Blog
My Medicaid plan denied a prescription or therapy, how do I appeal?
A step-by-step playbook for appealing a Medicaid managed care denial: the notice, the plan's appeal, expedited review, the state fair hearing and what to log.
When a Medicaid health plan says no to a drug, a therapy or a service, the "no" is the start of a process, not the end of one. Almost every Medicaid enrollee in a managed care plan has two layers of challenge: an appeal to the plan itself, then a state fair hearing in front of someone who does not work for the plan. The exact deadlines are printed on the denial notice, so the first job is to find that paper and read it.
This playbook walks the steps in order. It assumes your coverage runs through a private plan that your state contracts with (see Medicaid managed care and medicaid managed care explained: plans, networks and appeals), not through straight fee-for-service Medicaid. The details differ by state, and the notice, your state Medicaid agency and your state's ombudsman or legal aid office are the authority on yours.
Step 1: Read the notice for three things
A plan that denies, reduces, suspends or ends a service, or refuses to pay for one, must send a written notice. Federal Medicaid managed care rules call this an adverse benefit determination (adverse benefit determination). Pull it out and mark three things:
- The reason. The notice should say why in plain terms: the service is not covered, it was judged not medically necessary, the plan wanted a prior authorization that was not on file, the provider was out of network, or the request was incomplete. As of November 2026, a federal rule on prior authorization (CMS-0057-F) requires Medicaid managed care plans to give a specific reason for a prior authorization denial. If yours says only "does not meet criteria," that is worth pointing out in your appeal.
- The date and the deadlines. Note the date on the notice (not the date it reached you) and the deadline for asking for an appeal. Federal rules set a minimum window of 60 days for managed care appeals, and some notices give more. The notice states the number; do not rely on memory or on this page.
- Whether a service is ending. If the plan is cutting or stopping something you already receive, such as therapy visits or a drug you take now, there may be a much shorter deadline, often counted in days, to ask that services continue while the appeal is decided. That is covered in Step 4.
Put a copy of the notice in a folder, along with the envelope or the date the portal message appeared. Photograph every page if it came on paper.
Step 2: Ask for the criteria and your file
You are entitled to know what the plan used to decide. Call or write the plan's appeals or member services unit and ask for:
- the clinical criteria, guideline or policy the denial relied on;
- the name and credentials of the reviewer, if the notice does not state them;
- a copy of the records and documents the plan considered, free of charge;
- whether the plan's own policy lists a different route, for instance an exception process for a drug that is not on its preferred list (formulary exception).
Ask for these in writing as well as by phone, and note the date, the name of the person you spoke to and a reference number. The plan has to give you a reasonable opportunity to see the file, and the criteria are often what lets a doctor answer the plan's exact objection instead of arguing in general terms.
For a prescription denial, find out which of three situations you are in, because the fix differs:
- Prior authorization was required and was refused or never filed: the doctor's office must supply the clinical reasons (prior authorization).
- Step therapy applies: the plan wants you to try a cheaper drug first, and the appeal is about why that has failed, is unsafe or is not appropriate for you.
- The drug is not covered at all under the plan's list: you may need an exception request, and the appeal states why no listed alternative works.
For a therapy denial (physical, occupational or speech therapy, behavioral health, home health), the plan usually says either that the visits are not medically necessary at the requested amount or that the request exceeded a limit. The records that answer that are progress notes, test scores and a plan of care that shows measurable goals.
Step 3: Get a letter of medical necessity from the prescriber
The strongest single document in most Medicaid appeals is a letter from the doctor or therapist who ordered the service. Ask the office to write it, and make it easy by telling them exactly what the denial said and sending the criteria from Step 2. A letter that works usually contains:
- your diagnosis and how long you have had it;
- what the doctor ordered and the dose, frequency or number of visits;
- what has been tried before, with dates and results, including drugs that failed or caused side effects;
- what is likely to happen without the service: hospital stays, loss of function, risk of harm;
- why the plan's suggested alternative is not suitable for you, tied to the plan's own criteria where possible;
- the prescriber's signature, credentials and contact details, and an offer to speak with the plan's reviewer.
Attach relevant records: lab results, imaging reports, therapy notes, discharge papers. Do not send everything in the chart; send what answers the reason in the notice. how to write a health insurance appeal letter that gets read has a structure for your own cover letter, which should be short: who you are, your member ID, the denial date and reference number, what you want reversed, and a list of enclosures.
Many people also ask the doctor's office whether a peer-to-peer call is available. In a peer-to-peer call the prescriber talks directly with the plan's physician reviewer. It is not a formal step and does not always stop the clock on appeal deadlines, so keep the appeal timeline running while you pursue it.
Step 4: File the plan's internal appeal, on time
The plan's internal appeal (internal appeal) is normally required before you can ask for a state fair hearing in managed care. Most states let you file by phone, in writing, or sometimes through an online portal, and you may name someone, such as a family member, provider or advocate, to act for you, usually with your written permission. Check the notice.
A few points about timing:
- File within the deadline on the notice. A late appeal may still be heard if you show good cause, but do not depend on that.
- Ask for continued benefits if the plan is cutting something you now get. For a reduction, suspension or termination of a service you were already receiving, federal rules generally allow services to continue during the appeal if you file by a short deadline, often 10 days from the date the notice was mailed or before the change takes effect. The notice says what applies. In some states the plan can seek repayment if you lose, so ask what that would mean for you before you rely on continued services. medicaid cut my service: the notice, keeping benefits and the fair hearing goes through that choice in detail.
- Put everything in writing even if you phoned. If you appeal by phone, send a short written confirmation afterward.
- Ask for an expedited (fast) review when waiting could seriously harm your health. Your doctor can support this request. Plans must decide expedited appeals much faster than standard ones, in a matter of days rather than weeks. If the plan refuses to expedite, it should tell you so and handle the appeal on the standard clock, and you can then ask the state about it.
Keep your own copy of everything you send, and send it in a way that gives you proof: the portal's confirmation, a fax receipt or certified mail.
Step 5: Know the clock: a timeline table
The numbers below are the general federal managed care framework, shown so you can see the shape of the process. States may be stricter, and your notice controls. As of November 2026, use the dates written on your own paperwork.
| Stage | What you do | Typical timing under federal rules |
|---|---|---|
| Denial notice | Read it, copy it, note the date | The date on the notice starts your clock |
| Request continued benefits (only if a current service is being cut) | Ask the plan in writing or by phone | Short deadline, often about 10 days |
| File the plan appeal | Phone or write; attach doctor's letter | At least 60 days from the notice |
| Plan decides a standard appeal | Wait; answer requests for information | Generally within 30 days, with a limited extension allowed |
| Plan decides an expedited appeal | Ask for it; get a doctor's statement | A matter of days, generally 72 hours |
| Request a state fair hearing | File with the state agency | After the plan's appeal decision; the deadline is in the plan's appeal decision notice |
| Hearing and decision | Attend, present records and witnesses | State-set; expedited hearings are available |
If the plan does not decide within its allowed time, federal rules treat that as having exhausted the plan's appeal, which can open the way to a fair hearing. Confirm that with the state agency rather than assuming it. The appeal and external review deadline calculator can help you count days for a commercial plan, but for Medicaid the notice is the controlling document.
Step 6: If the plan upholds the denial, ask for a state fair hearing
The plan will send a written decision on your appeal. If it says no, it must explain how to request a state fair hearing. A hearing is held under the state Medicaid agency's authority, not the plan's. An impartial hearing officer or administrative law judge takes evidence from you and from the plan and decides whether the denial was right under Medicaid rules.
What helps at a hearing:
- Request it by the date in the plan's appeal decision notice. Hold on to proof that you filed.
- Ask the state for any free legal help it lists, and call your local legal aid office or Medicaid advocacy organization early. Many handle exactly this kind of case at no cost.
- Bring the doctor's letter, records and the plan's own criteria. If your doctor can testify by phone, ask how to arrange that.
- Be ready to say in two or three sentences what the service does for you in daily life. Hearing officers hear about eligibility rules all day; a concrete description of what will happen without the service stays with them.
- You can usually ask for the hearing to be expedited if your health is at stake.
Some states also offer an external medical review by an independent organization, either as an extra step or as an alternative to the hearing. This varies widely. Ask the plan's appeal notice, the state agency or the ombudsman whether your state has one (external review explained: when an independent reviewer decides explains the general idea). An external review decision can sometimes bind the plan; a hearing decision binds both the plan and the state agency.
Step 7: Keep a log that proves what happened
Disputes turn on dates. Keep one running document, on paper or on a phone, with a line for each contact:
- date and time;
- what you did (called, mailed, uploaded) and to whom;
- the name of the person you spoke with and the reference or confirmation number;
- what they told you, in a sentence;
- the next date that matters.
Add a column for deadlines. The prior authorization and claim tracker can hold the same kind of log. If you pay for a drug out of pocket while you appeal, keep the receipts, because a later reversal may allow reimbursement and the plan or state agency can tell you how to claim it.
Two tracks that are easy to confuse
Not every complaint is an appeal. An appeal challenges a decision about coverage: the denial of a service, a reduction, a refusal to pay. A grievance (grievance) is a complaint about something else: a rude office, a long wait, a hard-to-reach provider, a transport no-show. You can file both, and a grievance does not replace or pause an appeal deadline.
Other places to turn when the plan's process stalls:
- Your state Medicaid agency's complaint line or managed care ombudsman office, which can often get a plan to answer faster than a letter can.
- Your doctor's office staff, who may know that the plan has an exception or alternative billing code that avoids the denial.
- A legal aid or health advocacy group, which can tell you whether the denial matches how your state's rules are written.
- A state or federal elected official's constituent office, when a case is stuck with no response.
None of these replaces the written appeal and its deadline.
Common ways an appeal goes wrong
- Missing the continued-benefits deadline while focusing on the longer appeal deadline. They are different clocks.
- Sending a letter that argues in general terms. Tie each paragraph to the reason in the notice.
- Appealing by phone only, with no record of the call.
- Letting the doctor's office assume the plan will call back. Ask for a date by which the letter will be sent, and call to confirm.
- Dropping out after a first no. Many people stop at the plan's appeal decision, even though the fair hearing is a separate decision-maker. Reversals at hearings happen, though no one can promise yours.
- Changing plans mid-appeal without asking. In some states you can switch plans, but the appeal and any approved service may not follow you. Ask the state before you switch.
Key takeaways
- The denial notice states the reason and your deadlines; read it first and copy it.
- A short deadline to keep a current service going can be shorter than the deadline to appeal, so check both.
- A doctor's letter that answers the plan's stated reason, with records attached, is the most useful single document.
- The plan's appeal usually comes first; if it fails, a state fair hearing is decided by someone outside the plan, and some states add an independent medical review.
- Ask for expedited handling when waiting could seriously harm your health, and log every contact with dates and reference numbers.