Blog
Can I change my work health plan in the middle of the year?
Twelve questions employees ask mid-year, answered with the cafeteria plan consistent-change rule, the usual 30-day window and what to ask HR.
Usually not, and the reason is built into the tax rules rather than the whim of your employer. Most work health plans let you make choices once a year, at open enrollment, and then hold those choices for the plan year. The exceptions are specific life events, and they come with short deadlines. The questions below are the ones employees ask most often once the year is under way.
Two ideas explain nearly every answer. The first is the consistent-change rule: if your premium is paid pretax through a cafeteria plan (often called a Section 125 plan), the tax rules generally let you change your election mid-year only because of a recognized event, and only in a way that fits the event. The second is special enrollment: separate federal rules for group health plans require the plan to open a window after certain events, commonly marriage, a birth or adoption, and loss of other coverage. The window is often 30 days, and some plans allow longer. Your plan's documents set the exact rules.
What counts as a mid-year event
1. What are the events that let me change my work plan mid-year?
The list varies by plan, but these are the standard ones:
- Marriage, divorce or legal separation
- Birth, adoption or placement of a child for adoption
- Death of a spouse or dependent
- A change in employment status for you, your spouse or a dependent that affects eligibility for coverage (starting or losing a job, going from full time to part time)
- A dependent gaining or losing eligibility, such as a child turning 26
- Loss of other coverage, or gaining other coverage through a spouse's or parent's plan
- A move that changes which plan options are available to you
- Certain changes to the plan itself, such as the employer dropping an option or a significant change in cost or coverage
HR can show you the plan's list. If your event is not on it, the answer is generally no, and you wait for open enrollment. The special enrollment periods explained: qualifying life events and deadlines guide covers the same idea for marketplace plans, where the rules are different.
2. What does "consistent with the event" mean?
The change you make has to match what happened. A baby is born, so you may add the baby and, if the plan allows, move to a higher coverage tier. A baby does not generally let you switch from a PPO to an HMO just because you would now prefer one, unless the plan chooses to allow it. If your spouse loses their job, you may add the spouse, because the loss of spouse coverage is consistent with adding coverage. Dropping your own coverage in that situation would not be consistent.
Think of it as asking: "Would this event, on its own, explain this change?" If the answer is no, HR will usually decline.
3. How long do I have to ask?
Often 30 days from the event, sometimes 60 days when the plan or state rules are more generous. For some events involving public programs, such as losing Medicaid or CHIP coverage, federal rules give a longer window of 60 days. The plan's enrollment materials state the deadline, and the day counting starts on the event date, not on the day you hear about the rule. If the window is close, ask HR to confirm the date in writing. The newborn and life event coverage deadline calculator can help you count days.
Specific situations
4. I got married. Can I add my spouse and change anything else?
Yes, you can generally add a new spouse within the window, usually 30 days from the wedding. Coverage under the federal special enrollment rules starts no later than the first day of the month after the plan receives your completed request, though a plan can offer an earlier date. You may also be able to move to a different tier. Whether you can change plan options depends on the plan. The walkthrough in I just got married, so how do I add my spouse to my work health plan? follows a newlywed through the documents and dates.
5. We are having a baby. What should we expect?
A birth, adoption or placement for adoption is one of the strongest events. Under the special enrollment rules, coverage for the new child generally begins on the date of birth, adoption or placement, as long as you enroll within the window. That is why you should not wait for the birth certificate; the plan will ask for documentation, but you can usually start the paperwork earlier. If you are the parent who gave birth, the plan's maternity coverage applies under your own existing enrollment. The adding a baby to your health insurance: deadlines and steps guide covers what to submit and when.
6. My spouse lost their job and their coverage. Can I add them?
Usually yes, if your plan covers spouses. Loss of other coverage is a recognized event, and many plans allow 30 days from the date the coverage ended (or from the date of the notice, so read the plan carefully). You may also have to pick between adding the spouse to your plan, COBRA through their former employer and a marketplace plan. The My spouse was laid off, so do I add them, use COBRA or go to the marketplace? post works through three households.
7. Our premium just went up sharply. Can I switch to a cheaper option or drop coverage?
Maybe. The tax rules let a plan allow a change when the cost of coverage rises significantly, but they do not require the plan to do so. If your plan allows it, you could move to a similar option with a lower cost, or in some cases drop coverage if another option is not available. Employers that make a small increase, or that change premiums at the start of a new plan year, do not trigger this. Ask HR whether the plan includes a cost-change provision, and what the plan means by "significant."
Dropping employer coverage because it costs too much does not by itself open a marketplace special enrollment period; check HealthCare.gov for the current rules before relying on it. A marketplace credit may also be unavailable if the employer plan is deemed affordable. Our guide on employer coverage vs marketplace coverage: how to decide explains the test.
8. My employer dropped the plan option I was in. What now?
When a plan option goes away, you are generally allowed to pick from the remaining options during the same period the employer sets for the change. A change like this is typically handled by an announcement and a short election window. If the employer is ending its entire group plan mid-year, the picture is very different. My employer is ending its health plan mid-year, so what should I expect? explains that case.
9. My child turns 26 next month. What happens?
Coverage for a dependent child generally ends when the child turns 26, but the exact end date, such as the birthday itself, the end of that month, or December 31, depends on the plan. The dependent coverage to age 26 rule requires plans that offer dependent coverage to extend it to age 26, not beyond, unless the plan or the state sets a later age. The child has options, including COBRA, a special enrollment period for a marketplace plan, a job-based plan of their own or Medicaid. Our guide staying on a parent's health plan until age 26: the rules has the rules, and my child turns 26 next month, so what happens to coverage at my job? gives a timeline.
10. We are moving. Does that let me change plans?
A move can be a qualifying event if it changes which options are available to you, for example, you move out of an HMO's service area. A move within the same area usually does not. Moving often creates a network problem even when the plan still covers you: your doctors may now be far away. If you are moving between states, the health insurance when moving states: what carries over and what does not guide is the better starting point, because employer coverage, marketplace coverage and Medicaid each treat a move differently.
Rules to know
11. Can I change my HSA or FSA contributions mid-year?
They follow different rules. A health savings account contribution through payroll can generally be raised, lowered or stopped at any time, going forward, subject to how often your employer's payroll system processes changes; your employer may limit it to a certain number of changes. A health flexible spending account is a cafeteria plan benefit, so the consistent-change rule applies. A new baby or a change in spouse coverage might allow a change, but a general wish to put in more money will not. The tax limits are set each year by the IRS; HR or the plan's summary shows the current numbers.
12. What happens if I miss the window?
The usual answer is that you wait until the next open enrollment, with coverage starting at the beginning of the next plan year. For an employer plan, the open enrollment period is set by the employer, so ask when it is. In the meantime you may need another source of coverage, such as a spouse's plan, a marketplace plan (if you qualify for a special enrollment period), Medicaid or COBRA. For the case of a missed 30-day window for a new dependent, see I missed my work's 30-day window to add a dependent, so what can I do now?.
A dated example of the window
Say Jordan marries on Saturday, June 6, and her plan allows 30 days for special enrollment after marriage. Counting from June 6, the last day is July 6 (June has 30 days, so June 6 plus 30 days lands on July 6). If Jordan turns in the completed form and the marriage certificate on June 20, the new spouse's coverage can start no later than July 1 under the federal rule. If she waits until July 2, the form is late by the plan's count, and she would be looking at the next open enrollment or another event. Plans can be more generous, and some give 60 days: on the same wedding date, 60 days runs to August 5. The date to trust is the one in your plan's documents. The dates and names here are invented.
What to ask HR
When an event happens, send the questions in writing so you have a record:
- What is the deadline to make a change because of this event, and how is it counted?
- What documents do I need to send (marriage certificate, birth record, a letter showing loss of other coverage)?
- What coverage tiers and plan options can I pick?
- When does the new coverage start, and will my deductible carry over for the people already enrolled?
- How will the premium change, and from which paycheck?
- Will I receive written confirmation, and by when?
Not sure which rule applies?
The plan's summary plan description spells out the events and deadlines. If the plan is subject to state insurance rules, the state insurance department can explain them. If a deadline passes and you believe HR gave wrong information, ask the plan's appeals process and, if needed, the U.S. Department of Labor's benefits advisors. A waiting period for new employees is a separate rule; see the plan documents.
Key takeaways
- Mid-year changes to a work health plan generally require a recognized event, such as marriage, a birth, a dependent gaining or losing eligibility, or loss of other coverage, and the change must fit the event.
- The window is commonly 30 days and sometimes longer, counted from the event; get the deadline in writing.
- Coverage for a new baby generally starts at birth, while coverage after marriage generally starts no later than the first of the month after the request.
- Employers are not required to allow every change the tax rules permit, so the plan's own rules decide cost-change and option-change requests.
- If you miss the window, the next open enrollment is the usual fallback, so plan for a gap and check the other coverage options.