Blog

How to compare Part D plans when you take six medications, step by step

A walk-through for a hypothetical 71-year-old on six drugs: entering them, choosing pharmacies, reading tiers and rules, and pricing two plans.

Pat is a hypothetical 71-year-old with six prescriptions: two brand-name drugs and four generics, all taken every month. Pat has the stand-alone drug plan that came with Original Medicare, a notice says it is changing for next year, and the Annual Enrollment Period ends December 7. Pat's question is the one this post answers: how do I compare drug plans when the list of medicines is long enough that no single price tells the story?

The drugs, doses and plan prices below are invented, with round numbers chosen so the arithmetic is easy to follow. They are not real drugs or real plans. What is real is the order of the steps, and the Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov, which does the calculation for the plans in your area. We will do one pair of plans by hand so that you can see what the estimate is made of and why the lowest premium is often not the lowest cost.

Step 0: gather the facts before opening the tool

Plan Finder asks for exactly what a pharmacist would. Collect, for each medicine:

  • the name, spelled as on the bottle, and whether it is a brand or a generic;
  • the dose and form (for example, a 10 mg tablet, not just the name);
  • how many you take and how often, so the tool can work out the quantity per fill;
  • the length of each fill, usually 30 days or 90 days, and the pharmacy you use.

Pat's list, in the invented example: Generic 1, Generic 2, Generic 3 and Generic 4, each one tablet daily; Brand 1, one tablet daily; Brand 2, one tablet daily. Also note the doses, because the dose determines the quantity and sometimes whether a plan's limit applies. If you have a Medicare online account, the tool can load the drug list the doctor and pharmacy have reported, which saves typing but should be checked against the bottles.

Step 1: enter every drug, with the exact dose and quantity

Every medicine goes in. People tend to leave out cheap generics, inhalers, injections and drugs they take only some months, and that is a mistake, because the tool's estimate reflects what you enter. A missing medicine means a missing cost, and a plan can look cheaper than it is. For a drug you take only occasionally, enter it with a lower frequency, and note that Plan Finder estimates are for a year's pattern.

If a medicine comes in several forms, such as an extended-release version, choose the one you take. A different form can sit on a different formulary tier or not be covered at all.

Step 2: choose the pharmacies you will actually use

Plan Finder asks which pharmacies you use, and the choice changes the price. Many plans have a preferred group of pharmacies with lower copays and a standard group at higher ones, and some plans do not cover certain pharmacies at all. A plan whose price looks low at a preferred pharmacy can cost more at the pharmacy you use if that pharmacy is standard in that plan. Mail-order may also be cheaper for 90-day fills.

Select the pharmacy where you fill most prescriptions, and if you would switch to save money, run the comparison twice, once for each pharmacy. A detailed look at preferred pharmacies is in Preferred pharmacies in Part D: why my copay differs across the street.

Step 3: read the estimate for what it is

The tool lists the plans that serve your ZIP code and, for each, an estimate of your total drug costs plus premium for the year. It also lists the premium, the deductible and the star rating. Treat the estimate as the first screen, not the answer, for three reasons.

  • It uses today's prices and your entered list. A new prescription during the year, a change in dose or a price change will move the result.
  • It does not tell you whether there is a rule on a drug that will stop the first fill. That is Step 4.
  • It cannot see the cash price of a cheap generic at a discount pharmacy, which is sometimes lower than the plan's copay. For most people a plan is still the right way to pay, and the spending counts toward the yearly cap, while a cash purchase may not. Ask the pharmacist which way is cheaper for a given medicine.

Sort by lowest estimated cost, then look at the top handful, not only the first. A plan that is slightly higher but has none of the rules in Step 4 may be a better fit.

For reference, as of November 2026 the Part D standard benefit for 2027 has a deductible of up to $700 and a $2,400 limit on yearly out-of-pocket drug costs (CMS's rate announcement). Plans may set lower deductibles. The Part D out-of-pocket cap means that however many drugs you take, Part D cost sharing on covered drugs stops at that ceiling for the year, so the comparison of plans is mostly a comparison of how quickly you reach it, how much you pay along the way, and the premium. See The Part D out-of-pocket cap and the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan.

Step 4: for each finalist, check tiers and rules, drug by drug

Click into a plan's details for each of your drugs. Record three things for each: the tier, the cost at your pharmacy, and any restriction. The restrictions are:

  • prior authorization: the plan must approve the drug before it pays, usually with a form from the prescriber.
  • step therapy: you must try a different drug first.
  • quantity limit: the plan pays for a set amount in a given period.

Pat's two finalists, with invented details, are in the table. Brand 1 has a plan price of $500 a month and Brand 2 has a plan price of $400 a month; the generics are inexpensive. "Plan A" and "Plan B" are made up.

Plan A Plan B
Monthly premium $45 $15
Deductible $0 $250, tiers 3 to 5 only
Tier 1 copay $0 $0
Tier 2 copay $10 $10
Tier 3 copay $45 $40
Tier 4 cost not used by Pat 30% coinsurance
Generic 1 tier 1 tier 1
Generic 2 tier 1 tier 1
Generic 3 tier 2 tier 1
Generic 4 tier 2 tier 2, quantity limit of 30 tablets per 30 days
Brand 1 tier 3 tier 3
Brand 2 tier 3, prior authorization tier 4

Two lines in that table are not about price. In Plan A, Brand 2 needs a prior authorization, which means Pat's prescriber must file a form and wait for approval before the first fill. In Plan B, Generic 4 has a quantity limit of 30 tablets per 30 days. Pat's prescription is for 60 tablets a month, two a day, so under Plan B the pharmacy would pay for half. Pat's prescriber would have to request an exception to the limit or change the prescription. A tool estimate that ignored this would be wrong on the day Pat went to the pharmacy.

Step 5: do the arithmetic yourself, once

Plan Finder's estimate is built from lines like these. Doing it by hand for a finalist makes the result believable.

Plan A. No deductible, so copays apply from January.

  • Generic 1 and Generic 2: $0
  • Generic 3 and Generic 4: 2 × $10 = $20 a month
  • Brand 1 and Brand 2: 2 × $45 = $90 a month
  • Monthly drug cost: $0 + $20 + $90 = $110
  • Yearly drug cost: 12 × $110 = $1,320
  • Yearly premium: 12 × $45 = $540
  • Total: $1,860

Plan B. The $250 deductible applies to tier 3 and above. Assume the first fill of Brand 1 in January, at $500, is the first deductible cost.

  • January, Brand 1: Pat pays the $250 deductible, then the $40 copay on the remaining $250, which is $290
  • January, Brand 2: the deductible is already met, so 30% of $400 = $120
  • January, Generic 4: $10; Generics 1, 2 and 3: $0
  • January total: $290 + $120 + $10 = $420
  • February through December, each month: Brand 1 $40 + Brand 2 $120 + Generic 4 $10 = $170
  • 11 months × $170 = $1,870
  • Yearly drug cost: $420 + $1,870 = $2,290
  • Yearly premium: 12 × $15 = $180
  • Total: $2,470

Plan B has a premium $360 lower than Plan A's ($540 minus $180). Yet it costs $610 more over the year ($2,470 minus $1,860). The reasons are visible in the lines: the deductible cost Pat $250 up front, and Brand 2 sits on a tier with 30% coinsurance, $120 a month against $45 in Plan A. The low premium was real, and so was the cost it was paying for.

Check each result against the yearly ceiling. Plan B's drug costs of $2,290 are below the $2,400 limit, so the limit does not reduce them, though it is close. Had Pat's brand drug prices been a bit higher, Plan B's costs would reach the ceiling, and from there Pat would pay nothing more for covered drugs that year. That is a reason to look at how the ceiling interacts with the plan, and the Medicare Part D out-of-pocket calculator shows it.

Step 6: decide, then make it work

On cost alone, Plan A is the lower-cost choice in this invented example, and it avoids the quantity-limit problem. Its one extra task is the prior authorization for Brand 2. So before enrolling, Pat takes these actions:

  1. Ask the prescriber's office to submit the prior authorization once the plan year starts, or ask the plan whether a form can be submitted ahead of time. A new member usually has a transition supply or a way to request one, so a denied first fill does not leave Pat without medicine. Ask the plan how it works.
  2. Check that the pharmacy is in the plan's network, and which tier of pharmacy it is.
  3. Call the plan and confirm two things the website may not make clear: the quantity limits on each drug, and how Pat's prior authorization would be handled.
  4. Ask a SHIP counselor to look at the comparison. SHIP counselors know the local plans and can check the choice without charge.

If the costs in January worry Pat, the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan lets a person spread out-of-pocket drug costs across the year in monthly bills rather than paying at the counter. It does not reduce the total, but it can smooth a January bill like Plan B's $420. Ask each plan how to opt in.

If Pat's income and savings are limited, Extra Help, the Part D low-income subsidy, could reduce premiums and copays a great deal. For 2026 the program's limits were annual income below $23,940 for a single person and resources below $18,090 (Medicare.gov), and the limits are updated each year. Pat can apply through Social Security or ask a SHIP counselor to screen. Premiums and rules differ, so Pat would check the current-year figures first.

What to do when the answer changes mid-year

Plans can change their drug lists during the year, and a doctor can change a prescription, so the best plan in November may not be the best plan in July. Pat keeps the notes made during the comparison, and when a new drug is added, runs it through Plan Finder with the current plan to see what it would cost. If a drug the plan refuses to cover is medically necessary, the formulary exception and coverage determination processes are the tool, rather than a change of plan. Changes of plan in the middle of the year are limited to special enrollment periods.

Finally, the comparison belongs to this year. The set of stand-alone plans changes. KFF reported in October 2026 that the number of stand-alone drug plans fell from 360 to 316 for 2027, so repeating the comparison every fall is worth the hour it takes. The broader approach is in How to compare Part D plans: formulary, pharmacies and total cost.

Key takeaways

  • Enter every medicine with the exact dose and quantity, and the pharmacy you actually use, because both change the price.
  • The estimate is a first screen. Check each drug's tier and any prior authorization, step therapy or quantity limit before choosing.
  • In the invented example the plan with the lower premium cost $610 more over the year because of a deductible and a higher tier for one brand drug.
  • Part D cost sharing has a yearly ceiling, $2,400 for 2027 as of November 2026, so the comparison is about how quickly you reach it, what you pay along the way, and the premium.
  • Before enrolling, confirm rules and pharmacy status with the plan, and ask a SHIP counselor to review the choice.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic