Blog

How much do pretax payroll deductions really save on my health premium?

A worksheet with round-number math shows what a pretax premium deduction saves in income and payroll tax, where savings shrink, and how to rerun it for you.

Look at a pay stub and you will often see a line such as "medical, pretax" next to the amount taken for your health plan. That label means the money leaves your paycheck before certain taxes are figured, so the premium costs you less than its face amount. It does not mean the plan is cheaper, and it does not mean the premium is free. This worksheet shows how much the pretax treatment is worth, using round invented numbers, and then lets you repeat the math with your own pay.

Everything below is an illustration. The rates are chosen to make the arithmetic easy to follow, not to describe your tax bracket. A tax professional or your payroll department can confirm what applies to you.

What "pretax" means on a pay stub

Most employers that offer health coverage run the employee share of the premium through a cafeteria plan, often called a Section 125 plan after the tax code section that allows it. Under that arrangement you choose between taking all of your pay in cash or giving up part of it for a qualified benefit such as a health premium. Because the choice is made in advance, under written plan rules, the part you direct to the benefit is not counted as taxable wages for several taxes.

Three taxes are usually affected:

  1. Federal income tax. The deduction lowers the wages on which withholding and your annual tax are figured.
  2. Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes (together often called FICA). The long-standing statutory employee rates are 6.2% for Social Security and 1.45% for Medicare, a combined 7.65% on most wages. Pretax premiums generally escape both.
  3. State and local income tax, in many but not all places. Some states follow the federal treatment and a few do not. Your state revenue department or payroll office can tell you.

The savings depend on the taxes that would otherwise have applied to those dollars. That is the point of the worksheet: the savings are a percentage of the premium, and the percentage is different for each reader.

The calculation in five lines

Here is the whole method.

  1. Find the employee premium per pay period on your stub (the pretax medical line, plus dental and vision if they are also pretax).
  2. Multiply by the number of pay periods per year to get the annual premium.
  3. Add your marginal rates: federal income tax bracket, payroll tax (7.65% for most wages) and state income tax if it applies.
  4. Multiply the annual premium by the combined rate. That is the tax savings.
  5. Subtract the savings from the annual premium. That is the true net cost of your share of coverage.

A marginal rate is the rate on your last dollar of pay, not the average rate on all of it. A pretax deduction removes dollars from the top of your taxable income, so the marginal rate is the right one to use, with one exception covered in the section on limits below.

Worked example: Maya, paid every two weeks

Say Maya earns $2,500 gross every two weeks, which is 26 paychecks a year. Her health premium share is $200 per paycheck, taken pretax. These numbers are invented for the illustration.

Assume Maya's marginal federal rate is 22%, her payroll tax is 7.65%, and she lives in a state with no income tax.

Per paycheck

  • Premium deducted: $200.00
  • Federal income tax avoided: $200 × 22% = $44.00
  • Payroll tax avoided: $200 × 7.65% = $15.30
  • Total tax avoided: $44.00 + $15.30 = $59.30
  • Net cost of the premium: $200.00 − $59.30 = $140.70

Per year

  • Annual premium: $200 × 26 = $5,200
  • Annual tax avoided: $59.30 × 26 = $1,541.80
  • Annual net cost: $5,200 − $1,541.80 = $3,658.20

Check the answer two ways. The annual tax avoided should equal $5,200 × 29.65% (22% plus 7.65%): $5,200 × 0.2965 = $1,541.80, which matches. The net cost should equal $5,200 × 70.35%: $5,200 × 0.7035 = $3,658.20, which also matches.

In words: Maya's $200 premium reduces her take-home pay by about $140.70, not $200.

The same worksheet with a state income tax

Now suppose Maya lives in a state that taxes wages at a marginal 4% and follows the federal pretax treatment. Add one line.

  • State income tax avoided per paycheck: $200 × 4% = $8.00
  • Total tax avoided: $59.30 + $8.00 = $67.30
  • Net cost per paycheck: $200.00 − $67.30 = $132.70
  • Annual tax avoided: $67.30 × 26 = $1,749.80
  • Annual net cost: $5,200 − $1,749.80 = $3,450.20

The state tax adds $208 a year in savings ($8 × 26). Where the state does not follow the federal rule, that line stays at zero.

What the stub looks like with and without the deduction

A second way to see the benefit is to compare two paychecks. Both start at $2,500 gross. In the first, the premium is pretax. In the second, the premium is paid with after-tax money, which is what would happen if you bought the same coverage outside the plan and had no other deduction available. Use Maya's invented rates (22% federal, 7.65% payroll, no state tax).

Line Pretax premium After-tax premium
Gross pay $2,500.00 $2,500.00
Taxable wages after any pretax deduction $2,300.00 $2,500.00
Federal tax at 22% of taxable wages $506.00 $550.00
Payroll tax at 7.65% of taxable wages $175.95 $191.25
Premium paid $200.00 $200.00
Cash left from the $2,500 after these items $1,618.05 $1,558.75

The table applies the 22% and 7.65% rates to the whole paycheck purely to keep the comparison simple, so the totals are not what a real stub would show. What matters is the difference. The cash left under the pretax column is $1,618.05 and under the after-tax column is $1,558.75. The gap is $59.30, the same per-paycheck savings found above. Rates applied to the whole check overstate real tax, but the gap between the two columns is exactly the savings on the marginal $200.

Where the savings shrink or disappear

The worked example is the clean case. These are the common reasons yours may be smaller.

Your marginal bracket is lower. At a 12% federal bracket instead of 22%, Maya's annual federal savings fall from $1,144 ($5,200 × 22%) to $624 ($5,200 × 12%). Payroll tax savings stay the same, $397.80, so her total would be $1,021.80 rather than $1,541.80.

You are near a bracket edge. If the deduction pulls part of your income down into a lower bracket, the savings on those dollars are at the lower rate. Using the top marginal rate overstates the savings slightly in that case.

Your pay is above the Social Security wage cap. The 6.2% Social Security tax applies only up to a yearly wage limit that the Social Security Administration sets each year. Once your pay passes it, a pretax deduction no longer saves that 6.2% on the dollars above the cap, though the 1.45% Medicare portion generally continues. Check the current year's limit on the SSA's site before assuming either way.

Your employer's plan does not use a cafeteria plan. Some employers deduct premiums after tax, which is allowed. Your stub or HR can tell you which applies.

You are not an eligible participant. Sole proprietors, partners and certain owners of S corporations generally cannot use a cafeteria plan for their own coverage. They have a separate self-employed health insurance deduction explained route instead.

Your state does not follow federal treatment. Then the state line is zero.

What pretax does not change

  • The premium itself. The plan's price and your share of it are set by your employer. The tax treatment changes what that share costs after tax.
  • What the plan pays. Coverage, deductible and out-of-pocket limit are the same either way.
  • Your ability to deduct premiums later. Dollars paid pretax were never taxed, so they cannot also be deducted as a medical expense. The guide to How to deduct medical expenses on your taxes: the AGI floor explains the separate rules for expenses that count toward the deduction.
  • Marketplace subsidies. Pretax premiums for employer coverage do not turn into marketplace credits. Whether an employer offer blocks a premium tax credit depends on whether the offer meets the affordability and value tests, a separate question.

Other pretax items that follow the same math

The same worksheet works for other benefits taken through the cafeteria plan. Each is a separate line on your stub, and the savings come from the same stack of taxes.

  • A health flexible spending account (FSA), up to the yearly election limit your employer sets within the IRS cap. Money not used by the plan's deadline can be lost, so the worksheet's savings have to be weighed against that risk.
  • Dental and vision premiums, if the employer offers them through the plan.
  • A health savings account (HSA) funded through payroll, which avoids payroll taxes on the contribution in a way a deduction claimed on your own return does not. The HSA contribution and tax savings calculator estimates the tax effect, and FSA vs HSA: the differences in eligibility, limits and rollover covers the differences between the two accounts.

For the premium, FSA and HSA together, add the pay-period amounts, multiply by periods per year and apply the same combined rate. Counting them separately is useful when only some are pretax.

Your own worksheet

Copy the blanks below and fill them in from your stub.

Step Your number
A. Pretax premium per pay period $______
B. Pay periods per year (12, 24, 26 or 52) ______
C. Annual premium (A × B) $______
D. Federal marginal rate ______%
E. Payroll tax rate (7.65% unless above the cap) ______%
F. State marginal rate (0% if none or not followed) ______%
G. Combined rate (D + E + F) ______%
H. Annual tax avoided (C × G) $______
I. Net annual cost (C − H) $______
J. Net cost per pay period (I ÷ B) $______

Two tips for filling it in. Your federal marginal rate depends on filing status and taxable income, so use last year's return, where the bracket is shown, or ask a tax professional. And if your pay changes mid-year, rerun the worksheet; the percentages move when your bracket does.

Using the number

The result helps with three decisions.

Comparing plan options at open enrollment. If one plan costs $60 more per paycheck than another, the true difference after tax is smaller. At Maya's 29.65% combined rate, an extra $60 per paycheck costs about $42.21 net ($60 × 0.7035). For a side-by-side with deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums included, see how to add up the real yearly cost of two employer plans side by side.

Deciding whether to add a spouse or dependent. Adding a person usually raises the premium and the pretax deduction together. The net added cost is the extra premium times (1 − your combined rate), not the sticker difference. The how employer health insurance works: premiums, plan choices and rules guide covers how family tiers are built.

Judging an outside quote. A premium for coverage bought independently is paid after tax unless some other rule applies, so comparing it with your pretax share on face value tilts the comparison toward the outside option.

The tax effect is one input, not a reason to choose a plan. Premium, deductible, network and drug coverage still decide the real value. For a plain-language companion on the Section 125 rules themselves, see why are my health premiums pre-tax, and how much does that save me?.

When to ask for help

Your payroll or HR office can tell you whether premiums are pretax, what the pay-period amount is, and which taxes are affected where you live. For your own bracket, and for cases such as ownership stakes, multiple jobs, very high pay or a state with unusual rules, a tax professional is the right person. The IRS publishes guidance on cafeteria plans for employers and employees if you want the primary source.

Key takeaways

  • A pretax premium deduction removes the premium from wages before federal income tax and, usually, payroll tax, so the true cost is the premium times one minus your combined marginal rate.
  • In the invented example, a $200 per-paycheck premium costs about $140.70 net at a 22% federal rate and 7.65% payroll tax, and about $132.70 with a 4% state tax.
  • Savings shrink with a lower tax bracket, pay above the Social Security wage cap, or a state that does not follow the federal rule.
  • Pretax treatment does not change the plan's price or coverage, and the same dollars cannot also be deducted as a medical expense.
  • Rerun the worksheet with your own stub, then compare plans on net cost alongside deductible, network and drugs.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic