Blog

My employer switched insurance carriers, so what happens to my deductible?

A timeline of what happens when an employer changes insurers mid-year, from notices and claims run-out to deductible credit, with a worked deductible example.

When an employer changes carriers in the middle of the year, nothing in federal law guarantees that the money you have already spent toward your deductible follows you. Some new insurers credit it, some do not, and the difference can be a few hundred dollars or a few thousand. The rest of the switch, which includes ID cards, claims from before the change, prior authorizations and your doctors, runs on a fairly predictable schedule. This post follows that schedule from the announcement to the first full months on the new plan, then works a deductible example with invented numbers.

Everything here describes what commonly happens. Your employer's contract with the new insurer, the type of plan and your state's rules decide the details, so use the questions in each stage to get answers in writing.

Why a switch lands in the middle of the year

A group plan runs on a plan year. Many employers use a calendar year, but others follow a fiscal year or a renewal date set when the company first bought coverage. A change can also follow an acquisition, a merger of two benefit programs or a decision to leave a carrier after a large rate increase. Companies that pay claims themselves can move to a new third-party administrator without changing the plan's design, which employees often experience as a "new carrier" because the cards and phone numbers change. The distinction between a self-funded plan and a fully insured plan matters here, and self-funded vs fully insured employer plans: why it matters to you explains it. A switch is not the same as an employer ending its plan; for that case, see My employer is ending its health plan mid-year, so what should I expect?.

The timeline

60 to 90 days before: the announcement

Employers usually announce a change well ahead of the date, often in an all-hands email or an HR session. At this stage you may not know whether you need to take any action. Ask three things:

  1. What is the exact effective date?
  2. Will I be enrolled automatically, or do I need to re-enroll?
  3. Will the new plan credit what I have already spent toward the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum?

The third question rarely has an answer yet, but asking it early gets it on the employer's list. The deductible credit is often a term the employer negotiates with the new insurer, and it is easier to get when someone asks before the contract is signed.

30 to 60 days before: new plan materials and enrollment

New plan documents arrive. Look for the summary of benefits and coverage, a standard-format summary that shows the deductible, coinsurance, copays, out-of-pocket maximum and examples. The guide on How to read a Summary of Benefits and Coverage walks through it. Compare it with your old plan for:

  • the deductible and whether it is for one person or a family, and whether an individual limit is embedded in the family deductible
  • the out-of-pocket maximum
  • the network and whether your doctors and hospital are in it
  • the drug list and your medications
  • referral and prior authorization rules

If the plan requires active enrollment, miss the deadline and you can end up with the default option, or with none.

14 to 30 days before: network, prescriptions and open treatments

This is the practical window. Check whether each of your doctors, your pharmacy and any facility you expect to use is in the new network, using the new insurer's directory and a call to the office to confirm. If you are in the middle of treatment, such as physical therapy, pregnancy care, chemotherapy or a series of procedures, ask the new insurer about a transition or continuity-of-care process. Some insurers and some states have such rules and others do not; what applies depends on the plan and the state, and the state insurance department can tell you which rules cover your plan.

Also deal with approvals. If you have a prior authorization on file with the old insurer for a surgery, an infusion or a drug, do not assume it transfers. Ask the new insurer whether it honors existing authorizations for a period and what paperwork it needs. The prior authorization and claim tracker gives a place to log reference numbers, dates and who you spoke to. See how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied for how the process works.

Fill prescriptions before the date if the old plan allows, since a refill at the end of the old plan avoids a gap while the new plan processes your information. Check for a refill-too-soon limit.

The effective date

On the effective date the old plan generally stops covering care you receive from that date onward, and the new plan starts. You will usually get new ID cards a week or two before, sometimes after. If a card has not arrived, ask the new insurer for a temporary proof of coverage and tell the provider's office. Bring the new card to every appointment from day one, and ask your doctor's billing staff to update the insurance on file. A claim sent to the wrong insurer is a common cause of denials in the first month.

The first 90 days: claims run-out and the double paper trail

Care you received before the switch is still billed to the old insurer, and that insurer keeps processing those claims for a period after its contract ends, called the run-out period. For the next several weeks you may receive an explanation of benefits from the old insurer and a different one from the new one. Do not throw out the old ones. They show how much you paid toward the old deductible, which matters for the credit discussed below.

Keep a simple record by date of service. A one-page log with these columns works: date, provider, insurer, amount billed, amount you paid, and whether the claim went to the right insurer. The deductible and out-of-pocket tracker and the guide on how to track your deductible and out-of-pocket spending explain what counts. If a provider bills the wrong insurer for a visit that straddles the date, ask them to resubmit; most claims carry a filing deadline, so do not sit on it.

Months 2 to 4: the deductible credit is applied or denied

The deductible credit, where it exists, is not automatic in practice. The new insurer needs data from the old one about what has been applied to each person's deductible and out-of-pocket maximum. That data can take weeks, and in the meantime the new insurer may process claims as if you had met nothing. If the credit is later loaded, claims can be reprocessed and refunds issued. Keep your own record so that you can spot a gap.

If the credit does not appear, ask HR whether the employer negotiated one. If it did not, the new plan starts from zero. If it did and the insurer is not applying it, you can file a complaint with the insurer's customer service, follow up with the employer's benefits team and, for an insured plan, contact the state insurance department.

A worked example

Say Marcus is covered by an employer plan with a calendar year. The employer switches carriers on July 1. These numbers are invented round figures.

  • Old plan: $2,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance after the deductible.
  • New plan: $2,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance after the deductible.
  • By June 30, Marcus has paid $1,200 toward the old deductible.
  • In September, Marcus has a procedure with an allowed amount of $10,000.

Case A: the new insurer credits the $1,200.

  • Remaining deductible: $2,000 − $1,200 = $800
  • Coinsurance on the rest: ($10,000 − $800) × 20% = $9,200 × 20% = $1,840
  • Marcus pays: $800 + $1,840 = $2,640
  • Total spent in the year, counting the earlier $1,200: $1,200 + $2,640 = $3,840

Case B: the new plan starts from zero.

  • Deductible: $2,000
  • Coinsurance on the rest: ($10,000 − $2,000) × 20% = $8,000 × 20% = $1,600
  • Marcus pays: $2,000 + $1,600 = $3,600
  • Total spent in the year: $1,200 + $3,600 = $4,800

The gap between the two cases is $3,600 − $2,640 = $960, which is the credited $1,200 times Marcus's 80% share of the plan's coinsurance. The credit is worth $1,200 minus the 20% that he would have paid in coinsurance on that same $1,200 either way: $1,200 × 80% = $960. The arithmetic checks both ways.

Case C: the new plan has a $2,500 deductible and credits $1,200.

  • Remaining deductible: $2,500 − $1,200 = $1,300
  • Coinsurance on the rest: ($10,000 − $1,300) × 20% = $8,700 × 20% = $1,740
  • Marcus pays: $1,300 + $1,740 = $3,040

A higher deductible on the new plan costs him $3,040 − $2,640 = $400 more than Case A. If the new deductible is the same or lower, credit matters most.

An out-of-pocket maximum works the same way. If the old plan's maximum was $6,000 and the new one also has $6,000, a credit for the $1,200 means he reaches the cap after $4,800 more in the year rather than $6,000 more. If the new plan has no credit, spending toward the new maximum starts over.

A family version of the same switch

Families have one more wrinkle: the deductible is often tracked both per person and for the household. Say the Okafor family has a plan with a $4,000 family deductible and a $2,000 limit for any one person. The employer switches carriers on July 1 and the new plan credits prior spending. By June 30, one parent has paid $1,500 toward the deductible and a child has paid $700, for a household total of $2,200. These figures are invented.

  • The household still has $4,000 − $2,200 = $1,800 of family deductible to go.
  • The parent has $2,000 − $1,500 = $500 left before their individual limit is met, and the child has $2,000 − $700 = $1,300 left.

Without a credit, all of those numbers go back to the full deductible. If the credit is only partial, for example it counts the parent's $1,500 but misses the child's $700 because a claim was still in run-out, the household shows $4,000 − $1,500 = $2,500 left. That is $700 more than it should be until the missing claim is processed. The remedy is the log described above: send the missing explanation of benefits to the new insurer and ask for a reprocessing.

Check, too, whether the new plan counts spending toward the deductible differently, for instance whether an individual meets the deductible on their own or only the family total counts. The summary of benefits states which design applies.

What to do if your doctor is not in the new network

Losing a doctor is the hardest part of a switch for many people, and it is separate from the deductible. The usual order of steps is:

  1. Confirm in the new insurer's directory and by phone that the doctor is out of network; directories are not always right.
  2. Ask the doctor's office whether they plan to join the new network or have a contract pending.
  3. Ask the insurer about a transition-of-care or continuity-of-care request, which can allow in-network cost sharing for a limited time during active treatment.
  4. If an equivalent in-network provider does not exist within a reasonable distance, ask the insurer for a network exception.
  5. If the request is denied, ask for the denial in writing, and use the appeal route in the plan documents.

The rules for these requests vary by plan and state. HR and the state insurance department can tell you what applies to yours.

What does not reset

  • Savings accounts. A health savings account or health flexible spending account is separate from the insurer. A change of carrier does not by itself empty the account. Ask HR whether the carrier change affects FSA claim procedures or the HSA's eligibility (a new plan must still qualify as a high-deductible plan for new HSA contributions).
  • Your right to appeal old claims. A denial of a claim from before the switch goes to the old insurer's appeal process. See how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step if that happens.

Questions to put to HR in writing

  1. What is the effective date, and what happens to claims for earlier dates of service?
  2. Will the new insurer credit amounts applied to the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, and for whom (individual, family)?
  3. How and when will the new insurer get the data from the old one?
  4. Will existing prior authorizations be honored, and for how long?
  5. Is there a transition-of-care process for ongoing treatment, and whom do I call?
  6. When will new ID cards arrive, and what proof of coverage do I use until then?
  7. Who do I contact if a claim goes to the wrong insurer?

The same questions work if you changed employers rather than carriers; see I changed jobs in July, so what happens to the deductible I already met?, where a new job usually means a full reset.

Key takeaways

  • Federal rules do not require a new insurer to credit your deductible, so ask HR before the switch whether the employer negotiated a credit and get the answer in writing.
  • Care before the effective date is billed to the old insurer; keep every explanation of benefits from both so you can prove what you paid.
  • In the worked example, a $1,200 credit saved $960 on a $10,000 procedure, and a higher new deductible ate part of that gain.
  • Do not assume prior authorizations, ID cards or doctors transfer; check the network, approvals and prescriptions in the weeks before the date.
  • If something is wrong, escalate in order: the new insurer, the employer's benefits team, then the state insurance department for insured plans.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic