Blog

The Medigap trial right and going back after trying Medicare Advantage

Four hypothetical households show when a Medigap trial right or other guaranteed-issue right applies after Medicare Advantage, and what to do first.

Medicare Advantage can feel like a decision you can undo. Sometimes you can, with no questions about your health, and sometimes you cannot. The difference is a set of federal guaranteed-issue rights, including a "trial right" for people who try Advantage and want to go back. They apply only in defined situations and only for a limited time, and they are easy to lose by moving in the wrong order.

Below are four hypothetical households. The names, dates and amounts are invented. For each, the question is the same: does a trial right or another guaranteed-issue right apply, how long is the window, and what must the person do first? The rules described are general, and details vary by state and by insurer, so confirm each case with a counselor.

The two ideas to hold onto

Guaranteed issue means an insurer must sell you a Medigap policy without medical underwriting: no health questions that can lead to a decline, no higher price because of your health, and no waiting period for pre-existing conditions. The guaranteed issue entry has the general definition. These rights are narrower than the six-month Medigap open enrollment period, and they come with deadlines.

A trial right is a guaranteed-issue right for people who try Medicare Advantage and decide, within the first 12 months, to leave it. There are two versions, and they correspond to the first two households below. What a trial right does not do is let you leave and return as often as you like. It applies to the first attempt.

In each of the cases below, the window commonly begins about 60 days before the Advantage coverage ends and runs until 63 days after it ends, and the insurer may ask for proof, such as a plan letter or disenrollment confirmation. Exact timing and the list of plans you may buy are in Medicare's published guidance and in the medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue guide.

Household 1: Joined Advantage at 65 and wants out

Maria turned 65 and, wanting a plan with a low premium and drug coverage included, joined a Medicare Advantage plan on June 1 as her first Medicare coverage. She did not buy a Medigap policy. Eleven months later she is having trouble getting approvals for treatment and wants Original Medicare with a supplement.

Does a right apply? Yes, probably. She joined an Advantage plan the first time she was eligible for Medicare, and she is leaving within the first 12 months of the plan. That is the first kind of trial right. It lets her buy a Medigap policy from an insurer in her state without health questions.

The window. Say she disenrolls effective May 1 of the next year, so her Advantage coverage ends April 30. Her window to apply would run from about March 1 (60 days earlier) to July 2 (63 days after April 30). She does not have to use the whole stretch, and applying before the Advantage plan ends gives the best chance of a seamless start.

What she may buy. The trial right names which plan letters an insurer must sell her. It is a defined set, which may not include every letter that insurers sell, and it may differ depending on when she became eligible for Medicare. Her counselor or the insurer can give her the set that applies. The medigap plan comparison chart shows what each letter covers.

What she must do first. Confirm with a SHIP counselor that she is within the 12 months. Pick the Medigap policy and ask the insurer to set the start date for May 1. Then disenroll from the Advantage plan, with a stand-alone drug plan to start the same day, because her Advantage plan's drug coverage ends when the plan does.

The date trap. The 12-month limit counts from when she joined, not from when she decides. If she waits until the end of the following June, she is past the window, and she moves into the underwriting world covered in the fourth household.

Household 2: Dropped a Medigap policy to try Advantage

Henry, 70, had a Medigap policy for five years. On July 1 he dropped it to join an Advantage plan for the first time, attracted by a $0 premium and added dental benefits. By February he finds his doctors are not in the plan's network, and he wants his old coverage back.

Does a right apply? Yes. This is the second kind of trial right: he dropped a Medigap policy to join Advantage for the first time and is leaving within 12 months.

What the right gives him. If his old insurer still sells that same policy, he has a right to buy it back, with no health questions. If the insurer no longer sells it, he has a right to choose among a defined set of other policies from any insurer in his state. Either way, an insurer cannot decline him or charge more because of his health, and the premium may reflect his current age and the insurer's current pricing, not the price he paid before. Henry should ask for a quote before dropping anything.

The window and the route. He is in the middle of a Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period, January 1 to March 31, in which people already in an Advantage plan can switch to Original Medicare and add a drug plan. A request made in February generally ends the Advantage plan on March 1. His window to apply for the Medigap policy would run from about 60 days before March 1 until 63 days after the Advantage coverage ends. The Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period entry describes that window.

What he must do first. Call his old insurer or a counselor and ask whether the old policy is still sold. Get the offer in writing before he disenrolls. Then request the disenrollment so that it ends the day before the Medigap policy begins. Arrange a drug plan.

A caution. If Henry was in Advantage before and returned to Medigap earlier, or if he has used a trial right once, the answer may differ. He should tell the counselor his full history.

Household 3: The plan is leaving the area

Priya, 72, has a chronic condition and is in an Advantage plan that tells her in October it will not be offered in her county after December 31. She is not at fault, and she has options.

Does a right apply? Yes. When a Medicare Advantage plan ends in your area, or you move out of its service area, you generally have a guaranteed right to buy a Medigap policy. As of November 2026, KFF reported that about 4.3 million people in Medicare would lose their Advantage or stand-alone drug plan at the end of 2026, so this is a situation many people face this year.

The window. With coverage ending December 31, her window runs from about 60 days earlier, around November 1, until 63 days after, which is early March of the following year. Because this is a plan termination, Medicare also gives her a special election period to choose new coverage; the plan's notice and Medicare.gov state its dates, and the medicare special enrollment period entry describes how it works.

What she must do first. She has two real choices: join a different Advantage plan, or return to Original Medicare with a supplement and a drug plan. If she wants the supplement, the guaranteed right is what lets her obtain it without health questions, which for someone with a chronic condition is valuable. Before she decides, she should keep the plan's termination letter, since the insurer may ask for it.

The difference from Household 1. Priya's right does not depend on how long she has been in the plan. A person who has had an Advantage plan for six years and sees it end has the same right.

Household 4: No trial right and no ending plan

Greg, 69, joined Advantage at 65, stayed four years and now wants a supplement. The plan is not ending, he did not drop a Medigap policy to join it, and his state is not one that sets its own annual window.

Does a right apply? Not under the situations above. Greg's open enrollment period ended long ago, and his Advantage plan is stable. He is outside the guaranteed-issue rights, so he goes through medical underwriting: an insurer can ask about his health and may decline, charge more or add a waiting period. The Can a Medigap insurer turn me down after my open enrollment ends? post explains how that works, and I'm in Medicare Advantage and want Medigap. What happens when I apply? describes the safe order of applying.

State exceptions. A few states offer more. As of October 2026, KFF described Connecticut and New York as having continuous guaranteed issue, Massachusetts as having a February 1 to March 31 window, Maine as having a one-month annual window and Rhode Island, Delaware and Minnesota as having recent laws for Advantage enrollees or older adults, with conditions. If Greg lives in one of them, he may have an opening. If not, his best path may be to apply to several insurers while staying in his plan until he has a written approval.

A quick way to sort yourself

Question If yes
Did you join Advantage the first time you were eligible for Medicare, and are you leaving within 12 months? Trial right, version one
Did you drop a Medigap policy to join Advantage for the first time, and are you leaving within 12 months? Trial right, version two
Is your plan ending, or are you moving out of its area? Guaranteed issue around the end date
Does your state have its own window open now? State right; check conditions
None of the above Underwriting applies

The first two questions count months from the date you joined, so check your enrollment date before anything else.

What to do first, in every case

  1. Find your enrollment date and the date your Advantage coverage will end. Everything is measured from them.
  2. Call a SHIP counselor before you cancel anything. They can confirm which right applies and what the window is.
  3. Get the Medigap offer in writing with the start date.
  4. Then disenroll from the Advantage plan so it ends the day before the Medigap policy begins.
  5. Add a drug plan with the same start date, since Original Medicare has none.
  6. Keep copies of the letters, confirmations and dates.

If you are comparing the systems rather than leaving one, Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: how to compare the two lays out the trade-offs.

Key takeaways

  • A trial right lets you leave your first Advantage attempt within 12 months and buy Medigap without health questions, in two versions.
  • Windows commonly start about 60 days before the Advantage coverage ends and run until 63 days after, and the 12-month count starts when you joined.
  • A plan that ends or leaves your area gives a guaranteed right regardless of how long you were in it.
  • Outside those rights, underwriting applies, though a few states add their own windows.
  • Confirm the right and the window with a SHIP counselor, and disenroll only after you hold a written Medigap offer.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic