Guides

Medical identity theft and insurer data breaches: what to do

Spot medical identity theft through your statements and bills, then freeze credit, fix your records and report it. Breach notices follow federal rules.

Medical identity theft happens when someone uses your name, insurance number or Social Security number to get care, drugs or equipment, or to file false claims. A data breach at an insurer, hospital or billing company can expose the information that makes this possible. The steps are the same either way: read your statements, put a freeze on your credit, ask your insurer and providers to flag your account, correct your records, and report what you find. If a breach notice arrives, it is the start of your response, not the end.

How it shows up

Medical identity theft is harder to notice than a stolen credit card because the signs are in paperwork that most people skim. Look for:

  • An explanation of benefits for care you did not receive, from a provider you do not know.
  • A bill or collection notice for a visit, prescription or device you never used.
  • A plan notice that you have reached a benefit limit when you have not.
  • A denied claim because the plan says you already had the same service.
  • A change to your medical record, such as a condition, blood type or allergy that is not yours.
  • A call from a debt collector for an account you do not recognize.
  • Prescriptions at a pharmacy you did not use, or refusals to fill one because "you just picked it up."

Read every explanation of benefits when it arrives, or review claims in your insurer's portal at least monthly. How to read an explanation of benefits (EOB) line by line shows what each line means, and the Medical bill and EOB checker gives a checklist.

What to do right away

  1. Write down what you found. Record dates, providers, claim numbers and who you talked to. Save the documents.
  2. Contact your insurer's fraud or member services line using the number on your card. Ask them to note the account, review the claims you dispute and tell you what they will do. If they offer a new member ID number, accept it.
  3. Contact the provider's billing and privacy office. Ask them to hold the account and stop collection while it is investigated. Ask for copies of what was billed under your name.
  4. Freeze your credit with each of the three nationwide credit bureaus: Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. Freezes are free by federal law and stop most new accounts from being opened in your name. An initial fraud alert is another free option and lasts one year.
  5. Report it at IdentityTheft.gov, the Federal Trade Commission's site. It produces a recovery plan and an identity theft report you can show to providers and collectors.
  6. If Medicare is involved, call 1-800-MEDICARE and ask about replacing your number; see How to spot and report Medicare fraud, hospice fraud and billing abuse.
  7. If a claim or bill needs a formal fix, file a complaint with your plan, then with your state insurance department if the plan does not respond.

Fixing your medical record

Wrong information in a record is more than an inconvenience: it can lead to the wrong treatment. Under the federal privacy law known as HIPAA, you have a right to see and receive a copy of your records from covered providers and plans. You can also ask in writing for corrections. The provider generally has 60 days to act on the request, with a possible 30-day extension. If it refuses, you can submit a statement of disagreement that becomes part of the record. Ask each provider where the thief received care, and ask the insurer for a list of claims paid under your number so you can find them all.

How breach notices work

When a HIPAA-covered entity, such as an insurer or a hospital, discovers a breach of unsecured protected health information, the federal Breach Notification Rule requires it to notify affected individuals without unreasonable delay, and no later than 60 days after discovery. Breaches that affect 500 or more people also must be reported to the Department of Health and Human Services and to the media in the affected area, and the department keeps a public list. Smaller breaches are reported to the department yearly. A company that handles data for a covered entity, called a business associate, must notify the covered entity, which then notifies you. Many states have their own breach laws, some with shorter deadlines, and your state attorney general or insurance department can tell you what applies.

A breach letter should say what happened, what information was involved, what steps you should take, what the organization is doing and how to reach it. Many letters offer free credit monitoring for a period. Credit monitoring watches credit files; it does not watch medical claims, so keep reading your explanations of benefits.

A scenario

Say Priya, in this illustration, receives a breach notice from a company that processed claims for her insurer. The letter says names, member IDs and dates of birth may have been exposed. She does not know whether anything has been misused. In that case a reasonable set of steps is to freeze credit at the three bureaus, enroll in the monitoring offered, check her insurer portal each month for claims she does not recognize, and keep the letter. Three months later she sees a claim for a service in another state. She calls her insurer, requests a claim dispute, files at IdentityTheft.gov, and asks the provider to send what was billed under her name.

Limiting the risk

  • Share your insurance number only with providers, plans and pharmacies you use.
  • Be wary of anyone who calls to "verify" your member ID; call back at the card's number. See how to spot a health insurance scam and what to do about it.
  • Shred paper statements and card copies you no longer need.
  • Do not lend your card to anyone to get care; it can also be a form of fraud.
  • Use unique passwords for portals, and turn on two-step sign-in if it is offered.
  • Review explanations of benefits for family members you manage, including children.

If the problem has created medical debt, see medical debt and your rights: collections, credit reports, lawsuits for how to challenge and dispute it.

Key takeaways

  • The signs of medical identity theft are in paperwork: statements for care you did not get, collection notices and benefit limits you did not reach.
  • Freeze your credit for free at all three bureaus, report at IdentityTheft.gov and tell your insurer and the providers involved.
  • HIPAA gives you the right to see and ask to correct your records.
  • Breach notices to individuals are due no later than 60 days after discovery under the federal rule; states may set shorter deadlines.
  • Credit monitoring does not watch medical claims, so keep reviewing your explanations of benefits.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic