Blog

Should I pay cash instead of using my insurance for a lab test or scan?

Three ways to pay for a lab or scan compared: billing insurance, a provider's cash price and a cash-only site, with deductible math and contract limits.

Sometimes the cash price is lower than what you would pay with insurance, and sometimes it is far higher. Which one wins depends on three things: where you are in your deductible, what your plan has negotiated for that test, and what a cash-only provider charges. The only way to know is to ask for both prices before the test, and to ask one more question about whether the cash payment would count toward your deductible.

This post compares three routes on one table, works through an example with invented prices, and then explains the catches: contract limits on cash billing, deductible credit, the claims record and the cases where preventive coverage makes the question moot.

The three routes

Route A: bill insurance Route B: provider's cash price Route C: low-cost cash lab or imaging center
Who sets the price The plan's contract with an in-network provider The provider's own self-pay rate A site that sells tests or scans for a posted price
What you pay before the deductible is met The full network rate The cash price The posted price
What you pay after the deductible Coinsurance or copay, then $0 at the out-of-pocket maximum The cash price, regardless The posted price, regardless
Counts toward your deductible Yes Depends on plan and state Usually no
The claim goes on your record with the plan Yes No No
Contract limits None for you An in-network provider's contract may restrict it Rarely, since these sites are often out of network
Preventive services Often $0 Pointless Pointless
Best when Deductible is met or will be, or the service is preventive A big gap between your network rate and the cash price The test is simple and a posted price is far below your network rate

The table is a framework, not a ruling. Each cell varies by plan, state and provider, which is why the section after the example shows how to confirm them.

A worked example (invented prices)

The numbers below are illustrations with round figures. They are not real prices, and real prices vary widely by location, provider and plan. Say Rosa, a hypothetical patient, has a plan with a $3,000 deductible and 20% coinsurance after it. Her doctor orders a basic blood panel and a knee MRI. Rosa has met none of her deductible this year.

Blood panel

  • Network rate (what insurance would allow): $90
  • The provider's cash price: $60
  • A low-cost cash lab's posted price: $25

Knee MRI

  • Network rate at a hospital outpatient department: $1,400
  • Cash price at the hospital: $1,100
  • Cash price at a freestanding imaging center: $450

Before the deductible is met, billing insurance means Rosa pays the full network rate: $90 and $1,400. Paying cash at the cheapest site costs $25 and $450. On those prices she would save $65 on the panel and $950 on the MRI by paying cash, for $1,015 in total.

But what if she will meet the deductible anyway? Suppose Rosa knows she will have a planned surgery in the fall that will push her well past the $3,000 deductible regardless.

  • Route A: the MRI's $1,400 counts toward her deductible. She was going to pay the full $3,000 anyway, so the MRI does not add to her total deductible spending. It uses up $1,400 of a $3,000 she owed regardless.
  • Route C: she pays $450 in cash for the MRI, and it does not count. Her deductible is still $3,000 when the surgery comes, so she pays $450 plus the full $3,000.

For the year, Route A costs her $3,000 of deductible. Route C costs $3,450. In this case, using insurance is $450 cheaper, even though the cash price looked cheaper on the day.

And after the deductible is met? If the deductible is already met and coinsurance is 20%, billing insurance costs $280 for the MRI (20% of $1,400, which is $280) and $18 for the panel (20% of $90). The cash site's $450 and $25 are now higher. After the out-of-pocket maximum is reached, insurance costs $0 for covered in-network care.

Comparing the same MRI across three situations:

Situation Insurance Cash at imaging center
Deductible not met, will not be met this year $1,400 $450
Deductible not met, will be met by surgery Counts toward the $3,000 she owes anyway $450 extra
Deductible met, 20% coinsurance $280 $450

The lesson is that the question is not "which price is lower today" but "which route costs the least over the plan year."

Does cash count toward the deductible?

It depends, and it is a question for the plan, not the lab. Three possibilities:

  • Many plans count only claims the plan has processed. A cash payment the plan never sees does not count.
  • Some plans accept receipts and credit out-of-pocket payments to the deductible, usually when the service is a covered one from a licensed provider. Ask member services whether there is a form for this and whether it applies to out-of-network or cash purchases.
  • Some states have laws that affect whether and how out-of-pocket payments count, particularly for drugs. The state insurance department can tell you what applies where you live, and the plan documents or summary of benefits may describe it.

The practical rule: assume it does not count unless the plan confirms in writing. The guide what is a deductible and how does it work in health insurance? explains how the deductible works, and a call to member services is the right way to confirm for your plan.

Contract limits on paying cash

A provider that is in your plan's network has a contract with the insurer. Many such contracts require the provider to bill the plan for covered services and limit what it can charge a member. That can mean:

  • an in-network provider may refuse to offer a cash price for a covered service, or may require you to sign a form waiving insurance for that visit;
  • a provider that offers a cash price may still be bound by the contract on how it can bill you;
  • a cash-only lab or imaging center that is out of network is usually free to set any price and is not restricted by the contract, because it has none.

Ask the provider directly: "Can I pay your self-pay price for this test instead of billing my plan, and is that allowed under your contract?" The answer is theirs to give. If you are in an in-network hospital, a facility fee may also be part of the cost; the glossary entry facility fee explains it. For the difference between network types, see in-network vs out-of-network care: what it means for your bill.

What it does to your claims record

When you bill insurance, the claim appears in your plan's records and on your explanation of benefits. When you pay cash, there is no claim with the plan, though the test result is still in your medical record at the provider and with your doctor.

For individual and small-group plans covered by the Affordable Care Act, the insurer cannot charge you more or deny coverage because of your health history, so an extra claim does not change your premium. Other kinds of insurance, such as life, disability or long-term care insurance, may ask about your medical history in underwriting, and a test that is in your medical record is still there. Whether that matters to you depends on what you plan to buy. A broker or the insurer's underwriting guidelines can say.

Another consideration is continuity of care. If you pay cash at a lab your doctor does not use, make sure your doctor receives the results. Ask the site to send them, and ask your doctor's office whether they accept outside results and in what form.

When preventive coverage makes the question moot

Under the Affordable Care Act, non-grandfathered plans must cover recommended preventive services without cost sharing when you use an in-network provider. If a test is billed as preventive, such as certain cancer screenings or routine blood work as part of a covered preventive visit, your cost can be $0 with insurance, and a cash price cannot beat that. The catch is the way the test is coded: the same blood panel can be preventive when screening a healthy person and diagnostic when investigating a symptom, and a diagnostic code usually brings cost sharing. The guide Free preventive care under the ACA: what is covered at no cost lists what is covered, and the glossary entry preventive care defines it.

Before paying cash for something that sounds like a screening, ask your doctor's office and the plan whether it would be covered as preventive.

Ask both prices: a short script

  1. Ask your doctor's office for the test name and the code (CPT code) the order will use.
  2. Ask the plan's member services or price tool: "What is the allowed amount for this code at this provider, and how much of my deductible have I met?"
  3. Call the provider: "What is your self-pay price for this code, and does it include the facility fee, the reading fee and any interpretation by a radiologist?"
  4. Ask: "Can I pay the self-pay price and also submit the receipt to my plan?"
  5. Compare the total cost to you under each route, then add the deductible effect.
  6. Get the price in writing or by email, with the date.

Hospitals are required to post prices online, including a cash price for many services, under the federal price transparency rule, so a hospital's cash price is often findable before you call. Check the files against what the person on the phone tells you, because the posted price and a quoted price can differ.

For deeper walkthroughs, see Pay cash or run it through insurance? How I decide for a procedure, which covers larger procedures, and How to shop for an MRI or blood work and pay less before I schedule it, which covers how to find a cheaper site for the same test.

Mistakes that turn a bargain into a bill

A few errors show up often when people try to save with cash:

  • Comparing a cash price with the billed charge instead of the network rate. A hospital's list price is rarely what insurance pays. The comparison that matters is your cost under the plan's negotiated rate against the cash price, not the chargemaster number printed on a statement.
  • Forgetting the second bill. A scan can come with a separate fee for the radiologist who reads it, and a hospital-based test may add a facility fee. Ask whether the quote is all-inclusive, and ask for the reading fee in the same call.
  • Skipping the order. A cash lab or imaging center often still needs a prescription or order from a licensed clinician. Get it before you book, and ask whether the site takes it by fax, portal or paper.
  • Paying cash for something already covered at $0. A screening coded as preventive may cost nothing through the plan, so paying even a small cash price is a loss.
  • Not telling the doctor. A result that sits at an outside lab does not help a clinician unless it reaches them. Ask the site to send it and confirm that your doctor has it.
  • Assuming the HSA or FSA rules change. An HSA or health FSA can generally pay a cash price for a qualified medical expense, but keep the itemized receipt, because the account administrator can ask for it.

A fair counterpoint is that cash pricing is not always easy to get. Many providers have no posted self-pay price for a particular test, and some quote one only after a long phone call. When you cannot get a clear number, the network rate through your plan is often the safer choice because it comes with the protections of a contract, an explanation of benefits and an appeals process if something goes wrong.

Who each route tends to suit

  • Billing insurance tends to suit people who have met or will meet their deductible, people with preventive tests, and people whose providers will not offer a cash price.
  • The provider's cash price tends to suit people who want to stay with their doctor or hospital, face a high network rate before the deductible, and are told the cash price is lower.
  • A low-cost cash site tends to suit people with a simple, standard test, a deductible they will not meet this year and a plan with a high network rate.

None of these is the right answer for everyone, and a navigator, the plan's member services or a licensed broker can answer questions about a specific plan.

Key takeaways

  • Ask for both prices, the plan's allowed amount and the provider's self-pay price, before the test, and put the quotes in writing.
  • Before your deductible is met, the cash price can be far lower, but if you will meet the deductible anyway through other care, insurance can cost less over the year because the payment counts.
  • Whether a cash payment counts toward the deductible depends on the plan and the state, so assume it does not unless the plan confirms.
  • In-network contracts may limit cash billing, and preventive screenings are often $0 with insurance, so check coding first.
  • Cash purchases stay out of your plan's claims record but not out of your medical record; send results to your doctor.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic