Blog

Medical credit card or hospital payment plan: which one for my bill?

Four ways to spread out a $3,000 medical bill compared with exact arithmetic, including how deferred interest turns a "no interest" offer into a surprise.

Say the bill in your hand is $3,000 and you do not have $3,000 today. Four options usually appear within a week: a payment plan from the hospital or clinic itself, a medical credit card offered at the front desk or by a billing office, a personal loan, and the credit card already in your wallet. They look similar on a monthly statement and behave very differently when something goes wrong in month eight.

This post compares the four with one invented bill, shows exactly how "deferred interest" works with the arithmetic, and ends with a decision list. All the numbers are illustrations with round figures, not offers or typical rates. Real terms are on the agreement you are handed, and you should read that agreement before you sign.

Before choosing a way to pay, check the bill

Financing a wrong bill locks the mistake in. Before any of the four options, do three things, none of which costs anything.

  1. Match the bill to your explanation of benefits. The explanation of benefits (EOB) from your plan states what it allowed, what it paid and what you owe. If the provider's bill is higher than the "patient responsibility" line, call the billing office before you pay anything. The tool Medical bill and EOB checker walks through the comparison, and Worksheet: why my bill and my EOB show different amounts owed covers the common reasons the two differ.
  2. Ask for an itemized bill. A summary total hides duplicate charges, services you did not receive and codes that were billed separately when they should have been bundled. The guide how to get an itemized medical bill and spot billing errors explains how to ask for one and what to look for.
  3. Ask about financial assistance. Many hospitals, especially nonprofit ones, have a written policy that reduces or cancels bills for people under an income threshold, sometimes well above what people expect. The policy and application are usually available on request, and hospital financial assistance and charity care: how to apply describes the process. A bill reduced by assistance is a smaller number to finance, and in some cases there is nothing left to finance.

If the number survives those three checks and you still cannot pay it at once, the question becomes how to spread it out at the lowest total cost and the lowest risk.

Option 1: the provider's own payment plan

A provider's plan is an arrangement between you and the office that billed you. You agree to pay a set amount monthly until the balance is gone. Many providers offer this at no interest, because they would rather receive $250 a month than send the account to a collector. Others charge interest or a setup fee, and some require a minimum payment or a deposit.

What to ask:

  • Is there any interest or fee, now or later?
  • What is the monthly payment and the end date, written down?
  • What happens if I miss one payment: is there a grace period, or does the whole balance go to collections?
  • Does this arrangement get reported to a credit bureau? Does anything change if it goes unpaid?
  • Can I pay it off early without a penalty?

The case for it: it is usually the cheapest option, it involves no new credit account, and the provider has a stake in keeping you as a patient. A plan can also be negotiated: a provider may agree to a payment smaller than the first offer if you explain your budget. The post How to set up an interest-free hospital payment plan I can afford covers how to ask.

The case against it: terms vary widely, a missed payment can end the arrangement, and a plan with an oral promise but no paper is hard to enforce. If a provider hands the account to a collector while you are paying as agreed, a written plan is your proof.

Option 2: a medical credit card

A medical credit card is a credit card, sometimes offered through a provider's office, that is marketed for health expenses. Many carry a promotional period such as 6, 12 or 24 months. During that period the offer may be advertised as "no interest if paid in full." That phrase is where the risk lives.

How deferred interest works

With a true 0% offer, interest simply does not accrue during the promotional period, and whatever balance remains afterward starts accruing interest from that day forward. With a deferred interest offer, interest is calculated and tracked from the first day, at the card's regular rate, but not charged as long as you pay the full balance by the end of the promotional period. If one dollar remains, the interest from the first day on the original balance can be added to your account at once.

Here is a hypothetical. You put the $3,000 bill on a card with a 12-month deferred-interest promotion. The card's regular rate is 27% a year, which for this illustration we treat as 2.25% a month on the balance at the start of each month, with no compounding, to keep the arithmetic readable. Real cards compound and compute daily, so real figures differ.

If you pay $250 a month for 12 months: 12 × $250 = $3,000. The balance reaches zero in month 12 and you pay no interest. The offer worked as advertised.

If you pay $200 a month for 12 months: you have paid 12 × $200 = $2,400 and still owe $600. The interest that was tracked all year now lands on the account. Each month the starting balance falls by $200, from $3,000 to $800, and the interest tracked each month is 2.25% of that balance:

Month Starting balance Interest tracked (2.25%)
1 $3,000 $67.50
2 $2,800 $63.00
3 $2,600 $58.50
4 $2,400 $54.00
5 $2,200 $49.50
6 $2,000 $45.00
7 $1,800 $40.50
8 $1,600 $36.00
9 $1,400 $31.50
10 $1,200 $27.00
11 $1,000 $22.50
12 $800 $18.00

The twelve amounts add up to $513.00. Your balance after the promotion is $600 + $513 = $1,113, and from then on it accrues interest at the regular rate. You came $600 short of paying it off and the card charged you $513 for it.

Two features of these cards cause trouble. The monthly minimum payment printed on the statement is often smaller than the amount needed to clear the balance by the deadline; in the example, a minimum below $250 would never finish the job. And payments may be applied to other balances on the card first, depending on the terms and the law that applies to them. Read the terms for how a payment is allocated.

What a medical card can offer: quick approval at the point of service, a promotional period that gives you a clear target date, and no need to negotiate. What to weigh against it: a new credit account with a credit inquiry, a high standard rate once the promotion ends, a provider that may be paid by the card company immediately (so your leverage to dispute the bill afterward changes), and the deferred-interest trap. Some medical cards have no deferred-interest feature and simply charge interest from the start, so the label tells you little. The agreement does.

Option 3: a personal loan

A personal loan from a bank, credit union or online lender gives you a lump sum, which you use to pay the provider, and a fixed monthly payment for a fixed term. The structure is predictable, and the rate is usually lower than a regular credit card's but higher than zero.

Say the loan is $3,000 over 12 months at a hypothetical 12% annual rate, which is 1% a month on the remaining balance. The standard payment formula gives a monthly payment of about $266.55. Twelve payments total about $3,198.56, so the loan costs about $198.56 in interest. If the lender also charged an origination fee, that would be added on top; ask for the annual percentage rate (APR), which includes some fees, and for the total of payments.

The case for it: a fixed payment, a defined end date, no promotional cliff, and paying the provider in full lets you step out of the billing relationship. If a provider would give a cash discount for paying in full today, that discount can sometimes exceed the loan's interest. The case against it: it costs interest when a provider's plan might not, approval depends on credit, and you have converted a bill that might have been reduced by financial assistance or an audit into a loan you owe regardless. Do not take out a loan until the bill has been checked.

Option 4: the credit card you already have

Putting the bill on an ordinary credit card is the most flexible option and often the most expensive. Say the card charges 24% a year, which we treat as 2% a month on the balance. You pay $250 a month. Because each month's interest is added before the payment is applied, $250 does not retire $250 of the bill.

After 12 payments of $250 you would have paid $3,000 and still owe about $451.70. It takes two more months: 13 payments of $250 and a final payment of about $214.95, which is 14 months in all and a total of about $3,464.95. The interest cost is about $464.95.

The case for it: no application, no new account, possible rewards, and some card issuers' fraud and billing-dispute protections apply to the charge. The case against it: the rate is usually the highest of the four, a $3,000 balance can use up much of your credit limit, and a high balance relative to your limit can lower your credit score while it lasts. A card also invites the temptation to pay only the minimum, which stretches the debt and the interest out much longer.

Side by side

All figures below use the hypotheticals above and a $3,000 bill.

Option Monthly payment Months Approximate total paid Main risk
Provider plan, no interest $250 12 $3,000 Missed payment may end the plan
Medical card, deferred interest, paid on time $250 12 $3,000 Any shortfall brings back all tracked interest
Medical card, $200 a month $200 12, then more $2,400 plus $1,113 owed $513 added in month 13
Personal loan, 12% about $266.55 12 about $3,198.56 Interest cost; credit approval
Regular card, 24% $250 14 about $3,464.95 Highest cost; uses credit limit

The point of the table is the ranking, not the dollar figures. With round numbers, the cheapest outcome in every case required a plan with no interest and a monthly amount big enough to clear the balance on time.

How each choice touches your credit

Provider plan: often no credit check and nothing reported while you pay on schedule, but this varies by provider, so ask. If the account later goes to collections, a collection can appear on your credit report. Medical card, loan and regular card: each is a new or existing credit account. A new account usually involves a credit inquiry, which can lower a score slightly for a time; payments made on time are generally reported and can help; missed payments are reported and can hurt. The rules about when and how medical debt appears on credit reports have changed over the years and differ by bureau and state, so ask a nonprofit credit counselor about the current practice rather than relying on any article. The guide medical debt and your rights: collections, credit reports, lawsuits covers collections and credit reporting at a general level.

A decision list

Work down the list and stop at the first line that fits.

  1. If the bill has not been audited or screened for assistance, do that first. Do not finance a number that may shrink.
  2. If the provider offers a plan with no interest and no fee, and you can meet the payment from your budget without missing it, that is typically the lowest-cost route. Get the terms in writing.
  3. If the provider charges interest on its own plan and a lender would charge less, compare the total of payments, not the monthly amount. A fixed loan at a clear rate can beat a plan with hidden fees.
  4. If you are considering a promotional card, divide the balance by the number of months in the promotion, including the last month, and make that your fixed payment, not the minimum. If the result is more than you can afford, the offer will not work for you and the deferred interest is a real cost.
  5. If you must use a regular card, pay more than the minimum and plan a pay-off date. If you can pay more by cutting other costs for a few months, the interest falls quickly.
  6. If none of these fits your budget, do not take on more credit. Ask the provider for a smaller monthly amount or a longer plan, request a financial assistance review in writing, and consider speaking to a nonprofit credit counselor, a legal aid office or a consumer attorney about the options, including what happens if the account goes unpaid.

Questions to ask before you sign anything

  • What is the annual percentage rate after any promotion, and is interest deferred or waived?
  • What is the total of payments if I pay exactly the scheduled amount?
  • Is there a fee to open, to pay late, or to pay early?
  • If I am one payment short at the end, what is charged?
  • Does my payment go to the oldest or highest-rate balance first?
  • Who will be reported to a credit bureau, and when?
  • Can I dispute the bill with the provider after the card has paid it?

If a sales or billing person cannot answer in writing, take that as information. The state attorney general or your state's consumer protection office takes complaints about lending practices, and the state insurance department takes complaints about the insurer's handling of the claim if the bill is partly a claim-processing problem.

Key takeaways

  • Check the bill against your EOB, get an itemized copy and ask about financial assistance before choosing a way to pay, because financing a wrong or reducible bill locks the mistake in.
  • A deferred-interest promotion can charge all the interest tracked since day one if the balance is not cleared on time: in the example, $600 left over at month 12 triggered $513 of interest.
  • The cheapest route in the examples was a no-interest plan with a payment large enough to finish on time; the most expensive was a regular card with a balance that lingered.
  • Compare the total of payments and the written terms, not the monthly amount, and never rely on a promise that is not in writing.
  • A nonprofit credit counselor, a legal aid office or a consumer attorney answers the questions about your own credit and your own state's rules.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic