Blog

Should I pick an HMO or a PPO for a child who sees several specialists?

Criteria and a decision list for parents choosing between an HMO and a PPO when a child sees a cardiologist and a therapist, with a worked cost comparison.

Say the Reyes family has a nine-year-old who sees a pediatric cardiologist twice a year, a speech therapist every week and a pediatrician who coordinates the rest. Open enrollment is under way, and the employer offers an HMO and a PPO with a higher premium. The usual advice, "the PPO is more flexible", is true but incomplete. For a child with ongoing specialist needs, the better question is which plan keeps the child's actual care team in network with the least friction over a full year.

This post gives the criteria that matter, a worked cost comparison with invented numbers, a decision list and a reminder of who can answer the questions a plan document cannot. It does not tell any family which to choose. The network, the benefits and the prices differ plan by plan, so verify each point with the plan itself.

Start with the child's care team, not the plan type

The plan type is a label. What decides the year is whether each of the child's clinicians and facilities is in the network of the specific plan you are considering. Begin with a written list:

  • The pediatrician and any specialists, with their practice names and office locations.
  • The hospital or children's hospital where procedures, imaging and any surgery would happen.
  • Therapy providers, for example speech, occupational, physical or behavioral therapy.
  • Pharmacies, medical equipment suppliers and any home health agency.
  • Any center the child visits in another city or state for a rare condition.

Then check each against each plan's directory. Directories are sometimes out of date, so call each office and ask: "Do you participate in the [exact plan name] on the [insurer] network?" The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet gives a layout for recording the answers and the date. If you cannot confirm that a provider is in network, treat it as out of network until the plan says otherwise in writing.

Criterion 1: the children's hospital

For many families the deciding question is whether the children's hospital where the child's specialists work is in network. Pediatric specialty care is concentrated in a small number of hospitals, and a hospital may be in one network of an insurer and out of another. A plan may also include the hospital but exclude some of the doctors who practice there, or include the hospital for some services only.

Check three things: the hospital, the specific specialist and the specific services. Ask about imaging, anesthesia and lab work, which are sometimes billed by separate groups. If the hospital is in the HMO's network, an HMO may be a good fit. If it is in the PPO's network only, the answer is clear. If it is in both, move to the next criterion.

Criterion 2: the referral burden

An HMO often requires the child's pediatrician to issue a referral for each specialist, sometimes for each course of visits. For a child who sees a cardiologist and a therapist, that can mean paperwork every few months, and a lapse can delay an appointment. A PPO usually lets a family book in-network specialists directly.

The burden is not a reason to rule an HMO out. A good pediatric office handles referrals routinely, and many plans can issue a standing referral for a chronic condition, which covers repeat visits for a stated period. What matters is the fit: ask the pediatrician's office how it handles referrals for a child like yours and how long it takes. Some families find the coordination useful, because one office keeps track of all of the child's care. Others find it one more place for things to go wrong.

Criterion 3: prior authorization for therapy and procedures

Many plans require prior authorization for certain services, and therapy is a common one. A plan may approve a set number of visits, require periodic progress reports and then ask for a new review. It may also limit the number of therapy visits per year. The limits are written in the plan documents, and federal rules on habilitative and rehabilitative services mean that most ACA-compliant plans must cover them as an essential benefit category, though the amount and conditions vary.

Ask both plans: Does speech or occupational therapy need authorization? How many visits does the first approval cover? How are renewals handled, and how long do they take? Does the plan apply visit limits to children differently? how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied explains how these reviews work and what you can do when one is slow. The answers can differ between an HMO and a PPO offered by the same insurer, or between two employers' plans from the same company.

Criterion 4: out-of-state or specialty centers

Some children need care at a center far from home, for a rare condition or a complex surgery. Here the plan types differ most.

A PPO generally pays part of out-of-network care. That can be a meaningful safety valve, but it comes with a separate deductible, higher coinsurance and possible balance billing, so the family should ask for the plan's expected allowed amount before committing. An HMO generally pays nothing outside the network except in emergencies, unless the plan approves an exception because no in-network provider can deliver the service. That is a network gap exception. It is a request that must usually be made and approved before the care, and it is not automatic.

If a specific out-of-state center is part of the child's plan of care, ask the center's financial counselor which plans it works with, and ask the plan about its process for a network exception. Neither answer is certain until it is in writing.

Criterion 5: what the year costs

Costs matter, but they matter after the network question. Here is a worked comparison with invented, round numbers. The family's monthly premium contribution is $400 for the HMO and $520 for the PPO. Over the year, the child has four cardiology visits, 40 therapy sessions and two echocardiograms.

HMO (illustration): $40 copay per specialist visit, $30 copay per therapy session, $150 copay per echocardiogram.

  • Cardiology: 4 × $40 = $160
  • Therapy: 40 × $30 = $1,200
  • Echocardiograms: 2 × $150 = $300
  • Care subtotal: $1,660
  • Premiums: 12 × $400 = $4,800
  • Total: $4,800 + $1,660 = $6,460

PPO (illustration): $1,000 deductible, then 20% coinsurance on in-network allowed amounts. Allowed amounts: $200 per cardiology visit, $120 per therapy session, $600 per echocardiogram.

  • Cardiology: 4 × $200 = $800
  • Therapy: 40 × $120 = $4,800
  • Echocardiograms: 2 × $600 = $1,200
  • Allowed total: $6,800
  • You pay the first $1,000 and 20% of the remaining $5,800, which is $1,160
  • Care subtotal: $1,000 + $1,160 = $2,160
  • Premiums: 12 × $520 = $6,240
  • Total: $6,240 + $2,160 = $8,400

In this invented case the HMO costs $8,400 − $6,460 = $1,940 less over the year. The figures change with the actual copays, deductibles, out-of-pocket maximum and the child's care. Check the out-of-pocket maximum too. If a bad year pushes spending above it, the cap limits the in-network total, and a plan with a lower maximum can end up cheaper in a heavy-use year. The out-of-pocket maximum is the most important number for a family expecting a hospitalization. The cheapest plan on paper is not the best one if a key provider is outside it, so use cost to break a tie, not to start the search.

Questions to put to each plan

Write these down and record the answers with the date and the name of the person who gave them:

  1. Is the named children's hospital, and the named specialist at that hospital, in network for this exact plan?
  2. Does the child's cardiology care, including echocardiograms, need a referral, an authorization or both?
  3. How many therapy visits does the plan cover per year, and what documentation does the therapist have to send to continue past the first approval?
  4. If a provider leaves the network mid-year, does the plan offer a transition period for a child in active treatment? Many plans have a continuity-of-care process for members in the middle of a course of treatment, but its length and conditions vary.
  5. What is the out-of-pocket maximum for the child alone and for the family, and do therapy copays count toward it?
  6. Does the plan have a case manager for children with chronic conditions, and how does a family reach one?

Treat the answers as part of your records. A promise made on a phone call is much more useful if you can say when it was made and by whom, and the written plan document controls if the two conflict.

When a provider leaves the network mid-year

Networks change, and a plan year does not freeze them. A pediatric cardiologist might retire, a therapy practice might drop its contract with the insurer, or a hospital system and an insurer might fail to renew. For a child in the middle of treatment, the effect can be sudden. The plan's continuity-of-care rules, where they exist, may allow a period of in-network cost sharing for a child already under treatment, and employers, states and plan types handle it differently. That is another reason to ask the question before enrolling, and to keep the plan's member services number handy. My doctor just left my plan's network. Do I have to switch plans or doctors? covers the options in more detail.

Decision list

Use this as a sequence. Stop at the first line that settles the question.

  1. If the children's hospital or a critical specialist is in one plan's network and not the other, choose the plan where they are in network, subject to your own checking in writing.
  2. If both plans include the whole care team, compare the therapy limits and authorization rules; if one plan caps therapy below what the child's providers recommend, weigh that heavily.
  3. If the child may need care at an out-of-state center, ask both plans about out-of-network benefits and network exceptions, and prefer the plan that gives you a written, specific answer.
  4. If both plans cover everything above, compare the referral burden with your tolerance for it. A family that dislikes paperwork may lean toward the PPO; a family that wants a coordinator may lean toward the HMO.
  5. If everything is still equal, compare the total annual cost using your own numbers, including the out-of-pocket maximum for a high-use year.
  6. If the answer is unclear after all this, call the plan's case management or the benefits office and ask for help comparing the two with the child's diagnosis in mind.

Who answers what

  • The plan's case management or care coordination team. Many plans have nurses or care managers who help members with ongoing conditions, and they can explain referral, authorization and exception processes for a specific child. Ask whether the plan assigns one.
  • The employer's benefits office or a broker. They can explain what each option is and when you can change it. Outside open enrollment, a change generally requires a qualifying event.
  • The child's providers. The pediatrician and specialists' billing offices know which plans they accept and how often a plan changes its mind.
  • The state insurance department. It handles complaints about whether a plan's network is adequate for the care a member needs, and about denials. how to file a complaint with your state insurance department describes how to file one. The concept is network adequacy, and the standards vary by state.
  • The state Medicaid or CHIP office. Depending on income and the state, a child may qualify for public coverage, alone or in addition to a private plan. Health insurance options for children: employer, CHIP and marketplace describes the options.

Where a child sees a therapist for mental health or behavioral care, also see how to find an in-network therapist, and what to do when none exist, since therapist networks are often thinner than medical ones and a directory listing does not guarantee an open appointment.

What to do if the choice is already made

If you are past enrollment and the plan you chose turns out to have a gap, you are not out of options. Ask for a network exception, ask the plan about continuity of care if a provider left the network, and ask whether the plan's case management can find an in-network alternative. If the plan will not help and the denial seems wrong, use the appeal process on the denial notice. For help with a specific problem, a lawyer or a patient advocacy organization that works on children's health coverage may be the right next step.

Key takeaways

  • The child's care team, not the plan label, drives the decision: verify each provider and facility against each plan's network, in writing if possible.
  • An HMO's referral burden can be managed with standing referrals; a PPO's flexibility outside the network comes with a separate deductible, higher coinsurance and possible balance billing.
  • Ask both plans how therapy is authorized, how many visits the first approval covers and how renewals work.
  • In the worked illustration, the HMO cost $1,940 less over the year, but real numbers differ, and cost should settle the choice only after the network question does.
  • For network-adequacy questions, use the plan's case management first and the state insurance department if the plan cannot meet the child's needs.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic