Blog

What should I watch for if my insurer also owns doctors and a PBM?

A grouped checklist of questions about referrals, pharmacies, networks and appeals for members whose insurer's parent also owns clinics or a PBM.

Your card says one company, your primary care clinic is owned by a company with a similar name, and the pharmacy your plan prefers belongs to a third business under the same parent. Is that a problem, or just how modern health care is organized? The honest answer is that it can be either, and the difference shows up in specific choices you make: who refers you, where you fill prescriptions, who reviews your requests and who hears your appeal.

This post does not take a side. It sets out what supporters and critics of these arrangements say, then gives a grouped checklist of questions you can ask. Each question comes with a reason, so you can tell which ones matter for your situation. Nothing here says that any particular company behaves badly. It is a way to see what is connected to what.

What "vertically integrated" means here

vertical integration in health care means one corporate family owns businesses at several stages of getting care and paying for it. For a health insurer, that can include:

  • Clinics, physician groups, urgent care centers or surgery centers that deliver care.
  • A pharmacy benefit manager (PBM), the company that runs the drug benefit for the plan, negotiates with drug makers and pharmacies, and manages the list of covered drugs.
  • A specialty pharmacy or mail-order pharmacy that dispenses certain prescriptions.
  • Data, analytics and care-management companies that serve the insurer and other customers.

UnitedHealth Group, whose Optum businesses include care delivery and a PBM alongside the insurer UnitedHealthcare, is a well-known example, and the profile at UnitedHealthcare describes how that company is organized. It is not the only one: other large insurers are part of corporate groups that own pharmacy businesses or provider groups. Which companies own what changes over time through acquisitions and sales, so check the current ownership in the company's own filings and your plan documents.

A related but different structure is the plan that is owned by a hospital system or built around a single provider group. The guide on provider-owned health plans: when the insurer and the hospital are one covers that model, which members often choose on purpose.

The case supporters make

Supporters of integration argue that putting care, payment and pharmacy under common management can:

  • Coordinate care. When the clinic and the insurer share information, a nurse can follow a patient after a hospital discharge, and gaps (a missed prescription, a repeat test) are easier to catch.
  • Align incentives. A company that pays for the hospital stay and also employs the primary care doctor has a financial reason to prevent the stay.
  • Lower administrative cost. Fewer separate contracts and billing steps can reduce paperwork.
  • Offer lower prices or simpler benefits for services inside the family, such as lower copays at an affiliated clinic or a home-delivery pharmacy.

The case critics make

Critics raise a different set of concerns:

  • Conflicts of interest. A company that both pays for care and sells it may have reasons to steer patients to its own clinics or pharmacies even when another option would be better or cheaper.
  • Reduced independence. A doctor employed by an affiliate may be, or may seem to be, under pressure on referrals, tests or prescribing.
  • Market power. A large integrated company can have more leverage in negotiations with competing providers or drug makers, and rivals may find it harder to compete.
  • Opacity. When money moves between affiliates, it can be hard for a member or a regulator to see what a service really costs or where the savings, if any, go.

These arguments are made about different companies and different practices, and the evidence on each is contested. Legislators and regulators have examined parts of this area, including how PBMs are paid. The post on What PBM reform proposals would change for patients and what critics say sets out those proposals. Because that area changes quickly, check current news before relying on any summary, including this one.

The checklist

Use the groups that apply to you. If you already know the answer to a question, skip it.

Group 1: Learn who owns what

  • Find the parent company. Look at the "about us" or "family of companies" section of your insurer's website, the profile on this site, or the annual report of the parent. Why: you cannot judge a conflict until you know whether one exists.
  • Ask whether your doctor, clinic or hospital group is affiliated with your insurer. The clinic's front desk or website can tell you who owns it. Why: affiliation is not wrong, but it changes what "independent referral" means.
  • Ask which company runs your drug benefit and which pharmacies it owns. Your member services number or the pharmacy section of your plan documents should say. Why: the PBM controls the covered drug list and the pharmacy network.

Group 2: Referrals and care decisions

  • When your doctor refers you, ask whether the specialist is affiliated with the plan, and whether other in-network options exist. Why: in a plan with an referral requirement, the first name offered is not always the only name allowed.
  • Ask whether you can pick a specialist outside the affiliated group and still be in network. Why: if the answer is yes, a first suggestion is only a suggestion.
  • Ask whether your plan offers lower cost sharing for using an affiliated clinic or hospital, and by how much. Why: a lower copay is a real benefit, and it is also a way of steering. You can weigh the dollar difference against your own preference.
  • If a test, scan or procedure is recommended, ask where it can be done and what each in-network site would charge you. Why: the price to you can differ between sites even inside one network.

Group 3: Prescriptions

  • Ask whether your plan requires a specific pharmacy, such as a mail-order or specialty pharmacy, for any of your drugs. Why: some plans require it for certain drugs, and some give a lower price for a preferred pharmacy and a higher price elsewhere. The definitions of specialty pharmacy and mail-order pharmacy explain the terms.
  • Compare your cost at each pharmacy option. Say a hypothetical 90-day maintenance drug costs $45 at the plan's mail-order pharmacy and $90 at a retail pharmacy outside the preferred network. Over four fills in a year, mail order costs 4 × $45 = $180 and the retail option costs 4 × $90 = $360, a $180 difference. Why: a small convenience premium may be worth it to you, but you should know what it is.
  • Ask whether the plan's drug list, step requirements or quantity limits differ for drugs the affiliated pharmacy dispenses. Why: the rules are supposed to be set by clinical criteria, and you are entitled to see the criteria for your drug. The guide on what pharmacy benefit managers do and why they matter covers how these lists work.
  • If you are told to move a prescription, ask whether you can keep filling it where you do now and what it will cost. Why: a transfer can interrupt a refill, so confirm the timing with your prescriber before switching.

Group 4: Approvals and denials

  • Ask who reviews a prior authorization request: a nurse, a doctor, a vendor, or an affiliated unit. Why: the reviewer's identity matters less than whether the criteria are written and available to you.
  • Ask for the written clinical criteria behind any denial. Why: you are generally entitled to the basis for a decision, and your doctor can address it point by point.
  • Ask your doctor about a peer-to-peer conversation. Why: a direct discussion between your doctor and the plan's reviewing physician sometimes resolves a request without a formal appeal.

Group 5: Appeals and complaints

  • Know that the first appeal goes to the plan, usually to a different reviewer. Details are in how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step. Why: the question at this step is whether the plan applied its own coverage rules correctly, and your doctor's letter and the plan's criteria are the evidence.
  • Know that an independent review exists after the internal appeal. An external review is decided by an organization outside the plan, which is the main structural check on a company that both pays and delivers. Deadlines and eligibility vary, and the denial notice should explain them.
  • Know where to complain. For a plan regulated by the state, the state insurance department takes complaints. For an employer's self-funded plan, a federal agency is involved instead. Why: sending the complaint to the wrong place costs time.

Group 6: Your information

  • Read the plan's privacy notice for how claims and records are shared among affiliates. Why: federal privacy rules permit sharing for treatment, payment and operations, and some uses need your consent. If something in the notice surprises you, ask.

A few worked situations

A referral. Your primary care doctor, employed by an affiliate, suggests a cardiologist in the same group. You ask, as in Group 2, whether another in-network cardiologist is available. Say the answer is yes, and a second office is a 25-minute drive farther. You are now choosing between convenience and a doctor you can compare, and you know it is a choice.

A prescription. Your plan requires its specialty pharmacy for a drug you take monthly. You ask for the cost and the delivery timing, and you ask what happens if a shipment is late. If the answer is unclear, ask for it in writing, and keep a record of calls.

A denial. Your plan denies a scan. You request the written criteria, ask your doctor for a peer-to-peer call and file an internal appeal within the deadline on the notice. If it is upheld, you request external review, where someone outside the company decides.

What integration does not change

It helps to be clear about what stays the same whoever owns the clinic or the pharmacy.

  • The coverage rules. A plan must cover the benefits its documents promise, and your cost sharing is set by the plan design, not by which affiliate delivers the service. If a bill does not match your explanation of benefits, the usual steps apply, starting with the explanation of benefits itself.
  • Your appeal rights. Internal appeal and external review apply to the plan's decision, regardless of the plan's corporate relatives.
  • Your right to ask. You can ask for a second opinion, ask whether a different in-network option exists, and ask for a written explanation of a decision. Asking is not a complaint and does not mark you as difficult.
  • The role of your own doctor. A doctor employed by an affiliate still has professional duties to patients, and many integrated organizations say their doctors make independent clinical decisions. Critics question how independent that is in practice. You do not have to settle that debate to ask your doctor, plainly, whether a recommended option is the one they would choose if the cost were the same.

Medicare Advantage members should know that these plans follow separate federal rules on networks, prior authorization and appeals, which are covered in Medicare Advantage networks and prior authorization: what to expect. A SHIP counselor can explain how an affiliation affects a particular Medicare plan.

When the question is bigger than your plan

If you suspect that something broke a rule, such as being told you must use an affiliated provider when your plan documents say you do not, file a complaint with the state insurance department or the agency that oversees your plan. For individual advice, a navigator, a licensed broker, a SHIP counselor (for Medicare) or a lawyer who handles health coverage can look at your plan documents. The post on Who gets paid when I fill a $500 prescription? Following the money shows how the money flows in one prescription, which helps when you are trying to understand where an affiliate sits in the chain.

Key takeaways

  • Vertical integration means one corporate family owns insurance, care delivery, pharmacy or PBM businesses. Supporters see better coordination, and critics see conflicts of interest. Both views appear in current policy debates.
  • Start by finding out who owns your clinic, your pharmacy and the PBM that runs your drug benefit.
  • Ask whether an affiliated option is the only option or just the first one offered, and compare the dollar difference in what you would pay.
  • Written denial criteria, peer-to-peer calls, internal appeals and independent external review are the tools you have when you disagree with a decision.
  • Keep notes of who told you what and when, and use the state insurance department or a navigator when an answer does not hold up.

Terms used in this guide

Related insurers

Related guides

Latest on this topic