Blog
My insurer leaves the marketplace while I am in treatment, in three situations
Three hypothetical households (a pregnancy, chemotherapy, a child's daily medicine) show how to ask for continuity-of-care help, what resets and how to choose.
A letter arrives in the fall saying your marketplace insurer will not sell plans in your area next year. If you are healthy, that is an annoyance: pick another plan. If you are in the middle of a pregnancy, a course of chemotherapy or a child's long-term treatment, the same letter raises sharper questions. Will the new plan cover my doctor? Do I start my deductible from zero? Will the treatment be interrupted?
This post works through three hypothetical households. They are invented, the numbers are round, and none of them describes a real person or a real plan. Each shows a different pressure point: a network, a series of treatments and a prescription. After the three cases, there is a short section on how to ask for continuity-of-care help and what to expect.
What is true in all three cases
Some facts apply to every household below.
- The notice comes first. An insurer that stops selling in a market generally has to give members advance written notice. Federal rules generally call for at least 90 days when a plan is discontinued and longer when an insurer leaves a market entirely, and the notice should explain your options. The guide what to do if your insurer leaves the marketplace in your area covers the basics.
- Open enrollment is the shopping window. For plan year 2027, HealthCare.gov open enrollment runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027, with coverage starting January 1 if you enroll by December 15, 2026 and February 1 if you enroll from December 16 through January 15 (confirm on HealthCare.gov). State-based marketplaces have their own dates, and some end earlier or later. The tool open enrollment dates and coverage start calculator helps with the arithmetic.
- The market is moving. As of October 28, 2026, KFF counted 11 insurers announcing exits from at least one state's marketplace for 2027, and 7 announcing entries into new states. Check what your own state offers.
- Calendar-year plans reset on January 1. If your plan runs on the calendar year, your deductible and out-of-pocket progress start over every January 1 whether or not your insurer changes. What a change of insurer adds is a new network, a new drug list and a new set of approval rules.
- Continuity rules are narrower than people expect. Federal rules protect some patients, called continuing care patients, when a provider leaves a plan's network: the plan may have to let you keep seeing that provider at in-network cost sharing for a limited time, up to 90 days, in situations such as active treatment of a serious condition or pregnancy. Those rules are written around a provider leaving a network you already belong to. They may not clearly reach a plan you are newly joining, in which the doctor was never in the network. Some states have transition rules for new members, and many insurers have a process for transition-of-care requests. Ask the new insurer directly.
Situation 1: Maria, a pregnancy due in March
Maria is 29 and 22 weeks pregnant. Her due date is in March 2027. Her insurer is leaving her county. She likes her obstetrician and plans to deliver at a particular hospital.
What she needs to know first. Her 2026 spending does not carry into 2027 on any plan, because a calendar-year deductible resets on January 1. The question is what network and rules apply for the months that matter: prenatal visits in January and February and a delivery in March.
Step by step.
- She lists what she needs: her obstetrician, the delivery hospital, the anesthesia group and the pediatric practice she wants for the baby.
- She uses each candidate plan's directory to look up her obstetrician and the hospital, then calls the obstetrician's billing office to ask which marketplace plans it has contracts with for 2027. Directories can be wrong; the practice knows its own contracts. See how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network.
- She checks the plan's maternity cost sharing in the Summary of Benefits and Coverage. Plans may bill prenatal care, delivery and postpartum care in different ways. The guide maternity coverage: prenatal care, delivery and postpartum costs describes the usual pieces.
- She also checks for a rule on newborn coverage: a birth opens a special enrollment period, generally 60 days in most cases, to add the baby, so she notes the date.
The arithmetic. Say she finds a plan whose network includes her obstetrician and hospital. It has a $2,500 deductible, 20% coinsurance and a $7,000 out-of-pocket maximum. These are illustrative numbers.
- Prenatal labs and imaging in January and February have an allowed cost of $1,500. All of it falls in the deductible, so she pays $1,500. The remaining deductible is $2,500 − $1,500 = $1,000.
- The delivery and hospital stay in March have an allowed cost of $16,000. She pays the remaining $1,000 deductible, then 20% of the other $15,000 ($16,000 − $1,000), which is $3,000. Her share of the delivery is $1,000 + $3,000 = $4,000.
- Her total for the stretch is $1,500 + $4,000 = $5,500, which is below the $7,000 maximum, so the maximum does not come into play.
The decision. Maria weighs the plan where her obstetrician and hospital are in the network against cheaper plans where they are not. Out-of-network obstetric care often means higher cost sharing, a separate deductible or no out-of-pocket cap on the amount over the plan's allowed rate. A lower premium would have to cover that risk. She chooses the network that includes her team, and asks the plan in writing how prior authorization for the delivery admission works.
If her obstetrician is not in any plan she can buy. She asks the new insurer for a transition-of-care or network exception (network gap exception) for the remaining pregnancy and postpartum care, and puts the request in writing with the due date and her doctor's letter. Some insurers grant these, some do not, and some states require it. If the answer is no, she asks for the denial in writing and the appeal steps.
Situation 2: Sam, chemotherapy through spring
Sam is 54 and receives an infusion every three weeks at an oncology practice. His treatment is expected to continue through April. His insurer is leaving the marketplace at year-end.
What matters most. Sam's treatment plan includes four infusions between January and April, each with an allowed cost of about $9,000. The oncologist, the infusion center and the drug itself must all be covered, and the drug may need prior authorization every time.
Step by step.
- He asks the oncology practice's financial counselor which 2027 marketplace plans the practice and the infusion center accept. He also asks whether the center is a hospital outpatient department, which can add a facility fee.
- He asks the practice to identify the drug and the codes billed, then checks each candidate plan's formulary and prior-authorization rules for it.
- He asks the practice to submit a prior authorization to the new plan as soon as the plan assigns him an ID, which some insurers accept before the January 1 start and some do not. If an infusion falls on January 4 and approval takes a week, the practice needs to know.
- He asks the old plan whether any infusions scheduled in December are authorized, so that treatment does not depend on a transition.
The arithmetic. Sam compares two plans. Plan A has a $4,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance, a $9,000 out-of-pocket maximum and a $400 monthly premium. Plan B has a $1,500 deductible, 30% coinsurance, an $8,000 out-of-pocket maximum and a $520 monthly premium. Assume, for the comparison, that his oncologist is in-network on both.
| Plan A | Plan B | |
|---|---|---|
| Four infusions at $9,000 each | $36,000 | $36,000 |
| Deductible | $4,000 | $1,500 |
| Coinsurance on the rest | 20% × $32,000 = $6,400 | 30% × $34,500 = $10,350 |
| Deductible plus coinsurance | $10,400 | $11,850 |
| Capped by the out-of-pocket maximum at | $9,000 | $8,000 |
| Premiums for 12 months | 12 × $400 = $4,800 | 12 × $520 = $6,240 |
| Total for the year, treatment plus premiums | $13,800 | $14,240 |
Plan A costs $440 less for the year on these assumptions ($14,240 − $13,800). The difference is small, and it moves if the treatment plan changes, if there are scans and lab work not counted here, or if premium credits differ between the plans. The comparison is a way of seeing that the out-of-pocket maximum matters more than the deductible for someone certain to reach it.
The decision. The table assumed both plans include his oncologist. Now say the practice tells Sam that it is in Plan B's network but not Plan A's. Out-of-network infusion costs may not count toward the cap at all, and the $440 saving in the table disappears into that risk. Sam chooses Plan B and treats the extra $440 as the price of in-network protection. Sam still asks Plan B to confirm in writing that his drug and the infusion center are covered, and what approval it needs.
Situation 3: A child with a daily medicine and a specialist
Leo is nine and takes a brand-name seizure medicine every day. He sees a pediatric neurologist twice a year and has an annual scan. His mother, Dana, receives the discontinuation notice in October.
What matters most. For Leo, the drug list matters as much as the network. Most plans put drugs in tiers, with different cost sharing. A drug may be covered but in a higher tier, may require prior authorization, or may be subject to step therapy, which asks you to try a cheaper drug first. A gap in a seizure medicine is a medical risk, so the timing of the first fill matters.
Step by step.
- Dana asks the neurologist's office to write down the exact drug, dose and form (tablet, liquid or extended release), because a formulary can cover one form and not another.
- She looks up the drug in each candidate plan's formulary and records the tier, any prior authorization, any quantity limit and any step-therapy rule.
- She asks about transition fills. Medicare has a rule for new members; marketplace plans have no single federal rule, so some plans offer a one-time supply for new members and some do not. She asks each plan.
- She asks the pharmacy whether she can refill early in December, if the old plan allows a "vacation override" or similar. It is not guaranteed.
- If the drug is excluded or restricted, she asks the neurologist to file a formulary exception request as soon as she has an ID card, with a letter explaining why alternatives are not appropriate. The guide what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need explains how those requests work.
The arithmetic. Dana compares two plans. Plan X has a $620 monthly premium and lists the medicine in tier 3 with a $60 copay per fill. Plan Y has a $570 monthly premium and lists it as a specialty drug with a $500 drug deductible and 30% coinsurance, with an allowed cost of $800 per monthly fill. These are illustrations.
- Plan X drug cost: 12 fills × $60 = $720.
- Plan Y drug cost: the first fill is $800. She pays the $500 deductible plus 30% of the other $300, which is $90, for a total of $590. Each of the 11 remaining fills costs 30% × $800 = $240, which is $2,640. The year's drug cost is $590 + $2,640 = $3,230.
- Premium difference: Plan X costs $50 more per month, or 12 × $50 = $600 more per year.
- Net: Plan Y's drug cost is $3,230 − $720 = $2,510 higher. Subtract the $600 premium savings and Plan Y costs $1,910 more over the year for the medicine alone.
Leo's other costs (the neurologist visits, the scan) would be added to each plan, and a child's out-of-pocket maximum could cap Plan Y's total at some point. The point is that the cheaper premium can cost more once a regular medicine is counted.
The decision. Plan X has the lower cost for Leo's medicine and includes his neurologist. Dana chooses it, but she asks Plan X to confirm that the drug is covered without prior authorization, and she keeps a copy of the neurologist's letter in case the plan changes its rules.
How to ask for continuity-of-care help
The same steps work for all three households.
- Find the right office. Call the member services number on the new plan's materials and ask for the transition-of-care, continuity-of-care or network-exception process. Ask whether it applies to new members.
- Put the request in writing. Include your name, ID number, the doctor's name and contact details, the condition, the treatment dates and what you are asking for (for example, "an exception to see Dr. X at in-network cost sharing through delivery and six weeks postpartum").
- Ask the doctor for a letter. A short note from the treating clinician stating the diagnosis, the treatment and why a change would be harmful carries weight.
- Ask for the decision in writing, with the reason and the appeal steps if the answer is no.
- If you are refused, you may have a right to an internal appeal and then to an independent external review, as with any denial. The state insurance department can tell you what applies in your state.
What resets and what does not
| Item | Usually carries over | Usually resets |
|---|---|---|
| Deductible and out-of-pocket progress | Rarely, unless the insurer gives credit in writing | Every January 1 on a calendar-year plan; at a mid-year change of plan |
| Prior authorizations | Sometimes honored for a short time | Often need to be re-requested |
| Doctor relationships | Yes, if the doctor is in the new network | If not, an exception may be possible |
| Premium credits | Based on your income and the benchmark plan, not the plan you choose | Recomputed when you update your application |
| Drug coverage | Depends on the new formulary | Tiers and rules may differ |
Key takeaways
- A calendar-year deductible resets on January 1 whatever the insurer; what a change adds is a new network, drug list and approval rules.
- Check your doctors with the practice, not just the directory, and check each drug's tier, authorization and quantity limit before you choose.
- Federal continuing-care protections are written for a provider leaving a plan's network, so ask a new insurer for a transition-of-care exception in writing and add a letter from your doctor.
- Compare plans on the full year's cost for your known treatment, including premiums, and weigh the in-network protection separately from the arithmetic.
- A marketplace navigator or your state insurance department can answer what applies in your state, and the HealthCare.gov dates are the ones to confirm for plan year 2027.