Blog

Does HIPAA protect the health data in my fitness tracker and health apps?

Why most consumer apps and wearables fall outside HIPAA, what privacy policies usually allow, which other laws apply, and how to limit and delete your data.

Usually not. The federal health privacy rule, HIPAA, protects health information held by a defined list of organizations: most doctors and hospitals, health plans, and the vendors that work for them. A step counter, a sleep tracker, a meditation app or a symptom checker that you downloaded on your own is typically none of those. The data it holds can be just as personal as a lab result, yet it is governed by the app maker's privacy policy, by state law and by general consumer-protection law rather than by the health privacy rule.

This post explains where the line falls, what the fine print tends to permit, what happens when you connect an app to your doctor's patient portal, and how to limit and delete what apps hold. It does not rate or recommend any product.

The rule follows the organization, not the data

HIPAA does not say "all health data is protected." It says that two kinds of organizations must protect certain information, and that rules apply when they handle it.

  • Covered entities. Health plans (insurers, HMOs, Medicare, Medicaid and employer group health plans), clearinghouses that process claims, and health care providers that bill electronically. Your doctor, your hospital and your pharmacy are in this group.
  • Business associates. Companies that create, receive, maintain or send protected health information for a covered entity: a billing company, a claims administrator (see third-party administrator), a cloud host, a transcription service. They sign a contract with the covered entity and are directly bound by parts of the rule.

Everyone else, including you, your family, an employer acting as an employer, a retailer, a data broker and the developer of a consumer app, is outside the rule. If a covered entity discloses your records, HIPAA is the question (see Who can see my health information? Seven HIPAA myths, tested for what the rule does and does not allow). If your own watch uploads your heart rate to a company's server, HIPAA is generally not.

The same piece of data can be inside and outside the rule at different moments. A blood pressure reading entered in your doctor's chart is protected information. The same reading you type into a free wellness app is, as far as the federal privacy rule goes, a consumer's entry in a consumer product.

Why most apps and wearables fall outside

A consumer health app is usually in one of these positions.

  1. You downloaded it yourself and use it on your own. The developer has no contract with a doctor or plan. It is not a covered entity or a business associate.
  2. It is a wellness or fitness product that records activity, sleep, diet, mood, cycles or weight. These are not "health care" services for HIPAA purposes unless a provider or plan is involved.
  3. It is a direct-to-consumer service such as a genetic test kit, an online symptom checker or a telehealth marketplace that does not bill insurance. Some telehealth companies do bill insurance and are covered entities; check what the company says in its notice of privacy practices.

The rule can apply to an app in some situations:

  • The app is run for a provider or plan. If your hospital or insurer offers an app and the developer builds it on their behalf, the developer is likely a business associate and the data it handles for that purpose is protected.
  • An employer wellness program is part of the group health plan. A wellness program offered through the plan can be covered. A program the employer runs separately, outside the plan, generally is not. For how employer plans are structured, see how employer health insurance works: premiums, plan choices and rules.
  • A telehealth or digital clinic is itself a provider that bills insurance.

If you cannot tell which case you are in, look for a notice of privacy practices or a HIPAA statement in the app's legal pages, and ask the company directly: "Are you a covered entity or business associate under HIPAA for the data I enter here?" A company that is not will say so.

When data is outside HIPAA, the privacy policy and terms of service are the main rulebook, and they are written by the company. Policies differ, so read the one you are agreeing to. Common provisions, described in general terms:

  • Collecting more than you typed. Location, device identifiers, contacts, usage patterns and information from linked services.
  • Using data to run and improve the product, including research and the development of new features.
  • Sharing with service providers, such as hosting companies, analytics firms and payment processors, who act on the company's behalf.
  • Sharing for advertising. Many policies allow sharing certain data with advertising partners, sometimes in "de-identified" or "aggregated" form. Terms like "de-identified" are defined by the company or by a state law, not necessarily by HIPAA's stricter standard, so ask what the company means.
  • Transfer if the company is sold or merges. Your data may move with the business.
  • Changes at the company's discretion. Many policies let the company update the terms by posting a notice.
  • Retention. The policy may say how long data is kept after you delete the app. Sometimes deleting an app does not delete the account or the data.

Consent screens need careful reading too. A permission prompt that lets an app read your health data from your phone's health store is a decision about that app. It does not undo anything you have already agreed to elsewhere, and a toggle labeled "share data to improve services" may mean sharing with third parties. Read the label for what it says, not what you hope it says.

Which other laws apply

Outside HIPAA, protection comes from a patchwork.

  • Federal consumer-protection law. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) can act against companies that deceive consumers about privacy practices, for example by promising not to share health data and then sharing it. It has also enforced a breach notification rule that applies to some vendors of personal health records and related apps that are not covered by HIPAA; check the FTC's website for the rule's current scope.
  • State laws. Several states have passed consumer privacy statutes, and some address consumer health data specifically, with consent requirements and deletion rights. They differ in scope, and some apply only above certain business-size thresholds. Your state attorney general's website, or your state's consumer-protection office, is the place to check what covers you.
  • Genetic privacy and discrimination laws. Federal law limits health insurers and employers from using genetic information in some ways. It does not make a genetic testing company's data-sharing choices subject to HIPAA.
  • Contract law and your own agreement. What you clicked "I agree" to still counts.

The practical consequence: the protection you have is only as strong as the app's policy plus whichever state law reaches it. That is not an argument to avoid apps. It is an argument to decide, for each one, how sensitive the data is.

Why it matters for insurance specifically

For health insurance sold through the marketplace, the Affordable Care Act bars insurers from pricing individual and small-group policies on your health status, so an app's data does not change your premium for those plans. Other kinds of insurance work differently: life, disability and long-term care insurers do ask about health and may rely on information you provide and records you authorize. And a data breach at an app can expose information that someone can use in a scam; see medical identity theft and insurer data breaches: what to do and health insurance scam.

Whether any particular company sells or shares health-related data with insurers or brokers is a claim to verify with the policy, not to assume either way.

Many patient portals let you send your records to an app of your choosing. Under HIPAA, you have a right to access your records and to have a copy sent to a third party you designate. This is useful: it lets an app show your lab trends or consolidate records from several providers.

What changes at the moment of transfer:

  1. While the data sits in the provider's system, it is protected by HIPAA.
  2. Once the provider sends it to an app at your direction, the provider is generally not responsible for what the app does with it. The copy in the app is governed by the app's policy and by the laws above.
  3. The provider still has to follow your directions. It cannot refuse to send the data merely because it dislikes the app, though it may warn you that the app is not covered by HIPAA.

Questions to ask before you link:

  • What data will the app pull: everything, or only what you select?
  • Does the app let you delete data and your account, and does it say how long deletion takes?
  • Will it share data with advertisers or sell it?
  • Can you turn off the connection later, and does that remove what was copied?
  • Is the app run by or for your provider or plan? If so, the rule may apply.

If you are not sure, you can start by linking a small slice, such as medication lists or immunizations, rather than the entire chart.

A checklist for limiting and deleting your data

Use it once per app and repeat when an app updates.

Before you install

  • Read the privacy policy's sections on what is collected, who it is shared with, how long it is kept and how to delete it.
  • Check whether the company states it is subject to HIPAA, and for which data.
  • Look for the company's contact address for privacy requests.
  • Decide what you will enter. You can often use an app without entering a diagnosis, a name or a date of birth.

After you install

  • Turn off permissions you do not need: location, contacts, microphone, and access to the phone's health store beyond the categories you want.
  • Opt out of ad personalization and data sharing in settings, if offered.
  • Use a separate email address if you want to limit linking to other accounts.
  • Turn on two-step sign-in.

When you stop using it

  • Disconnect it from any portal or other service first, so it stops receiving updates.
  • Use the in-app account deletion option, if there is one, instead of only deleting the app. Many apps keep data after the icon is gone.
  • Send a written deletion request to the privacy contact and keep a copy. In states with consumer privacy laws, you may have a legal right to deletion and a deadline for the company to respond.
  • Ask a company that sold your data to others to pass your deletion request along; some state laws require it.
  • Revoke the app's access in your phone's settings, and in the settings of any linked account.

If something goes wrong

  • Ask the company for its explanation in writing.
  • Complain to the state attorney general or consumer-protection office and the FTC. If the app is run for a provider or plan, also complain to that organization and to the Office for Civil Rights. The steps in how to file a complaint with your state insurance department work for a state insurance complaint, which applies if the app belongs to a plan.

A note on health account cards and employer tools

A debit card tied to a health savings or flexible spending account (see HSA and FSA) shows merchants and category codes to the account administrator, and some administrators offer apps. These are financial and administrative records, usually handled under the account provider's own rules and, for FSAs that are part of an employer health plan, possibly under the plan's HIPAA duties. FSA vs HSA: the differences in eligibility, limits and rollover explains the accounts. If the privacy of what you buy matters to you, ask the administrator what it keeps and who can see it.

Key takeaways

  • HIPAA protects health data held by covered entities and their business associates, not health data as such, so most consumer apps and wearables you use on your own are outside it.
  • A privacy policy and the consent screens are the main protection for app data; read what is collected, who it is shared with and how deletion works.
  • The FTC, state consumer-health-privacy laws and your state attorney general may apply when HIPAA does not; check what your state offers.
  • Data you direct a provider to send to an app is generally no longer covered by HIPAA once it arrives, so choose how much to link.
  • Limit permissions, opt out of sharing, delete accounts (not only apps) and keep a written record of requests.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic