Blog
The January to March Advantage window: what you can and cannot change
Who can use the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period, the one change it allows, what it will not let you do, and two worked examples with dates.
It is the second week of January and the card has arrived, the doctor you have seen for years is no longer in the network, and the pharmacy says the drug costs more than last year. The fall window closed on December 7. Many people believe they are stuck until next October. Often they are not: people who are in a Medicare Advantage plan get a second, narrower chance from January 1 through March 31. This post explains who can use it, what the single change can be, what it cannot do, and how the dates fall in two worked examples. The rules come from Medicare; the plan's notices and a SHIP counselor, the free state Medicare counselor, can confirm how they apply to you.
What the window is
The Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period, or MA OEP, runs from January 1 through March 31 each year. It is separate from the Annual Enrollment Period, which runs October 15 to December 7 and applies to nearly everyone with Medicare. The MA OEP is only for people who are already enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan on the day they use it, and it allows one change. A change made in the fall takes effect January 1; a change made in the MA OEP takes effect the first day of the month after the plan receives the request.
The purpose is plain: some problems only show up after the new year begins. The network turns out to be thinner than the directory suggested, the prescription list changed, or a plan's prior authorization rules get in the way. The MA OEP gives people a short chance to fix a bad fit.
Who can use it
You can use it if both of these are true on the day you act:
- You are enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan. That includes plans with drug coverage and plans without.
- The change you want is one the window allows (the next section).
People in Original Medicare who have a stand-alone drug plan cannot use it. People who are not yet enrolled in Medicare have other windows, such as the Initial Enrollment Period. Anyone with a different kind of special enrollment period, for example because they moved or lost other coverage, may have other options, and the special enrollment periods are separate from the MA OEP. They are covered in medicare special enrollment period and by Medicare.gov.
The one change you get
Inside the window, you can make one election. The two kinds are:
- Switch to a different Medicare Advantage plan. That could be a plan from another company or a different plan from the same company, as long as it is available where you live. It can be an HMO, a PPO or another type.
- Leave Medicare Advantage and return to Original Medicare, and join a stand-alone Part D drug plan at the same time if you want drug coverage. The drug plan is available as part of the same step.
The word "one" is a limit. If you switch plans in February and then find the new plan is worse, you generally cannot use the MA OEP again to make a second change in the same year. After the window you wait for the fall period or a special enrollment period you qualify for. That is why the sequence of steps matters. The most careful approach is to check the new plan's network, drug list and rules before you act, not after.
What you cannot do
The window is narrower than people hope. It does not allow you to:
- Go from Original Medicare to Medicare Advantage. If you have no Advantage plan on January 1, the MA OEP does not apply to you. The fall window or a special enrollment period is the way in.
- Join or change a stand-alone drug plan while staying in an Advantage plan with drug coverage. In most Advantage plans with drug coverage, adding a stand-alone plan will disenroll you from the Advantage plan and return you to Original Medicare. Adding a stand-alone drug plan to an Advantage HMO or PPO: the trap describes that trap.
- Buy a Medigap policy as a matter of right. Leaving for Original Medicare in the MA OEP does not give you a right to buy a Medigap policy. In most states, insurers may ask health questions and decline or charge more. A few states have broader rules, and some people have a time-limited trial right, so ask your SHIP counselor about yours. See medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue.
- Make several changes. One election per window.
- Change after March 31. The window ends at the end of March, even if your problem began in April.
The Medigap point deserves emphasis because it is the most expensive misunderstanding. A person who leaves a plan in February expecting to buy Medigap without questions may be turned down, and then has Original Medicare with its 20% Part B coinsurance and no cap on what she can owe. If you want Medigap, apply first and wait for the answer, as the checklist in Leaving Medicare Advantage: the checklist for Medigap, drug plan and dates sets out.
How the dates work
Three rules cover most cases.
- The request date sets the start date. If the plan or Medicare receives your request in January, the new coverage starts February 1. A request in February starts March 1, and a request in March starts April 1. A request on January 1 or 2 still starts February 1, not immediately.
- Your current plan covers you until then. Care before the effective date is under your current plan's rules and network. So if surgery is scheduled in a month, check whether the date falls before or after the change.
- Month-end matters. A request submitted on March 31 counts, even though the effective date is April 1. A request on April 1 does not count.
For the safest paper trail, make the request in a way that gives you a confirmation: Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, or the new plan, which often handles your disenrollment from the old one automatically.
Example one: switching plans
Say Marcus, 70, is in an HMO-style Advantage plan with drug coverage. In January he learns that his cardiologist left the plan's network on January 1. The cardiologist is in the network of a different company's PPO-style plan in his county.
- January 12: He calls the cardiologist's office and confirms they take the PPO plan in the new year. He asks the plan for its prior authorization list and checks his two prescriptions against its drug list.
- January 15: He enrolls in the PPO plan through Medicare.gov and saves the confirmation.
- February 1: The PPO plan starts. His HMO plan ends the night before.
- What he used: his one change for the year. If he regrets it, he has no more MA OEP changes and would wait for the fall.
His appointments in January are in the old plan's network, so the cardiologist visit he had planned for January 25 would be outside the network. He asks the office to schedule it for February 2 or later, and checks that any authorization he needs is on the new plan's file.
Example two: leaving for Original Medicare
Say Dolores, 68, is in an Advantage plan and decides on January 20 she wants Original Medicare. She has two tasks and one deadline.
- Medigap first. On January 20 she applies to two Medigap insurers and states the date she wants coverage to begin: February 1. One company approves her on January 31 at a standard rate. The other asks for records.
- Drug plan next. She also compares stand-alone drug plans and chooses one that starts February 1 and covers her three prescriptions.
- Disenrollment last. On January 31, with the Medigap approval in hand, she enrolls in the drug plan and requests disenrollment from the Advantage plan, both effective February 1.
- What happens: Her Advantage plan covers her through January 31. Original Medicare, the Medigap policy and the drug plan start February 1. She keeps the Medigap approval letter, the Medicare confirmation and the drug plan confirmation.
If she had been denied Medigap, she would have had a real decision to make: stay in an Advantage plan she dislikes, or return to Original Medicare without a supplement, knowing that she would then be exposed to the 20% coinsurance. Applying first meant she knew the answer before she acted.
Neither example is a recommendation. They are meant to show how the dates and the order fit together.
If this window is not the right tool
Sometimes the MA OEP is the wrong fit even for an Advantage member, and another route is better:
- You have moved or your plan has left your area. A move out of the plan's service area opens a special enrollment period of its own, usually with a longer or differently timed window, and it can come with Medigap protections that the MA OEP does not carry. See I'm moving. What happens to my Medicare Advantage plan, and when can I switch?.
- You have Medicaid or Extra Help. People with low income and those with both Medicare and Medicaid have extra special enrollment options that are not limited to one change. The details have shifted in recent years, so ask a SHIP counselor what applies now.
- You were enrolled without agreeing to it. A mistaken or misleading enrollment has its own remedy, described in the related post above, and it does not use up the MA OEP change.
- You can wait until fall. If the problem is not urgent, the Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7 gives you a full set of choices, including every plan open to you, with changes effective January 1. See Medicare Annual Enrollment Period: October 15 to December 7.
- A different kind of problem. A single denied claim or a prior authorization dispute is usually better handled through the plan's appeals process than through a plan change, because changing plans will not erase the denial.
What to check before you use the window
- Is the new plan's network confirmed for each doctor and facility you use, by phone, this year?
- Does the drug list include each of your medicines, and at what cost sharing?
- What does the plan say about prior authorization for services you expect to need?
- Will the plan be in effect on the date of any scheduled care?
- What is the plan's yearly limit on in-network spending? It resets each year, so spending in the old plan does not necessarily carry over; ask the new plan.
- If leaving, do you have written Medigap approval and a drug plan with the same start date?
When to get help
The plan's member services can tell you how its own rules work. For a neutral view, a SHIP counselor will go through the plans in your county with you. Medicare itself, at 1-800-MEDICARE, handles enrollment requests. For a complaint about an enrollment that was made for you without your consent, see I was switched into a Medicare Advantage plan I didn't choose. How do I fix it?. Your state insurance department regulates Medigap insurers and handles complaints about them.
Key takeaways
- The Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period, January 1 to March 31, is only for people already in an Advantage plan.
- It allows one change: another Advantage plan, or a return to Original Medicare with a stand-alone drug plan.
- It does not let you move from Original Medicare into Advantage, add a drug plan while staying in an Advantage plan, or buy Medigap as a matter of right.
- A change takes effect on the first day of the month after your request, so your current plan covers care until then.
- Apply for Medigap and wait for the answer before you disenroll, and check the new plan's network and drug list before you use your one change.