Blog

How to shop for an MRI or blood work and pay less before I schedule it

Eight steps from the doctor's order to a written quote, with phone scripts and a worked cost gap between a hospital outpatient site and a freestanding center.

The doctor hands you an order for a knee MRI and says the scheduler will call. The scheduler books the hospital next door, because that is where the office sends everyone. You are about to commit to a price you have not seen, at a site chosen for convenience, for a test that is identical at a dozen other places in your area. The window to shop is the time between the order and the appointment, and it closes the moment you say yes.

This playbook walks through that window in order: what to get from the doctor, what to ask your plan, how to call sites, what to compare, how to confirm network status and prior authorization, and how to record the quote. It includes phone scripts and an example with invented numbers. It does not recommend any facility, and nothing here replaces your doctor's judgment about where a test should be done.

Step 1: Get the order and the code

You cannot compare prices without knowing exactly what is being priced. Ask the ordering office for:

  • the name of the test as written (for example, MRI of the right knee without contrast, or a basic metabolic panel and lipid panel);
  • the procedure code, called a CPT code, for each item. Codes distinguish similar tests, and an MRI with contrast carries a different code and price than one without;
  • the diagnosis or reason on the order, because it affects coverage and prior authorization;
  • whether the order is specific to a site or can go to any accredited facility.

Ask the question plainly: "Does this order have to be done at the hospital, or can I take it to another site?" Some reasons for a hospital are legitimate: a need for sedation, a complicated study, comparison with prior images stored at that system, or a pediatric patient. If the office says any site will do, you are free to shop. Ask them to send the order to the site you pick, or give you a copy.

For blood work, ask which lab the office uses. A doctor's office may draw blood and send it to a lab you never chose, and that lab may be out of network. The post Nine questions about bills from labs and specialists I never chose describes how that goes wrong. Ask the office to send your sample to an in-network lab.

Step 2: Use the plan's price tool and check coverage

Most insurers offer a cost estimator in their member portal or app, and federal rules require plans to provide a self-service price comparison tool. Log in and search by the code or test name. The tool usually shows an estimate of your cost at several in-network sites, based on the plan's negotiated rates and where you are in your deductible.

Treat the figure as a starting point. Tools can be out of date or incomplete, and they often leave out a separate fee for the doctor who reads the scan. If the portal has no result, call member services and ask for the allowed amount for each code at each site you are considering, and how much of your deductible remains.

The guide how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan puts these estimates in the context of a full year.

Step 3: Find two or three in-network sites

List candidates from the plan's provider directory and from your own search: your doctor's hospital, other hospitals nearby, and freestanding imaging centers or independent labs. Directories contain errors, and a listing that says "in network" can be out of date, a problem sometimes called a ghost network. Treat the directory as a lead and confirm in Step 6.

The guide how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network explains how to check network status, and in-network vs out-of-network care: what it means for your bill explains why it matters for the bill.

Step 4: Call each site with a script

Call the scheduling or billing line, not the front desk of a clinic. A short script works:

"I have an order for [test] with code [CPT code]. I'm with [plan name]. Can you give me the total price I would pay with my insurance, including the facility fee and the radiologist's reading? Is the facility part of my plan's network, and is the radiologist who reads the scan in network too?"

Write down the name of the person you spoke to, the date and every number. Ask these questions at each site:

  1. Is the price you quoted all-inclusive, or are there separate facility and professional fees?
  2. Is the site in network with my plan, for both the facility and the reading radiologist?
  3. Will you need a prior authorization from my plan before the test?
  4. What is your self-pay price, in case it is lower than my cost with insurance? (This is a separate comparison, covered in Should I pay cash instead of using my insurance for a lab test or scan?.)

If the site cannot give a price, say you will call back, and move on. Several calls take about an hour, and the cost gap can run into the hundreds or thousands of dollars.

Step 5: Compare hospital outpatient departments with freestanding centers

A hospital outpatient department is part of a hospital. A freestanding center is an independent facility, sometimes owned by a physician group. For the same test, in network, the two can be priced very differently.

The main driver is the facility fee. Hospital outpatient departments often bill a facility charge on top of the professional fee for the physician, while many freestanding sites bill one combined price. The facility fee entry explains it, and the post Why did I get two bills for one visit: facility fee and doctor fee? describes how two bills for one test arise.

Be fair to both sides. Supporters of hospital sites point to access to the full medical record, emergency backup, sedation and complicated cases. Supporters of freestanding sites point to lower prices for routine studies. Neither is better for every patient, which is why the order's reason matters. For a straightforward scan your doctor says can be done anywhere, price becomes a reasonable tiebreaker. Ask whether the site is accredited and whether the radiologist reading the study is board certified; a good site answers without hesitation.

Step 6: Confirm network status in writing

A verbal "yes, we take your insurance" is not network status. "Takes" can mean they will bill the plan as an out-of-network provider. Confirm three things:

  • The facility is in network for your specific plan, not just for the insurer's other products.
  • The radiologist or lab group is in network. A facility can be in network while the group reading the scan is not.
  • Your plan agrees. Call member services, ask for a reference number for the call, and ask them to confirm network status for the facility's name and address.

Then ask the site to send the quote by email or through its patient portal. If something goes wrong and a bill differs from the quote, a written record is what you point to. The guide Surprise medical bills and the No Surprises Act: what is protected explains which surprise bills are protected, but do not assume protection applies to a site you chose out of network; confirm network status first.

Step 7: Check prior authorization

Plans commonly require approval before an MRI and some other advanced imaging. The order alone does not mean the plan has approved it.

  1. Ask the ordering office whether the order requires prior authorization and who submits it. The office usually does.
  2. Ask for the authorization number, the date it was granted and the site it names.
  3. Check that the approval covers the specific code and the site you chose. Some approvals attach to a particular facility, so a change of site may need a new request.
  4. If authorization is denied, ask for the reason, and ask the doctor whether a peer-to-peer review is possible.

The guide how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied covers what to do after a denial, and the prior authorization and claim tracker helps you keep dates and numbers in one place.

Step 8: Write down the quote and book

Before you schedule, make a one-page record:

  • test and code;
  • the site, with name and address;
  • the quoted price to you, and what it includes;
  • the date and the name of the person who quoted it;
  • network confirmation and the call reference number;
  • the authorization number;
  • the date of the appointment.

Take a copy of the order and the authorization to the appointment. After the test, compare the plan's explanation of benefits with the quote. If the charge differs, call the site and the plan with your record in hand.

A worked example (invented numbers)

The prices below are illustrations, not real prices. Say Marcus, a hypothetical patient, has a plan with a $2,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance after it, and $0 of the deductible met. His doctor orders a knee MRI without contrast. He gets quotes from two in-network sites.

Hospital outpatient Freestanding center
Facility charge (plan's allowed amount) $1,300 included below
Radiologist reading (allowed amount) $200 included below
All-inclusive allowed amount $1,500 $500

If his deductible is not met:

  • Hospital: he pays the full $1,500.
  • Freestanding: he pays $500.
  • Gap: $1,500 minus $500 is $1,000.

If his deductible is already met:

  • Hospital: 20% of $1,500 is $300.
  • Freestanding: 20% of $500 is $100.
  • Gap: $300 minus $100 is $200.

So the same scan could cost $1,000 more or $200 more depending on where he stands in his deductible. Now add blood work. A lab panel at the hospital's lab has an allowed amount of $140. At an independent in-network lab it is $40. Before the deductible, the gap is $100 ($140 minus $40). With the MRI, the combined gap is $1,100 ($1,000 plus $100).

A caution: if Marcus will reach his deductible this year anyway because of other care, the saving is smaller than the table suggests. Money he pays toward the MRI counts toward a deductible he would have paid regardless, so the gap that matters is the difference in what he pays across the whole year, which his plan's estimator and his own deductible balance can show.

When to stop shopping

Shopping has costs of its own: time, a delay in diagnosis and sometimes a second set of records. Do not delay urgent testing to compare prices; if your doctor says the study is urgent, follow the doctor's instructions about site and timing. For routine or scheduled tests, a small number of calls is enough. If a site's quote is the lowest but the site is far away, count travel and time off work.

If the process is more than you can manage, a patient advocate, the plan's member services or a hospital's financial counseling office can help, and for questions about plan rules the state insurance department is the regulator.

Key takeaways

  • Get the test name, the CPT code, the reason and the freedom to choose a site from the ordering office before anything is scheduled.
  • Compare the plan's price tool with two or three phone quotes, and ask each site whether its price includes the facility fee and the radiologist's reading.
  • Confirm in-network status for both the facility and the reading group, ask for a reference number, and get the quote in writing.
  • Check that prior authorization covers the specific code and site, and keep the number.
  • The gap between a hospital site and a freestanding center can be large before the deductible is met and smaller after, so judge it against your whole-year cost.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic