Blog
How do Medicaid home care waivers work, and why are there waiting lists?
What home and community based services waivers are, how they differ from regular Medicaid services, why slots are capped, and how to get on a list early.
Most families who ask about Medicaid and long-term care want the same thing: help at home, so that a parent or a family member with a disability does not have to move into a nursing facility. Medicaid can pay for that help, but usually through a program called a home and community based services waiver, and many of these programs have more people who need them than places available. The result is a waiting list, sometimes a long one.
This post explains what a waiver is, how it differs from the ordinary home services in a state's Medicaid plan, how the assessment and the waiting list work, what self-directed options mean for paying a relative, and the steps to take now if you need help for someone. The rules differ by state, and the programs carry different names in different places, so the final word belongs to your state Medicaid agency and your local Area Agency on Aging.
What a waiver is and why it exists
Federal law treats nursing facility care as an entitlement for people who qualify: if you are eligible and need that level of care, the state must cover it. Home care was historically optional, so many people had no choice but to enter a facility. Congress created a way for states to cover home and community services for people who would otherwise need a facility, by allowing states to waive certain ordinary Medicaid rules. The word does not mean you give up any rights. It means the federal government has agreed that the state may run the program differently from the standard rules.
The most familiar versions are called home and community based services waivers, often shortened to HCBS waivers. The most common type is named for section 1915(c) of the Social Security Act, and states may run several, each for a different group: older adults, people with physical disabilities, people with intellectual or developmental disabilities, people with brain injury, or children who are medically fragile. Other legal routes exist, including broader demonstration programs known as section 1115 waiver programs, and some states combine them. The differences matter to the state's lawyers more than to families. What matters to you is which program in your state fits your person, and what it covers.
Typical services under a waiver include personal care help with bathing, dressing and meals, homemaker and chore services, adult day programs, respite care for family caregivers, home modifications such as ramps, non-medical transportation, and sometimes meals delivered to the home. Which ones are offered, and in what amounts, is set by each state's waiver.
Waiver services versus regular state plan services
Every state Medicaid program has a state plan, the standard package of covered services open to all eligible people in the state. Some home care is in it.
- Home health services are required in state plans for people who are entitled to nursing facility care. They are typically medical: nursing visits, therapy, supplies, aides who work under a clinical plan of care. They are not meant to provide all-day help.
- Personal care services are an optional state plan benefit. Many states offer them, with limits on hours.
- Other optional state plan programs allow states to offer home and community services without the caps that waivers can have, though states choose whether to use them and how to design them.
A waiver is different in four ways:
- It is aimed at a particular group of people, who must meet a level-of-care standard, which means they need the amount of help that would otherwise qualify them for a nursing facility or similar institution.
- It can offer a wider menu of services than the state plan.
- The state is allowed to limit the number of people it serves, so slots can be capped.
- It can be offered in part of the state, instead of everywhere.
The cap is the reason for waiting lists. A state that must cover everyone who qualifies for nursing facility care does not have to cover everyone who qualifies for the waiver. It budgets for a number of slots, and when the slots are full, new applicants are placed on a list. The tradeoff, which supporters and critics of the system both point to, is that home care is generally cheaper than facility care per person, so states can serve more people this way, but the cap means access is not guaranteed. Advocates argue the lists show unmet need and ask for more funding. State budget officers point to limits on state money. Both descriptions can be true at once.
Who qualifies
Qualifying has two tests, and both must be met.
The level-of-care assessment. A nurse, social worker or other assessor visits, or reviews records, and judges how much help the person needs with activities such as bathing, dressing, eating, moving around and managing medications, and whether the person has cognitive impairment or medical needs that put them at the facility level. The result is a score or a determination. Where you live, an Area Agency on Aging, an Aging and Disability Resource Center, a managed care plan or a state contractor may do this assessment.
The financial test. The person must meet the state's Medicaid income and asset rules for this kind of program. For long-term services, states typically use a higher income allowance than for other adult groups and look at a person's resources. The five-year look-back for transfers generally applies to waivers as well as to nursing facility care in most states. The post on How does the Medicaid five-year look-back treat gifts, and what is the penalty? shows how the penalty is calculated. The guide Paying for long-term care with Medicaid: income and asset rules gives the general income and asset picture, and our Q&A on Does Medicaid count my savings, car and house? Asset rules by group explains what counts.
A person can pass the level-of-care test and still be placed on a waiting list. A person can also meet the financial test and fail the care-needs test. Because the two are separate, a denial letter should say which one is the reason.
How waiting lists work
States manage waiting lists in different ways, and the terms vary: waiting list, interest list, registry, reserve capacity, priority category.
- Order of placement. Many states fill slots in the order people were added, though some give priority to people in crisis, to people leaving a nursing facility, to people whose caregiver is ill or has died, or to people with the highest assessed need.
- Releasing slots. A slot opens when someone leaves the waiver, moves, enters a facility or dies, or when the legislature funds more. Some states release slots in batches.
- Length. Waits range from none in some states and programs to years in others, and differ between the older adult waiver and the developmental disability waiver in the same state. The length is a state fact; ask the agency, not the internet.
- Staying on the list. Many lists require periodic confirmation of contact information and continued interest. Missing a mailed letter can remove a person. A change of address must be reported.
- Being screened out. Some states screen for financial eligibility before listing, others after.
Because dates of entry can matter, getting a name on the list early is the most useful single step, even if the person is not yet in need of everything the waiver provides.
Self-directed options and paying relatives
Many states offer a self-directed or consumer-directed option within a waiver or the state plan. Instead of an agency choosing and scheduling a worker, the participant, or a representative, hires, trains and supervises their own worker and may control a budget within set limits. A fiscal agent usually handles payroll and taxes.
Whether a relative can be paid is state-specific. Some states allow adult children, other relatives or friends to be hired. Many exclude spouses, and some exclude parents of minor children or limit the hours a relative can bill. Where relatives are allowed, there are typically background checks, training, timesheets and a limit on weekly hours, and the pay rate is set by the program. This is a topic where marketing claims and rumors circulate, so confirm with the program, not with a vendor.
Self-direction suits people who want control and have someone who can manage the paperwork. It adds responsibility for scheduling backup when a worker is sick. An agency-directed option takes that burden away.
What to do while you wait
A waiting list does not mean nothing is available. Ask about each of these:
- State plan services such as home health and personal care, which may start sooner than a waiver slot.
- Area Agency on Aging services funded under the Older Americans Act: home-delivered meals, some personal care, respite, caregiver support, transportation and information. These are not Medicaid and are often free or based on a contribution, though funds are limited.
- Medicare's limited home health benefit, which pays for part-time skilled care for people who meet its requirements, not for long-term help with daily living. The guide Does Medicare pay for nursing home care and home care? describes what Medicare covers, and the blog post why does insurance pay for skilled care but not custodial care? explains why skilled and custodial care are treated differently.
- A program of all-inclusive care for the elderly (PACE), available only in some places, which combines medical and long-term services for people 55 or older who meet the nursing facility level of care.
- A private long-term care policy, if one exists. See long-term care insurance.
- Faith groups, local nonprofits and veterans' programs, which can give practical help.
- Respite for family caregivers, which can prevent burnout while you wait.
Step list: calling your Area Agency on Aging
- Find the agency. The federal Eldercare Locator, run by the Administration for Community Living, can direct you to the local Area Agency on Aging by ZIP code. Your state's aging department or the state Medicaid website lists them too. For younger adults with disabilities, ask for the Aging and Disability Resource Center or the Center for Independent Living.
- Prepare a short description. Write down the person's age, diagnoses, what help they need each day, who is helping now, where they live, whether they receive Medicaid or Medicare, and whether anyone has told them they might need a nursing facility.
- Ask the first questions. "Which Medicaid waiver programs serve someone like this? Is there a waiting list for each? Can I get on it today, and what do you need from me?"
- Ask about an assessment. "Who does the level-of-care assessment and how long does it take to schedule?"
- Ask about services in the meantime. "What can start now, under the state plan or your agency?"
- Ask about priority categories. "Does a recent hospital stay, a caregiver emergency or a move out of a nursing facility change our place?"
- Ask about Medicaid eligibility. "Which office tests the financial rules, and what documents are required?"
- Write down the name of the person, the date, what was promised and what to send. Follow up by email or letter, keep copies and note the date for any callback.
- Re-confirm the place on the list every time the agency asks, and report new phone numbers or addresses.
- If you are denied, ask for the notice in writing and follow the fair hearing instructions in it. The deadline is usually short. A legal aid program for older adults or people with disabilities may represent you for free.
When a nursing facility is the other path
Sometimes the need grows faster than the waiting list, such as after a hospital stay or when a caregiver can no longer cope. A short stay in a facility may be covered by Medicare if requirements are met, and long stays by Medicaid. Ask the facility's social worker about programs that help people move back to the community from a facility, since some states give priority on waiver lists to people who have lived in a facility for a set period. A hospital or facility discharge planner is also required to discuss options. The post on setting up services after a hospital stay, My parent is leaving the hospital, so how do I set up covered home care?, goes through that moment.
Key takeaways
- A home and community based services waiver lets a state pay for home care for people who would otherwise qualify for a nursing facility, and the state may cap the number of people it serves.
- Waiting lists are a result of capped slots and state budgets, and their length depends on the state and the program.
- Qualifying takes both a level-of-care assessment and a financial test, and the five-year look-back generally applies.
- Get on every list early, confirm your place whenever asked, and ask what state plan, Area Agency on Aging and caregiver services can start in the meantime.
- Whether a relative can be paid under a self-directed option depends on the state, so ask the program directly.