Blog

Part B excess charges: why some Medigap plans cover them and others don't

How assignment, the Medicare-approved amount and the 15% limiting charge create an extra bill, and which Medigap plan letters pay it, with a worked example.

Picture a hypothetical reader, Ruth, who has Original Medicare and a Medigap policy. After a minor procedure she opens the Medicare Summary Notice and sees what Medicare approved and paid. Then a bill arrives from the surgeon for more than the notice says she owes, and her Medigap insurer pays none of the difference. Nothing went wrong in the claim. She has met the Part B excess charge, a rule that most people with Medicare never think about until a bill like this lands.

This post explains where that extra amount comes from, why it exists, which Medigap plan letters cover it, and what to ask before a visit so the bill does not surprise you. The numbers are round illustrations, not prices.

Where the extra bill comes from

Original Medicare Part B does not pay whatever a doctor charges. For each service Medicare sets an approved amount, sometimes called the Medicare-approved amount or fee schedule amount. Medicare pays 80% of it once you have met the Part B deductible, and you owe the other 20% as coinsurance. That is the whole bill if the provider "takes assignment."

Providers fall into three groups:

  • Participating providers sign an agreement to accept assignment on every claim. They accept the approved amount as full payment and may not bill you more than your deductible and coinsurance.
  • Non-participating providers are still enrolled in Medicare, but they decide claim by claim whether to accept assignment. When they do, the arrangement is the same as above. When they do not, they may charge more than the approved amount, up to a federal cap.
  • Opt-out providers have signed a private contract with you and bill outside Medicare altogether. That is a different situation, covered below.

The cap for the middle group is the limiting charge: 15% above the Medicare-approved amount. The amount between the approved amount and what the provider bills is the excess charge. It is your responsibility, it does not count as Medicare coinsurance, and Medicare pays nothing toward it. The idea is the same as balance billing in private insurance, except that Medicare puts a ceiling on how much balance a provider can bill.

You can read more about how accepting assignment works in the glossary, and the plain-English version of the choice a doctor is making is in What does it mean when a doctor does not accept Medicare assignment?.

A worked bill, with and without Medigap

Say a service has a Medicare-approved amount of $200, the provider does not accept assignment, and the provider charges the limit. Say also that Ruth has already met her Part B deductible for the year. All of these figures are illustrations.

  1. Limiting charge: 15% of $200 is $30, so the most the provider may bill is $200 + $30 = $230.
  2. Medicare pays 80% of the approved amount: 0.80 x $200 = $160.
  3. Coinsurance: 20% of the approved amount is 0.20 x $200 = $40.
  4. Excess charge: $230 - $200 = $30.

With no Medigap, Ruth owes $40 + $30 = $70. Medicare's actual handling of claims from providers who do not accept assignment has a few technical wrinkles, including how the approved amount itself is figured and who receives the payment, so the Medicare Summary Notice is the place to read your real numbers. The shape of the arithmetic stays the same.

Now compare three hypothetical Medigap holders on the same bill, each of whom has met the Part B deductible:

Policy Pays the $40 coinsurance Pays the $30 excess Ruth owes
No Medigap No No $70
Plan A or Plan N Yes (Plan N may require a small copay for some visits) No $30, plus any Plan N copay
Plan G Yes Yes $0

The difference between the last two rows is the whole subject of this post: Plan G covers the excess, and Plan N and Plan A do not.

Which plan letters cover excess charges

Medigap policies are standardized by federal rules: each lettered plan offers the same set of benefits no matter which company sells it (Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin use their own standardized formats). Of the ten letters, only two cover the Part B excess charge: Plan F and Plan G. Their high-deductible versions cover it too, once the plan's annual deductible is met.

That leaves Plans A, B, C, D, K, L, M and N without excess-charge coverage. Plan C, which pays the Part B deductible, still does not cover excess charges, which is a common point of confusion.

There is a wrinkle for new buyers. People who became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020 cannot buy Plan C or Plan F. For them the letters on offer are A, B, D, G, K, L, M and N, so Plan G is the only plan sold to newly eligible people that covers excess charges. Someone who was already eligible before 2020 may still be able to buy Plan F. The medigap plan comparison chart sets the letters side by side, and Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N covers the whole lineup.

Plan G still leaves you the Part B deductible. In 2026 that deductible is $283 a year. A high-deductible Plan G has its own deductible, $2,950 in 2026, before it pays anything.

Why the rule exists at all

The limiting charge is a compromise. Congress wanted to give doctors who do not sign the participation agreement a little pricing room while preventing open-ended billing. Participating providers accept a somewhat lower payment in exchange for simpler claims handling and a listing as participating. Non-participating providers keep the right to charge up to 15% more on claims where they do not accept assignment, and patients bear that difference.

Supporters of the arrangement say it keeps some clinicians in the program who would otherwise leave, and that the cap, unlike private balance billing, is fixed and predictable. Critics say the extra charge is a hidden cost of Original Medicare that patients cannot easily see in advance, and that it falls hardest on people without Medigap or on a Plan N or Plan A. Both views describe the same rule.

Some states go further than federal law. A few prohibit excess charges or set the limit lower than 15%. Whether yours does is a question for your state insurance department or your SHIP counselor, because the answer changes how much a Plan G adds in your state.

How common is it, and who actually meets it

It varies a great deal by region and specialty, and no single statement fits everyone. In some areas almost every clinician accepts assignment, so excess charges are rare. In others, certain specialties or practices that serve mostly private-pay patients take assignment less often. Because you cannot see the rate for your own doctors without asking, treat the possibility as a question to check, not as a worry to carry around.

It also matters which services are involved. Excess charges are tied to Part B services from providers who do not accept assignment. They do not apply to Part A hospital deductibles, and they are not the same as an out-of-network bill from a private plan.

What about opt-out providers

A small number of clinicians opt out of Medicare. If you see one, you sign a private contract saying you understand Medicare will not pay anything for that care. The provider sets the fee, there is no limiting charge, and a Medigap policy pays nothing either, because Medigap only supplements services Medicare itself covers. This is rare enough that most people will never meet it, but the contract is a signal: if you are asked to sign one, you are agreeing to pay the entire bill.

Medicare Advantage is a different set of rules

If you are in a Medicare Advantage plan rather than Original Medicare, this issue looks different. The plan sets its own copays, coinsurance and network, and it replaces the Original Medicare payment structure. The question to ask is whether the clinician is in the plan's network, and what the plan pays when a clinician is not. You also cannot use a Medigap policy with Medicare Advantage, so the question of Plan G versus Plan N does not come up. Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: how to compare the two compares the two systems, and Original Medicare has the short definition if you are unsure which one you have.

What to ask before a visit

The cheapest way to avoid an excess charge is to find out in advance.

  1. Ask the office, before scheduling: "Do you accept Medicare assignment on every claim?" The answer you want is a plain yes.
  2. If the office says "sometimes" or "it depends on the service," ask whether this particular service will be billed with assignment, and ask for that in writing or in a note on your account.
  3. Check the clinician on Medicare's own provider lookup on Medicare.gov, which can show whether a clinician accepts Medicare's approved amount.
  4. If you are choosing a new specialist and have a choice, ask a participating practice first.
  5. If the service is planned and expensive, ask for the billed amount in advance and compare it with the approved amount you can find from Medicare.

If a bill arrives for more than the limit, you can ask the provider to correct it. If they will not, 1-800-MEDICARE and your SHIP counselor can tell you whether the charge exceeds the limiting charge in your state. Medicare Summary Notices list a "maximum you may be billed" figure for each claim, which is the number to hold the bill against. How do I read my Medicare Summary Notice and spot billing errors? walks through the columns.

If you do not have Medigap yet

For someone on Original Medicare without Medigap, the excess charge is one more reason to weigh a supplement. It is only one reason, and not necessarily the deciding one. Many people choose Plan N and accept the small risk of excess charges to save on premiums, while others prefer the certainty of Plan G. Both are defensible, depending on how many of the clinicians you see accept assignment and how much of a premium difference you face.

What to keep in mind:

  • Plan G costs more than Plan N in most places, and the difference in premium may be larger than the excess charges you would ever meet. The reverse can be true if you see a specialist who never takes assignment.
  • Medigap is easiest to buy during the six-month open enrollment period that starts when you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. Outside that window, insurers in most states can use medical underwriting. Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N covers timing and the guaranteed-issue rules.
  • A licensed agent or your SHIP counselor can show you what each insurer in your state offers for a given letter. A counselor from the SHIP program is free and not paid by an insurer.

Common misreadings

  • "Plan C covers everything Plan F does." It does not: Plan C does not cover Part B excess charges.
  • "Medigap pays whatever the doctor bills." Medigap pays Medicare cost sharing for Medicare-approved services, and only Plans F and G also cover the excess charge.
  • "The excess charge is Medicare's fault." It is a charge by the provider, within a federal limit, for not accepting assignment.
  • "I can't be billed more than 20%." That is true only when the provider accepts assignment.

Key takeaways

  • A provider who does not accept assignment may bill up to 15% above the Medicare-approved amount, and Medicare does not pay that excess.
  • Only Medigap Plans F and G cover the excess, and newly eligible people can buy only Plan G of the two.
  • Ask the office whether it accepts assignment before a visit, and check any bill against the maximum shown on the Medicare Summary Notice.
  • Some states restrict or ban excess charges, so your state insurance department or SHIP counselor is the right source for your local rule.
  • Medigap works only with Original Medicare; Medicare Advantage uses network rules instead.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic