Blog
Original Medicare denied a claim: reading the Summary Notice and appealing
How to read a Medicare Summary Notice with a denied claim, why denials happen, the first appeal and its four-month window, and what an advance notice means.
The envelope says "This is not a bill" in bold at the top of the first page, and then the second page shows a service you remember, a column of dollar amounts and a line reading something like "Medicare did not pay for this service." Your stomach drops. Before anyone calls a collection agency or you pay out of habit, read the page again. A denial on a Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) is a decision you can question, and often the notice itself tells you whether you owe anything at all.
This walkthrough is for people with Original Medicare (Parts A and B; see Original Medicare). If you have a Medicare Advantage plan, you receive plan statements instead of an MSN and appeal through the plan, a different path.
What the Summary Notice is
Medicare mails an MSN about every three months, covering the claims processed in that period. The same information is available sooner in your online Medicare account. It lists each provider who billed Medicare for you, the dates of service, what the provider charged, what Medicare approved, what Medicare paid and what you may be billed. A separate notice is not sent for each claim, so a denial can sit unnoticed for weeks if you do not look.
Four columns of the notice matter most when a claim is denied:
- Amount Provider Charged: the provider's list price. It is not what you owe.
- Medicare-Approved Amount: the amount Medicare allows for the service. If the claim is denied, this may be shown as zero.
- Amount Medicare Paid: the share Medicare covered.
- Maximum You May Be Billed: the most the provider can charge you for that claim, according to Medicare's decision. This is the number to read first.
Next to each claim are numbered notes at the bottom of the page, in plain sentences. They explain the decision. A denied claim also usually carries a statement of whether you or the provider is responsible for the charge.
On the last page is a section titled something like "Appeal your claim." It gives the deadline, the address of the contractor that processed the claim and a tear-off form you can fill in and sign. Keep that page even if you intend to appeal by letter.
A denial is not the same as the deductible
A frequent misreading deserves its own section. Say, as a labeled illustration, that the 2026 Part B deductible is $283 (it is, according to the CMS fact sheet for 2026) and a retiree named Harold has met none of it this year. He visits a specialist; Medicare approves $200 for the visit.
- Medicare paid: $0, and the note says the amount was applied to the deductible.
- Harold owes: $200, the full approved amount, because it is below the $283 he must meet first.
- Nothing is wrong. The claim was approved, not denied, and there is nothing to appeal.
Now say Harold has already met the deductible and Medicare approves $1,000 for a procedure. Medicare pays 80%, or $800, and the coinsurance is the remaining 20%, or $200. Again, no denial. Both of these arrangements can look like "Medicare did not pay" at first glance. The notes under the claim will say "applied to your deductible" or "you may be billed for the coinsurance." A denial notes language like "not covered," "not reasonable and necessary" or "denied."
Read the note's wording before you decide that something has gone wrong. If you are unsure, the Medicare help line, 1-800-MEDICARE, can explain a specific note, and a SHIP counselor (see SHIP) will go through the notice with you for free.
Why Original Medicare denies claims
Medicare denials cluster into four groups, and which one you have decides what to do next.
Not reasonable and necessary
Medicare covers services that are reasonable and necessary for diagnosing or treating an illness or injury. A denial for this reason means the contractor decided the documentation did not show that the service met Medicare's coverage rules (see medical necessity). Often it is tied to frequency, as when a screening or test is covered once a year and the claim came sooner, or to diagnosis codes that do not match what the coverage policy lists. This type of denial is the most appealable, because new records or a physician's explanation can change the result.
Not a covered service
Some things are excluded by law: routine dental care, most hearing aids, routine eye exams for glasses and long-term custodial care are classic examples. The guide What Original Medicare does not cover: gaps to plan for lists them. If the service is excluded by law, an appeal rarely changes it, though it is worth confirming that the denial is correct and that the provider coded the service accurately.
Provider or billing error
A wrong code, a missing date, a mistyped Medicare number, a service billed to Part B that belongs to Part A, or a missing referring physician can all produce a denial that has nothing to do with your care. Do not appeal until you have called the provider's billing office and asked, "Did you submit this correctly?" The post billing mistakes that make a covered claim look denied describes the common ones. Providers can ask Medicare's contractor to correct clerical errors without a formal appeal, and that is often faster than the appeal process.
Another payer should have paid first
If you have coverage through your own or a spouse's current job, or other insurance that is primary, Medicare may deny a claim because the other plan should pay before Medicare does. The glossary entry on medicare secondary payer explains the order. The fix is to get the claim billed to the correct insurer first, then billed to Medicare for the remainder.
Who pays when Medicare says no: the advance beneficiary notice
The line on the MSN that tells you whether you owe the charge often depends on one piece of paper you may or may not remember signing: the advance beneficiary notice of noncoverage (ABN).
An ABN is a form a provider gives you before a service when it thinks Medicare may not pay for it, usually as not reasonable and necessary. It must be given before the service, in writing, and in a form you can read. It explains why Medicare might not pay and offers three choices:
- Option 1: you want the service, the provider bills Medicare, and if Medicare denies you agree to pay (or your other insurance does). Choosing this keeps your appeal rights, because Medicare must make a decision.
- Option 2: you want the service but do not want Medicare billed. You pay, and you give up the chance to have Medicare decide, so there is nothing to appeal.
- Option 3: you decide not to get the service.
How the ABN affects who pays:
- ABN signed, option 1, Medicare denies as not necessary. You can be held responsible. You can still appeal.
- No ABN given when one was required, and Medicare denies as not necessary. The provider is generally responsible and cannot bill you. The notice will usually say so.
- A service Medicare excludes by law. An ABN is not required for these, though providers may still use one voluntarily.
- Emergency care. An ABN cannot be required in an emergency.
Check whether you signed one: the provider's office should have a copy. If the MSN says the provider is liable and the provider's bill arrives anyway, tell the billing office what the notice says and ask for the account to be adjusted. If it will not, a SHIP counselor or 1-800-MEDICARE can help you press the point.
ABNs are not used in Medicare Advantage; those plans handle advance decisions through their own pre-service process.
The first appeal: a redetermination
The first level of appeal in Original Medicare is called a redetermination, and it is decided by the same type of contractor that processed your claim, but by a different reviewer than the person who made the first decision.
- Deadline: 120 days from the date you receive the MSN. Medicare treats the notice as received a few days after the date printed on it, but do not lean on the extra days. The notice tells you the date.
- How to file: use the form on the last page of the MSN, send a written request, or use the redetermination request form that Medicare publishes. In any case, say which claim and date you dispute, why, sign it and include your name and Medicare number.
- What to include: your doctor's records for the date of service, a short letter from the doctor explaining why the service was needed, any ABN or provider statements, and anything the denial note identified as missing.
- Decision time: generally about 60 days. You receive a written decision, which may be a full or partial approval or an upholding of the denial.
The 120-day limit is where claims go to die. Many people notice a denial on an MSN months after the service. If a few weeks have passed, act now; if the deadline is close, file first and add records later. If it has passed, you can ask for more time by showing good cause, such as a serious illness or not receiving the notice, but approval is not assured.
A short example
Say a patient, Dolores, has a bone density scan denied because the contractor says she had a similar scan eighteen months earlier and the frequency limit is not met. The MSN's note says the scan was not covered because of how often it was performed. Dolores asks her physician whether a documented condition, such as a recent fracture or a change in medications, supports an earlier scan. The doctor's office sends a letter and the chart note describing the fracture. Dolores files a redetermination request on day 40, well within the 120 days. The contractor reviews the added records and may reverse the denial. If the facts do not support an exception, the denial stands, and she can continue. This is a hypothetical: whether a specific scan is covered depends on Medicare's coverage policies and her records.
If the redetermination is denied
The decision letter lists the next steps. In outline:
- Reconsideration by an independent contractor, which must be requested within about 180 days of the redetermination decision, with a decision in about 60 days. This is the second, independent look.
- A hearing before an administrative law judge, if the amount in dispute meets a minimum that Medicare adjusts each year.
- Medicare Appeals Council review, and finally
- Federal court, where a higher yearly threshold applies.
Each level has its own deadline, usually around 60 days after the previous decision. The ladder is shaped like the Medicare Advantage one, with different names and a different first step; the post Medicare Advantage appeal levels from reconsideration to federal court shows the Advantage version if you want to compare. The appeal and external review deadline calculator can help you keep dates organized, though your notices control.
Where free help is
- SHIP counselors are state-run, free and unbiased. They help with Medicare notices, forms and appeal letters. Find yours through your state's page or Medicare's website.
- 1-800-MEDICARE can explain a note on the MSN and tell you whether your claim was submitted correctly.
- The provider's billing office can correct many errors and can tell you whether an ABN was signed.
- Your doctor can write the supporting statement that turns many medical necessity appeals.
- A Medicare advocate or attorney is worth considering for larger amounts or higher levels.
Mistakes to avoid
- Paying before reading the notes. If the notice says you owe nothing, paying a bill creates a refund chase later.
- Ignoring the MSN. It arrives quarterly, and the 120-day clock runs from the notice. Check your online account monthly if you have recent care.
- Appealing a billing error. Fix a coding error with the provider first. A formal appeal is for disagreements with Medicare's decision.
- Missing the ABN question. Whether you signed one shapes who pays.
- Filing without records. An appeal that says only "please reconsider" usually fails. Send the chart note.
Key takeaways
- A denied claim on a Medicare Summary Notice is a decision you can question; read the notes and the "maximum you may be billed" column before paying anything.
- Denials usually mean not reasonable and necessary, not covered, a billing error or another payer that should have paid first, and each has a different fix.
- An advance beneficiary notice signed before the service can make you responsible for a denied charge; without one, the provider is generally responsible for a necessity denial.
- The first appeal, a redetermination, must be filed within 120 days of receiving the notice, with a decision in about 60 days.
- SHIP counselors and 1-800-MEDICARE help at no cost, and the notice itself states the dates that apply to you.