Blog

Fired or quit, does it change my COBRA and special enrollment rights?

Seven common beliefs about layoffs, quitting and firing, tested against how COBRA and the 60-day marketplace special enrollment period actually work.

The reason you left a job matters much less than most people think. Under federal COBRA rules, the event that counts is the end of your job-based coverage, and the statute lets almost every way of leaving trigger it: a layoff, a firing, a resignation, a retirement, a cut in hours. One narrow exception, firing for gross misconduct, takes COBRA away. For the marketplace, the question is whether you lost coverage, and you generally did if the job ended and the plan ended with it, whoever's decision it was.

Rumors in break rooms and comment threads say otherwise, and some of them push people into skipping a deadline. This post takes seven of the most common beliefs one at a time and tests each against how the rules work. The rules below are the general federal ones. Your plan documents, your state's continuation law and the notice you receive from the plan are what govern your case.

First, the two systems and what each asks

Two separate systems are involved, and mixing them up causes most of the confusion.

COBRA continuation coverage is a federal law that lets people who lose job-based coverage keep it temporarily, usually by paying up to 102% of the full cost. It applies to group health plan coverage at employers with 20 or more employees, and many states have a similar law for smaller employers, often called state continuation coverage. The standard period is 18 months for job loss or reduced hours. The plan must give at least 60 days to elect, and the first premium is due at least 45 days after you elect, according to the Department of Labor's guide.

The marketplace special enrollment period is a different door. Losing job-based coverage opens a 60-day window to enroll in an ACA marketplace plan, either before or after the date coverage ends. See special enrollment periods explained: qualifying life events and deadlines for the full set of qualifying events.

Both systems ask first about the loss of coverage. Neither asks whether you deserved to lose your job, and neither requires you to prove who decided. With that in mind, here are the beliefs.

Myth 1: "COBRA is only for people who get laid off"

The claim. If you were not laid off, COBRA does not apply to you.

The test. COBRA's qualifying events for the employee are termination of employment for any reason other than gross misconduct, and a reduction in hours. Both are listed in the Department of Labor's guide. "Termination" does not distinguish between a layoff, a firing for performance, a resignation or a retirement. A person who quits to take care of a parent, to change careers or to leave a bad job has experienced a termination of employment, and the coverage that ends with the job is eligible for continuation.

The nuance. COBRA protects people only if the plan was in place when the job ended. It is not a way to get coverage you never had, and it does not apply to employers under the 20-employee line (although a state law may). Continuation also takes effect only if you elect it and pay.

Myth 2: "If I quit, I do not get special enrollment"

The claim. Special enrollment is for people who were pushed out. Quitting is a choice, so the door is closed.

The test. The qualifying event is a loss of other minimum essential coverage, and job-based coverage that ends because employment ends is a loss of coverage. The marketplace does not ask for a termination letter that says "laid off." What it does exclude is a loss that you cause by voluntarily dropping coverage or by not paying your premiums. The two situations are easy to confuse:

  • You quit on March 15, and the plan ends March 31 because your employment ended. That is a loss of coverage, and it opens a 60-day window.
  • You stay employed but cancel your enrollment in the employer plan in the middle of the year. That is a voluntary drop, and it does not open a window.
  • You stay employed, stop paying your share, and the plan terminates you for non-payment. That is generally treated as a loss due to non-payment, which does not qualify.

The nuance. Marketplaces may ask for documents showing the date coverage ended. A letter from the employer or plan, a final pay stub showing the last deduction, or a notice of coverage termination all work for that purpose. If your employer will not give you a letter, My employer won't give me a termination letter, so how do I prove it? covers the alternatives. The special enrollment period checker can help you check the dates.

Myth 3: "A firing for cause ends COBRA"

The claim. If the boss fired me for cause, my coverage ends the same day and I cannot get COBRA.

The test. COBRA's one exception for termination is gross misconduct. The law does not define the term, and it is not the same as ordinary misconduct, poor performance, attendance problems, insubordination or a breach of company policy. It is generally read narrowly, as serious and deliberate conduct, and the plan or employer has to decide, based on the facts, that the exception applies. A firing described as "for cause" in a personnel file is not automatically gross misconduct for COBRA.

The nuance. The exception is real, and employers do invoke it. If a plan administrator denies COBRA by calling the firing gross misconduct, the person can ask for the written basis and can challenge the decision, through the plan's claims process and, if necessary, a lawyer or the Department of Labor's benefits advisors. That is a place where a professional's help is worth seeking, because the facts of the termination matter and the outcome depends on them. Nothing here predicts how a given case would turn out.

Even where COBRA is lost, the marketplace door typically remains. A person fired for gross misconduct who loses job-based coverage still has lost coverage and still has the 60-day window, so the practical consequence is on cost and continuity, not on being locked out of coverage.

Myth 4: "My employer decides whether to tell me about COBRA, and silence means I do not qualify"

The claim. If nothing arrived in the mail, nothing is available.

The test. The law puts the notice burden on the plan. Under the Department of Labor's description, the employer notifies the plan administrator of a termination or reduction in hours within a set period, and the administrator then sends the election notice. The plan has to give you at least 60 days from the later of the date of the notice or the date coverage would end. A missing notice does not wipe out your rights, but it also does not stop the marketplace clock, which runs from the date coverage ends.

What to do. If you do not hear within a few weeks, call HR and the plan administrator and ask for the election notice in writing, with the deadline stated. I never received my COBRA paperwork, so what do I do? covers the follow-up in order. If you are the person who is also looking at marketplace plans, do not wait for the COBRA notice to start the 60-day count. Treat the date coverage ended as day zero.

Myth 5: "I must take COBRA first, or I lose my marketplace option"

The claim. The marketplace requires proof that you turned down COBRA.

The test. The Department of Labor's guide says that losing job-based coverage opens a 60-day special enrollment period before or after the loss, and it does not condition that on first electing or declining COBRA. You can go straight to the marketplace.

The direction of the trap runs the other way, and it is easy to miss. Once you are in COBRA, voluntarily ending it midyear is generally not treated as a loss of coverage for special enrollment purposes. People who elect COBRA, then find it too expensive and quit it, can discover that they have no marketplace window until open enrollment. A window generally does open when COBRA coverage runs out at the end of its maximum period. The safe approach is to decide between COBRA and the marketplace during the 60-day window, not afterward, and to check HealthCare.gov or your state marketplace for the current rule. COBRA or a marketplace plan after a job loss: how to compare sets out how to compare the two.

The nuance. A coverage gap before COBRA payment is allowed because you can elect after the fact and the coverage runs back to the loss date. Some people pay for COBRA only after a large bill, which is a risk-taking strategy with timing traps, and From layoff day to first COBRA payment, the dates I must not miss explains the dates.

Myth 6: "If I quit and my employer's plan ends, I lose everything on the same day"

The claim. Coverage ends the day you leave.

The test. The date coverage ends depends on the plan, not on the law. Many plans end coverage on the last day of the month in which employment ends. Some end it on the last day worked, and some on the end of a pay period. A resignation with notice, a paid severance period, accrued leave or garden leave may all extend the date. A person who gives two weeks' notice on March 1 may have coverage through the end of March or April, depending on the rules.

Why this matters: COBRA and the marketplace window both key off the date coverage ends, so a wrong assumption of the date can move your deadline by weeks. Ask HR to state, in writing, the exact last day of coverage. If you use the COBRA cost and deadline calculator, enter that date, not the last day of work.

Myth 7: "Voluntary quitters can stay on COBRA for free, or for as long as they like"

The claim. Quitting makes the plan keep me.

The test. COBRA is paid by the person who elects it, up to 102% of the cost of the plan, and the cost includes the share the employer used to pay. Periods are limited: 18 months is the standard period for termination or reduced hours, with longer periods in special cases such as disability or a second qualifying event. COBRA can also end early for several reasons, including missed payments, getting other group coverage or the employer ending all its group plans. When can COBRA end early, and how do I avoid losing it? lists them.

The nuance. The real cost of COBRA is often much larger than the old paycheck deduction suggests, because the employee share was only part of the premium. Say a hypothetical employee paid $200 a month and the employer paid $600 for a plan whose full premium is $800 a month. The COBRA bill is 102% of $800, which is $816 a month, four times what came out of each month's paycheck. That is an invented example, but the proportion is typical enough that the comparison with marketplace options is worth running, including whatever premium tax credits you might qualify for given your income.

Putting the myths together: three short cases

These are invented to show how the pieces fit.

  • Marcus quits on March 15. The plan ends March 31. He has 60 days before and after March 31 to pick a marketplace plan, and the plan must give him at least 60 days to elect COBRA. He can compare both.
  • Dana is fired for repeated lateness. That is not gross misconduct on its face, so COBRA is available. If the plan administrator says otherwise, she asks for the reason in writing. Either way, the marketplace window opens when coverage ends.
  • Lee leaves and elects COBRA, then drops it in month five because of the cost. Lee does not have a clean marketplace window at that point and may have to wait for open enrollment unless another event, such as a move, applies. Lee should have compared options during the first window.

What to do in the first week

  1. Ask in writing for your last day of coverage and for the COBRA election notice and its deadline.
  2. Write down three dates: the day coverage ends, the end of the 60-day marketplace window (60 days after that day) and the COBRA election deadline in the notice.
  3. Price COBRA against a marketplace plan, including any premium tax credit and the plan's deductible so far this year.
  4. Check whether your state has continuation rights if the employer is small.
  5. If a plan administrator denies COBRA or the termination was disputed, contact a lawyer or the Department of Labor's benefits advisors. A navigator or a licensed broker can walk you through the marketplace side at no charge in many areas. See health insurance when you lose your job: your options and deadlines.

Key takeaways

  • COBRA turns on the loss of coverage and covers termination for nearly any reason, including quitting, with a narrow exception for gross misconduct that is not defined by statute.
  • The marketplace 60-day special enrollment period follows loss of job-based coverage, not the reason you left; it does not apply when you voluntarily cancel coverage or lose it for non-payment.
  • You do not have to elect COBRA before shopping the marketplace, but dropping COBRA midyear generally does not reopen the door, so compare both within the first window.
  • Coverage often ends at month's end, not on your last day. Get the exact date in writing, because both clocks start there.
  • A disputed firing, a missing notice or a denied election are the moments to involve the plan administrator, a lawyer or the Department of Labor.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic