Blog

I was assigned a Medicaid health plan, should I keep it or switch?

How to decide whether to keep an auto-assigned Medicaid managed care plan: check network and drugs, compare extras, know the change window.

If a state assigned you to a Medicaid health plan, you can usually switch, but only inside a window that is often short. The decision turns on a few facts you can check in an afternoon: whether your doctors, your hospital, your pharmacy and your specialists take the plan, whether your drugs are covered, and what the plan adds beyond the basics. If the assigned plan covers all of those, there is usually little reason to change. If it misses one that matters, you want to know before the window closes.

This post is a decision aid. It gives the criteria in the order that tends to matter, a decision list, a call script for the state's enrollment broker, and a before-and-after table you can fill in. The details differ by state, so your enrollment letter and the state's Medicaid website are the final word, and a plan's member services line or the broker can answer what is specific to you.

Why you were assigned

Most states run Medicaid through managed care: the state pays private health plans, called managed care organizations (managed care organization), to arrange your care. The state invites new enrollees to choose a plan. If you do not choose by a deadline, the state assigns one. States often try to assign sensibly, for example by matching a plan a family member is in, or one your past providers took, but an assignment can also be a rotation or a random split among plans. The assignment says little about whether the plan fits you.

What matters is that the choice is not yet final. Federal rules generally give new enrollees at least 90 days after enrollment to change plans for any reason, and a chance each year after that. Your state may set a longer window, and your notice states the dates. After the window, you are generally "locked in" until the next yearly opportunity, though the rules allow a change in the middle of the year for good cause, such as being unable to get covered services or a provider you need in the plan. The guide on medicaid managed care explained: plans, networks and appeals covers how managed care works, and Medicaid managed care summarizes it.

Some groups are handled differently. In certain states, people in particular categories, such as American Indians and Alaska Natives, or people with some complex conditions or disabilities, may be able to choose an alternative or opt out of managed care. Read the notice or ask the broker if you think you may be in such a group.

The first things to find in the letter

Before comparing plans, find four facts in your enrollment materials or on the state's site:

  1. The date the window to change closes. Write it on a calendar.
  2. How to change: online, by phone, by mail.
  3. Who the enrollment broker is. The broker, sometimes called a choice counselor or enrollment helpline, is a contractor of the state that explains the plans and processes plan changes. It is not one of the plans, so it can explain your options without selling you one.
  4. Which plans are offered where you live. The list is often by county.

If you cannot find the letter, the state's Medicaid website or your caseworker can tell you the assigned plan and the deadline.

The criteria, in the order they usually matter

1. Your doctors, hospital and pharmacy

The network is the set of doctors, hospitals and other providers that have agreed to serve the plan's members. In Medicaid managed care, going out of network is often not covered except in an emergency or with approval. So check your people first:

  • Your primary care provider (primary care physician). If you do not have one, the plan assigns you one; you may be able to choose.
  • Specialists you see regularly, such as a cardiologist, a therapist or an oncologist.
  • Your hospital for the care you may need, and the nearest in-network hospital if you are far from it.
  • Your pharmacy, since some plans have preferred pharmacies.
  • Providers for behavioral health, dental, vision and transportation where these are offered through the plan.

Use the plan's provider directory, then confirm by calling the office: ask whether they take this plan's Medicaid product by name. Directories can be out of date, so a phone call matters. The guide on how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network explains how, and the worksheet doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet gives you a table to fill in.

2. Your medications

Plans have a list of covered drugs, and some require prior authorization, a plan's approval before it covers a drug or service, or require trying a cheaper drug first. In many states Medicaid has a state-wide preferred drug list that plans follow, but not all do, so look up each of your regular medicines on the plan's list. If a medicine you take daily is not covered, call the plan and ask how an exception works before switching or staying.

3. Care in progress

If you are in the middle of treatment, pregnant, scheduled for surgery or using home health, therapy or equipment, that care is a decision of its own. Ask each plan:

  • Will you honor my current treatment plan and authorizations for a transition period?
  • Can I keep a provider who is not in your network while I finish this course of treatment?
  • Who is the case manager or care coordinator for a patient like me?

Prior authorizations from one plan often do not carry to another, so the answer on continuity should be in writing or noted with a name and date.

4. Extra benefits and care coordination

Plans can add benefits beyond the state's required set, such as rides to appointments, over-the-counter items, extra dental or vision services, a phone or a gym membership. The extras vary by plan and year and are often marketing at the margins. Weigh them after the first three criteria. A ride benefit can matter a lot to a person without a car, and a gym benefit may matter to no one. Ask each plan to describe the extras in writing and the limits on them.

Care coordination is less visible and sometimes more valuable. Ask how the plan helps someone with several conditions, what the case management program looks like and how to reach a human.

5. Service and how problems get handled

Ask how long the member line typically takes to answer, whether interpreters are available in your language and how the plan decides on a denial. You also have rights outside the plan: if the plan denies a service, you can appeal to the plan and then ask for a state fair hearing, which the blog post on My Medicaid plan denied a prescription or therapy, how do I appeal? explains. Some states publish report cards on plan quality; if yours does, it is worth a look, though it is a weaker guide than your own providers.

A decision list

Use this after you have filled in the table below.

  • If all your doctors, your pharmacy and your drugs are in the assigned plan, and your care in progress is covered, keep it. Switching adds risk and rarely adds enough.
  • If one of your key providers is not in the assigned plan but is in another, and the other plan covers the rest, switch before the window closes.
  • If each plan misses something, rank what matters most. A specialist you will see monthly usually outweighs a transportation benefit. Ask the missing provider whether they are applying to join, and ask the plan about a network exception.
  • If no plan includes a provider you need, ask the plans about continuity of care and a single-case agreement (an arrangement to pay an out-of-network provider for your treatment), and ask your provider whether they treat other Medicaid patients under a different arrangement.
  • If you cannot get answers before the deadline, keep the assigned plan for now, if the state allows a change later in the 90-day window, and use the time to test it: schedule a visit, fill a prescription and call member services.
  • If your family has several members, ask whether everyone can be in the same plan. Some states encourage it, and it can simplify care and mail.
  • If your situation involves a complex condition, pregnancy or a disability, talk to a care coordinator, a clinic social worker or a navigator before deciding.

A call script for the enrollment broker

When you call the number in your letter, you can say something like this:

"My name is ___, and I was assigned to ___ plan. I'm calling to ask about my options before the change deadline. First, what is the last date I can change plans, and how do I do it? Second, which plans are available in my county? Third, I see Dr. ___ for ___, and I take ___ and ___. How can I tell which plans include them? Fourth, if I switch, when does the new plan start? Will I have a gap? Fifth, if I stay and later want to change, what are the rules? Can I have the date in writing?"

Then call the plan or plans you are considering and ask:

"Is Dr. ___ at ___ in your Medicaid network today? Is ___ [medicine] on your drug list, and does it need prior authorization? I'm in treatment for ___; what happens to my authorizations if I join? What extra benefits do you offer, and what are the limits? Who is the case manager for someone like me?"

Write down the name of each person and the date, and the answers.

Before and after: a comparison table

Fill in one column for the assigned plan and one for the plan you are considering, with the facts you confirmed by phone. This version shows the idea with invented entries.

Question Assigned plan (example) Other plan (example)
Primary care provider in network? Yes, Dr. Lee Yes, Dr. Lee
Specialist in network? No, cardiologist is out Yes, confirmed by phone
Hospital in network? Yes, nearest hospital Yes, 20 minutes farther
Pharmacy in network? Yes Yes
Medicine 1 covered? Yes Yes, needs prior authorization
Medicine 2 covered? Yes Yes
Care in progress honored? Not sure Yes, 90 days, in writing
Extra benefits that matter to me Rides Over-the-counter allowance
Notes Specialist is the problem Prior authorization to start

In this invented example, the assigned plan misses the cardiologist, and the other plan covers it with one added step on a medicine. For a person who sees the cardiologist often, the decision list says to switch. For a person who has only a yearly check-up with that cardiologist, it might say to stay. The table does not make the choice for you; it keeps the facts in one place.

What to do after you decide

  • If you keep the plan, keep a copy of the member handbook, save the member services number, pick or confirm a primary care provider, and schedule a first visit.
  • If you switch, confirm the effective date and keep using your current plan until then. Ask when the new card arrives, and bring both cards to visits during the changeover.
  • Either way, watch your mail. State and plan notices carry deadlines, and renewals are a leading way people lose coverage. The blog post on How do I end Medicaid in one state and start it in another when I move? is useful if you have moved, because a new address has to reach both the plan and the state.

If something goes wrong after the window, such as a needed provider leaving the network or services being denied, ask the broker about changing for good cause, and appeal denials.

Key takeaways

  • An auto-assignment is a starting point; federal rules generally give at least 90 days to change for any reason, and your notice states your state's window.
  • Check network first (doctors, hospital, pharmacy, specialists), then drug coverage, then care in progress, then extra benefits and service.
  • Call the offices and the plan: directories and drug lists can be out of date, and a name and date on a phone answer is worth recording.
  • Use the decision list and the comparison table to keep the choice about your own care, and ask the enrollment broker, which does not sell a plan, for help.
  • After the window, you are generally locked in until the next yearly opportunity, except for good cause.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic