Blog
First-year Medicare mistakes that cost people money
Seven mistakes people make in their first year on Medicare, how each one happens, what it can cost and how to avoid it, with worked examples in round numbers.
Most of the money lost in the first year of Medicare is not lost to big decisions. It goes to small things that nobody mentioned: a drug plan that was never chosen, a doctor who billed more than expected, a supplement window that quietly closed, a bill that was paid twice. The seven mistakes below are the ones counselors see often. For each one, the entry shows how it happens, what it can cost and how to avoid it. Costs use invented round numbers unless a figure is labeled as an official one.
Mistake 1: Ignoring the Part D choice
How it happens. Original Medicare, Parts A and B, mostly does not cover prescriptions you take at home. Drug coverage is Medicare Part D, a separate plan from a private company, or a drug benefit built into a Medicare Advantage plan. Someone who is healthy at 65, takes no regular medications and has no other drug coverage may decide it can wait.
What it costs. If you go 63 days or more without creditable drug coverage after you first become eligible, you pay a penalty when you eventually join: 1% of the national base beneficiary premium for each full uncovered month, added to your premium for as long as you have drug coverage. The 2027 base premium is $41.33 (CMS, July 2026). Twelve uncovered months would be 12% of $41.33, about $5 a month. Twenty-four would be about $10 a month, every month, for life. The penalty is not large in any single month, but the bill for a new medication can be, and the person joining a plan after starting a drug cannot always pick the month.
There is also a cost from picking wrong, not just from not picking. Plans differ in the drugs they cover, the pharmacies they treat as preferred, and the tier each drug sits on. A plan chosen for its low premium can cost more in total than one with a higher premium that covers your drugs at a lower price.
How to avoid it. Pick a plan, even a low-cost one, in the Initial Enrollment Period unless you have drug coverage that Medicare treats as creditable. Your employer or retiree plan sends an annual notice saying whether its drug coverage is creditable; keep it. Each October the plans change, and the Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, lets you compare again. As of November 2026, the 2027 standard deductible is $700 and the out-of-pocket cap is $2,400, and many people will see changes in plan lineups. The How to compare Part D plans: formulary, pharmacies and total cost guide explains how to compare, and Medicare Part D explained: drug plans, formularies and costs covers how the benefit works. If your income is low, ask about Extra Help.
Mistake 2: Assuming every provider accepts assignment
How it happens. Under Original Medicare, you can see any provider enrolled in Medicare. Most accept the Medicare-approved amount as full payment, which is called accepting assignment. Some enrolled providers do not, and they may charge up to 15% above the approved amount. Others have opted out of Medicare entirely.
What it costs. Say the Medicare-approved amount for a specialist visit is $200. Medicare pays 80% after the deductible, and you owe 20%, which is $40. If the provider does not accept assignment, it may charge up to $230, so you owe the $40 coinsurance plus $30 in excess charges, a total of $70, and only some supplement plans pay the excess. If the provider has opted out, you pay the entire fee, and Medicare pays nothing toward it. Some states cap excess charges lower than 15%.
How to avoid it. When you book a new provider, ask two questions: "Do you accept Medicare assignment?" and "Are you a participating provider?" Ask the same of labs and imaging centers the practice uses. The What does it mean when a doctor does not accept Medicare assignment? post works through more examples, and the Medicare.gov provider search is a place to start.
Mistake 3: Missing the supplement window
How it happens. If you want a Medigap policy to pay the costs Original Medicare leaves, the best time to buy is the six-month medigap open enrollment period. It starts the first month you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During it, an insurer must sell you a policy regardless of health, at the same price as a healthy applicant of your age. The window is one-time, and it does not pause if you are busy, ill or still deciding.
What it costs. After the window, in most states an insurer can ask health questions, decline you, charge more, or apply a waiting period for pre-existing conditions. For someone who later develops a heart condition or cancer, that can mean no supplement at all and an Original Medicare plan with no cap on spending. Some states have broader protections, such as year-round or annual windows, but they vary, and the medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue guide covers the rules.
How to avoid it. Mark the end of your six-month window on a calendar the day your Part B starts. Collect quotes in the first four months, so you have time to compare and apply. If you plan to choose an Advantage plan instead, find out in the first year what protections exist if you want to switch back, since some are time-limited. Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor can explain your state's rules for free.
Mistake 4: Paying a Medicare bill twice
How it happens. Medicare paperwork has three things that look like bills and are not, and one thing that is a bill. The Medicare Summary Notice, mailed quarterly or available online, is not a bill; it lists what providers billed, what Medicare paid and what you may owe. An explanation of benefits from your supplement is not a bill either. A statement from a provider may be a bill, but it may have been sent before Medicare or your supplement paid its share.
What it costs. Say a clinic bills you $60 for your coinsurance right after a visit. You pay it. A few weeks later your supplement pays the same $60 when the claim crosses over from Medicare. You now have a $60 credit with the clinic, and getting it back requires a call or a letter. Small duplicates add up across a year of visits, and a few providers hold credit balances for months.
The first Part B premium has a similar trap. People who enroll before Social Security deductions begin may get a bill for several months at once. If you pay it and later see the deduction start, check that you were not charged for the same months.
How to avoid it. Wait for the Medicare Summary Notice and the supplement's explanation of benefits before paying a provider's balance. Compare the "you may be billed" figure with the statement. The How do I read my Medicare Summary Notice and spot billing errors? post shows how to read each line. If you did pay twice, ask the provider for a refund in writing and keep a copy of the request.
Mistake 5: Not telling your employer or plan about Medicare
How it happens. If you are still working, or your spouse is, or you have retiree coverage, an employer plan may keep paying alongside Medicare. Who pays first depends on the situation, and the medicare secondary payer rules decide it. Generally, with a large employer and current employment, the employer plan pays first and Medicare second. With a small employer (fewer than 20 employees), Medicare generally pays first. For retiree coverage, Medicare usually pays first.
The mistake comes in assuming everyone knows. Providers bill the wrong payer first, claims bounce, and you get a bill. In other cases the employer plan changes when you enroll in Medicare, because some plans reduce or end coverage for people eligible for Medicare, or end spouse coverage.
What it costs. Say a claim goes to Medicare first when it should have gone to the employer plan. Medicare may deny or recoup it, and the provider rebills. Months can pass, and you may be asked to pay in the meantime. In the worse case, you give up your employer coverage thinking Medicare would replace it and then discover that it covers less for your spouse.
How to avoid it. Before you enroll, ask the benefits office in writing how the plan coordinates with Medicare, whether your spouse stays covered, and whether the drug coverage is creditable. Give providers both cards. The medicare and employer coverage: who pays first if you work past 65? guide explains the usual order of payment.
Mistake 6: Forgetting about HSA contributions
How it happens. A health savings account requires you to be covered by a qualifying high-deductible plan and not enrolled in Medicare. Once Medicare starts, you can no longer contribute to the account, though you can spend what is already in it on qualified medical expenses. When you enroll in Part A after 65, coverage can start up to six months earlier, so contributions made in those months can become excess.
What it costs. Say Ana, 66, applies for Medicare in September and Part A is backdated six months to March. If she contributed $400 a month from March through August, that is $2,400 of contributions made while she was technically enrolled. Excess contributions are generally taxed unless withdrawn by the filing deadline, and the tax professional who files her return can tell her what applies.
How to avoid it. Stop contributing about six months before you plan to apply for Medicare, if you are not collecting Social Security. If you are collecting, enrollment is automatic, so ask your tax professional how to time the last contribution. The HSAs and Medicare: when you must stop contributing guide has the dates, and the money already in the account is yours to spend.
Mistake 7: Ignoring notices and payments you do not understand
How it happens. A new enrollee gets a flood of mail: a letter confirming Part A and B dates, a notice about the Part B premium, plan letters, an Annual Notice of Change each fall, and a Medicare Summary Notice every quarter. Some are routine. A few ask for action by a date.
What it costs. A missed notice about your premium, an income-related surcharge, a plan ending or a Part D penalty can cost you a window to respond. A related example: in October 2026, CMS made a one-time $90 payment from the Medicare Improvement Fund to about 20.8 million Original Medicare Part B enrollees who do not get Medicaid premium help and do not pay the income-related surcharge. Medicare Advantage enrollees were not eligible. Someone who did not receive it, or who did and mistook it for a scam, had to read the explanation to know why. As of November 2026, check Medicare.gov for whether any further payment has been announced.
How to avoid it. Open every piece of Medicare mail within a week. Sort it into three piles: "action needed," "keep" and "not a bill." Create an online Medicare account so notices are available in one place. Never give your Medicare number to an unsolicited caller.
Key takeaways
- Choose a Part D plan in your first window unless you have creditable drug coverage; the penalty is 1% of the base premium per full uncovered month for as long as you have coverage.
- Ask each new provider, lab and imaging center whether it accepts Medicare assignment; excess charges and opt-outs can add costs a supplement may not cover.
- Treat the end of the six-month Medigap window as a hard deadline, since after it most states allow underwriting.
- Wait for the Medicare Summary Notice and supplement statement before paying a balance, and tell your employer plan and providers which pays first.
- Stop HSA contributions in time, and open and sort your Medicare mail.