Blog

How much will insurance pay for a crown and root canal? A worked dental example

A dental cost worksheet with round numbers: deductible, coinsurance tiers, the annual maximum, waiting periods, downgrades and splitting work across years.

A root canal followed by a crown is one of the costliest ordinary dental treatments, and it is a good test of how a dental plan works, because it touches nearly every feature at once: a deductible, different coinsurance for different kinds of care, a yearly cap on what the plan will pay and sometimes a waiting period. The cap is the feature people discover last and regret most.

This post is a worksheet. It defines a hypothetical plan, shows how to calculate what the plan pays and what you owe, and runs the same two procedures under three situations. Every dollar amount is an invented round number, not a price, and your own plan's booklet and your dentist's estimate replace them. The method is the part to keep.

The six numbers you need from your plan

Find these in the dental plan's summary of benefits or booklet. Write them in the blanks.

  1. The deductible, per person per year: $______. Many dental plans waive it for preventive care and apply it to basic and major services. A deductible resets every plan year.
  2. The coinsurance for each tier, the percentage the plan pays after the deductible. Plans group services into tiers: preventive (cleanings, exams, X-rays), basic (fillings, simple extractions, often root canals and periodontal treatment) and major (crowns, bridges, dentures, implants, often oral surgery). Typical patterns are higher plan payment for preventive and lower for major. Basic: ___%. Major: ___%. Which tier a procedure falls into is set by the plan, not by the dentist, and root canals are classified as basic in some plans and major in others.
  3. The annual maximum: $______. This is the most the plan pays in a plan year, and the dental annual maximum is typically a modest figure compared with the cost of major work. Many plans count preventive care toward the maximum, while some do not.
  4. Waiting periods by tier: preventive ___ months, basic ___ months, major ___ months. A waiting period means a service in that tier is not covered until you have been enrolled that long.
  5. Whether the plan has a downgrade clause, sometimes called an alternate benefit: if a cheaper material would work, the plan pays based on the cheaper option.
  6. The network status of your dentist. In-network dentists agree to the plan's fee schedule, so the "allowed amount" is the contracted fee, which is often lower than the dentist's standard charge. Out of network, the plan may pay on a lower "usual and customary" figure and the dentist can bill you the difference. For plans that restrict you to a network, such as a Dental HMO, coverage looks different; see dental insurance explained: plans, waiting periods and annual limits.

The formula

For each procedure, in the order the plan processes the claims:

  • Step 1. Start with the allowed amount (the contracted fee if in network).
  • Step 2. Subtract any deductible you have not met yet. The remainder is what the coinsurance applies to.
  • Step 3. Multiply the remainder by the plan's percentage for that tier. That is the plan's share.
  • Step 4. Check the annual maximum. If the plan's total payments for the year would exceed the cap, the plan pays only what is left of the cap.
  • Step 5. Your share is the allowed amount minus the plan's share.

The hypothetical plan

Say the plan has:

  • A $50 deductible, applied to basic and major services and waived for preventive care.
  • Preventive care paid at 100%, basic at 80% and major at 50%.
  • A $1,000 annual maximum, which includes preventive care.
  • No waiting periods (a variant at the end adds one).
  • The plan treats a root canal as basic and a crown as major.

The dentist is in network. The allowed amounts are $900 for the root canal and $1,100 for the crown. Earlier this year the plan paid $200 for two cleanings and exams, so the plan has $800 left under its cap.

Scenario 1: both procedures in the same plan year

Root canal (basic, 80%).

  • Allowed amount: $900.
  • Subtract the unmet deductible: $900 minus $50 is $850.
  • Plan's share: 80% of $850 is $680.
  • Your share: $900 minus $680 is $220 (the $50 deductible plus $170 coinsurance).
  • Remaining annual maximum: $800 minus $680 is $120.

Crown (major, 50%).

  • Allowed amount: $1,100. The deductible is already met.
  • Before the cap, the plan's share would be 50% of $1,100, which is $550.
  • The cap leaves only $120, so the plan pays $120.
  • Your share: $1,100 minus $120 is $980.

Total for the year: the plan pays $680 plus $120, which is $800. You pay $220 plus $980, which is $1,200.

The plan's coinsurance promised 50% on the crown, but the annual maximum cut it to about 11%. That is how a plan that looks generous on paper can leave a big bill.

Scenario 2: split the work across two plan years

Now say the root canal is done in December and the crown is placed after January 1, when the plan year resets. Ask your dentist whether this is clinically acceptable. After a root canal the tooth is often protected with a temporary filling until the crown is ready, and leaving it too long can risk fracture or reinfection, so the dentist decides how long it is safe to wait.

December (year 1): root canal. Same as above: the plan pays $680, you pay $220. The plan has paid $200 plus $680, which is $880 for the year, under the $1,000 cap.

January (year 2): crown. The deductible and the annual maximum start fresh.

  • Allowed amount: $1,100.
  • Subtract the new deductible: $1,100 minus $50 is $1,050.
  • Plan's share: 50% of $1,050 is $525.
  • Your share: $1,100 minus $525 is $575.
  • The $525 is far below the new $1,000 cap, so the cap does not bind.

Total across the two years: you pay $220 plus $575, which is $795. In Scenario 1 you paid $1,200. Splitting saved $405 in this illustration.

Two cautions. First, plans decide which date counts for a crown: some use the date the tooth was prepared, some the date the final crown is seated. Ask the plan or the dentist's office which, because the same treatment can fall in different years depending on the rule. Second, the saving only exists when the cap is the problem. If the cap were $1,500 instead of $1,000, the plan would have paid $200 plus $680 plus $550, which is $1,430, and you would pay $770, so there would be nothing to gain by waiting.

Scenario 3: the plan has a waiting period for major work

Say the plan is new, with a 12-month waiting period for major services and a 6-month period for basic. If you enrolled three months ago, neither procedure is covered yet. You would pay the allowed amounts in full: $900 plus $1,100, which is $2,000. If you have waited 7 months, the root canal is covered (plan pays $680, you pay $220) but the crown is not covered for another five months, and you would pay the crown's full $1,100, for a total of $1,320.

If treatment can safely wait for the period to end, the savings can be large. If it cannot, you pay out of pocket, and you can ask the dentist whether any low-cost payment plan is offered. People who change jobs and plans should ask whether the new plan credits their time in the old plan; some do, and the waiting period is often waived for people who had prior coverage. Check the booklet.

The downgrade clause, in numbers

Say the dentist recommends a porcelain-fused crown at an allowed $1,100, but the plan's alternate benefit is based on a metal crown allowed at $900. Using the Scenario 2 crown in year 2:

  • Plan's share is calculated on the alternate amount: $900 minus $50 deductible is $850, times 50%, which is $425.
  • Your share: $1,100 minus $425 is $675, instead of $575.

The $100 difference is the cost of choosing the more expensive material. Ask the dentist or the plan whether the alternate-benefit clause applies to your crown, and ask about the material the dentist recommends and why.

Scenario 4: an out-of-network dentist

Everything above assumed an in-network dentist. Suppose instead the dentist is out of network and bills $1,400 for the crown, while the plan recognizes $1,100 as the usual and customary fee for it. Use the plan year with the cap not binding and the deductible already met.

  • Plan's share: 50% of the recognized $1,100 is $550.
  • Your share: $1,400 minus $550 is $850.
  • If the same crown had been done in network at an allowed $1,100, your share would have been $550.

The $300 difference is the part of the bill above what the plan recognizes, which an out-of-network dentist can generally charge you. Some plans pay out-of-network dentists less overall, or pay a lower percentage. If your regular dentist is out of network, ask the office for the cost under both situations before deciding, and ask whether the office would accept the plan's fee as payment in full. The general idea is the same as in in-network vs out-of-network care: what it means for your bill.

Questions to ask the dentist's office

Before any of this arithmetic is final, the office can answer questions that the plan's booklet does not:

  1. Which procedure codes will be billed, including any build-up, post, temporary crown or X-rays? Each code can fall in a different tier.
  2. Is the root canal done by a general dentist or an endodontist, and is the specialist in network?
  3. Is the treatment urgent, and how long is it safe to wait between the root canal and the crown?
  4. What is the fee if the plan pays nothing, and does the office offer a discount for paying in full or a payment plan?
  5. If the plan's estimate differs from what the claim pays, who is responsible for the difference?

Use a pre-treatment estimate

Before major work, ask the dentist's office to submit a pre-treatment estimate (also called a predetermination) to the plan. The plan responds with how it expects to process the claim, including the deductible, coinsurance, the maximum remaining and whether a downgrade applies. It is not a guarantee of payment, because eligibility and the remaining maximum can change before the claim is filed, but it removes most surprises and gives you the numbers for your worksheet. Allow a few weeks for it.

Things to confirm when the estimate comes back:

  • Which tier did the plan put each procedure in?
  • Does the estimate show the deductible and the remaining annual maximum?
  • Is the dentist in network, and is the estimate based on the contracted fee?
  • Does the estimate include a build-up or post for the crown? These add-on services are sometimes billed separately and classified differently.
  • Is there any alternate benefit?

If the estimate and the claim later differ, ask the plan to explain the difference in writing and the dentist's office to compare its codes. The guide how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan shows the same budgeting method for medical care.

Your blank worksheet

Fill in one row per procedure, in the order the dentist will do them.

Item Procedure 1 Procedure 2
Procedure
Allowed amount
Tier and plan percentage
Deductible still owed
Amount the coinsurance applies to (allowed minus deductible)
Plan's share before the cap
Annual maximum remaining
Plan's actual share (lower of the two lines above)
Your share (allowed minus plan's share)

Then add up your shares for the total. Run it twice, once for treatment in one plan year and once split across two, and compare. Add any waiting period or downgrade as a separate line if it applies.

When to get help

If a claim is processed in a way that does not match your estimate, call the plan's member services and ask for an explanation of how each line was calculated. If it still looks wrong, an appeal follows the same pattern as a medical denial, and the state insurance department takes complaints about dental plans sold in the state. Dental coverage that is bundled into a marketplace or employer health plan is a separate question from stand-alone dental; Do I need a stand-alone dental plan for my kids on the marketplace? covers one version of it. For problems that might be medical rather than dental, see Is a mouth or jaw problem covered by dental or medical insurance? Myths checked.

Key takeaways

  • Calculate each procedure in order: allowed amount, minus the deductible, times the plan's percentage, limited by what remains of the annual maximum.
  • The annual maximum often matters more than the coinsurance percentage, because it caps what the plan pays no matter how large the bill is.
  • Splitting treatment across two plan years can reset the deductible and the maximum, but only if the dentist considers the wait safe and only if you know which date your plan counts.
  • Waiting periods and downgrade clauses can change the total by hundreds of dollars, so read the booklet before choosing a material or a start date.
  • Ask for a pre-treatment estimate before major work and run your own worksheet against it.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic