Blog

Why did my child's free checkup come with a bill?

How one pediatric visit splits into a free preventive part and a billable problem part, seven common mistakes, a worked bill and a script for the clinic.

The plan says well-child visits are free. The visit happened, the vaccines were given, and a month later an explanation of benefits shows a balance owed. Usually nobody lied and nothing was a mistake in the sense of a typing error. One appointment produced two kinds of service, and the plan treats them differently. The preventive part is covered with no cost sharing for in-network care. The part that deals with a problem is billed under the plan's ordinary rules, which often means the deductible.

This post walks through how that split happens, the mistakes that lead to it, a worked bill with invented numbers, and a way to ask the clinic to look at the coding. It describes how billing works in general. It is not medical advice, and it does not suggest holding back a concern from your child's doctor to avoid a charge. Whether a symptom needs attention now is a clinical question for the doctor.

What "free" covers

Under the Affordable Care Act, most non-grandfathered plans cover recommended preventive services for children without a copay, coinsurance or deductible when the child sees an in-network provider. That includes well-child visits on the recommended schedule, many screenings and the immunizations on the recommended childhood schedule. See Free preventive care under the ACA: what is covered at no cost. The rule does not cover every service that happens at the appointment, and it does not cover care for a problem, even if the problem comes up at the same visit.

Two points explain most surprises:

  • Preventive means checking a healthy child against a schedule. Growth, development, vaccines, screenings and counseling are on the list. A rash, an ear that has hurt for a week, a cough that won't go away or a school concern are medical problems that need evaluation.
  • The plan pays what the clinic bills. It doesn't see what was said in the exam room. It sees the claim, made of billing codes. When the doctor evaluates a problem in a significant way, the clinic can bill a second service on the same day, and the plan then treats it as a regular office visit.

Children covered by Medicaid or CHIP are in a different situation. Those programs have their own checkup benefit for children, and cost sharing is limited, so a bill is less likely. See What is EPSDT? Why Medicaid covers more for kids than parents expect.

How one visit becomes two claims

A medical billing code is a standardized number that describes a service. See CPT code. A well-child visit has its own set of codes, which vary by age. When a clinician also does work for a separate problem that goes beyond the normal checkup, the practice may add a second office-visit code with a modifier that tells the plan the two services were separate. The plan then pays the first as preventive and applies the member's cost sharing to the second.

The result looks like two charges on the same date. If you see two lines for the same date of service on an explanation of benefits, one with a $0 patient amount and one with a balance, this is probably what happened. How to read an explanation of benefits (EOB) line by line explains each column.

Billing rules require that the second service be significant and separately identifiable. A quick question about a mild symptom, answered in a sentence, is often part of the normal checkup. A detailed look at a problem, a prescription, a new plan of care or an order for a test generally supports a second charge. Where the line falls is a judgment by the clinician and the practice's coders, and practices differ, which is why a polite question can sometimes change the result.

Seven mistakes and misunderstandings

1. Bringing up a new problem at a preventive visit, without knowing it may be billed

How it happens. A parent mentions a sore throat, a knee pain or a worry about sleep, the doctor examines and treats it, and the visit becomes two services.

What it costs. Usually the plan's price for an office visit, often the full allowed amount if the deductible hasn't been met. In the example below, $110.

How to avoid it. Don't skip real concerns, because the doctor needs to hear them. For something that isn't urgent, ask when you book, "I'd like to cover a rash too. Should we do that as a separate visit, or will it be billed in addition?" At the visit, ask the doctor or the front desk before the exam begins. That way you decide with the cost in view.

2. Assuming every test done that day is part of the checkup

How it happens. A quick test (a rapid strep test, a urine check, an allergy screen) is done during the visit because of a symptom, and it is not on the preventive list.

What it costs. The allowed amount for that test, often applied to the deductible.

How to avoid it. Ask "Is this test part of the routine checkup, or because of a symptom?" Routine screenings on the recommended schedule, such as vision, hearing or developmental checks at certain ages, are generally preventive. A test ordered to diagnose something is not.

3. Using a clinic that isn't in network

How it happens. The child sees a new doctor, a walk-in clinic or a practice that is in network for one plan but not yours, and the checkup is billed as out-of-network.

What it costs. The no-cost rule applies to in-network care. An out-of-network checkup can bring a bill for the part the plan does not cover, and that part doesn't count toward your out-of-pocket maximum. See in-network.

How to avoid it. Confirm the practice and the individual doctor for your exact plan before booking. Directories can be wrong, so call the plan.

4. Vaccines billed separately or outside the schedule

How it happens. Vaccines are billed on their own lines, and a vaccine that is not on the recommended schedule for your child's age, such as a travel vaccine, a catch-up that the plan considers outside the schedule, or one given at a pharmacy, may be treated differently.

What it costs. Anywhere from nothing to the full price of the vaccine plus an administration fee.

How to avoid it. If a vaccine is offered that is not part of the usual schedule, ask whether the plan covers it before it is given. For pharmacy vaccines, ask whether the pharmacy is in the plan's network for vaccines.

5. School, camp and sports forms

How it happens. A parent asks the clinic to fill out a sports physical, a camp form or a school form. These are administrative, and the insurer does not cover paperwork.

What it costs. Often a flat fee set by the practice, often $15 to $50, though this varies. Some practices charge nothing, and some will do the form during a regular visit.

How to avoid it. Ask the front desk for the fee when you request the form. If the visit is a sports physical done just for the form, ask whether the plan covers it, since many do not, and whether a well-child visit can serve both purposes.

6. Not realizing the first bill is not the final bill

How it happens. The clinic sends a statement before the plan finishes processing the claim, or the plan processes the preventive service in one batch and the problem visit later. A parent pays the statement and later finds the amounts differ.

What it costs. Overpayment, or a long wait for a refund.

How to avoid it. Wait for the explanation of benefits and compare it with the bill before paying. Ask for an itemized bill. See how to get an itemized medical bill and spot billing errors.

7. Assuming a plan's preventive benefit is the same for every plan

How it happens. A parent moved from one plan to another, or has a plan that is grandfathered, and expects the same rules.

What it costs. Cost sharing on services that were free under a previous plan.

How to avoid it. Read the plan's summary of benefits for the child's preventive services. Ask the plan whether the plan is grandfathered.

A worked bill, with invented numbers

This is an illustration. The amounts are made up and round. Say a child with an in-network clinic and a plan with a $2,500 family deductible, not yet met this year, goes to a seven-year-old checkup. During the visit the parent mentions that the child's ear has hurt for three days, and the doctor examines the ear, runs a rapid test for a sore throat and prescribes an antibiotic. The family also asks for a sports form.

Item Allowed amount Plan treats it as You owe
Well-child visit $220 Preventive, covered in full $0
Recommended vaccines, with administration $180 Preventive, covered in full $0
Office visit for the ear pain $110 Regular visit, applied to deductible $110
Rapid strep test $30 Diagnostic test, applied to deductible $30
Sports form fee $25 Not insured, flat fee $25
Total $565 $165

The arithmetic: the plan pays the preventive items, $220 + $180 = $400. The family pays $110 + $30 = $140 toward the deductible, plus the $25 form fee, for $165. Check the total: $400 + $165 = $565. Of the $165, $140 counts toward the deductible and the $25 does not.

The family expected $0 and got $165. Two of the charges ($140) came from the problem the child had, which was treated. Two things might still deserve a question: whether the second visit code reflected significant added work, and whether the form fee was explained at booking.

How to ask the clinic to review the billing

First, wait for the explanation of benefits. Then take these steps:

  1. Read the explanation of benefits and identify each line, its date and the amount you owe. The Medical bill and EOB checker can help you check it.
  2. Call the clinic's billing office, not the front desk, and say something like:

I'm calling about my child's visit on [date]. It was scheduled as a well-child checkup, and the plan processed part of it as a separate office visit with a balance of $110. Could you tell me what was billed and why? If the discussion of the problem was brief, could the visit be reviewed to see whether the second charge is correct?

  1. Listen to the answer. The billing office may explain that the doctor spent significant time on a problem, in which case the second charge is correct. Or it may agree that the coding can be reviewed. A clinic may be willing to correct the claim. It will not do so just because the result is inconvenient, and it shouldn't be asked to change what the visit was.
  2. If the clinic corrects the claim, ask it to send a corrected claim to the plan, and ask for a note of the date. Then watch for a revised explanation of benefits.
  3. If the plan processed something wrongly, such as charging cost sharing on a routine vaccine on the schedule, call the plan and ask it to reprocess the claim. If it will not, request a written denial and file an appeal. See how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step.
  4. Ask about a payment plan or a discount if the balance stands and is hard to pay.

For the adult version of this problem, see my free checkup turned into a bill: preventive versus diagnostic care.

Before the next visit

A few habits keep the next checkup simple:

  • When you book, say it is a well-child visit and ask whether the clinic expects to add anything. Note any concerns you may want to raise.
  • Ask whether the vaccines due are on the recommended schedule for the plan.
  • Bring the school or camp forms to the visit if the clinic will complete them during the checkup, and ask about the fee.
  • Keep the plan's preventive services list for children with the insurance card.
  • After the visit, look for the explanation of benefits and compare it with the bill.

Key takeaways

  • A checkup can become two claims. The preventive part is generally free in network, and a separately evaluated problem is billed under the plan's usual rules, often the deductible.
  • The most common surprises are a new problem raised during the visit, a test done for a symptom, an out-of-network clinic, a vaccine outside the schedule and a flat fee for a form.
  • In the worked example, a $565 visit left the family owing $165, because $400 of preventive items were free and $140 went to the deductible, with a $25 form fee.
  • Raise real concerns with the doctor. If cost matters, ask in advance whether a problem will be a separate visit, or ask the clinic to review the coding after the fact.
  • Wait for the explanation of benefits before paying, and use the clinic's billing office, then the plan and an appeal, in that order.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic