Blog
Why are my diabetes test strips, pump and sensor billed to different benefits?
How the pharmacy, durable medical equipment and medical benefits split diabetes supplies, why a sensor may need approval, and what switching suppliers changes.
A person with diabetes can have supplies that arrive from three different places, on three different cost-sharing rules, because the plan sorts each item into the benefit it thinks the item belongs to. Insulin and test strips usually go through the pharmacy benefit. An insulin pump is usually durable medical equipment. A continuous glucose monitor (CGM) can land in either place, depending on the plan. The result is that your deductible, your copays and the company you call for help can change from one item to the next.
This post explains how the benefits divide, why each has its own rules, and what that means for approvals, quantity limits, suppliers and your yearly costs. It describes how plans generally work. Your plan's documents decide the details, and your clinician decides what you need.
The three benefits and what each one is for
A health plan is not a single pool of coverage. It is a set of benefits, each with its own rules, its own claims systems and, often, its own vendors.
The pharmacy benefit covers prescription drugs and some supplies dispensed by pharmacies. It runs on a formulary, a list of covered drugs sorted into tiers, with copays or coinsurance by tier. Many plans hire a pharmacy benefit manager to run it, which is why pharmacy claims are processed in a different system from doctor and hospital claims. what pharmacy benefit managers do and why they matter covers what a PBM does.
The durable medical equipment (DME) benefit covers equipment that is used repeatedly, is meant for medical use at home and lasts for a reasonable time. Wheelchairs, oxygen equipment and insulin pumps are typical examples. DME is usually part of the medical benefit and is typically supplied by a contracted DME company, not by a pharmacy. Cost sharing is often a percentage of the allowed amount after the deductible.
The medical benefit covers services from clinicians and facilities: visits, tests, diabetes education and eye exams. A claim for an office visit or a lab test goes through the plan's medical claims system.
A single supply can be sorted into any of these three. The sorting is a plan decision, made by contract, and it is why a friend with a different plan may tell you a completely different story about the same device.
Where each diabetes item usually lands
Plans differ, so use this as a map of what to ask, not an answer.
| Item | Often billed under | Common rules to expect |
|---|---|---|
| Insulin (vials, pens) | Pharmacy | Formulary tier, possibly prior authorization for some products, quantity limit |
| Glucagon | Pharmacy | Tier, quantity limits |
| Test strips and lancets | Pharmacy, sometimes DME | Quantity limit per month, preferred meter brand |
| Blood glucose meter | Pharmacy or DME | Often tied to a preferred brand |
| Pen needles and syringes | Pharmacy | Usually low tier |
| Continuous glucose monitor (reader, sensors, transmitter) | DME or pharmacy | Prior authorization, documentation of need, supplier rules |
| Insulin pump | DME | Prior authorization, purchase or rental, replacement rules |
| Pump supplies (infusion sets, cartridges) | DME or pharmacy | Monthly quantity limits, supplier |
| Tubeless or patch-style pump pods | Pharmacy or DME | Varies by product and plan |
| Diabetes education, eye exams, foot exams, A1C tests | Medical | Visit rules, sometimes preventive or chronic-care programs |
Plans also move products between benefits over time. A plan that sent CGM sensors through DME one year may move them to the pharmacy benefit the next, which is one reason to check at renewal and not assume last year's routing still applies.
Why a CGM may need prior authorization
A continuous glucose monitor costs more over a year than strips, and plans manage the spending by asking for documentation that the device is appropriate. prior authorization for a CGM often turns on a few facts: the diagnosis, the type of treatment (for example whether the person uses insulin and how often), a history of problems such as low blood sugar, and whether the person has been seen by a clinician recently. Plans set their own criteria and change them over time, so the answer for you depends on this year's plan.
If you are approved, the approval may be for a set period, with renewal requiring a visit or documentation. Ask when it ends, and ask the clinic to start the renewal early. If you are denied, the notice should state the reason and the criteria, and you can appeal; how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied and what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need explain the steps. A letter from the prescriber explaining why this device suits your situation is the most useful document you can add.
Quantity limits on test strips and other supplies
Plans cap how many strips and lancets they will cover in a month, because the number a person uses varies widely and strips are a high-volume item. A typical rule sets a monthly limit and allows more if the prescriber documents the need, for example for a person who tests many times a day, who is pregnant or who is adjusting a regimen. If your prescriber writes the prescription for the number you really use, and the plan's limit is lower, the pharmacy fills the limit and you pay cash or go without for the rest of the month.
To handle this:
- Ask the plan what the monthly limit is and whether an exception process exists.
- Ask your clinician to write the prescription with the testing frequency in the directions, and to submit an exception request if you need more.
- Check that the meter and strips are matched. Plans often cover one or two preferred brands, and strips are not interchangeable between meters.
- If you use a CGM, ask whether the plan still covers strips for backup, and how many.
Pumps are equipment, and the equipment rules apply
An insulin pump is usually bought or rented through a DME supplier. The plan's DME rules can include:
- Prior authorization for the pump, with documentation of your diagnosis and your treatment history.
- A network of suppliers. The plan may require a particular supplier or manufacturer relationship, and an out-of-network supplier may be covered at a lower level or not at all.
- Purchase or rental. Some plans rent the pump for a period before owning it. Ask who owns it and what happens if you leave the plan.
- A replacement schedule. Plans commonly cover a replacement only after a set number of years, often matched to the warranty, with exceptions for failure.
- A deductible and coinsurance on the allowed amount, instead of a flat copay.
Pump supplies, such as infusion sets and cartridges, are sometimes billed through the same DME supplier on a monthly schedule and sometimes through the pharmacy. Changing from one pump to another is a change in equipment, which can change the benefit that applies. A tubeless pump that is supplied through a pharmacy can be billed on a different benefit from a tubed pump supplied by a DME company, with a different cost for the same person.
If you have Medicare, the Part B and Part D split is a separate issue, and How does Medicare pay for a CPAP, walker or wheelchair, and what do I ask? covers how Medicare supplier rules work for equipment generally.
What it means for your yearly costs
The same device can cost very different amounts depending on the benefit. Here is an illustration with round numbers invented for this post.
Suppose a plan has a $1,500 deductible on medical and DME services, 20% coinsurance after it, a $4,000 out-of-pocket maximum shared by medical and pharmacy, and pharmacy copays of $30 a month for insulin and $20 a month for strips. A CGM costs an allowed $300 a month. Compare two ways the plan could route the sensors.
| Item | Annual calculation | Your cost |
|---|---|---|
| Insulin | 12 x $30 | $360 |
| Strips | 12 x $20 | $240 |
| CGM sensors, routed to DME | 12 x $300 = $3,600; first $1,500 deductible, then 20% of $2,100 = $420 | $1,920 |
| CGM sensors, routed to pharmacy at $50 a month | 12 x $50 | $600 |
Under DME routing, the total for the three items is $360 + $240 + $1,920 = $2,520. Under pharmacy routing, it is $360 + $240 + $600 = $1,200. The difference of $1,320 comes from the benefit, not from the device.
Now add a pump purchased in the same year for an allowed $6,500, which goes through the DME benefit. With DME-routed sensors, the DME total allowed amount is $6,500 + $3,600 = $10,100. The deductible takes the first $1,500, and 20% of the remaining $8,600 is $1,720, so the DME cost is $1,500 + $1,720 = $3,220. Add the $600 in pharmacy copays for insulin and strips, and the total is $3,820, just under the $4,000 out-of-pocket maximum. If the maximum were lower, the plan would pay everything above it.
Two lessons follow. First, ask which benefit each item is billed under before you compare plans, because the deductible and coinsurance that apply to equipment are different from pharmacy copays. Second, timing matters. A pump bought in December and sensors starting in January fall in different plan years, with two deductibles. how to track your deductible and out-of-pocket spending and the deductible and out-of-pocket tracker show how to keep a running total across both benefits.
Some plans use a copay accumulator, which means manufacturer assistance does not count toward your deductible or maximum. How to find out if my plan has a copay accumulator before I enroll explains how to check for it.
How to switch suppliers or move an item to another benefit
A change of supplier is possible but needs preparation, because the new supplier has to have the order, the approval and the documentation.
- Check the network first. Ask the plan which suppliers are in network for the specific item, and ask the new supplier whether it is in network for your plan on the date you want to start.
- Ask the old supplier about the timing of the last shipment so you do not run short or receive two shipments.
- Get a new prescription or order if the supplier requires its own, and ask your clinician to send the supporting notes.
- Ask whether the prior authorization transfers. Some are tied to a supplier, and some to the member. If a new approval is required, ask how long it takes.
- Check ownership and warranty. If your pump or reader was supplied under a rental or a manufacturer arrangement, switching may affect the warranty and the support line.
- Confirm the first shipment's cost before it ships.
If the plan has moved an item to a different benefit, ask for the notice in writing and for the date. Sometimes a plan allows a transition fill or a continuity-of-care period; ask whether one applies.
For insulin pricing, caps and manufacturer programs, see How can I lower my insulin costs with insurance and assistance programs?, which covers that subject in detail.
Questions to ask your plan
- Under which benefit is each of my items billed: insulin, strips, meter, sensors, pump and pump supplies?
- What is my cost sharing for each, and do they share one deductible or out-of-pocket maximum?
- Which items need prior authorization, and for how long is it valid?
- What are the monthly quantity limits, and how do I request more?
- Which suppliers and pharmacies are in network for each item?
- What happens to my coverage if I change pump or sensor brands?
Key takeaways
- A health plan routes diabetes items to the pharmacy, durable medical equipment or medical benefit, and each benefit has its own approvals, networks and cost sharing. The routing is a plan decision and can change between years.
- A CGM often needs prior authorization with documentation of need, and the approval may expire. Ask the clinic to renew early.
- Strips are limited by monthly quantity caps and matched to preferred meters. Ask the prescriber for an exception when your actual use is higher.
- In the illustration, the same sensors cost $1,920 a year under a DME deductible and $600 under a pharmacy copay, so ask which benefit applies before comparing plans.
- Switching suppliers needs a network check, a new order and confirmation that the approval transfers.