Blog
I changed jobs in July, so what happens to the deductible I already met?
Why a met deductible stays with the old plan, what the new plan starts from, and how to compare a fresh deductible against COBRA for the rest of the year.
The deductible you met belongs to the old plan, not to you. When the old coverage ends, the amount you have paid toward its deductible and its out-of-pocket maximum stops counting, and the new plan starts its own tally at zero. There are a few exceptions, mostly when an employer changes insurers but keeps the same group of workers, and they are worth asking about. For most people who change jobs midyear, the practical question is not "how do I carry my progress over?" but "which arrangement for the rest of the year costs less, and does the timing of a planned procedure matter?"
This explainer walks through why the rule works the way it does, then runs the numbers for one invented worker in two situations. Every figure below is a round-number illustration. Your own plan documents decide the real amounts.
Why the deductible follows the plan
A deductible is a term in a contract. The contract is between the insurer (or the employer, in a self-funded plan) and the group that bought the coverage. The deductible tells that plan how much of the covered, allowed cost it expects you to pay before it begins sharing the cost. The plan keeps a running total of what you paid toward that deductible for the plan year, and the total lives in that plan's claims system.
A new employer's plan is a different contract, often with a different insurer, a different claims system and a different deductible amount. It has no record of your spending, and it did not collect premiums for the months you were on the old plan. Its actuaries priced its deductible on the assumption that members start the year at zero or join partway through at zero. Crediting every new hire for payments made elsewhere would also be hard to verify, because the plan would have to trust another plan's records.
The same logic applies to the out-of-pocket maximum. That cap protects you within one plan's year. It is not a lifetime counter and it does not travel. If you had spent $3,000 toward an old out-of-pocket limit, the new plan's limit is still the full amount for the new plan.
Two phrases matter in plan documents. Plan year is the 12-month period the deductible runs on. It may be the calendar year or a different period, such as July through June. Coverage period is the span during which you were actually enrolled. A deductible resets at the start of the plan year, not on your hire date. So a new hire who joins a calendar-year plan on August 1 faces a full deductible for August through December, then a new full deductible on January 1.
The situation: a July job change
Here is the scenario we will use. Say Priya, 34, has worked for an employer whose plan has a $2,000 deductible and 20% coinsurance. She has paid $1,600 toward the deductible so far this year, which is 80% of it. Her old coverage ends on July 31. Her new employer's plan starts on August 1, and it is a calendar-year plan with a $1,500 deductible, 20% coinsurance and a $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum. The old plan's out-of-pocket maximum was $5,000. These numbers are invented.
Priya has $400 left on the old deductible: $2,000 minus $1,600. She is considering an elective procedure in September with an allowed amount of $10,000, meaning the amount the plan's contracted rate allows, not a sticker price. She has two realistic ways to be insured in September.
Situation one: the new plan starts August 1
Priya takes the new employer's plan. Her $1,600 of progress disappears from the new plan's point of view. The September procedure runs like this:
- She owes the full new deductible first: $1,500.
- The remaining allowed amount is $10,000 minus $1,500, or $8,500.
- She pays 20% of that: $8,500 times 0.20 equals $1,700.
- Her total for the procedure is $1,500 plus $1,700, which is $3,200.
The new plan's $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum is not reached, so $3,200 is what she owes, assuming the care is in network and covered. Over August through December she also pays her share of the monthly premium. Say the employee share of the new plan is $150 a month. Five months at $150 is $750.
So the cost of the procedure plus premiums for those five months is $3,200 plus $750, or $3,950.
Situation two: COBRA to finish the year
Priya could instead elect COBRA continuation coverage and stay on the old plan through December. COBRA lets a person who loses employer coverage keep the same plan, at a cost of up to 102% of the full premium, for a limited period. The federal rules apply to group health plans of employers with 20 or more employees, and states have similar rules for some smaller employers. See How COBRA works: eligibility, cost and how long it lasts for the eligibility rules and the election window.
Because she stays on the same plan, her $1,600 of deductible progress and any out-of-pocket progress continue. For the same September procedure:
- She owes the remaining deductible: $400.
- The remaining allowed amount is $10,000 minus $400, or $9,600.
- She pays 20% of that: $9,600 times 0.20 equals $1,920.
- Her total for the procedure is $400 plus $1,920, which is $2,320.
Her out-of-pocket year to date on the old plan would be about $1,600 plus $2,320, or $3,920, below the $5,000 maximum. Now the premium. Say the full monthly premium for her old plan, employer share included, is $700. At 102% the COBRA bill is $714 a month. Five months is $3,570.
The total for the procedure plus the five months of premium is $2,320 plus $3,570, or $5,890.
The comparison
| New plan from August 1 | COBRA on the old plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Procedure cost to Priya | $3,200 | $2,320 |
| Premiums, August to December | $750 | $3,570 |
| Total | $3,950 | $5,890 |
In this illustration COBRA costs about $1,940 more, because the lower out-of-pocket cost of $880 is far smaller than the extra $2,820 in premiums. Change the inputs and the answer can flip. Suppose she faced a much larger bill, such as a $40,000 allowed amount:
- Under COBRA, the old plan would cap her out-of-pocket spending at $5,000 for the year. She has already paid $1,600, so the most she could pay for the rest of the year is $3,400.
- Under the new plan, the cap is $6,000 for the new plan year, all of which is still ahead of her because her earlier spending does not count.
At that scale the gap in the cap is $2,600, and the extra COBRA premiums of $2,820 still outweigh it in this example, though the margin is narrow. A surgery on a family with several people on the plan, or a condition with ongoing high costs, can tip the other way. The method stays the same: compute each option's total for the rest of the year and compare.
Two other facts belong in the comparison, neither of which fits into a simple formula. First, a network difference may matter more than a few hundred dollars. If your surgeon or your specialist is in the old plan's network and not the new one, the lower on-paper cost of the new plan can be misleading. Second, a COBRA election is not tied to a deadline of July 31. The plan must give at least 60 days to elect, and coverage is retroactive to the loss of coverage if you elect and pay. The COBRA cost and deadline calculator can help lay out the dates, though the notice from the plan controls.
Do you need the gap covered?
Many job changes have a gap or an overlap, and the gap is where people get surprised. If Priya's old coverage ends July 31 and the new plan starts August 1, there is no gap. If the new plan has a waiting period (employer plans may impose one for up to 90 days under federal rules), there is. A waiting period is a separate topic, and My new job's health plan has a waiting period, so how do I cover the gap? covers how to cover it. For this post, the point is that a short stretch of COBRA, or of a marketplace plan, can fill a gap without committing to the full year.
If there is no gap, COBRA is optional and is a way to keep progress and a network, not a way to stay insured. Priya can also change her mind: she may be able to elect COBRA within her election window, use it for a month or two, and stop. Paying for months she does not need is the cost of that flexibility, and the plan's notice explains when coverage may end for non-payment.
When timing an elective procedure matters
Planning an elective procedure around a job change is legitimate, and a few patterns come up.
Before the old coverage ends. If Priya has the procedure on July 20, the old plan pays under its own rules. Her cost is $400 plus 20% of $9,600, which is $2,320, with no COBRA premium needed at all. Scheduling constraints, referrals and prior authorization may stand in the way, since the approval must be in place before the date. This is a real option for care that your doctor says can reasonably be scheduled sooner or later. It is not a reason to rush care the clinician says should wait or happen immediately.
After the new plan starts. Priya pays the new deductible in full. If the procedure were scheduled for December instead of September, nothing changes for the new plan's year: the $1,500 deductible applies whenever it falls in the calendar year.
Early in the new plan year. A procedure in January faces another fresh deductible on the new plan, so a procedure in December and a follow-up in January each start from different counters. A two-part treatment, such as a surgery followed by physical therapy, can cross the line. Ask the provider for an estimate of each stage and see which year each falls in.
Check what the old plan owes after it ends. A service delivered before July 31 can be billed weeks later, and the old plan still pays it under the old rules. If the hospital sends a bill to the wrong plan, the cleanup is covered in The hospital billed my old insurance after I changed jobs.
Exceptions worth asking about
A few arrangements do preserve your progress. Ask HR the exact question, and get the answer in writing:
- A midyear carrier change. If your employer switches insurers during the year, some employers arrange for the new carrier to credit what members paid under the old one. This is an employer decision and not a legal requirement in every case. my employer switched insurance carriers, so what happens to my deductible? covers it.
- A move between plans at the same employer. Some employers let you switch plans only at open enrollment. If a qualifying event allows a switch within the same insurer, the insurer may or may not carry over the accumulators. Ask.
- A spouse's plan. If you move onto your spouse's plan, it has its own year and its own tally, and nothing from your old plan carries.
- Family coverage. In a plan with an embedded deductible, each family member has an individual deductible inside the family one. When you join a new plan, each person's counter starts at zero, so a child with high bills has to meet the new individual figure.
- Health savings account money. An account you funded stays yours. A balance in a HSA remains in your control when you change jobs, and it can pay deductible costs on the new plan if you are enrolled in a qualifying high-deductible plan. A health FSA works differently, and its fate depends on your plan and whether you elect COBRA for it.
What to ask before you decide
- What is the new plan's deductible, out-of-pocket maximum, and plan year start date? The summary of benefits and coverage states them.
- Is the new plan's deductible individual, family or embedded, and which applies to me?
- Does the new plan use a different network, and are my doctors in it?
- What does COBRA cost per month, and by what date must I elect and pay?
- Do any scheduled treatments need prior authorization from the new plan, and can approvals from the old plan transfer? Some plans have transition rules for people in the middle of treatment.
- Is the new plan's start date the first of the month after I begin, or on the first day of work?
HR and the plan's member services answer the questions about your specific plan. A licensed broker or a state insurance department can help when your employer or insurer will not explain. For tracking what you have paid so far this year, how to track your deductible and out-of-pocket spending explains how to read your explanation-of-benefits statements, and the deductible and out-of-pocket tracker gives a simple place to log amounts.
Key takeaways
- A met deductible and out-of-pocket progress stay with the plan that tracked them. A new employer's plan starts you at zero unless it says otherwise in writing.
- To compare options for the rest of the year, add the procedure cost under each plan to five or six months of premiums. In the illustration, a lower deductible was outweighed by a COBRA bill of $714 a month.
- COBRA preserves your accumulated deductible and your network, at up to 102% of the full premium, and it is optional when the new plan begins right away.
- Timing an elective procedure before the old coverage ends or after the new coverage starts can change what you owe by hundreds of dollars, but only for care your clinician agrees can be scheduled.
- Ask HR whether any credit applies, and get a written answer. Rules and amounts differ from plan to plan.