Blog
Medicaid cut my service: the notice, keeping benefits and the fair hearing
A walkthrough for enrollees and caregivers whose home care or equipment was cut: reading the notice, keeping services, the plan appeal and the hearing.
A letter arrives saying that the home health aide who comes six days a week will come four days starting on the 15th. Or the wheelchair that was approved last year is now "not medically necessary." Or the therapy hours a child receives are cut in half. For people who depend on Medicaid services, a notice like this lands in the middle of daily life, and the clock on it is shorter than people expect.
This walkthrough follows the notice from the moment it is opened to the end of a state fair hearing. It is written for the enrollee or for the family member or caregiver acting for them. Dates and rules differ by state and by whether the service comes through a managed care plan or straight from the state, so the notice itself controls. Use the numbers below as the usual shape of the process, not as your deadlines.
Step 1: Open the notice and find four things
Federal Medicaid rules require a written notice when a service is denied, reduced, suspended or ended. Managed care plans call this an adverse benefit determination (adverse benefit determination). Put the notice on a table and mark:
- What is changing. Which service, how much of it (hours, visits, items), and from what to what.
- The effective date. The day the change takes effect. When a notice reduces something you already get, there is normally a gap between the date printed on it and the effective date, and that gap is where your options live.
- The stated reason. Examples include a new assessment score, a finding that the service is no longer medically necessary (medical necessity), a policy limit, a missing document or a change of rules. A notice that gives no real reason is itself something to raise.
- The deadlines. There are usually at least two: one for asking that your services continue while you appeal, and one for the appeal or hearing itself. Circle both and write the dates on a calendar.
Also keep the envelope or the date the portal message appeared. Some deadlines run from the date the notice was mailed, not the date it was read.
Step 2: Decide quickly whether to ask for continued benefits
When a service you already receive is being cut or stopped, federal rules generally allow you to keep receiving it at the old level while the appeal or hearing is decided, if you ask in time. In both fee-for-service Medicaid and managed care, the request deadline is usually short, measured in days (commonly about 10 days from the date of the notice or before the change takes effect, depending on the program). The notice says which date applies to you.
Things to know before you decide:
- It is a separate request from the appeal itself. In many states you do both at once, but they are different asks. Say the words: "I am appealing and I am requesting that my services continue during the appeal."
- It applies to a service already authorized and being delivered. It generally does not help with a request for something new that was denied.
- Ask what happens if you lose. In many programs the state or plan may seek repayment for services delivered during the appeal if the original decision is upheld. Whether it does, and how, varies by state and plan. Ask the plan or the state agency, and ask legal aid, before you rely on it. For many families the stakes (an aide, a ventilator supply, a therapy slot) are worth the risk, but it should be a decision rather than a surprise.
- Get the request in writing or get confirmation. If you ask by phone, follow with a short written note and keep proof of the date.
If you are close to the deadline and unsure, filing the request is usually the safer move. Withdrawing is possible later; reviving a missed deadline is much harder.
Step 3: Understand which route you are on
There are two common routes, and the notice tells you which:
- Managed care. The plan sent the notice. You file an appeal with the plan first (the plan's internal appeal, internal appeal), which often must be requested within about 60 days of the notice, and the plan decides within a set time, generally 30 days for a standard appeal and about 72 hours for an expedited one. If the plan upholds its decision, you may ask for a state fair hearing, with its own deadline measured from the plan's decision notice. medicaid managed care explained: plans, networks and appeals and My Medicaid plan denied a prescription or therapy, how do I appeal? go through this route in detail.
- State agency or fee-for-service. The state or its contractor sent the notice. Appeal rights run directly to a fair hearing, usually with a deadline of up to a few months from the notice.
Waiver programs that pay for home and community-based services (home and community-based services) can follow either route, depending on the state. When a case manager or "support coordinator" works with you, ask them which one applies in writing.
Step 4: Gather what a hearing officer will weigh
A reduction in hours or equipment usually rests on an assessment: a nurse or case manager scores how much help a person needs with bathing, dressing, eating, moving, medications and similar tasks. Your evidence should answer that assessment, not argue in general terms. Collect:
- A copy of the assessment and the policy. Ask for the assessment tool, the score, the criteria and the date of the visit. Federal rules give managed care enrollees a right to the case file free of charge; ask for it in writing.
- A statement from the doctor or therapist. It should say what the diagnosis is, what has changed or not changed since the last authorization, what the service does and what is likely to happen without it: falls, hospital stays, pressure sores, missed medications, a move to a facility.
- Records that show need: discharge summaries, therapy notes, imaging, prescriptions, emergency room visits since the last assessment.
- A caregiver log. Two weeks of notes (what help was needed, when, how long it took) are persuasive, especially when the assessment was done on a good day.
- Photos or measurements, for equipment: a bed that no longer fits, a wheelchair with a broken frame.
- A list of what happens if the service is cut, in specific terms: who will do the bathing at 7 a.m., and what that does to the caregiver's job.
Here is a hypothetical, with round numbers invented for illustration. Say a notice cuts an aide's hours for a parent, Mr. Alvarez, from 30 hours a week to 18. That is 12 hours a week fewer, or 12 × 52 = 624 hours a year, about 78 eight-hour days of help no longer in the house. If the caregiver's own log shows that morning care takes 2 hours a day and evening care 1.5 hours a day, that is 3.5 × 7 = 24.5 hours a week for those two routines alone, more than the 18 the notice would allow. That one calculation, tied to dated entries, says more to a hearing officer than the phrase "he needs more help."
Step 5: File the appeal or hearing request
Whichever route, put the request in writing even if a phone option exists. Include:
- the enrollee's name, ID number and the notice's date and reference number;
- a plain statement: "I disagree with this decision and request an appeal (or fair hearing) and continued benefits";
- the reason in a sentence or two, matched to the notice's stated reason;
- a list of documents enclosed;
- the name and phone number of a person who can be reached, and written permission if a caregiver or advocate is filing on someone else's behalf (the agency or plan can supply the form).
If the enrollee needs the service urgently, say so and ask for an expedited decision. A doctor's statement that waiting could seriously harm the enrollee's health supports the request. Expedited appeals and hearings move on a much shorter clock, typically days rather than weeks.
Keep proof you filed: a fax receipt, an online confirmation, a certified mail slip, or the name of the person who took a phone request and the time. The appeal and external review deadline calculator can help you count days, though for Medicaid the notice outranks any calculator.
Step 6: Prepare for the state fair hearing
If the plan or agency stands by its decision, the fair hearing is where someone with no stake in the outcome decides. Hearings are conducted by a hearing officer or administrative law judge for the state. Many are held by telephone or video, some in person. Typically:
- Before the hearing, you can ask to see the agency's or plan's evidence packet and to have it explained. Ask for it early, and ask for the exact policy relied on.
- At the start, the hearing officer explains the procedure, identifies those present and may place people under oath.
- The agency or plan states why it reduced the service.
- You or your representative respond: your evidence, your witnesses, your questions for the plan's witness.
- The hearing officer asks questions, then closes the record. A written decision follows, usually within a time set by state rules, with a shorter one for expedited cases.
Hearing tips that apply almost everywhere:
- Be there on time and ready to be reached. A missed phone hearing can end the case. Ask how the call will be placed and from what number.
- Organize documents in the order you will refer to them, with a copy for each party if sent by mail, and number the pages.
- Cross-examine the assessment, not the assessor. Ask when the visit occurred, how long it lasted, what the person was asked to demonstrate and which tasks were observed rather than reported.
- Use the agency's own policy. If the policy lists criteria the assessment did not address, point to the line.
- Bring someone who knows the daily routine, and let them speak. A hearing officer has not met the enrollee.
- Say what you want, in a sentence: "restore 30 hours a week as authorized, effective from the date of the reduction."
- Ask for time if you receive the agency's documents late. A request for a short postponement is common.
- Consider legal help. Legal aid offices and disability or senior advocacy groups regularly represent people at Medicaid hearings at no charge, and many ask to be called before the hearing is scheduled. For a nursing facility resident, the state long-term care ombudsman is another free contact.
Step 7: After the decision
If the hearing officer sides with you, the decision should order the plan or agency to restore the service and, when benefits were stopped in the meantime, to authorize or pay for the services for the gap. Ask for the date by which it must act and put a calendar reminder on it. If services were not restored by that date, contact the plan's appeals unit, the state agency and your advocate in writing and cite the decision.
If the decision goes against you, the notice states whether the state offers a further review or a court appeal and by when. Another option, outside the appeal track, is a new request: if the enrollee's condition has changed, a fresh assessment or a new authorization request with new medical evidence is not barred by the earlier decision. Ask the care team whether to file one in parallel.
What to do while you wait
An appeal does not feed anyone this week. If services stop or continue at a lower level, plan the interim:
- Ask the plan's case manager or the waiver case manager for a temporary arrangement, such as a short-term authorization of hours.
- Call the local area agency on aging or disability resource center about non-Medicaid help, such as meal delivery or respite.
- Ask the doctor's office whether any part of the cut service can be supplied another way, for example through a different Medicaid benefit.
- Tell the family or employer what is coming, so that you are not discovering the gap on the first morning.
For some households the cut also raises larger questions about long-term care costs and eligibility rules; How Medicaid works: who qualifies, what it covers and who runs it and Paying for long-term care with Medicaid: income and asset rules give the background, and an elder law attorney or SHIP counselor can address your state's specifics.
Two things that look like appeals but are not
A complaint about how an aide behaves, a late van or a rude call center is a grievance (grievance), not an appeal of the cut. Grievances matter, and plans must respond to them, but they do not stop the appeal clock. File the appeal first and the grievance second.
A call to a state legislator's office or the governor's constituent line can sometimes get a stalled case looked at. It does not replace a request filed on time.
Key takeaways
- The notice names the change, the effective date, the reason and two deadlines; the one for keeping current services in place is often the shortest, measured in days.
- Ask for continued benefits in the same request as the appeal, and ask what repayment risk applies if you lose.
- A hearing is won with evidence tied to the assessment: the doctor's statement, records, a caregiver log and the agency's own policy.
- Managed care enrollees usually appeal to the plan first and then to the state; fee-for-service enrollees go to a hearing directly.
- Legal aid and disability advocacy groups often represent Medicaid enrollees at hearings for free, so call them before the hearing is scheduled.