Blog

Leaving Medicare Advantage: the checklist for Medigap, drug plan and dates

A checklist in order for returning to Original Medicare: Medigap approval first, a stand-alone drug plan, the right window, cancellations and confirmations.

If you have decided to go back to Original Medicare, the order in which you do things matters more than how fast you do them. The usual mistake is to cancel the Advantage plan first and sort out the rest afterward. Done in that order, a person can end up with no Medigap policy, no drug plan and a gap in coverage that cannot be undone. The checklist below puts the steps in a safer order, with the reason for each. It describes how the rules generally work; your state's Medigap rules and your own health history can change the answers, so the last step is always a counselor from SHIP, the free state program for Medicare questions.

Before you start: two decisions that come first

This checklist assumes you have already decided to leave. If you are still deciding, the trade-offs are in Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: how to compare the two. Two questions determine the rest of the order:

  1. Can you get a Medigap policy at all? Outside a few protected situations, most states let Medigap insurers ask health questions and decline you or charge more for pre-existing conditions. KFF has estimated that roughly three of four Advantage members have a condition that could lead to a denial outside protected windows. If you cannot get Medigap, you would return to Original Medicare without a supplement, and your share of costs is not capped. That may still be right for you, but it is a different decision.
  2. Which window will you use? The two main windows are the fall period and the January through March period, and they have different timing. Step 3 below covers them.

Step 1: Apply for Medigap and wait for approval

Apply for the Medigap policy before you cancel anything. The reason is that the approval is the one step you do not control: the insurer decides, and in most cases it decides after reviewing your health history.

What to do:

  • Pick the lettered plan you want and get quotes from more than one company for the same letter. The benefits of each letter are standardized, so you are comparing price and service, not coverage. The medigap plan comparison chart shows the letters side by side.
  • Apply during the fall period, ideally in October or early November, so there is time for underwriting. An application may be approved, approved at a higher price, or denied. Some companies ask for a medical questionnaire and records; others use a short health screen.
  • Choose the start date carefully. A Medigap policy should begin on the day your Original Medicare coverage resumes, usually the first of a month. It cannot start before your Advantage plan ends, and it should not start after, or you have a gap.
  • Wait for written approval with an effective date. A quote is not approval.

If you are in one of the protected situations, such as certain trial rights or a plan ending in your area, an insurer must sell you a policy without health questions. Those rights have deadlines, usually counted in days, so read medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue and ask your SHIP counselor whether one applies to you. Do not cancel the Advantage plan until you know.

Step 2: Choose a stand-alone drug plan

Original Medicare does not cover most outpatient prescriptions. Part D does, and when you leave an Advantage plan that included drug coverage, you lose the drug coverage with it. You need a stand-alone Part D plan that starts on the same day your Original Medicare starts.

The reason this step is on the list is the penalty. Medicare charges a late enrollment penalty if you go without creditable drug coverage for 63 days or more in a row after your initial window. The penalty is 1% of the national base beneficiary premium for each full uncovered month, and it is added to your drug plan premium for as long as you have Part D. The base premium was $38.99 in 2026 and is $41.33 for 2027, so each uncovered month adds about $0.41 a month for 2027, by arithmetic: $41.33 x 0.01 = $0.4133. The amount looks small, but it continues for life and grows with the base premium each year. See Medicare late enrollment penalties for Part B and Part D.

What to do:

  • List your drugs and your pharmacy, then compare plans on the drugs you take, not on the premium alone. The Medicare plan finder at Medicare.gov and your SHIP counselor can run the comparison.
  • Enroll in the drug plan so it begins on the same date as Original Medicare. If you use the fall period, that is January 1. If you use the January to March period, it is the first day of the month after you ask.
  • Check one trap: if your Advantage plan includes drug coverage and you join a stand-alone drug plan, you are usually disenrolled from the Advantage plan automatically. That can be a way to leave, but only if your Medigap is in place first. Joining the drug plan by itself, without a Medigap decision, can end your Advantage coverage on a date you did not plan.

Step 3: Pick the window

There are two windows for most people.

Window Dates When the change takes effect Notes
Annual Enrollment Period (fall) October 15 to December 7 January 1 Most time to apply for Medigap before the start date
Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period January 1 to March 31 The first day of the month after your request Allows one change; includes leaving for Original Medicare and joining a drug plan

The fall window is the better choice for most people who can wait, because you can finish underwriting before you cancel. The January to March window is the right choice when you discover in January that the plan is not working. In that case, you are already in the plan, so the order of steps still applies: apply for Medigap, then act on the Advantage plan. See The January to March Advantage window: what you can and cannot change for what the second window allows and does not.

A hypothetical to show the timing. Say Elena decides on November 20 to leave and applies for Medigap that day. The approval arrives on December 3 with an effective date of January 1. She enrolls in a stand-alone drug plan effective January 1 on December 5 and submits her disenrollment from the Advantage plan on December 6, a day before the fall window closes. Her Advantage plan ends December 31, and Original Medicare, Medigap and the drug plan start January 1. If she had waited until after December 7, the fall change would have been unavailable.

Step 4: Cancel, in the right way

Once you have written approval for Medigap and a confirmed drug plan, you can leave the Advantage plan.

  • The cleanest way is to request disenrollment through Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE or Medicare.gov) or the plan itself, in the same window as your drug plan enrollment. Ask what date your Advantage coverage ends and get that in writing.
  • Do not just stop paying the premium. Plans can disenroll you for nonpayment, but that is not an orderly exit and can leave you without coverage.
  • Cancel the extras. If you bought a separate dental, vision or hearing plan, a rider or a supplemental plan that depends on your Advantage plan, find out whether it continues, and cancel it if not. If you paid a premium directly to the Advantage plan, ask for a refund of any month after the end date.
  • Ask the plan to confirm your last day of coverage. Claims for care before that date are paid by the plan, even if the bill arrives later.
  • Tell your doctors and your pharmacy that your coverage is changing on a specific date, because their records will still show the old plan.

Questions to ask each Medigap company

Because the letters are standardized, the useful differences are in how the company prices and handles you. Ask each one, in writing where you can:

  • Is the premium priced by your age when you buy, by your attained age as you get older, or by community rating? The three methods change the cost over time, and Why does my Medigap premium keep rising? Three pricing methods explained explains how.
  • Does it ask health questions, and does it apply a waiting period for pre-existing conditions? A waiting period may apply if you are not covered by other creditable coverage.
  • What discounts apply, and do they expire?
  • What is the exact effective date, and does it match the date your Original Medicare resumes?
  • How does it handle a rate increase, and how will you be told?

Write the answers next to each quote so you are comparing the same things.

If the plan is ending anyway

Sometimes the decision is made for you: the plan leaves your county, you move out of its service area, or the plan stops operating. In those cases federal rules give some people a guaranteed right to buy certain Medigap policies without health questions, if they apply within a limited window, counted in days, after the coverage ends. The notice from the plan states the date, and the window can be as short as two months, so do not set the letter aside. A SHIP counselor can tell you whether you have the right and which policies it covers. The related post My Advantage plan is ending: do I get a guaranteed Medigap policy? goes through the case.

Step 5: Keep the paperwork

Treat this like moving house. Keep:

  • The disenrollment confirmation, with the date and the plan's name.
  • The Medigap approval, the policy and the effective date.
  • The drug plan's enrollment confirmation.
  • The date, time and name for every phone call.
  • Your Original Medicare card, the red, white and blue one. If you cannot find it, you can request a replacement from Medicare.

If anything goes wrong later, the confirmation is the proof of what you did and when.

Step 6: Check the new cards and the first claims

Check three things in the first weeks after the date:

  1. You have your cards. The Medigap card and the drug plan card should arrive before or soon after the start date. Original Medicare is the card you show for Medicare-covered services, with your Medigap information alongside.
  2. A claim or two goes through as expected. After your first doctor visit, check the Medicare Summary Notice for what Medicare paid and the Medigap statement for what it paid. If something was denied, call right away.
  3. Your pharmacy has the drug plan on file. Fill a prescription early in the month and check the price against what you were told.

What can go wrong

A few things catch people:

  • Cancelling first. If Medigap is denied after you left, you are in Original Medicare without a supplement, and in most states it will be hard to get one later.
  • Forgetting the drug plan. A gap of 63 days or more can lead to the penalty described above, which lasts as long as you have Part D.
  • Starting dates that do not line up. A Medigap policy that starts a month late leaves a month with Original Medicare's 20% coinsurance and no supplement.
  • Assuming the plan will tell you. Plans must send notices, but a mailing address change or a missed letter can leave you unaware of the date.
  • Counting on a second try. In the January to March window you get one change. If you use it badly, you cannot undo it.

If you are unsure, the people to ask are a SHIP counselor, a licensed insurance agent who is independent of any one company, or 1-800-MEDICARE. Your state's insurance department can tell you what rules your Medigap insurers must follow.

Key takeaways

  • Get written approval for a Medigap policy first, because it is the one step that depends on a company's decision and in most states cannot be assumed.
  • Add a stand-alone drug plan that starts the same day as Original Medicare, since going 63 days or more without creditable drug coverage can add a penalty for as long as you have Part D.
  • Use the fall window when you can, so underwriting finishes before you cancel; the January to March window allows one change.
  • Make sure all three coverages, Original Medicare, Medigap and the drug plan, start on the same date, and keep every confirmation.
  • Check the first claims and the first prescription, and call a SHIP counselor if anything does not match what you were told.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic