Blog
My hospital and my insurer are in a contract fight. What do I do?
A notice says your hospital may leave your plan's network. The order for confirming the date, asking for a transition, moving care and keeping records.
Picture a household in a hypothetical. Maya is 31 weeks pregnant and plans to deliver at the hospital where her obstetrician has privileges. A letter from her insurer arrives saying the contract with that hospital system "may end" on January 1, 2027, and that members should "consider their options." She has a plan that does not pay for out-of-network care at all outside emergencies. The letter does not say what happens to a delivery that falls in early February.
A notice like this is alarming and vague at the same time. It usually does not mean the hospital is closing or that you are cut off today. It means two businesses have not agreed on prices and terms, and the clock on their current agreement is running out. This post is an order of operations for the person who is caught in the middle: what to confirm first, what to ask for in writing, what to do about scheduled care, which protections stay in place no matter what, and where to complain if the notice was misleading.
What the notice does and does not tell you
A network is the set of doctors, hospitals and other providers that have signed a contract with your plan to accept negotiated rates. When that contract expires or is terminated, the hospital becomes out-of-network for that plan from the end date. Your plan's out-of-network benefits, if it has any, then apply, and the hospital may bill you for the difference between its charges and what the plan pays. The guide in-network vs out-of-network care: what it means for your bill explains how those bills are built.
Most of these notices share three features:
- They give a date that the contract could end, not a date that it will. Many contract fights end in a new agreement, sometimes close to the deadline and sometimes after a short gap. Neither side can promise you which.
- They name the hospital system, which can include affiliated clinics, labs, imaging centers and employed physicians. Whether a particular doctor is covered by the same contract is a separate question you have to ask.
- They say little about patients in the middle of treatment. That gap is where most of the practical work lies.
Notice periods before a contract ends are set by the contracts themselves and, in some states, by law. This post does not state one, because it varies. Your notice and your plan's website should show the end date; if they do not, ask for it in writing.
Step 1: confirm the date and exactly who is affected
Call the number on your member ID card and ask four questions. Write down the answers, the date and the name or ID of the person who gave them.
- What is the exact date the contract with this hospital system ends?
- Which facilities and which physician groups are covered by that contract? (Ask by name about your hospital, your doctor's group, the hospital's lab, radiology and anesthesia groups.)
- If the contract ends, what are my benefits at that hospital: no coverage, or out-of-network coverage with a higher deductible and coinsurance?
- Does my plan have a continuity-of-care or transition-of-care process, and how do I start it?
Then check the same facts a second way. The provider directory on your plan's site may already show a termination date. Ask the hospital's patient financial services office whether it expects to be in network after the date, and whether it will honor in-network rates for patients already in treatment. Hospitals sometimes publish a patient page about the dispute; read it as one side's account, the same as the insurer's letter.
If your coverage is through an employer, the employer's benefits office can often tell you which of these rules apply to your plan, including whether it is self-funded, which changes the regulator and some of the protections (see below).
Step 2: find out whether you count as a continuing care patient
The federal No Surprises Act includes a continuity-of-care rule. In broad terms, when a contract between a group health plan or an insurer and a provider or facility ends, certain patients in the middle of care can keep receiving that care at in-network cost sharing for a transition period of up to 90 days. The categories are usually described as people who are:
- in a course of treatment for a serious and complex condition,
- receiving inpatient or institutional care,
- scheduled for a non-elective surgery, including the follow-up care,
- pregnant and receiving care for the pregnancy, or
- terminally ill.
As of November 2026, this is the federal framework; confirm the details with your plan's documents, because the plan must tell eligible patients about it and must have a process for it. Two limits matter. A transition period is not permanent. And the rule is about a contract ending, so a provider removed for quality or fraud reasons is treated differently.
Many states have their own continuity-of-care laws for insured plans, and some are more generous than the federal minimum, for example in how long a pregnancy-related transition lasts. The rules differ widely, so the right place to look is the state insurance department's website or a call to it. Plans that sit outside these laws include Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed care plans, which have their own continuity rules and their own regulators, so ask the plan and, for Medicare, a SHIP counselor what applies. How do I ask for a transition period when my doctor leaves the network? walks through the request itself.
Maya would fall in the pregnancy category. A person with elective cataract surgery on the calendar probably would not, but a person halfway through chemotherapy would.
Step 3: ask for the transition in writing, now
Do not wait for January. Send a short message through the plan's secure portal or by letter, and keep a copy:
I am a member (ID number). I am pregnant with an expected delivery date of February 10, 2027, and receive care at the named hospital. I understand the plan's contract with this hospital may end on January 1, 2027. I am requesting continuity of care so that my prenatal care, delivery and postpartum care continue at in-network cost sharing. Please confirm in writing that I qualify, the length of the transition period, and what the hospital and my physicians must do. My obstetrician's letter is attached.
The attachment matters. Ask the doctor's office for a short letter naming the diagnosis or condition, the treatment plan, the dates of upcoming care and the expected end of the course of care. The plan can approve a request faster when the clinical facts are on one page. If your request does not clearly fit a protected category, still send it; the plan can say no, and the written no is the document you need for the next step.
Step 4: list your scheduled care and decide what to move
Make a list of every appointment, procedure, scan, prescription refill with prior authorization and referral that touches the hospital system between now and, say, three months after the end date. Next to each, write the date and whether it falls before the contract ends.
Then sort the list:
- Before the end date and medically appropriate now: keep it. A visit that is scheduled before the contract ends is in network.
- After the end date and not urgent: ask your clinician whether it can safely be done earlier or later, or at a different in-network facility. This is a clinical call. Do not move a surgery or a delivery because of a contract date unless the person treating you agrees it is safe.
- After the end date and not movable: this is the care your continuity-of-care request has to cover.
Here is the arithmetic that makes the difference concrete. These are invented, round numbers to show the mechanism, not prices. Say Maya's plan has a $3,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance and a $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum, and she has already paid $1,000 toward the deductible this year. Say the in-network negotiated price for a hospital delivery is $20,000.
- Remaining deductible: $3,000 minus $1,000 is $2,000.
- Coinsurance: 20% of the remaining $18,000 ($20,000 minus $2,000) is $3,600.
- Her share in network: $2,000 plus $3,600 is $5,600, which is under the $6,000 maximum.
Now say the hospital is out of network and the plan, an EPO-style plan with no out-of-network benefits, pays nothing for a non-emergency stay. If the hospital's billed charge were $60,000, the exposure is not $5,600 but potentially the bill itself. Real plans differ: a PPO might pay part of an allowed amount while the hospital balance bills the rest. The gap between $5,600 and an open-ended figure is why the written transition decision is worth the effort.
If you use a plan with out-of-network benefits, ask the plan to explain the allowed amount it would use. balance billing describes how the leftover amount arises.
Step 5: remember what stays protected: emergencies
Contract fights do not change emergency rules. Under the No Surprises Act, emergency care at an out-of-network hospital is covered with in-network cost sharing, and the hospital generally cannot balance bill you for it. Plans apply the prudent layperson standard: if a person with an average knowledge of health would reasonably think the condition is an emergency, the visit is treated as one, whatever the final diagnosis. Surprise medical bills and the No Surprises Act: what is protected explains the rule and its limits; for example, it does not cover ground ambulance rides.
For a pregnancy, this means labor that starts early, a bleeding problem or a sudden drop in the baby's movement does not need pre-approval or a network check. Go where you can be seen. What the rule does not protect is a planned stay that you choose at an out-of-network hospital. Ask your obstetric practice, before the date, which hospital it will use if you need to deliver after the contract ends and whether that hospital is in network for you.
Step 6: keep a record that a stranger could follow
The people who sort these disputes out afterward, whether a complaints specialist or a billing office, need dates. Keep a simple log:
| Date | Who you spoke with | What they said | Reference number or document |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 17 | Plan member services | Contract ends Jan 1; they will send transition form | Call ref. 12345 (invented) |
| Nov 18 | Obstetrician's office | Will write a letter; confirms hospital for delivery | Letter requested |
Keep the plan's letters, portal messages and any denial notice together. Screenshots of the provider directory with the date visible are useful too. A written answer from the plan about who is covered is worth more than three conflicting phone calls.
Step 7: if you were misled, complain to the state
Plans and hospitals are expected to give accurate information about network status. If the plan told you a facility was in network and it was not, or the directory listed a doctor as covered after the contract ended, you may have a complaint. For an insured plan, that goes to the state insurance department; the guide how to file a complaint with your state insurance department lists what to include. For a self-funded employer plan, the state department generally cannot act, and the Labor Department's benefits agency is the usual contact.
A complaint is not an appeal. If the plan denies your continuity request, the denial notice tells you how to ask for review and by when, and urgent situations get a faster clock. Ask the plan's appeals unit or a navigator which route fits your case. The directory lists my doctor as in network. How do I confirm before I enroll? covers how to document a directory error.
When these rules may not reach you
Your protections depend on the kind of coverage:
- Individual and fully insured group plans: the federal continuity rule and your state's law both can apply. The state insurance department is the regulator.
- Self-funded employer plans: the federal rule applies, but state mandates generally do not.
- Medicare Advantage: the plan follows Medicare's own rules; your recourse is the plan's appeals process and, beyond it, Medicare. A SHIP counselor can help.
- Medicaid managed care: the state Medicaid agency sets the rules, and members usually have a fair-hearing right.
- Short-term and other limited plans: they may not be bound by the same protections, so read the contract.
What to do while the fight continues
During open enrollment, the choice may be bigger than the continuity request. Marketplace plan-year-2027 enrollment is open as of November 2026, and Medicare's Annual Enrollment Period runs through December 7. If you can still change plans, compare the networks of the alternatives for the hospital and your doctors by name, and confirm in writing; how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network shows how. Changing plans in the middle of a pregnancy or treatment has its own costs, since a new plan may reset deductibles. A navigator or broker can run the numbers for your household.
If the two sides announce a new agreement, ask the plan for a written confirmation of the new term and keep your continuity request on file in case talks fail again later. If they do not, you will already have the paper trail, the care plan and the written decision that shields the care you cannot move. If you want to understand why these disputes happen and what each side is arguing, see why insurer and hospital contract talks break down, and how rates get set.
Key takeaways
- A contract-end notice is a date that could pass without a deal, not a cutoff; confirm the exact date and which facilities and physician groups are covered.
- Ask in writing, early, for continuity of care. Federal law offers a transition period of up to 90 days for certain patients, including those who are pregnant or mid-treatment, and many states add their own rules.
- Emergency care stays protected at in-network cost sharing; planned care at an out-of-network hospital is where the large bills come from.
- Move only what your clinician agrees can safely move, and keep a dated log and the plan's written answers.
- If you were told the wrong network status, an insured plan's complaint goes to the state insurance department; self-funded plans usually go to the Labor Department.