Guides

How to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs

Compare plans by total yearly cost in a light, typical and bad year, then check the network and drug list. A four-plan worked example shows the math.

Compare health plans on what you would pay in total over a year, not on the monthly premium alone: add the premiums you will pay to the share of care you are likely to use, then check that your doctors, hospital and prescriptions are actually covered. A plan is only cheap if it is cheap in the year you need it and it covers the care you need. The steps below turn that into arithmetic you can do on paper.

Step 1: list what you expect to use

Before you open a plan list, write down the care you already know about for the coming year: regular doctors and specialists, prescriptions (name, dose, how often), planned procedures, a pregnancy, therapy visits, and any recurring tests. Then add a guess for the unknown, because most people have at least a few surprises. If you have last year's explanation of benefits statements or pharmacy history, use them: they are better evidence than memory.

Sort the list into three rough pictures of the year: a light year (a checkup and a few generic prescriptions), a typical year (what you used last year), and a bad year (a hospital stay or major treatment). A good comparison looks at all three, because the plan that wins in a light year often loses in a bad one.

Step 2: pull four numbers from each plan

For every plan you are considering, record these from the plan page or its Summary of Benefits and Coverage:

  1. The monthly premium, multiplied by 12 (and reduced by any tax credit you are entitled to; the marketplace shows the net figure).
  2. The deductible for one person (or for the family, if you are insuring several people).
  3. What you pay after the deductible: the coinsurance percentage or the flat copays for the services you use most.
  4. The out-of-pocket maximum, the most you can be asked to pay in covered in-network care in a year. For plan year 2027 the federal ceiling is $12,000 for one person and $24,000 for a family (CMS, January 2026); many plans set theirs lower.

Check whether the plan has a separate drug deductible or fixed copays by drug tier, because that changes the picture for anyone on regular medication.

Step 3: run the three years on each plan

Say four plans are on your screen. The numbers below are made-up round figures for illustration, not real prices. Assume covered, in-network, allowed charges for the year, and ignore copays for simplicity.

Plan A Plan B Plan C Plan D
Premium per month $300 $450 $550 $400
Premium per year $3,600 $5,400 $6,600 $4,800
Deductible $6,000 $4,000 $1,500 $3,000
Coinsurance after deductible 40% 30% 20% 30%
Out-of-pocket maximum $9,000 $8,000 $6,000 $8,000
Network Broad Broad Broad Narrow

Light year, $500 in allowed charges. You pay the whole $500 on every plan, since it all falls inside the deductible. Total cost is premium plus $500: A $4,100, B $5,900, C $7,100, D $5,300.

Typical year, $6,000 in allowed charges.

  • Plan A: the $6,000 deductible absorbs everything, so you pay $6,000. Total $3,600 + $6,000 = $9,600.
  • Plan B: $4,000 deductible, then 30% of the remaining $2,000 is $600, so $4,600. Total $5,400 + $4,600 = $10,000.
  • Plan C: $1,500 deductible, then 20% of $4,500 is $900, so $2,400. Total $6,600 + $2,400 = $9,000.
  • Plan D: $3,000 deductible, then 30% of $3,000 is $900, so $3,900. Total $4,800 + $3,900 = $8,700.

Bad year, $50,000 in allowed charges. Every plan reaches its out-of-pocket maximum. Total cost is premium plus the maximum: A $12,600, B $13,400, C $12,600, D $12,800.

Read the result: the cheapest plan changes with the year. Plan A wins a light year, Plan D wins the typical year, and A and C tie in the bad year. Plan C costs the most before you use care and the least risk if things go badly. That trade-off is the real decision, and the health plan comparison calculator does the same arithmetic with your own figures. The related question of when a higher premium pays for itself is covered in Higher premium or higher deductible? How to find the break-even.

Step 4: check the network and the drug list

Plan D in the example is cheapest in the typical year, but it has a narrow network. If your surgeon or children's hospital is outside it, the "cheap" plan may cover little of your actual care. For each plan, look up every doctor, clinic and hospital you expect to use in the plan's own directory, and confirm by phone with the provider's billing office that they accept this specific plan (not just the insurer's name). Directories are sometimes out of date, so write down who you spoke to and when. The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet gives you a place to record this, and how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network walks through the lookup.

For drugs, search the plan's formulary for each prescription. Note the tier (it sets your copay or coinsurance), and whether it needs prior authorization, step therapy or has a quantity limit. A drug that is not on the formulary may cost its full price until you win an exception.

Step 5: weigh what the numbers leave out

Some differences do not show up in a yearly total:

  • Plan type. An HMO usually requires a primary care doctor and referrals; a PPO usually does not but costs more. The four plan types are compared in a separate guide on HMOs, PPOs, EPOs and POS plans.
  • Metal level. Bronze, silver, gold and platinum describe how costs are split on average, not quality of care; described in the glossary entry on metal levels. Silver plans are the ones that can carry extra cost-sharing reductions for people with lower incomes.
  • Where care is available. Urgent care, telehealth and out-of-area coverage matter if you travel or have a child away at school.
  • Cash flow. A $6,000 deductible is a real bill. If you could not pay it, a lower-deductible plan protects you in a way the yearly average does not show.

Where to get help

A navigator or certified enrollment counselor can walk through a comparison for free; see how to work with a health insurance broker or navigator. For Medicare plans, a State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) counselor does the same. They can answer questions about your own situation that a general guide cannot.

Key takeaways

  • Compare total yearly cost (premiums plus what you would pay) in a light, a typical and a bad year, not the premium alone.
  • Four numbers drive the math: premium, deductible, coinsurance or copays, and the out-of-pocket maximum.
  • A lower premium usually means more risk in a bad year; a higher premium buys protection and predictability.
  • A plan that excludes your doctors or drugs is not cheap, whatever its price; verify both before you choose.
  • Record every answer you get, with the date and the name of the person who gave it.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic