Blog
My job's family coverage costs too much: can my spouse and kids get credits?
Four hypothetical households show how the affordability test treats the employee and the family, and what that means for credits. Verify the current IRS rule.
A worker can look at a paycheck stub showing $200 a month for her own health plan and $1,000 a month for the family plan, and reasonably ask why the family's cost does not count when the marketplace decides who gets help. For years it did not. Under the rules the IRS finalized in 2022, which apply to plan years beginning in 2023 and later, it generally does. Family members can be tested on what coverage for them costs, separately from the employee.
This post works through four hypothetical households with the same income and different family shapes, shows how the test applies to each, and says what to ask. It describes the rule as the IRS has stated it in recent years. The rules on this subject have drawn debate and proposals, so confirm the current version with a navigator, the instructions for Form 8962 or a tax professional before you decide anything. The prices below are made up.
The test in plain terms
An offer of employer coverage can block a premium tax credit in two ways: if the coverage is affordable and if it provides minimum value. Both must be true for the offer to block it.
- Minimum value means the plan pays at least about 60% of the average cost of covered services (minimum value). Most large-employer plans meet it. Some very thin plans do not.
- Affordable means the cost to the person for the lowest-priced coverage that meets minimum value does not exceed a set percentage of household income. For plan years beginning in 2026, that percentage is 9.96%. For plan years beginning in 2027, it is 10.22%. A plan that starts in 2026 on a non-calendar year keeps the 2026 figure for its whole term. (affordability and Is your employer coverage affordable? The affordability test explained explain the definition.)
The difference this post is about is whose cost is tested.
- For the employee: the cost of the cheapest self-only coverage that meets minimum value. Dependents do not enter into it.
- For a spouse or child: the cost of the cheapest coverage that includes that person and meets minimum value, meaning the employee's share of the premium for the family tier. Before the rule changed, family members were tested on the employee's self-only price too, so a cheap employee-only plan blocked credits for everyone, which is what people called the family glitch.
Someone who is offered affordable coverage is not eligible for the credit for the months of the offer, whether or not they enroll.
The prices used in all four households
Every household earns $60,000 a year. The test for plan year 2027 uses 10.22% of household income, which for $60,000 is 0.1022 × $60,000 = $6,132 a year, or $511 a month. If the employee's share of the cost is above $511 a month, the coverage is not affordable.
Say the employer's lowest-priced minimum-value plan costs the employee:
| Coverage tier | Employee cost per month | Per year | Share of $60,000 | Affordable at 10.22%? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Employee only | $200 | $2,400 | 4.0% | Yes |
| Employee and spouse | $650 | $7,800 | 13.0% | No |
| Employee and children | $600 | $7,200 | 12.0% | No |
| Employee, spouse and children | $1,000 | $12,000 | 20.0% | No |
For the marketplace side, the examples use the poverty guidelines that apply to 2027 coverage ($27,320 for three people, $33,000 for four) and expected-contribution percentages that are invented: 8% of income for households of two and three, and 6% for the household of four. Assume each adult's benchmark premium is $7,200 a year and each child's is $2,400.
Household one: a single employee
Dana is single and the only person covered. Her cost for employee-only coverage is $200 a month, or 4.0% of her $60,000 income, which is below 10.22%. The offer is affordable. Dana is not eligible for a marketplace credit for the months the offer stands, though she can buy a marketplace plan at full price if she wants one.
The family-versus-self question does not arise, but this household shows why you must find the right row of the table. For an employee, the self-only row is the only one that counts.
Household two: an employee with a spouse
Chris is covered on the employer plan at $200 a month. Chris's spouse, Alex, would add $450 a month, bringing the employee-plus-spouse tier to $650, or 13.0% of $60,000. That is above 10.22%, so coverage for Alex is not affordable. Chris's own offer remains affordable, so Chris is not eligible for a credit, but Alex generally may be.
Household income is $60,000 for two people. The poverty level for two is $21,640, so the household is at about 277% of poverty, inside the 400% line. With the invented 8%:
- Expected contribution: 8% × $60,000 = $4,800 a year.
- Alex's benchmark: $7,200 a year.
- Credit: $7,200 minus $4,800 = $2,400 a year.
The two ways of covering Alex compare like this:
| Cost to the household per year | |
|---|---|
| Add Alex to the employer plan | $5,400 more ($650 minus $200, times 12) |
| Buy a benchmark marketplace plan for Alex | $4,800 ($7,200 minus the $2,400 credit) |
The marketplace plan is cheaper on paper by $600 a year in this example. Cost is not the only difference. The employer plan may offer a shared family deductible, a broader network or an employer contribution toward an HSA, and a marketplace plan has its own deductible and network. Chris and Alex are two people on two plans, with two deductibles. If employer cost rises or falls, so does the comparison.
Household three: an employee with children
Sam covers himself at $200 a month. Adding two children brings the employee-and-children tier to $600, or 12.0% of $60,000, above 10.22%. The children are not offered affordable coverage, which makes them eligible for marketplace credits in principle.
First, check CHIP and Medicaid. At $60,000 for a household of three, income is about 220% of the poverty level. Children's coverage through CHIP or Medicaid reaches different income levels in different states, and children who qualify for it are generally not eligible for the credit. A navigator or the state's CHIP office can tell you. Kids on CHIP, parents on a marketplace plan: how does a split family work? covers a split household.
Now suppose the children do not qualify for CHIP. With the invented 8%:
- Expected contribution: 8% × $60,000 = $4,800.
- The children's benchmark: 2 × $2,400 = $4,800.
- Credit: $4,800 minus $4,800 = $0.
This household is eligible and gets nothing, which is a result people overlook. The credit equals the benchmark premium of the people enrolled minus a share of the whole household's income. When the people enrolled are children, whose premiums are low, the share of income can eat all of the benchmark. If the children's benchmark had been $5,400, the credit would have been $600. Eligibility is a yes or no; the credit is an amount, and it can be zero.
Household four: the whole family
Pat, a spouse and two children make up a household of four. The family tier costs Pat $1,000 a month, or 20.0% of the $60,000, so family coverage is not affordable. Pat's own self-only price is $200, so Pat is not eligible, but the spouse and children generally are.
At $60,000, the household is at about 182% of the poverty level for four ($33,000), under 200%, so use the invented 6%:
- Expected contribution: 6% × $60,000 = $3,600 a year.
- Benchmark for the spouse and two children: $7,200 + $4,800 = $12,000.
- Credit: $12,000 minus $3,600 = $8,400.
The comparison:
| Cost to the household per year | |
|---|---|
| Move the family from employee-only to the family tier | $9,600 more ($1,000 minus $200, times 12 = $800 a month) |
| Marketplace plans for spouse and children | $3,600 ($12,000 minus the $8,400 credit) |
In this invented example the gap is large because the income is modest for a family of four. People in real situations see a wide range of gaps, from a large saving to none, and the cost-sharing, network and deductible differences remain. The household could also use CHIP for the children if they qualify, which would change the numbers again.
How to check your own situation
- Get the prices for every tier. Ask HR for the employee's cost, for the lowest-priced plan that meets minimum value, for employee-only, employee and spouse, employee and children, and family. The Form 1095-C from a large employer shows only the self-only cost, so it will not answer the family question. I got a Form 1095-C from my employer, so what do the codes mean? explains the form.
- Ask whether the plan meets minimum value. The summary of benefits and coverage or the benefits office can tell you.
- Compute each tier's share of household income. Divide the annual cost by your household income, using the marketplace's definition of income (modified adjusted gross income). Compare with the plan year's percentage.
- Run the credit estimate for the people who would be on the marketplace plan, with the employer coverage affordability test and the ACA subsidy estimator or a navigator's tool.
- Compare the whole cost, including deductibles, networks and any HSA or employer contribution, not only the premium.
- Check the timing. Declining job-based coverage for family members on your own is generally not a special enrollment event (special enrollment period). The usual window for dropping family members from the employer plan is the employer's open enrollment, with the marketplace open enrollment dates at HealthCare.gov or your state exchange.
- Answer the employer questions truthfully on the marketplace application. If the IRS later decides the coverage was affordable, the credit has to be repaid.
Cases that change the answer
A few situations do not fit the four households, and each is worth a question to HR or a navigator.
- The plan does not meet minimum value. If the cheapest plan the employer offers falls below the standard, the offer does not block a credit for anyone, at any price. The summary of benefits and coverage should say whether the plan meets it.
- The employer offers a choice of plans. The test uses the lowest-priced plan that meets minimum value, even if you would never choose it. A very high-deductible plan can set a low price for the test.
- The employer contributes differently by tier. Some employers pay most of the employee's own premium and much less toward dependents, which produces the pattern in the tables above. Others pay a flat share of every tier. Your own tier prices decide the result.
- The offer begins midyear. The credit is figured month by month, so months before an offer begins can still qualify. i had marketplace coverage for only part of the year: how is my credit figured? shows how.
Mistakes to avoid
- Testing the plan you would pick instead of the cheapest. The test uses the lowest-cost plan that meets minimum value, not the richest or the family's preferred plan.
- Using the employee-only price for the family. That was the old rule. For family members, the family tier is generally the test.
- Assuming eligible means a positive credit. Household three shows a zero.
- Forgetting CHIP. Children may be better off there, and the credit disappears if they qualify.
- Treating the spousal surcharge as the premium. Some employers add a surcharge if a spouse has other coverage available (spousal surcharge). Whether it counts in the affordability test depends on how the plan is set up, so ask.
- Not asking for current rules. The test has changed before. A navigator or tax professional has the current IRS rule.
Key takeaways
- An employee is tested on the cost of self-only coverage; a spouse or child is generally tested on the cost of coverage that includes them, under IRS rules in effect since plan years beginning in 2023. Confirm the current rule before you act.
- For plan years beginning in 2027 the affordability line is 10.22% of household income (9.96% for 2026), and the offer must also meet minimum value to block a credit.
- A family member can be eligible for a credit and still receive zero if the benchmark premium of those enrolled is small compared with a share of household income.
- Compare the whole package, including deductibles, networks and employer contributions, and check CHIP for children.
- Get every tier's price from HR, because the Form 1095-C shows only the self-only price, and a navigator or tax professional can confirm your own numbers.