Blog
I'm leaving my job with money left in my FSA. What are my options?
Four hypothetical households leaving a job mid-year show how a health FSA behaves: the day-one rule, incurred dates, run-out deadlines and COBRA.
When a job ends in the middle of the year, a health FSA does not end neatly. Whether you are ahead or behind on the account depends on how much you have been reimbursed compared with how much has come out of your pay, and what you can still do depends on the dates. The four households below are hypothetical, with round numbers, and each shows a different version of the problem. Your plan document and your benefits office decide the real answer for your account, because plans differ on several of the details.
Before the households, four rules explain most of what follows.
The rules behind the scenarios
The full election is available from day one. A health FSA has to make the employee's entire annual election available at the start of the plan year, even though the money comes out of pay a little at a time. A person who elects $2,400 can be reimbursed for $2,400 of eligible costs in January, with only one paycheck's contribution in the account.
The employer generally cannot recoup an overpayment. If you have been reimbursed more than you contributed by the time you leave, the employer generally cannot ask you to pay the difference back. The employer takes that risk, which is the other side of the day-one rule. This is a general rule of how these plans are designed, and a few situations (such as reimbursements for expenses later found to be ineligible) are different.
Only costs incurred while you participate are reimbursable. An expense is incurred when the care is given, not when you are billed or pay. Costs from after the date your participation ends are generally not covered. The end date is set by the plan: it may be your last day of work or the end of that month.
A run-out period applies to claims. After participation ends, plans usually give a window to submit claims for costs incurred earlier. Its length is the plan's choice. A claim filed after the window closes is generally refused, even if the expense was eligible.
One further option exists in rare cases: continuing the FSA under COBRA continuation coverage, with after-tax payments. Whether it is offered, and whether it makes sense, is the subject of the second household.
Household 1: Ana, who has spent more than she contributed
Ana (hypothetical) elected $2,400 for the year, which is $200 a month. Early in the year she had a procedure that cost her $2,000 after insurance, and the FSA reimbursed it. Her last day is June 30. By then she has contributed six months of $200, or $1,200.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Annual election | $2,400 |
| Contributed through June 30 (6 × $200) | $1,200 |
| Reimbursed so far | $2,000 |
| Reimbursed beyond contributions (2,000 minus 1,200) | $800 |
| Election still available (2,400 minus 2,000) | $400 |
Ana has received $800 more than she paid in. In general the employer cannot ask for that back. She can also still claim up to $400 more for eligible costs incurred through June 30. If she has glasses or a dental visit she was going to schedule anyway, doing it before her last day uses the money. After June 30 the account stops covering new costs.
Her decision is less about the $800, which she can keep, than about finishing the paperwork: she should submit receipts for anything incurred before June 30 within the run-out period. COBRA for the FSA would not help her, because she has already been reimbursed more than she would pay in for the rest of the year.
Household 2: Ben, who has a big unspent balance
Ben (hypothetical) elected $3,000, which is $250 a month. His last day is August 31. He has contributed eight months, or $2,000, and has been reimbursed $500.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Annual election | $3,000 |
| Contributed through August 31 (8 × $250) | $2,000 |
| Reimbursed so far | $500 |
| Contributions not yet used (2,000 minus 500) | $1,500 |
| Election still available (3,000 minus 500) | $2,500 |
Ben has $1,500 of his own contributions that have not come back to him. Unless he does something, that is generally forfeited when his participation ends. He has two paths.
Spend down before the last day. The plain choice is to bring forward care he was going to have anyway: dental work, glasses, a refill of a long-term prescription (the plan decides what date counts for the refill), an eye exam. Care incurred by August 31 can be claimed even though he has contributed less than the full election. He should check what the plan counts as eligible so he does not spend on an ineligible item; see What can I buy with my HSA or FSA? Everyday items sorted by yes, maybe, no.
Ask whether COBRA for the FSA is offered. Federal rules generally require an offer only when the account is "underspent," meaning the benefit still available is more than the premium for the rest of the year. Here, the remaining election of $2,500 is far above the cost to continue. The COBRA price is up to 102% of the contribution rate, paid with after-tax money. Four months of $250 at 102% is $1,020 (4 × 250 × 1.02). If Ben expects $1,300 of dental work in October, continuing the FSA would cost $1,020 and return $1,300, a gain of $280. If he expects only $500 of care in those months, he would spend $1,020 to get back $500 and lose $520. The COBRA cost and deadline calculator handles the general COBRA deadlines, and How COBRA works: eligibility, cost and how long it lasts covers the standard version for medical coverage. Ben must also meet the election deadline, which for COBRA is at least 60 days from the notice.
Which option wins depends on the dates of his care. Spending down before August 31 is free if he needs the care anyway. COBRA is a bet on the next four months.
Household 3: Chloe, whose last day falls in mid-month
Chloe (hypothetical) elected $1,200, which is $100 a month. Her last day is March 14. Her plan ends participation on the last day of employment, not the end of the month. She has two items on her mind.
- A dental visit on March 10 with a cost share of $180. The bill will not arrive until late April.
- New glasses that she ordered on March 8 and picked up on March 20, for $250.
The dental visit was incurred March 10, before her participation ended, so it is reimbursable even though the bill comes later, as long as she files within the run-out period with the itemized bill or the explanation of benefits. The glasses are murkier. If the plan counts the date of delivery, March 20 falls after her participation ended, and the $250 would be refused. If it counts the order date, the claim may pass. This is exactly the question to ask the benefits office before the last day, not after. If she had waited to order the glasses until after March 14, there would be no ambiguity: they would not be covered.
The lesson from Chloe is that the plan's end date (the last day of work versus the end of the month) changes which costs count. A person leaving on March 14 on a plan that ends participation on March 31 would have had two more weeks.
Household 4: Dev, with a claim still pending
Dev (hypothetical) filed a $400 claim in mid-October for a procedure on October 5. His last day is October 31. In early November, the administrator wrote to say the claim was denied because the receipt did not show the date of service.
Dev's problem is not eligibility but paper. The claim can usually be fixed by sending a corrected itemized bill or the explanation of benefits, within the run-out period. Three practical steps:
- Before the last day, set up access that does not depend on work email. Add a personal email and phone to the FSA portal, and download the claim history and plan summary.
- Ask for the run-out deadline in writing, along with the address or portal for claims.
- Answer any request for documentation promptly. A plan can refuse a claim for missing paperwork even after you have spent the money on eligible care.
The post Why was my FSA card declined or flagged, and what do I send to fix it? lists what a valid receipt shows and how to escalate when the administrator will not budge.
What the four households share
Nobody here had a choice about the plan's rules, but each had a choice about timing and paperwork. The plan document, which the employer must provide on request, states the end date for participation, the run-out period and whether COBRA is offered. The related post I'm leaving my job, so what happens to my HSA, FSA and HRA? covers the other accounts people carry, and FSA use-it-or-lose-it rules, carryover and grace periods explains carryover and grace periods, which generally apply to people who stay in the plan.
A few other points:
- A new employer's FSA is a new account. The new plan has its own election and its own limit. Unspent money from the old plan does not transfer.
- A dependent care FSA is separate. Its rules about when expenses count differ, and the plan document for that account is the place to check.
- If you had an HSA-eligible plan, an HSA is not affected by leaving, because it belongs to you; see HSA.
- When you land at a new employer, the FSA election planner helps you set the next election from the care you really expect.
Questions to put to the benefits office
Employers vary, so the most useful thing you can do in the last week is ask questions and keep the answers. A short email works and leaves a record.
- On what exact date does my FSA participation end?
- What is the last date to submit claims for costs incurred before that date, and how do I submit them after my work email stops?
- Does the plan reimburse a cost on the date of service, the date of purchase or the date of payment? How does it treat glasses ordered before and picked up after the end date?
- Is COBRA offered for the health FSA in my situation, what would it cost per month, and what is the election deadline?
- If I am rehired by this employer later in the same plan year, does my old election resume?
- Will my final paycheck include a contribution, and will any contribution be refunded if I am not reimbursed?
What changes if you are rehired or get another job
A person rehired by the same employer in the same plan year may or may not be allowed to pick up the old election, depending on the plan's rules and the length of the gap. A person who starts at a new employer starts fresh, with a new election, a new plan year and the full-election rule applying again. If the new employer's plan year starts in January and you start in October, the usual choice is a small election tied to the care you expect before December, or waiting until the next open enrollment period. The qualifying life event rules let some people make an election outside the usual window, and the benefits office decides whether a new job counts.
A short checklist for the week you get the news
- Ask when participation in the FSA ends, in writing.
- Add up how much you have contributed and been reimbursed.
- List eligible care you were going to have anyway and schedule it before the end date if the plan allows.
- Find the run-out deadline for claims and mark it on a calendar.
- Ask whether COBRA for the FSA is offered and what it would cost.
- Download receipts, statements and the plan summary while you still have access.
Key takeaways
- A health FSA makes the whole election available from day one, so some people leave having received more than they paid in, and the employer generally cannot recoup it.
- Only costs incurred while you participate are reimbursable; the plan sets whether participation ends on the last day of work or the end of the month.
- Claims for earlier costs can usually still be filed during the run-out period, but the length is set by the plan and late claims are generally refused.
- COBRA for an FSA is rare and is generally relevant only when the remaining benefit exceeds the remaining cost; it is paid with after-tax money.
- Get portal access, receipts and the plan document before your last day, and ask the benefits office to confirm each date in writing.