Blog

Do I need a stand-alone dental plan for my kids on the marketplace?

Why child dental is an essential benefit yet often sold separately, how embedded and stand-alone dental count costs and credits, and a cost example.

Dental care for children is on the federal list of essential health benefits, so you might assume every marketplace medical plan includes it. Many do, but some leave it out and rely on a separate dental plan to meet the rule. Whether you need to buy that separate plan depends on three things: whether your medical plan already covers your children's teeth, what the dental coverage would cost compared with the work your children are likely to need, and whether the children could get dental coverage some other way, such as Medicaid or the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP).

This post explains the two designs, how each one counts costs, what happens to your tax credit, and how to decide with round numbers. The figures are illustrations, not prices.

Why child dental is "required" and still sold separately

The ACA lists ten categories of essential health benefits for individual and small-group plans, and one of them is pediatric services, including oral and vision care. A plan with all ten categories can be certified for sale on a marketplace. The Essential health benefits: the 10 categories ACA plans must cover guide lists the categories.

The rules let pediatric dental be delivered in two ways:

  • Embedded: the medical plan itself covers children's dental, so you buy one policy.
  • Stand-alone: the medical plan leaves out children's dental, and a separate dental plan sold on the same marketplace provides it. The two plans together meet the requirement.

For adults, the picture is different. Adult dental is not an essential health benefit. A stand-alone dental plan that also covers adults is covering something the ACA does not require, and its adult portion is priced on its own.

Federally, an enrollee is not required to buy the stand-alone plan, and the old federal tax penalty for not having health coverage is $0. A few states take a different approach and may expect or encourage children to have dental coverage, so check the state marketplace or your state insurance department. Rules for who counts as a child for the dental benefit also differ, but under the federal framework the benefit generally reaches to age 19, and some states set a different cutoff.

How to tell which kind you are looking at

When you shop, each medical plan's details should say whether it includes pediatric dental. The plan's summary of benefits and coverage and its policy documents should show what the dental benefit pays. A medical plan that does not include it will say the dental benefit is not included, or the shopping screen will offer a separate dental plan to add.

Do not assume. Two medical plans with similar premiums can differ here, and the one without embedded dental will look cheaper in the list of plans. Compare them on equal terms by adding the price of the dental plan you would need to the cheaper medical plan, or by subtracting the value of the embedded benefit from the other.

If your children might qualify for Medicaid or CHIP, check that before buying anything, because both programs cover dental care for children. The Health insurance options for children: employer, CHIP and marketplace and CHIP explained: low-cost health coverage for children guides explain who qualifies, and rules vary by state.

How each design counts the costs

This is the part that surprises people, because the same dental visit can cost very different amounts.

Embedded dental is usually built into the medical plan's cost-sharing. Depending on the plan, children's dental may have its own copays, may share the medical plan's deductible, and may count toward the plan's out-of-pocket maximum. Many plans cover cleanings and exams with no cost sharing, but fillings, crowns or extractions may fall under a deductible that is sized for hospital bills, not dental work. That makes the plan's medical deductible the thing to read first. A family with a $4,000 per person medical deductible whose child needs two fillings could pay the full price of the fillings.

Stand-alone dental is a separate policy with a separate premium, a separate (usually much smaller) deductible, its own coinsurance, and its own out-of-pocket limit for children's dental. Federal rules limit what a stand-alone dental plan can charge a child out of pocket in a year for the pediatric benefit. The plan documents list the exact limit; do not rely on a number you read elsewhere. Pediatric dental under the ACA also cannot have an annual dollar limit on essential benefits, which means a child's covered dental care typically has no yearly cap, unlike many adult dental plans (see dental annual maximum). The plan documents state this for your particular plan.

A stand-alone plan's separate deductible matters less when it is small, but it still applies per child, and some stand-alone plans use waiting periods or have rules about services such as orthodontia, which is usually covered only when medically necessary. Read the benefit schedule, not only the premium.

What happens to the tax credit

The premium tax credit is calculated against the benchmark plan, the second-lowest-cost silver plan in your area. The benchmark's premium is adjusted so that it reflects the pediatric dental benefit, so a medical plan without embedded dental does not make your credit smaller for that reason.

The tax calculation also treats the pediatric part of a stand-alone dental premium as part of the coverage you bought. When the medical plan you choose costs less than the benchmark, the unused part of your credit can sometimes be applied to the pediatric portion of the dental premium. That reduces what you pay for children's dental. It does not apply to the adult portion of a dental plan, and it does not make a credit that was already used up by the medical plan any bigger. How much you save, if anything, depends on your income and on your plan choices, so use the net price shown at checkout and ask a navigator to confirm. The How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share guide covers the mechanics and the ACA subsidy estimator shows the credit for your household. Dental premiums also appear on your tax form, so a tax professional can confirm how they were treated.

A round-number example

Say a family has two children and two medical plans to choose from. Plan E includes pediatric dental. Plan S leaves it out but the family could add a stand-alone dental plan. For simplicity, assume the medical premiums and credit are identical, so only the dental cost differs. All numbers are hypothetical.

  • Plan E (embedded): no extra premium. Cleanings and exams are covered in full. Other dental work is paid at full price until the child's $4,000 medical deductible is met, then 20%.
  • Stand-alone plan: $30 a month for both children, or $360 a year ($30 x 12). Cleanings and exams are covered in full. $50 deductible per child, then 20% coinsurance on fillings and crowns.

Preventive care only. Both children get two cleanings and exams, which are covered in full under either design. Embedded costs $0 extra. Stand-alone costs $360. Embedded is $360 cheaper.

One child needs two fillings. Allowed price $200 each, $400 in total. Embedded: the child pays all $400 because it is under the $4,000 deductible. Stand-alone: premium $360, plus the $50 deductible, plus 20% of the remaining $350, which is $70. That is $360 + $50 + $70 = $480. Embedded is $80 cheaper.

Both children need significant work. Allowed price $1,500 each, $3,000 in total. Embedded: each child is under the $4,000 deductible, so the family pays $3,000. Stand-alone: premium $360, plus two $50 deductibles ($100), plus 20% of the remaining $2,900 ($580). That is $360 + $100 + $580 = $1,040. Stand-alone is $1,960 cheaper ($3,000 minus $1,040).

Dental needs this year Embedded (Plan E) Stand-alone Cheaper
Cleanings and exams only $0 $360 Embedded by $360
Two fillings for one child ($400) $400 $480 Embedded by $80
$3,000 of work across two children $3,000 $1,040 Stand-alone by $1,960

The break-even is easy to find. With both deductibles met, stand-alone costs $360 + $100 + 20% of (work minus $100) = $440 + 20% of the work. That equals the embedded cost when the work is $550 ($440 divided by 0.8). If only one child has work, the break-even is $500 ($360 + $50 + 20% of the work minus $50, set equal to the work). In this illustration, once the children's non-preventive dental work is likely to pass $500 to $550 in a year, the stand-alone plan costs less.

Real embedded plans vary a lot. Some have copays for fillings, some have a separate dental deductible, and some count the cost toward the out-of-pocket maximum, which can pull the embedded cost down. Redo the arithmetic with the numbers in your own plan documents.

Other things to check before you buy

  • Dentist network. Confirm your children's dentist is in the network of the plan you are considering, and whether it is a dental HMO that requires a primary dentist or a PPO that does not. The Dental insurance page explains the types.
  • What counts as a child. Ask what age the pediatric benefit ends and when the dental plan stops covering your child.
  • Orthodontia. Braces are often covered only for a severe medical need. If orthodontia is likely, ask the plan how it decides and what it pays.
  • Waiting periods and exclusions. A few plans delay major work. Ask whether any waiting period applies to essential pediatric benefits.
  • Enrollment timing. A stand-alone dental plan is generally bought on the same enrollment timeline as medical coverage. Check the dates for your marketplace.
  • Coverage you already have. An employer's dental plan, a parent's plan, or Medicaid or CHIP may already cover your children.
  • Duplicate coverage. If your medical plan already includes children's dental, a stand-alone plan would overlap and the two plans coordinate which pays first.

The How much will insurance pay for a crown and root canal? A worked dental example post shows how dental annual maximums work for adults, which is a different animal from the pediatric benefit.

A decision list

  1. If your children qualify for Medicaid or CHIP, use that coverage and skip the stand-alone plan.
  2. If your medical plan includes children's dental with low cost sharing, a stand-alone plan adds little. Check whether the plan's dental deductible and coinsurance are friendly.
  3. If the embedded dental falls under a large medical deductible and your children are likely to need fillings or other work, a stand-alone plan often costs less.
  4. If your children need nothing beyond cleanings and exams, and the embedded plan covers those in full, you probably do not need a separate plan.
  5. If an orthodontist has already recommended braces, read each plan's orthodontia rule before deciding, because it may drive the whole choice.
  6. If you want adult dental too, compare the adult portion separately, because it is not covered by the credit and is priced on its own.

When the answer is not clear, a navigator, a licensed broker or your state marketplace can compare the actual plans, and your dentist's office can tell you which plans they accept.

Questions to ask before you pick a dental plan

Bring this short list to the plan's customer service line, the dentist's front desk or a navigator.

  1. Does my medical plan include pediatric dental, and where do I see the benefit schedule?
  2. For a filling, a crown and an extraction, what does my child pay under each plan, in dollars, before and after the deductible?
  3. Does the dental cost count toward the medical plan's out-of-pocket maximum, or does it have its own limit?
  4. Is our dentist in the network, and does the office accept this exact plan name?
  5. How does the plan decide whether braces are medically necessary, and what does it pay if it approves them?
  6. When the dental premium is added to the medical premium, what is the total after my credit?

Writing the answers down for each plan makes the comparison fair, and it gives you a record if a claim is processed differently from what you were told.

Key takeaways

  • Children's dental is an essential health benefit, but a marketplace medical plan may include it or rely on a separate stand-alone dental plan.
  • Embedded dental often sits under the medical plan's larger deductible; stand-alone dental has its own premium, a small deductible and its own limit.
  • In the round-number example, embedded dental won when children needed only cleanings or a couple of fillings, and stand-alone dental won when the work reached about $500 to $550.
  • The credit is based on a benchmark that already accounts for pediatric dental, and part of an unused credit can sometimes help with the pediatric portion of a stand-alone dental premium.
  • Check Medicaid and CHIP first, then compare dentist networks, the age cutoff and the orthodontia rule.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic