later looks higher than the estimate, how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan describes how to plan a year's spending and you can ask for an itemized bill. Read the post on Why does it matter whether I was admitted or kept 'in observation'? if a procedure turns into an overnight stay, because the status the hospital assigns then changes how it is billed.

Key takeaways

  • An ambulatory surgery center and a hospital outpatient department can perform the same procedure, but they bill under different rules, often with a hospital facility fee that the center does not charge.
  • Under a deductible-and-coinsurance plan, a lower allowed amount cuts your share in proportion; in the worked example the gap was $700 for the patient and $2,800 for the plan.
  • Verify network status for the facility, the surgeon and the anesthesia group separately, and ask whether a hospital-owned center bills as a hospital department.
  • Ask about licensing, accreditation, emergency transfer arrangements and hospital privileges before booking anywhere.
  • People with significant heart, lung or airway conditions or a likely need for overnight care may be better served at a hospital, and that decision belongs to the surgeon and anesthesiologist.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic