Blog
Work coverage is cheap for me but costly for my family, what are my options?
How the affordability test treats employee coverage and family coverage separately, the 2026 and 2027 thresholds as of November 2026, and a worked example.
If your own job coverage costs little but adding your spouse or children costs a lot, the family members may be able to get marketplace premium tax credits even though you cannot. As of November 2026, the federal affordability test for a family member looks at what the employer charges for coverage that includes the family, not at what the employee pays for self-only coverage. Whether a particular household actually qualifies depends on income, the plan and tax filing, so a navigator or tax professional should confirm the answer, but the mechanism is worth understanding before open enrollment decisions are made.
This is a fast-moving area. The figures and dates below are as of November 2026 and apply to plan years 2026 and 2027. Check HealthCare.gov or a navigator for changes before acting.
Two tests, one employer plan
An employer plan can be affordable for one person and unaffordable for another, because the test is run separately for the employee and for family members.
The employee test. The employer's lowest-cost plan that meets minimum value is judged by what the employee would pay for self-only coverage. If that cost is no more than a set percentage of household income, the plan is "affordable" for the employee, and the employee is generally not eligible for premium tax credits. The affordability entry has the definition.
The family-member test. Under a rule the Treasury Department and the IRS finalized in 2022, which took effect for tax years starting in 2023, a spouse or child's affordability is measured by the premium the employee would pay to cover the employee and those family members, not by the self-only price. If that family cost is above the percentage, the employer plan is not affordable for the family members. They may then qualify for credits to buy a marketplace plan, provided they meet the other conditions.
Before that rule, the self-only price was used for everyone, so a family with cheap employee-only coverage and expensive family coverage was shut out of credits. People called this the "family glitch." The name persists, though the 2022 rule changed the test. The research behind this post, as of November 2026, found no announced change to that rule. Policy on credits has changed repeatedly, so confirm before relying on this.
The thresholds: 2026 and 2027
The percentage is the "required contribution percentage," set by the IRS each year.
- 2026: 9.96% of household income, per IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-25.
- 2027: 10.22% of household income, per IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-26, the highest on record. A plan with a non-calendar plan year that starts in 2026 generally keeps the 2026 percentage for the whole plan year, according to a secondary summary, so ask your employer which year applies to your plan.
The percentage is applied to household income, which for credit purposes is modified adjusted gross income for the household. Employers sometimes use safe-harbor shortcuts for their own purposes, such as the employee's W-2 pay, but a family's credit eligibility is judged on the household's actual income on the tax return. The employer coverage affordability test runs the comparison with your numbers.
A worked example
Say Dana, her spouse Leo and their child have a household income of $70,000 in 2027. These figures are invented.
Dana's employer offers one plan that meets minimum value. It costs $120 a month for Dana alone and $950 a month for coverage that includes Leo and the child.
Step 1: the threshold in dollars. 10.22% x $70,000 = $7,154 a year, or about $596 a month.
Step 2: the employee test. Dana's self-only cost is $120 x 12 = $1,440 a year. That is $1,440 / $70,000, about 2.1% of income, well under 10.22%. The plan is affordable for Dana. She would generally not qualify for a credit, and she is happy to stay on the plan.
Step 3: the family test. The cost of family coverage is $950 x 12 = $11,400 a year. That is $11,400 / $70,000, about 16.3% of income, which is above 10.22%. The employer plan is not affordable for Leo and the child.
Step 4: what that opens. Leo and the child may qualify for marketplace credits if they do not enroll in the employer plan and they meet the other conditions, such as income within the credit range and eligible immigration status. Dana keeps her employee-only coverage at $1,440 a year.
What the household might save
Say the benchmark marketplace plan, the second-lowest-cost silver plan, costs $900 a month for Leo and the child, which is $10,800 a year. Suppose the marketplace's table sets the household's expected contribution at 8% of income. This percentage is invented for the example, and the real one comes from the IRS table for the household's income. 8% x $70,000 = $5,600 a year. The credit is the benchmark premium minus that contribution: $10,800 - $5,600 = $5,200 a year, about $433 a month.
If they choose the benchmark plan, Leo and the child pay $5,600 a year. Add Dana's own $1,440 and the household pays $7,040 a year in premiums, compared with $11,400 for family coverage on the employer plan. The difference is $11,400 - $7,040 = $4,360 a year.
The example leaves out deductibles, networks and the rest of the cost. Two plans means two deductibles. The marketplace plan for Leo and the child has its own network and out-of-pocket maximum, and Dana's plan has another. The post my job's family coverage costs too much: can my spouse and kids get credits? covers this situation from a family's side, and the guide How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share explains the credit calculation.
Reading the premium on your payroll sheet
Most payroll sheets list several tiers: employee only, employee plus spouse, employee plus children and family. The family-member test uses the cost of the lowest-cost tier that covers the employee and the family members in question. That produces different answers for different people in the same household:
- If the spouse alone would be covered, the relevant cost is the employee-plus-spouse tier.
- If only the children would be covered, the relevant cost is the employee-plus-children tier.
- If everyone would be covered, the relevant cost is the family tier.
So one household can have a spouse who passes the test and children who fail it, or the reverse, and each group is judged on its own tier. Where the employer offers more than one plan, the test generally uses the cheapest plan that meets minimum value, not the one you would choose.
A related case is an employer that offers coverage to the employee but does not offer dependent coverage at all. No offer of family coverage means the employer plan is not available to the family members, and their credit eligibility turns on income and the other usual conditions. Ask the benefits office in writing which tiers exist and what each costs per month, and whether the amounts quoted include any wellness or tobacco surcharge, which can change the price used in the test.
Last, a family may be able to move only part of its members. A household can keep the employee and one child on the employer plan and put a spouse in the marketplace, if the tier rules and the plan's enrollment choices allow it. Each such split changes both the premiums and the number of deductibles the household faces, so price each version before choosing.
The conditions that can stop it working
The 2022 rule does not give credits to everyone with expensive family coverage. Check these:
- The 400% line. As of November 2026, credits end above 400% of the federal poverty level for both 2026 and 2027, because the enhanced "no cliff" credits expired on December 31, 2025. A household just over the line may get nothing. The federal poverty level entry explains the measure, and the poverty guidelines are published each year.
- The plan must meet minimum value. Affordability is judged only for a plan that provides minimum value, a basic level of coverage. A plan that does not meet it is treated differently, and the post My employer's coverage costs too much, can I get marketplace credits? covers that case. The minimum value entry explains the test.
- Enrollment in the employer plan. A family member who is actually enrolled in the employer plan generally cannot receive credits for a marketplace plan for the same months. The family must decline employer coverage for those members.
- Tax filing. Married couples generally must file a joint return to receive credits, with narrow exceptions.
- Immigration status. According to KFF, as of November 2026, from January 1, 2027, premium tax credits are limited to lawful permanent residents, Cuban and Haitian entrants and residents of Compact of Free Association states, so family members in other statuses may lose eligibility.
- Income that is not known yet. Credits are advanced based on estimated income. If the estimate is low, the household may owe back the difference when it files. As of November 2026, excess advance credits must be repaid in full, with no cap, starting with tax year 2026, as the guide Repaying excess premium tax credits: reconciliation and Form 8962 explains. Update the marketplace when income changes.
Children may have another option
A child in a household with moderate income may qualify for Medicaid or the Children's Health Insurance Program, which can cost little or nothing, whatever the employer plan charges. Eligibility depends on the state and on income. The CHIP explained: low-cost health coverage for children guide lays out the program. Checking it first can change the whole math, because it may leave only the spouse needing a marketplace plan.
Timing and how to act
The sequence matters, because the employer plan and the marketplace run on different calendars.
- Find the family cost. Ask the benefits office for the premium of the lowest-cost plan that covers you and the family members, in writing. Ask if the plan meets minimum value.
- Estimate the household's income for the coverage year. Use the tax return as a guide and adjust for changes.
- Run the test. Compare the family cost to the threshold for your plan year. Use the ACA subsidy estimator to see the possible credit for the family members who would enroll in the marketplace.
- Decide on the employer enrollment. Many employer plans let employees enroll themselves without dependents, but not every plan does, and the choice is usually locked for the year. Declining dependents at the employer's open enrollment is easier than changing in the middle of the year, and dropping coverage by choice generally does not open a special enrollment period.
- Enroll through the marketplace in the window. For plan year 2027 on HealthCare.gov, open enrollment runs from November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027, with coverage starting January 1 if you enroll by December 15, as of November 2026. State-based marketplaces use their own dates.
- Keep records. Save the employer's written statement of family coverage cost, as the tax return asks about employer coverage offers.
A navigator, who gives free enrollment help, can test your numbers, and a tax professional can say how the credit will interact with your return. If your employer's information is unclear, the benefits office can often supply a statement of the family premium on request.
Key takeaways
- The affordability test is run separately for the employee, using the self-only premium, and for family members, using the cost of coverage that includes them.
- As of November 2026, the percentage is 9.96% of household income for 2026 and 10.22% for 2027. A family cost above it makes the employer plan unaffordable for the family members.
- When the family test fails, spouse and children may qualify for marketplace credits if they decline the employer plan, but credits end above 400% of the poverty level and depend on other conditions.
- Compare the household's total premiums, deductibles and networks across the two plans, not only the premium.
- Estimated income drives advance credits, and excess credits must be repaid in full starting with tax year 2026, so update the marketplace when income changes.