Guides
Employer coverage vs marketplace coverage: how to decide
Check whether your job offer is affordable, because that decides marketplace credits, then compare total yearly cost, networks and drug coverage.
If your employer offers health insurance and you could also buy a marketplace plan, the deciding question is usually whether your job offer is affordable and adequate. If it is, you generally cannot get marketplace premium tax credits, so the choice is between the employer plan and a marketplace plan at full price. If it is not, you can usually turn it down and use credits if your income qualifies. After that test, compare the total cost over a year, the doctors and drugs each plan covers, and the rules about when you can switch.
Step 1: Check whether the employer offer counts
The ACA sets two tests for a job-based offer. If a plan passes both, you are treated as having access to good coverage and cannot take the premium tax credit for the months you could have enrolled, even if you buy a marketplace plan instead.
- Minimum value. The plan must pay at least 60% of the total cost of covered benefits and cover substantial hospital and physician services. Your employer or the plan's summary can confirm. See minimum value.
- Affordability. What you would pay for the lowest-cost employee-only plan that meets minimum value must not exceed a set percentage of your household income. For plan years beginning in 2026 that percentage is 9.96% (Rev. Proc. 2025-25); for 2027 it is 10.22% (Rev. Proc. 2026-26). A plan year that starts in 2026 keeps the 2026 percentage for its whole term.
The test looks at the employee-only premium, not the cost of covering your family. The rules for family members have been revised over the years, so confirm the current treatment with the marketplace or a tax professional. The employer coverage affordability test runs the arithmetic, and Is your employer coverage affordable? The affordability test explained covers the details.
A labeled hypothetical
Say a single worker has $50,000 of household income and is offered a plan that meets minimum value. The employee-only premium is a number in the table below.
| Employee-only premium | Per year | Share of $50,000 | Affordable at 9.96%? |
|---|---|---|---|
| $400 a month | $4,800 | 9.6% | Yes |
| $450 a month | $5,400 | 10.8% | No |
The 9.96% line equals $4,980 a year, about $415 a month. In the first case the offer is affordable, so the worker would not get credits on the marketplace. In the second the offer is not, so the worker can decline it and apply for credits if income and other conditions allow. These are round numbers for illustration, not typical prices.
Step 2: Compare the real yearly cost
Premium is only part of the cost. For each option add:
- The premium for the year (your share of it, for an employer plan).
- The deductible, copays and coinsurance you would expect to use, up to the out-of-pocket maximum.
- Tax effects: employer premiums are usually paid pre-tax, and marketplace credits depend on your income.
- Any employer contributions to a health savings account or other accounts that come only with the job plan.
Employer plans benefit from the employer's share of the premium. KFF's 2026 survey found that workers paid about 18% of the average single premium and about 27% of the average family premium, with employers paying the rest. A marketplace plan at full price has no employer subsidy, but credits can lower it if you qualify, and cost-sharing reduction can lower your deductible on certain silver plans. Tax credits for 2026 and 2027 end above 400% of the poverty level, so income near that line matters. The ACA subsidy estimator estimates what a marketplace credit would be.
Step 3: Compare networks, drugs and benefits
The cheaper plan is not the better fit if your doctors are out of network or your drugs are not covered. Check each plan's provider directory and formulary, and compare the plan summaries side by side; how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs shows how. Employer plans are often built around a regional network, which can be an advantage if you use local providers and a limit if you travel or live apart from the employer's base.
Step 4: Know the timing rules
You choose the employer plan during its enrollment window. Marketplace enrollment usually happens during open enrollment, which for plan year 2027 began November 1, 2026 on HealthCare.gov. Outside it, you need a special enrollment period. Turning down an employer offer does not by itself open one, so someone who declines job coverage in the fall and wants a marketplace plan should plan the dates in advance. Losing job-based coverage does open a 60-day marketplace window.
If you are covering a spouse or children, each person's choice can differ. A family may keep one person on a job plan and others on the marketplace, but credits for the marketplace members depend on whether the employer offer counts for them.
Other options that blur the line
An employer may offer an individual coverage health reimbursement arrangement (ICHRA, now branded CHOICE Arrangement by CMS), which gives you a monthly allowance to buy your own plan. It changes how the credit test works; see ICHRA explained: employer allowance for individual health insurance. If you are leaving the job, COBRA or a marketplace plan after a job loss: how to compare compares the two paths.
Key takeaways
- A job offer that is affordable and meets minimum value generally rules out marketplace credits.
- For 2026 plan years the affordability line is 9.96% of income, and for 2027 it is 10.22%, applied to the employee-only premium.
- Compare total yearly cost, not only premiums, and check networks and drug coverage.
- Marketplace credits end above 400% of the poverty level in 2026 and 2027.
- Declining job coverage does not open a special enrollment period, so check the dates first.