Guides

How to find an in-network therapist, and what to do when none exist

Use the plan directory, then call to confirm. If no in-network therapist can see you soon, ask for a network exception or out-of-network reimbursement.

Start with your plan's online provider directory or the member services number on your card, filter for therapists who treat what you need, and then call each office to confirm they accept your specific plan and are taking new patients. Directories are often out of date, so the call matters more than the listing. If you cannot find an in-network therapist who can see you within a reasonable time, you can ask your plan for a network exception (sometimes called a network gap exception or single-case agreement), use out-of-network benefits if your plan has them, or file a complaint that the plan's network is too thin. Document every call.

Step 1: Understand what "in-network" means for you

A therapist is in-network if they have a contract with your plan to accept its negotiated rate. You pay your copay or coinsurance, and the therapist agrees not to bill you for the difference. Out of network, the therapist has no such contract, may charge a higher fee, and your plan may pay less or nothing. Many plans also use a separate company to manage behavioral health, so the list of therapists may be separate from the list of doctors. Ask member services whether your plan does this and which directory to use.

Also check the type of clinician. Plans credential therapists by license: psychologists, licensed clinical social workers, licensed professional counselors, marriage and family therapists and psychiatrists are common categories, and a plan may cover some and not others. Ask which licenses the plan covers and whether a supervised trainee's sessions are covered.

Step 2: Search the directory well

When you use the plan's provider directory:

  1. Search by specialty and by what you need, such as a type of therapy, an age group or a condition. Use the filters for telehealth if you want video sessions.
  2. Note the date the directory was last updated if it shows one.
  3. Make a short list of five to ten names rather than starting with one.
  4. Ask friends, your primary care doctor or a clinic for names, then check each against the plan's directory.

Some therapists list themselves in outside directories and may say which insurers they accept. Treat that as a lead, not proof. Your plan decides who is in its network.

Step 3: Call and confirm

For each name, call and ask:

  • Do you accept my plan, by its exact name and ID prefix, and are you currently in network?
  • Are you accepting new patients, and what is the wait for a first appointment?
  • Do you offer telehealth or in-person sessions?
  • What is your fee for an intake session and for a regular session?
  • Do you bill the plan directly?

Write down the date, the name of the person and the answers. A listing may be wrong because of a closed practice, a retired clinician or a change of network, which people sometimes call a ghost network. If you call five or ten in-network listings and most are not accepting patients, treat the directory as unreliable and say so to the plan. Keep the call log: it is the evidence if you later ask for an exception or file a complaint.

Step 4: Use your plan's own help

Call member services or the behavioral health line and say you are trying to find an in-network therapist and cannot get an appointment. Many plans have care coordinators who can find openings, and some plans have a standard of how quickly a member should be able to get an appointment. Ask what the plan's standard is and whether the plan can find an in-network option. If the plan cannot, ask for the next step in writing.

Federal and state rules require many plans to maintain a network that gives members reasonable access to mental health care, a concept called network adequacy. The standards differ by state, plan type and market, and they commonly address distance, appointment wait times or the number of providers. Your state insurance department can tell you what applies to your plan.

Step 5: Ask for a network exception

If no in-network therapist can see you in a reasonable time or has the training you need, ask the plan for a network gap exception. In some plans this is called a network gap exception, a single-case agreement or a continuity-of-care arrangement. If approved, you can see an out-of-network therapist and pay in-network cost sharing. Plans may grant them case by case when the plan's network does not have an appropriate provider available.

Make the request in writing:

  • Identify yourself, your plan and your diagnosis or reason for seeking care, as far as you are comfortable.
  • Describe your searches: who you called and what you were told.
  • Name the therapist you want to see, with their license and fee.
  • Ask the plan to approve a number of sessions at in-network cost sharing.
  • Ask for the decision in writing, with the reason if it is denied.

If the plan denies the request, you can appeal as with any denial; see how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step and the mental health parity law: what insurers must treat equally if you think the network is handled more strictly than medical networks.

Step 6: Out-of-network reimbursement

If your plan has out-of-network benefits (common in PPO plans and many employer plans, less common in HMO or EPO plans), you may see a therapist who does not take your plan and submit claims yourself. Usually the therapist gives you a receipt with the codes the plan needs, often called a superbill. You pay the therapist, then send the claim to the plan. How much comes back depends on the plan's out-of-network deductible, its reimbursement percentage and its allowed amount, the amount the plan treats as the covered rate.

Say, hypothetically, a plan has a $500 out-of-network deductible and reimburses 60% of an allowed amount of $120 per session, while the therapist charges $200 (illustrative round numbers). In each of the first four sessions you pay the full $200, because the plan counts only the $120 allowed amount toward the deductible and pays nothing ($480 counted after session 4, so $20 of the deductible remains). In session 5 the plan applies the last $20 to the deductible, then pays 60% of the remaining $100, which is $60, so you pay $140. From session 6 on, the plan pays 60% of $120, which is $72, and you pay $128. The therapist's fee above the allowed amount may not count toward your limits, and it is a charge the plan did not agree to. See how out-of-network claims work: allowed amounts and balance bills for how out-of-network claims work.

The federal No Surprises Act protects patients from many out-of-network surprise bills for emergency care and for some care at in-network facilities, but it does not generally cover a therapist you choose to see out of network.

Other options

  • Telehealth in your state. Therapists must typically be licensed in the state where you are located during the session, so ask.
  • Employee assistance programs. Many employers offer a few free sessions.
  • Sliding-scale clinics and training clinics at universities.
  • Lower-cost options at a different level of care, such as group therapy, which some plans cover at a lower cost per session.

If you are in crisis, call or text 988.

Key takeaways

  • Use the plan's directory as a starting list, then call each therapist to confirm they accept your exact plan and are taking patients.
  • Keep a log of calls, because a record of failed searches supports an exception request or a complaint.
  • If no in-network option is available in a reasonable time, ask the plan in writing for a network exception or single-case agreement at in-network cost sharing.
  • Out-of-network reimbursement depends on your plan's separate deductible, percentage and allowed amount, and the therapist may charge more than the plan counts.
  • Your state insurance department can say what network standards apply and take complaints about thin networks.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic