Blog

Nonprofit hospital rules: what must it do before it sues me?

How federal tax-exemption rules limit what a charitable hospital can do before a lawsuit: assistance policy, reasonable efforts, notice periods, enforcement.

Most people who get a hospital bill assume the hospital can send it to a collection agency whenever it likes. For a large share of U.S. hospitals, that is not quite true. Hospitals that are tax-exempt charities have to follow a set of federal rules that limit what they can do about unpaid bills and require them to offer financial help. Those rules do not erase a bill, but they put steps and waiting periods between an unpaid balance and a lawsuit.

The rules sit in section 501(r) of the Internal Revenue Code and the Treasury regulations that implement it. This post explains them in general terms, shows a timeline with invented dates, and says what to do when a nonprofit hospital's collection practices do not match them. It is general information, not legal advice. State law adds its own rules in many places, and a legal aid office or lawyer is the right person for a particular account.

Why a nonprofit hospital has extra obligations

A hospital organization that is exempt from federal income tax as a charity receives a benefit: it generally does not pay federal income tax and often avoids some state and local taxes too. In return, Congress set conditions on that status. Among them, a charitable hospital must meet several requirements, and the ones that matter to a patient with a bill are these:

  • A written financial assistance policy that says who is eligible for free or discounted care, how the discount is figured and how to apply.
  • A limit on what eligible patients are charged for emergency and other medically necessary care, tied to what the hospital generally receives from insured patients rather than to its full list prices.
  • A written billing and collection policy that says what the hospital may do if a bill goes unpaid and when.
  • Reasonable efforts to find out whether a patient qualifies for assistance before taking the most serious collection steps.
  • A community health needs assessment every few years, which matters to the community but not to your bill.

None of this applies to every hospital. For-profit hospitals and many government-run hospitals are not charities under this part of the tax code. They may still have financial assistance programs, and some state laws reach them, but the federal tax rule that sets the sequence of steps described below is the one for tax-exempt hospital organizations. A hospital's website, billing office or patient advocate can say which kind it is. A hospital that belongs to a larger system may be covered even if the building's name does not sound like a charity.

The key idea: extraordinary collection actions

The regulations use a term for the harsh end of collection: an extraordinary collection action, often shortened to ECA. In general terms, the list includes:

  • Reporting a patient's debt to credit reporting agencies.
  • Selling the debt to another party, with some exceptions for sales on terms that protect the patient.
  • Lawsuits and other legal or judicial processes to collect.
  • Liens on property in some circumstances.
  • Garnishing wages or attaching bank accounts through a legal process.

A nonprofit hospital, or a collection agency working for it, generally may not do these things to a person until the hospital has made reasonable efforts to decide whether the person qualifies for financial assistance. Phone calls, letters and ordinary billing statements are not ECAs. A hospital can bill you, call you and send reminders during the whole period. What it must hold back is the legal and credit-reporting escalation.

The practical consequence for a patient is that a lawsuit from a nonprofit hospital should come after, not before, a window in which you had notice of the assistance policy and a chance to apply.

The waiting periods

The regulations set time limits that work like a clock starting when the first bill reaches you after discharge. In general terms:

  1. A waiting period of at least 120 days. The hospital generally may not begin extraordinary collection actions until at least 120 days after it sends the first post-discharge billing statement.
  2. Written notice before an ECA. At least 30 days before starting an ECA, the hospital must tell you in writing which action it intends to take and the date after which it may do so. The notice must include a plain-language summary of the financial assistance policy.
  3. An application window of at least 240 days. A patient generally has until at least 240 days after the first post-discharge bill to apply for assistance.
  4. A pause when you apply. If you submit an application, the hospital must suspend extraordinary collection actions while it decides. If you submitted an incomplete application, it must give you a chance to finish it.
  5. Reversal if you are approved. If you are found eligible after an ECA has started, the hospital generally has to take steps to reverse it where it can, such as asking a credit bureau to remove the entry.

These timing rules come from the federal regulations. Treat them as a framework, not a promise about a specific account. Hospitals sometimes act more slowly or more generously than the minimums, and a hospital's own policy is the best statement of what it will do. Verification that a particular hospital is a covered charity, and that it followed the right steps, is a question for the hospital's billing office first and a legal aid office or lawyer if there is a dispute.

A timeline with invented dates

Say Marcus is discharged from a nonprofit hospital in February and receives the first statement dated March 1. The dates below are illustrations that show how the clock runs, not the dates of any real case. They are counted from March 1.

Event Date How it is counted
First billing statement after discharge March 1 Day 0
Earliest date an ECA could begin June 29 120 days after March 1
Latest date to send the 30-day ECA notice, to start on June 29 May 30 30 days before June 29
Application window closes at the earliest October 28 240 days after March 1

Here are the counts. From March 1, there are 30 days to March 31, 30 more to April 30 (60 total), 31 more to May 31 (91 total) and 29 more to June 29, which makes 120 days. For the 240-day window, continue from June 29: 31 days to July 31, 31 to August 31, 30 to September 30 and 28 to October 28, for 120 more days, so 240 in all.

The lesson is in the gaps. The hospital may send an ECA notice before day 120 as long as the ECA itself does not begin until day 120 and at least 30 days after the notice. In this timeline, the hospital would need to send its notice by May 30. Marcus could still apply for assistance until at least October 28, so an application filed after a lawsuit threat in July could still be timely under the minimum window. If he filed on July 15, the hospital would have to hold off on extraordinary collection actions and decide the application first.

None of this means Marcus owes nothing. If his income is too high for assistance, he still owes the amount the policy sets. The rules decide the order of events, not the result.

What the rules do not do

It helps to be clear about the limits, because patients sometimes expect more than the rules give.

  • They do not require every nonprofit hospital to forgive bills, and they do not set a federal income cutoff for who qualifies. Each hospital's policy sets that. The hospital financial assistance and charity care: how to apply guide and the blog post on four households, one $18,000 hospital bill: who gets financial help? show how different policies produce different results.
  • They do not prohibit all collection. The hospital can bill you, send you to a collection agency for ordinary calls and letters, and sue after the steps are met.
  • They do not give the patient a private right to sue the hospital for breaking the tax rules. The enforcement tool is the Internal Revenue Service, which reviews charitable hospitals and can ask them to correct problems or, in serious cases, affect their tax status. Patients can report concerns, but a complaint to the IRS is not a defense in a collection case and does not stop a lawsuit.
  • They do not override state law. Some states add their own limits, require a hospital to provide assistance more broadly or restrict suits and wage garnishment. Others add very little. A legal aid office knows the local rules.

Courts have taken different views in different places about whether a patient can use a hospital's failure to follow its own assistance policy as a defense to a collection suit. Because that is a legal question that depends on the state, it is a conversation to have with a lawyer instead of a thing to count on.

How to ask for the policy

The hospital must make the financial assistance policy, the application and a plain-language summary widely available, typically on its website and in paper form at admissions and in the emergency department. In practice, here is how to get it:

  1. Search the hospital's website for "financial assistance", "charity care" or "patient financial services".
  2. If you cannot find it, call the billing office and say: "Please send me your written financial assistance policy, the application and the plain-language summary."
  3. Ask whether the hospital is a nonprofit and whether its policy meets the federal charitable hospital rules. The answer is not secret.
  4. Ask for the billing and collection policy too, which says what steps follow a missed payment.
  5. Ask for an itemized bill so you can see exactly what is being charged. The guide on how to get an itemized medical bill and spot billing errors explains how to check it for mistakes such as duplicate lines and charges for services you did not receive.

Keep a note of the date, the person's name and what they said. If the hospital will not provide the policy, that is itself useful information for a patient advocate or a legal aid lawyer.

What to do at each stage

Before the account goes anywhere. Apply for assistance as soon as you have a bill you cannot pay, and ask the hospital to place the account on hold while the application is decided. Ask about a payment plan for any balance that remains. The post on How to set up an interest-free hospital payment plan I can afford covers what to get in writing.

After you get a collections notice. Read it for the action and the date. If it comes from a nonprofit hospital and mentions legal action, compare the date against the timeline above. If you have not been given the financial assistance policy or a chance to apply, say so in writing and ask for the application. A letter by a collection agency is not automatically a hospital's ECA notice. The guide on medical debt and your rights: collections, credit reports, lawsuits explains validation letters and what rights a debt collector must respect.

After you are served with a lawsuit. A lawsuit is a court case with a deadline to respond, and the deadline is short and set by the court, not by the hospital. Ignoring it can lead to a default judgment. Contact a legal aid office or lawyer right away, and bring the court papers, the bills, any financial assistance correspondence and the notices you received. The checklist in i was served with a lawsuit over a hospital bill: first-week checklist lays out a first week.

After a judgment or a garnishment. State law controls what can be taken and how much of your pay is protected. Legal aid offices handle many of these cases for people with limited income, and many have a hospital-billing specialist.

Questions to ask the hospital

  • Is the hospital, or the entity that billed me, a tax-exempt charity?
  • What is your written financial assistance policy, and what income and asset rules does it use?
  • What is the date of the first post-discharge bill on this account, and what deadline does the application window have?
  • Has this account been referred to a collection agency, and if so, has anything been reported to a credit bureau?
  • Will you pause collection while my application is reviewed? Please confirm in writing.
  • If I qualify, what will I be charged, and how is that amount calculated?
  • Who is the patient advocate or financial counselor I can work with?

When to bring in a lawyer

A lawyer or legal aid office is the right step if you have been served, if a judgment has been entered, if wages or accounts are being garnished, or if you believe the hospital skipped the notice and application steps before going to court. Many legal aid programs and state bar referral services offer help at low or no cost for people who qualify by income. A state attorney general's consumer protection office may also take complaints about hospital billing practices. None of these is a guarantee of an outcome; they are the places that can tell you what your state's law adds to the federal rules.

Key takeaways

  • Tax-exempt charitable hospitals must have a written financial assistance policy and a billing and collection policy, and must make reasonable efforts to decide whether you qualify before extraordinary collection actions such as lawsuits and credit reporting.
  • In general terms, the federal rules set at least 120 days after the first post-discharge bill before ECAs, a written notice at least 30 days before one, and an application window of at least 240 days.
  • Applying for assistance should pause extraordinary collection actions while the hospital decides.
  • The rules set the order of events, not the outcome: you may still owe a balance, and enforcement runs through the IRS, not through a private suit.
  • State law varies, so ask the hospital for its policies in writing and call a legal aid office or lawyer before a court deadline passes.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic