Blog

How do I choose a plan when one hospital system dominates where I live?

Four hypothetical rural households show what network adequacy means in practice, what to check about the local system and when to call the state regulator.

In many small towns and rural counties, a single health system owns the hospital, the clinics, the urgent care and the employed doctors. Choosing a plan there can feel like choosing among several doors that open into the same building. The real decisions are narrower than they look: whether every plan on your list includes that system, what each plan does about the things the system does not offer, and what you would do if the system and an insurer fell out.

Below are four hypothetical households, each with a different pressure point. The names, towns and dollar amounts are invented round numbers meant to show the reasoning, not prices from any plan. Your own plan documents and your state insurance department decide the details.

What network adequacy means when there is one system

A network is adequate when it gives members reasonable access to the kinds of care the plan covers. Regulators measure that in different ways: how many providers of each type the plan has, how far a member must travel to reach one, and how long a member waits for an appointment. Standards for network adequacy differ by state, by plan type and by whether the coverage is a marketplace plan, a plan regulated by the state, or a self-funded employer plan that is largely outside state insurance rules. Some regulators relax the standards in sparsely populated areas, since a time-and-distance rule written for a city cannot be met where the nearest cardiologist is a long drive away.

Two things follow in a single-system area:

  • Almost every plan sold there has to contract with the dominant system, because the plan could not meet access standards without it. That is why the plans can look alike on hospital coverage and differ on prices, referral rules and coverage outside the area.
  • A system with that much market power has real leverage in contract talks. Insurers and systems occasionally let a contract lapse over price. When that happens, members can lose in-network access to nearly every local provider at once. It is uncommon, but it is the largest risk in this kind of market, and it is the reason to look at what the plan offers outside the local area.

The system's own plan, where one exists, is a related variation. provider-owned health plans: when the insurer and the hospital are one covers insurers owned by hospital systems, who they tend to suit and where they can fall short.

Household 1: the retired farmer, 61, buying his own plan

Say Walt retired from farming at 61, owns his house outright and has two prescriptions and a bad knee. He is four years from Medicare. He is shopping on the marketplace. Health insurance for early retirees before Medicare at 65 covers the general options; here is what the single-system market changes for him.

Walt's local plans all include the nearby hospital and its clinics. The difference is in three places:

  1. Plan type. One plan is an HMO with a referral step for any specialist; another is a PPO that costs more each month. In a market where one system employs most specialists, the referral step is a smaller obstacle than in a city, because the referral goes to a doctor in the same system.
  2. Out-of-area care. Walt winters two months a year with a daughter in another state. He asks each plan what it pays for non-emergency care out of the plan's service area. Many HMO-style plans pay only for emergencies there. The PPO pays something for planned care.
  3. The knee. If he eventually needs a replacement, he wants to know whether the hospital's orthopedic group is in the plan's network and at what cost tier.

Say the PPO costs $120 a month more than the HMO. That is $1,440 a year. If Walt expects to need out-of-area care only in an emergency, which every plan covers, the HMO's savings are likely worth keeping. If the knee replacement or regular care away from home is likely, the PPO's extra $1,440 buys flexibility. The marketplace's subsidy, if he qualifies, shrinks the cost gap in a way he can see only by running his income through the tools. A useful step for Walt is a call to a marketplace navigator, who can run both plans against his expected income at no charge.

Household 2: the young family with a toddler and a baby on the way

The Okoyes, both 31, live in a town where the only hospital with a maternity unit belongs to the dominant system. Both of the plans they are considering include it. The question they should ask is different: what happens if the baby needs a higher level of care than the local unit provides?

Small hospitals often transfer very premature or seriously ill newborns to a larger children's hospital, sometimes by air. Each plan's rules for that transfer can differ. The Okoyes look for:

  • Whether the receiving children's hospital, 90 miles away, is in the plan's network. One plan includes it. The other, $60 a month cheaper, does not.
  • What the plan's emergency language says about transfers. Emergency care rules protect care to stabilize a patient, but the plan's rules about continuing care at a non-network facility after stabilization vary, and an air-ambulance bill is a separate question; the No Surprises Act covers some air ambulance bills but not ground ambulances.
  • Whether the plan's out-of-pocket maximum is the same family-wide.

The cheaper plan saves $60 × 12 = $720 a year. If the baby had a complicated start, a stay at a facility outside the network could run to tens of thousands of dollars. Say a one-week stay at an out-of-network children's hospital is billed at $60,000, and the plan pays none of it. The $720 saving does not come close to that exposure, even at a low chance of it happening. A $720 saving is real, but it is not the right yardstick for this family at this moment. If instead the plan's network also covered the children's hospital, the larger risk would be gone, and the saving would again be the best reason to choose.

The Okoyes also ask whether the toddler's pediatrician is in the network on both plans. A system that owns the clinics usually includes its pediatricians in any plan that includes the hospital, but an independent practice in town may contract with only some plans, so a call to the office settles it.

Household 3: the small-town teacher with three employer choices

Priya, 44, teaches at the local high school. Her district offers three plans, all through payroll deduction. One has a narrow network built around the local system. The second is a statewide PPO. The third is a high-deductible plan with a health savings account. Because she works for a public school, the plans may follow rules different from those of a private employer. health plans for teachers and public employees: how they differ explains how the plans for those employees can differ.

Say the HMO costs her $75 a month less than the PPO, a saving of $75 × 12 = $900 a year. She and her husband see doctors inside the system, and their child's pediatric asthma care is managed by a practice in the next county, 35 miles away. The question is whether that practice is in the HMO. If it is not, the family's choices are to keep the PPO, change the child's doctor, or pay out-of-network rates for each visit.

Priya's useful move is to ask the district's benefits office three questions:

  1. Is the plan fully insured or self-funded? The answer decides whether state insurance rules and the state insurance department apply, or the federal Department of Labor does.
  2. Who is the contact at the insurer for network questions, and can the contact confirm in writing that the pediatric practice is in the network for the plan year?
  3. What happens during the year if a contract with the system changes?

The decision, in her case, is clear once the practice is confirmed. If it is in the HMO's network, the $900 is worth taking. If not, she compares $900 against the cost of out-of-network visits, which can quickly exceed it.

Household 4: the specialist two hours away

Marisol, 52, has a condition treated by a specialist team at a university hospital two hours away. The local system has no one who treats it. She needs the specialist to be in her network, or she needs a network exception, which is a plan decision that lets a member use an out-of-network provider at in-network rates when the network lacks someone suitable. See network gap exception for how those requests work.

Her arithmetic involves distance as much as price. Say she goes eight times a year. Each trip is 240 miles round trip, so 1,920 miles. At an illustrative $0.50 a mile, that is $960, plus meals and perhaps a hotel night for early appointments. Choosing a plan that includes the university hospital is worth more than any $60 or $90 monthly premium gap, since without it each visit might cost the full billed amount.

Marisol should call each plan before enrolling and ask:

  • Is [named specialist] at [named hospital] in the network under this exact plan name?
  • If the plan's network has no specialist for my condition within a reasonable distance, how do I request an exception, and what is the standard for granting one?
  • Does the plan pay for telehealth visits with the specialist? Telehealth coverage varies by plan and can reduce the number of trips.

Where a plan refuses and she believes the network lacks a suitable provider, the next steps are the plan's internal appeal and, after that, external review. The state insurance department can tell her which standards apply and how to file a complaint; how to file a complaint with your state insurance department walks through that.

What to check about the dominant system itself

Whatever your household, a few checks apply to the system that dominates your area:

  • Which plans include it, and for which services? A system can be in a network for hospital care and out for its employed physicians, or in for primary care and out for a particular specialty group. Ask by service, not by name.
  • When does the plan's contract with it end? Insurers will not always say, but many will tell you whether a contract is in negotiation. If both sides are public about a dispute, local news usually covers it.
  • What does the system offer for patients with no coverage or a large bill? hospital financial assistance and charity care: how to apply describes charity care and how to apply.
  • What is outside the system? Make a list of the services you cannot get locally, such as certain cancer care, high-risk obstetrics, pediatric subspecialties or dialysis, and check each in the plan's network.

State programs aimed at rural care, such as the federal Rural Health Transformation Program that sends money to states, do not change what a plan covers or what you pay. Their effect, if any, shows up in whether the local hospital and clinics stay open and add services.

When to call the state insurance department

The state insurance department is the right place for questions that no plan representative can settle: what network adequacy standards apply to a marketplace plan or fully insured plan in your state, whether a plan has been granted a waiver of those standards, and how to file a complaint if a plan denies an exception you believe it owes you. It will not usually pick a plan for you, and it generally cannot help with a self-funded employer plan, for which the employer's benefits office and the federal Department of Labor are the contacts.

The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet gives you a place to log every provider you checked, who confirmed it and when. A provider directory is a starting point and not a promise, so keep your own record.

Key takeaways

  • In a single-system area nearly every plan includes the dominant system, so compare plans on referral rules, out-of-area coverage and what they do about care the system does not provide.
  • The largest risk is the contract between the system and the insurer ending. Ask what each plan offers outside the local area before that happens.
  • Check the specialist, the children's hospital or the university center you would actually use, not only the local hospital.
  • Price distance and travel at a per-mile figure, and compare the total with the premium gap.
  • For network adequacy standards or a denied exception, the state insurance department is the right contact; for a self-funded employer plan, start with the benefits office.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic